Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 09:36

bussteward · 26/06/2023 08:56

No, but I’d expect a diplomat husband or one on the brink of millions to outsource enough help to enable me to exist as a human outside of my role as “mummy”. I think OP has been fairly clear she doesn’t actually want to give up work and be a SAHM, but she can’t see an alternative.

(As it happens one of the coolest women I know was the wife of a diplomat, three kids close in age, and absolutely refused to play the “diplomat wife” role – and her husband did everything to make sure she didn’t have to be subsumed by his role and motherhood.)

Otherwise the children of these high-flying male diplomats, scientists (it’s always the cure for cancer, isn’t it?), millionaires, etc, grow up seeing men achieving great things but doing nothing domestic, and women giving up work and doing nothing but the domestic, and the cycle continues for another generation.

There are also plenty of Big Jobs that aren’t office jobs that don’t have defined hours, but that also aren’t international diplomat/curing cancer/making millions. Why are those jobs (and indeed the strawman jobs in your scenarios) more worthy than a routine salary, than an “ordinary job”, than OP’s or any woman’s desire to work outside the home? Where do you draw the line: is it money-based? Is it what the job achieves? Who defines what is an important job Vs a routine one? What happens if both parents are on the brink of curing cancer but can’t stretch to a nanny?

It's also interesting that women on here with ''big jobs'' are often called materialistic, a wage slave, selfish, greedy etc.

The attitude about OP's DH is very different.

anouskita · 26/06/2023 09:34

It is a general point I was making. There are people who earn, or who have the potential to earn, life-changing amounts of money. And yes, some (many) of them will be men. And some women will be married to those type of men. It is what it is.

Yes you could hire a nanny, but some families feel very strongly that they don't want to do that.

Of bourse, I completely understand why prioritising a husband's career would be seen as a risk. But it doesn't need to be.

I would never recommend giving up work to live off 'his salary.' There needs to be more than that. The way it would work is that the money he earns gets invested in both your names - in properties or other investments. So, even if you split, you'd be fine (and actually much better off than if you hadn't prioritised his career). In a family unit, it's not 'his' money - it's everyone's money. You invest that money as a family for everyone's future. It's prioritising and protecting your children and their education and future financial security. And if the DH is able retire early, all the better. As parents, you support, balance and facilitate each other in the best interests of the children and their futures. This is the priority. It's not a competition about who does what. Equality is about mutual respect - it's a mindset, not a petty game if who does this and who does that. You are a family.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/06/2023 09:33

In my experience, a lot of really high flying types tend to be attracted to other really high flying types - most very ambitious people tend to appreciate drive in others. So the guy who is busy trying to cure cancer or whatever may well have a wife who is doing the same. Is she still supposed to quit her job in order to facilitate his important job, or do they need to work together effectively in order to ensure that both of them are able to continue with their research and contribute equally to family life?

What if she is the cancer researcher and he is an investment banker? She earns less than him, so should she quit her job/be the default parent so that he can maximise his earning potential? Should she be the one to cover all the sick days, pick up the slack at home etc?

Why is it always the perception that men with big important jobs couldn't possibly be expected to pull their weight at home, whereas women on equally big important jobs somehow seem to manage? I wonder...

SouthLondonMum22 · 26/06/2023 09:31

GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 08:36

Do people do no planning around having children then? Or not think about whether it’s a good idea to have children with someone that’s never around when there are no/few childcare options?

Only women.

Several on this thread alone have talked about giving up jobs that included a lot of travel. Men aren't expected to do that though.

I wouldn't have married someone with a job that involved extensive travel because I'd be unwilling to parent alone.

Grumpyfroghats · 26/06/2023 09:30

newstart1234 · 26/06/2023 09:25

His wife is also a high-flying diplomat. Maybe wrong, but I think you'd have to be fairly enthusiastic about your career progression to get to that level, which indicates that she was interested and motivated to see her career progress in that way. It's not for everyone though.

His wife is the ambassador

newstart1234 · 26/06/2023 09:25

Grumpyfroghats · 26/06/2023 09:15

No one told the spouse to the current British ambassador to the US to stay at home with the kids...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Roxburgh

His wife is also a high-flying diplomat. Maybe wrong, but I think you'd have to be fairly enthusiastic about your career progression to get to that level, which indicates that she was interested and motivated to see her career progress in that way. It's not for everyone though.

Grumpyfroghats · 26/06/2023 09:15

No one told the spouse to the current British ambassador to the US to stay at home with the kids...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Roxburgh

Charles Roxburgh - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Roxburgh

bussteward · 26/06/2023 08:56

anouskita · 26/06/2023 08:20

I don't understand some people on here. Not everyone has an office job with defined hours. If your husband was a diplomat to Kazakhstan, O suppose people on here would still say, 'sorry darling, you need to fly home every day at 5pm to load the dishwasher etc, so I can do my 40k office job that I hate but, you know.... 'feminism.' If he was a scientist on the brink of a cure for cancer, I suppose it's more important he does. 50/50 housework and enables you to do a routine job. If he's on the brink of millions (with a bit of effort), I suppose you'd say - "nooo DH. Leave that opportunity that could put our children through school, Uni, set them up for life and will mean we never have to worry about our pensions or mortgages and you can retire yourself ... Don't be silly. It's more important for me to work for a routine salary and we can just stay static and keep plodding along with a mortgage for ever.,,, " Er no.

No, but I’d expect a diplomat husband or one on the brink of millions to outsource enough help to enable me to exist as a human outside of my role as “mummy”. I think OP has been fairly clear she doesn’t actually want to give up work and be a SAHM, but she can’t see an alternative.

(As it happens one of the coolest women I know was the wife of a diplomat, three kids close in age, and absolutely refused to play the “diplomat wife” role – and her husband did everything to make sure she didn’t have to be subsumed by his role and motherhood.)

Otherwise the children of these high-flying male diplomats, scientists (it’s always the cure for cancer, isn’t it?), millionaires, etc, grow up seeing men achieving great things but doing nothing domestic, and women giving up work and doing nothing but the domestic, and the cycle continues for another generation.

There are also plenty of Big Jobs that aren’t office jobs that don’t have defined hours, but that also aren’t international diplomat/curing cancer/making millions. Why are those jobs (and indeed the strawman jobs in your scenarios) more worthy than a routine salary, than an “ordinary job”, than OP’s or any woman’s desire to work outside the home? Where do you draw the line: is it money-based? Is it what the job achieves? Who defines what is an important job Vs a routine one? What happens if both parents are on the brink of curing cancer but can’t stretch to a nanny?

newstart1234 · 26/06/2023 08:55

GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 08:36

Do people do no planning around having children then? Or not think about whether it’s a good idea to have children with someone that’s never around when there are no/few childcare options?

You can plan all you like but circumstances change in unpredictable ways when you have children. Unknown unknowns and all. Someone can work 9-5 at the point of planning a family and opportunities to progress come about in the next 10-20 years following which require different or additional commitments. You also can't predict or plan for the needs of each child which can vary wildly. Again, unknown unknowns.

Toooldtoworry · 26/06/2023 08:47

@Bluewatersummer I get it, and I feel you are validated in giving up work if you feel it would work for your family currently.

Zanatdy · 26/06/2023 08:37

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 17:09

@Sissynova but then what do you suggest, seriously? DH gets a job that pays poorly and I work FT just so that my job isn’t a ‘hobby’? More stress less money but everything is ‘fair.’

I’m not sure I want to be a SAHM! But once my DC1 starts school, it will be tough, there’s no two ways about it. I’ll have to drop him at school for wraparound care then drop my DC2 at nursery then onto work myself, same thing in reverse at the end of the day. illness is tough to manage as are things like eg the strikes and so on.

I’m not making any big decisions, there are benefits to me working but equally there are benefits to me NOT working.

That’s not too bad though is it? Millions of women (largely) do it every day. I used to drop both at separate places then run down to the train station and go into London 5 days a week. I had no family locally either. Their dad did help sometimes but largely fell to me. I mean if you want to be a SAHM, be one. You don’t have to justify it, but it will be do-able what you’re going to have to do a few days a week for a few years until both in same school. Once you’re in a routine it’s really not that bad

AmenAmin · 26/06/2023 08:36

anouskita · 26/06/2023 08:20

I don't understand some people on here. Not everyone has an office job with defined hours. If your husband was a diplomat to Kazakhstan, O suppose people on here would still say, 'sorry darling, you need to fly home every day at 5pm to load the dishwasher etc, so I can do my 40k office job that I hate but, you know.... 'feminism.' If he was a scientist on the brink of a cure for cancer, I suppose it's more important he does. 50/50 housework and enables you to do a routine job. If he's on the brink of millions (with a bit of effort), I suppose you'd say - "nooo DH. Leave that opportunity that could put our children through school, Uni, set them up for life and will mean we never have to worry about our pensions or mortgages and you can retire yourself ... Don't be silly. It's more important for me to work for a routine salary and we can just stay static and keep plodding along with a mortgage for ever.,,, " Er no.

And they’ll ignore people like me who say they have up work and the world didn’t fall apart. I was teaching, next to nothing after childcare, stressed and sad. Quit, had years off then got a flexible job, mainly working from home that’s more per hour and zero stress. Not a career in the same way, but I just don’t care. Life is good, I love it. Work pays enough to live.

GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 08:36

anouskita · 26/06/2023 08:20

I don't understand some people on here. Not everyone has an office job with defined hours. If your husband was a diplomat to Kazakhstan, O suppose people on here would still say, 'sorry darling, you need to fly home every day at 5pm to load the dishwasher etc, so I can do my 40k office job that I hate but, you know.... 'feminism.' If he was a scientist on the brink of a cure for cancer, I suppose it's more important he does. 50/50 housework and enables you to do a routine job. If he's on the brink of millions (with a bit of effort), I suppose you'd say - "nooo DH. Leave that opportunity that could put our children through school, Uni, set them up for life and will mean we never have to worry about our pensions or mortgages and you can retire yourself ... Don't be silly. It's more important for me to work for a routine salary and we can just stay static and keep plodding along with a mortgage for ever.,,, " Er no.

Do people do no planning around having children then? Or not think about whether it’s a good idea to have children with someone that’s never around when there are no/few childcare options?

Zanatdy · 26/06/2023 08:31

We always made it work. I say we. Largely me as my ex worked overseas for most of their childhood. 18 & 15 now, time flies. Mine had a lot of sickness too, but I never considered for one minute quitting my job.

anouskita · 26/06/2023 08:20

I don't understand some people on here. Not everyone has an office job with defined hours. If your husband was a diplomat to Kazakhstan, O suppose people on here would still say, 'sorry darling, you need to fly home every day at 5pm to load the dishwasher etc, so I can do my 40k office job that I hate but, you know.... 'feminism.' If he was a scientist on the brink of a cure for cancer, I suppose it's more important he does. 50/50 housework and enables you to do a routine job. If he's on the brink of millions (with a bit of effort), I suppose you'd say - "nooo DH. Leave that opportunity that could put our children through school, Uni, set them up for life and will mean we never have to worry about our pensions or mortgages and you can retire yourself ... Don't be silly. It's more important for me to work for a routine salary and we can just stay static and keep plodding along with a mortgage for ever.,,, " Er no.

GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 08:19

I guess the difference is that we planned the changes needed to go from two people able to push careers unfettered to what two people would need to do when a child came along without detriment of one party.

BIL and SIL had 3 babies in 5 years. She went back full
time at 9 months each time, chasing promotions etc. (They had pretty full on help with childcare and domestic stuff from PIL, admittedly.)

Anywho, fast forward 3 years and BIL is made redundant from his job unexpectedly. The market he works in has shrunk and he can’t get another job at a similar salary, so he starts a business. No doubt it will be successful at some point. At the moment it’s in the money guzzling phase. SIL is the one keeping them afloat. Had she quit work to look after the kids they’d have been down the river without a paddle.

Bluewatersummer · 26/06/2023 08:15

Apologies missed the last post, started typing then got distracted Blush

OP posts:
Bluewatersummer · 26/06/2023 08:15

OK stealth but I really do feel whatever I say isn’t good enough to be honest. I have said and pretty nicely that I just posted a few days ago fretting and being a bit daft due to an exceptionally bad run with illness - I don’t think I deserve the personal comments tbh.

OP posts:
stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 08:02

Anyway, I will bow out now. I wish you luck and hope the rest of the pregnancy and birth goes well!

stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 08:00

but no one is pushing it as a solution - merely as an alternative. Plenty of solutions have been suggested from additional /alternative childcare to cleaners but apparently none of them work. And ultimately you are pondering doing something drastic (giving up work) which you don’t want to do. I honestly genuinely find it madness that you would take this all on yourself without thinking about whether there are other ways you could structure family life differently. Plenty of women have posted about changing jobs or working differently post kids. It’s part of the deal. This is why the thread has derailed into “feminism” discussions - because you are having to bear ALL the burden of having kids.

Franticbutterfly · 26/06/2023 07:53

I used to work evenings and weekends when mine were little to keep earning (a bit of) my own money. It did leave me a bit stuck in dead end jobs as I gave up a decent career that would have me earning the same as DH is on now had I continued with it, but honestly I wouldn't have wanted the stress or trying to "do it all". I still don't work FT now 15 years later and am studying for a career that will only ever be pt (although the money is equivalent to most ft jobs). There's more to life than work! Enjoy your children, but have a plan and keep your hand in with something.

Bluewatersummer · 26/06/2023 07:49

stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 06:53

The point would be that it would enable him to parent his kids, which he doesn’t do now as he is unreliable and flitting in and out of family life. That you can’t see that is absolutely mind blowing.

Stealth, I genuinely don’t see that he isn’t parenting his children. He is. But he is sometimes away … that’s all really. Like most people we have a life based on a certain level of income and if I did what you wanted me to do, we’d have to move house, I’d probably have to go back sooner after maternity leave, and so on.

You seem to think it would be as simple as DH applying for and getting another job that pays similarly (or at least, only a little less) and I keep trying to explain to you that that’s not what it is like. Even for me, there’s no way I could get a different job that pays as well as my current one with no prior experience or qualifications in that field and I don’t earn as much.

And money isn’t the most important thing but to drastically reduce our income to the extent that is being pushed at me here especially at the moment I do think would be beyond foolish. I also think it would lead to a huge rift and resentment in this family and beyond even if DH agreed to it.

Can you imagine (honestly) I do what you think I should do here and I insist DH gets a different job. He no longer travels round the country or abroad but he’s permanently based in the nearest city. He earns so much less than he once did, he’s lost the flexibility, the bonuses and everything else. Can you really not see that that’s going to ultimately make him so unhappy and resent me and that would end the relationship?

As it is, I know DH loves me and our DS and will love this child when he or she arrives. He can take a certain amount of flexibility - eg in the weeks after the birth he will be wfh (as I will be having a c section) but as I’ve tried to explain it’s other times when things are unpredictable that are harder.

I really don’t want to argue and I’ve repeatedly said this. But what a minority of posters are pushing as the solution would be absolute madness!

OP posts:
SunnySomer · 26/06/2023 07:45

I stopped working and don’t regret it at all. DH regularly works overseas and I was quite overwhelmed with the idea of juggling everything. Before I did so:

  • we agreed how our money would work for both of us
  • i was registered for child benefit (didn’t receive it as not eligible) to ensure state pension contributions
  • We put extra savings into ISAs to act as a pension for me and went through our plans in case of disaster
  • i kept up membership of the chartered organisation I belonged to so I could return to work (cost a bit but not crazy amount)
  • we made sure our wills were sorted properly
It worked for us. But I’m fortunate that my DH is quite respectful and seemed to comprehend what was being done at home. We all found the transition back to me working full time difficult- cleaners truly don’t solve all the problems as someone mentioned above. It’s really worth sitting down together and sorting out all the detail before the baby is born. But do remember there is no right way - people will judge and question your decisions whatever you do, just work out what’s right for your family. Good luck!
GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 07:31

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/06/2023 07:19

What would be the actual point of the higher earner in a family doing less hours, so that OP can do more hours for less money? It's cutting off the nose to spite the face.

I guess if you see money as the most important thing, then you're right. It makes more sense for the higher earner to work all hours and for the person with lower earning potential to pick up all of the domestic stuff.

Money is not all-important for me, though, so I see it differently. I see value in both parents having a close, hands-on relationship with their children. I see value in both parents having a life and an identity outside of the home. I see value in modelling a more equal division of responsibilities to your children. And I see advantages in both parents retaining their earning potential.

I see the logic in your thinking. I just don't agree that money is the only consideration.

Sorry, meant to quote this. 😴

GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 07:30

ABSOLUTELY.

This is also what creates different choices for our daughters.