Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
Parisj · 21/06/2023 12:27

Women don't just earn less coincidentally though, it's a systemic and societal pay gap. Which gets entrenched by the exact choice you are making right now. So you either polarise the situation more and effectively sacrifice yourself for the good of the whole family system by stopping work (and slightly inevitably losing some of that adult time and role outside the home) or you trudge on juggling and everything is more difficult for everyone (but it passes, and flexible employment and good childcare can mitigate). There's no right answer to the conundrum, and both choices will have a heap of positives too, but one or both of you do need some flexibility to make both working work well. Personally I trudged on part time and I now have grown up children, a career I love and an improving pension. But I nearly burnt out.

yut · 21/06/2023 12:27

When someone has a name in their user name and are writing controversial things it's worthwhile taking what they say with a pinch of salt.

yut · 21/06/2023 12:25

@Sarahtm35 yeah I don't know why he bothered to have kids if he's not going to be with them himself though? Letting you raise them? What's the point?

Grumpyfroghats · 21/06/2023 12:21

HotPenguin · 21/06/2023 12:15

A lot of people on MN talk about an ideal where both parents work near full-time, sharing the responsibility for pick up and drop off equally. But in the real world this doesn't work for the vast majority of people. Main reasons being:
-Many people are required to travel for work which means they then cannot pick up or drop off
-Kids get ill very frequently
-Few kids are happy to spend most of the school holidays in holiday camps, and even if they are, its very expensive and difficult to find places.

-Most well paid jobs, as well as many lower paid jobs, don't fit within nursery or school wrap around care hours, particularly if you are commuting for an hour or more.

I can think of perhaps three families I know where both parents work near full time. Two have only one child, the other has parents helping out most days to ferry to and from school.

Interesting - we both work four days (compressed hours so basically full time) with two children and no family support. It's really fine but I agree that there are some important factors:

Neither of us have to travel frequently for work and we both WFH two days a week

Our children are sometimes ill but it's not that common - this whole school year, one has had one day off, that's it.

They don't need to spend most of their holiday in holiday club because we have 6 weeks of annual leave each - and they are fine with the 3 weeks or so that they do spend.

Our school wraparound is very reliable and 7:30-6:30 - we don't use the full hours but it's reassuring to know that if we are held up at work, it's alright

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 12:19

@HotPenguin I think this is what I’ve been realising. Because if I insisted everything was equal I could potentially impede DHs career progression which would have more of an effect than my career progression stalling or stopping. Which is unfair but only in the sense that different jobs pay differently.

OP posts:
Xmasbaby11 · 21/06/2023 12:19

part time work is the answer. I worked 3 days a week and it was a great balance. 2 year age gap, no family help. It all worked fine. Dc were in nursery initially, then nursery and school, then school and wraparound

Not sure about all the panic about illness. Yes they were off here and there, but only 3 days a week to cover between us so wasn’t that bad.

my dc are 9 and 11 so this was pre wfh days - it would actually be easier now with both of us having more flexibility. We still use the cm for wraparound and holidays as school holidays are long.

I wouldn’t want to give up work personally but I enjoy work, it’s good for me on many ways and worth the effort of juggling childcare.

Beseen22 · 21/06/2023 12:18

I've worked full time, SAHM and part time over the past 6 years that I have been a mum.

Full time; incredibly difficult, always juggling, guilt from not being there and then guilt for my head not being in the game at work because I wanted to be with my DS. Needed a lot of support from grandparents at that time, wasn't sustainable for us.
SAHM; was pregnant and 2yo. Very enjoyable and stress free without time constraints. It was always going to be temporary but I did miss my job and felt a bit stressed about needing to work enough hours to revalidate and continue to be able to work my profession.
Parttime; definitely my favourite of the bunch. I'm lucky to work nightshift and tend to just do one a week so can easily work around the kids and I get to be at every drop off and pick up and never miss a school event but also continue professional development and maintain the career that I trained so hard to do.

Personally for us I wouldn't go SAHM again. We have been through a 6 month redundancy for my DH and I wouldn't risk not being able to immediately pick up shifts and be able to pay the mortgage while he looks for another job. Full time wouldn't work for us as we have no family support here.

Dixiechickonhols · 21/06/2023 12:17

Your scenario is different from both working similar jobs and being able to share childcare.
If he’s so much higher earning and away a lot You know it’s going to be you doing most of childcare for practical reasons.
I’d run through all the scenarios.
If a career break is right for your set up go for it.
i’d want to keep up skills either pt, training, re training.

RosesAndHellebores · 21/06/2023 12:16

Different things work for different people. I'm a planner and despite not getting married before my mid 30s, I had a strong maternal urge from when I was a child.

I had a career from 20 to 35 in the City, earnt a lot, bought my own house, stashed into a pension as part of the foundation for future security/choice re giving up work. By 34 I was burnt out, DH was earlier in his career and had excellent long term prospects. Therefore I could give up work and focus on the dc which I did for 7 years. It was marvellous and I got NI contrivutions for those years towards my state pension.

I went back to work part-time initially, in the public sector in my early 40s and was sponsored to do prof quals. 20 years on work at director level.

An au-pair sorted the DC after school, did the laundry, tidied their rooms and cooked their dinner. A cleaner cleaned.

It worked well for us and there has been little detriment regarding my pension. Full state contributions (35 years) and about 75% final salary occupational pension.

We took the decision jointly and could because of the pre marriage cushion I had. Also dh never questioned any household or child related expenditure and didn't for a second ever resent my personal expenditure.

HotPenguin · 21/06/2023 12:15

A lot of people on MN talk about an ideal where both parents work near full-time, sharing the responsibility for pick up and drop off equally. But in the real world this doesn't work for the vast majority of people. Main reasons being:
-Many people are required to travel for work which means they then cannot pick up or drop off
-Kids get ill very frequently
-Few kids are happy to spend most of the school holidays in holiday camps, and even if they are, its very expensive and difficult to find places.

-Most well paid jobs, as well as many lower paid jobs, don't fit within nursery or school wrap around care hours, particularly if you are commuting for an hour or more.

I can think of perhaps three families I know where both parents work near full time. Two have only one child, the other has parents helping out most days to ferry to and from school.

Kilorrery · 21/06/2023 12:15

Sarahtm35 · 21/06/2023 11:47

My husband is a man and his job is to provide for us. But when our youngest was born very ill and he took time off, he shared the hospital stay with me. He’s a great father, a great provider and he takes his role as a father very seriously. He would have never put me in a position where I felt the pressure to work when they were babies and on his 1 day off a week he always spends it with the children. We’ve always put our children first and the defined roles have enabled us to do that successfully. Besides my children were worth 3 years of putting my career on hold.

You seem to be equating the role of ‘provider’ with being male. That is your own gender essentialism talking. I am my child’s mother and I ‘provide’ for him too, as does my DH, just as we both parent him and love him equally.

I think it’s deeply bizarre that you talk about how your DH didn’t ‘put pressure on you to work’, as if he was doing you a favour? What about whether he enabled you to continue your career, by either taking a step back in his own or working flexibly to do half of pick ups and drop offs or to stay at home some days, or to cover sickness? Or wouldn’t he have facilitated you continuing to work, to the possible detriment of his own career?

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 12:13

Comtesse · 21/06/2023 12:08

This is why part time work was invented. It’s not a binary choice between work full time or not at all.

I think this was meant to be biting and sarcastic and I don’t know why.

I realise part time work has many advantages but it also brings many problems with it. If I only work three days a week but DC throws up on Monday, it looks worse in a way taking the whole of my working week off (Monday - Wednesday) than it would if I was in all week.

It is less money (obviously) and less paid into a pension.

It can make life difficult when you’re actually in work - missing things, deadline is Friday but I have to get it done by Wednesday as am not here Friday. That sort of thing.

If I continue with PT work, I still have to navigate wraparound care and pick ups and drop offs and childhood illnesses for three days a week PLUS actually work!

OP posts:
BeachBlondey · 21/06/2023 12:10

I think the trick is to work part time, so that you are keeping your hand in, but you're not totally frazzled. Time away from the kids is good for you. You get your work clothes on, put your make-up on, have some adult time. You are still making pension contributions, and critically would have no massive gaps on your CV.

In my first marriage, my then H suggested that I give up work. We could have afforded this, but I chose to keep working in a professional environment, just 15 hours a week, gradually working my way back up to full time, as the children grew. Thank goodness I did, because years later we divorced (due to his cheating) and I had that job to keep me going.

pumpkintart · 21/06/2023 12:09

If it works for you and your family then yes I would.

Sounds like your partner is out of the country and travels a huge amount for work therefore it makes sense for you to need more flexibility.

However if the thought of it makes you unhappy then don't do it and hire a nanny, turn over is much lower, kids get 121 care, majority will also chip in with very basic bits around the house and will look after kids who are poorly (obviously not hospital poorly).

Feminism for me is having choices and the confidence to follow those choices free from fear. It sounds like you have that.

Comtesse · 21/06/2023 12:08

This is why part time work was invented. It’s not a binary choice between work full time or not at all.

SilverCatStripes · 21/06/2023 12:07

I’m going to give a different viewpoint for you to think about OP, I never planned on giving up work but during my maternity leave our plans had to change and I gave up work.

I absolutely loved it! (And this is coming from my dream job which I adored by the way , so this was a real surprise to me !)

We had another DC a few years later and once she was full time at Primary I returned to work , and now I work in HR for the NHS (around school hours) and family life is fantastic , and work is also fantastic.
And I wouldn’t trade those early years for any amount of money !

It’s worth mentioning that - our mortgage can be paid for on one salary , and in the event we do spilt I will receive a portion of DHs pension.

Anyway the point I wanted to make was that being a SAHP can be the right choice for some mums (or dads).

Catspyjamas17 · 21/06/2023 12:05

I did as I was stressed out of my mind and had depression - combining a demanding job with young children was extremely difficult, and something had to give, if I hadn't given up my job I probably wouldn't be here today. I turned it into a career break and just did something else for a couple of years which only earned a fraction of what I'd earned before but meant I could be at home- and retain my sanity.

SimonsCow · 21/06/2023 12:01

Depends on a lot of things really. Your work and how flexible they are. Your wrap around care.

For us, a childminder was the answer. Both kids went to the same one who does pick ups and drop offs at the nearby primary school. In theory I could drop them both off at 7 there and pick them up at the same place. I want to be present at the school gates though, so I do the morning drop off myself which means I don’t start work til 9.30 and my work are fine with me either doing an extra half hour in the evening or taking a shorter lunch.

Champsandbubbles · 21/06/2023 12:01

Sarahtm35 · 21/06/2023 11:23

Personally I think it’s anti-feminist for a women to have to give birth and then go out to work, it’s also not very kind to the child either.
having worked in childcare, I can tell you these children who spend all day in a childcare setting are not happy and a lot of the parents refuse to acknowledge it as they’re too busy with work and life.
I understand many women have no choice but to work, but if you’re husband earns enough or you’re able to make cutbacks to stay home, then I think that’s the kindest thing to do for your child.

Comments like yours infuriate me and I'm not sure if it intends to make that type of parent i.e. make me feel terrible.

  1. We have no family support so we rely upon childcare for our children so we can work to provide them a roof over their head, food in their stomachs and a good quality life.
  1. Why is it my husband should carry on in his career which is substantially more senior to mine with a better salary, continue to work and never worry about relying on someone else and having financial security. Unlike if I stopped working.
  1. Why should I have to give up my good career and independence to become a SAHM because I earn less. Very good salary just not like his.
  1. Why should I become the financially vulnerable one that if my marriage breaks down I have no financial security but my husband will be perfectly fine.

Our decision isn't a case of making our children miserable in childcare it's about giving them a good quality of life with maintaining financial independence now and into later years.

I have no issues of people taking the SAHM route that's their choice, of course I would love not to have the pressure of work and family and just concentrate on family it seems nice. You choose the right choice for you. In my experience SAHM continue to send children to nurseries when they don't work and still don't return FT when kids at school. That is their choice but please stop telling parents that if their children go to childcare full time they're miserable because I can assure you they're not.

Is it hard to work and maintain a family , absolutely it is, there's a lot to do but not impossible.

Shinier · 21/06/2023 12:00

@Sarahtm35 you do you. But stop hectoring others.

mummymeister · 21/06/2023 11:59

when did choosing to not go into paid work but to look after the children - the ones that you made a positive choice to have because you wanted them - become non - feminist? I am a feminist. so is my dh. we made a positive choice for one of us to not work to raise the children the way we wanted them to be raised. not to be raised by a succession of randoms who might not have the same views on things as we do. We spent a couple of years with me doing it and then both decided to start our own business so that we could both have the stay at home role. This idea that somehow you are "less" if you choose to devote your time and effort to other human beings is bonkers in my opinion.

ContinuousProcrastination · 21/06/2023 11:59

Remember op you probably have as much as 30+ years of your working life left after children.

Women who leave the workplace entirely for a few years tend to struggle to return to it, vs those who stay working, even part time or treading water a bit while kids are young. These women are then faced with a skill & experience gap, lack of confidence, partners who are used to not pitching in at home/with kids, and employers reluctance to invest in retraining older staff. People also tend to allow housework and life admin to fill their time quite inefficiently in a way that makes it quite overwhelming to consider adding in work outside the home. These factor combine to form a huge hurdle and lead to women getting stuck in unfulfilling, low paid work, with poor pension provision.

Add in marriage breakdown and the fact that men typically die before women and you have a lot of struggling older women, spousal maintenence is incredibly rare now so there's an expectation that you have the capacity to support yourself financially. Don't give it up lightly.

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:59

@mindutopia I’m with you on that. Gap between DC1 and 2 will mean that after my maternity leave there’s only one year of them both at home before DC1 starts school and then DC1 will have some free nursery hours. So there is that.

My ‘worry’ I suppose is that we are all tired and stretched every which way.

OP posts:
BigGreen · 21/06/2023 11:57

I chose to slow down career progression by going part time (3, then 4 days pw). Now back up to full time with the kids at school. I wouldn't have wanted to give up, I hate chores and would have resented the household management role that inevitably comes with staying at home. I also want things for myself, care about pension, to feel secure if DH were to get sick or leave.

Comedycook · 21/06/2023 11:57

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:53

I think sex is interchangeable. I wish I was the higher earner and could be an excellent role model, but I’m not. It isn’t about giving up work because I’m a woman, it’s about potentially giving up work because I don’t earn as much.

@Comedycook you can throw money up to a point but the problem is if the nanny leaves or is sick or goes on maternity leave … what then? I don’t think there is watertight childcare unfortunately.

That's true...no childcare is watertight. I'd say though I think a nanny is the best option logistically. So in my case, I had a baby who would have needed a nursery or childminder. Another DC in school. That's two locations to get them to. School is 9-3 so you need breakfast and after school club. You need a commute which allows you to get kids to their locations and to work on time. As for school, you have 14 weeks holiday a year. Childcare settings won't take your kids if they're ill. Its a nightmare...hence why I gave up work. Money will give you more choices...so an emergency nanny from an agency if things go wrong. But unless you have money or family support, you're screwed