Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 13:53

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 13:45

Feminism means being able to raise your children yourself if you want to. (many people prefer to work and that’s fine also) Just because the system is so messed up at the moment that very few people can run a home or family without two full time incomes doesn’t mean the system is right or makes sense in terms of meeting our wider needs as humans.

It doesn't mean that though.

Every time this topic comes up someone wheels out the "feminism is about choice" line. (Or my other favourite bit of bollocks, that being a SAHM is a "valid choice" -- which means absolutely nothing. Of course its "valid").

Of course it's everyone's right not to work if they have sufficient money coming into the home that they don't have to. That's fine and understandable. But I really wish people would stop presenting it as "feminism". It's not feminism, by any stretch of the imagination.

Feminism would mean equality. Equality would mean equality of income or equity or financial security. It would mean that a man is just as likely to be at home as a woman. It would mean a woman is paid on par with a man for doing equal work. And it would mean that in couples where both parents work, the man and the woman are both doing their equal share of childcare and domestic tasks.

The reality, where in nine out of ten cases its the woman who downgrades her career to favour the man's is manifestly nothing to do with feminism. And the more women choose to do this (or have it forced on them), the less feminism there is because the harder it is for those of us who have to do it to support our families.

So please by all means take career breaks or stop work altogether if you want do. But be honest enough to admit that you do it because want to do it and stop whitewashing it as feminism.

Well said.

I also want to add that working parents also raise their children. Nurseries/nannies etc care for children but they don't raise them.

AuntieJune · 21/06/2023 13:53

These threads always imply there has to be some kind of consensus and one size fits all. There are so, so, so many variables that it's impossible to say. There are pros and cons in both directions.

I do think that the duration of struggling with this (five years-ish?) might be shorter than the duration of impact on earning ability and career progression, which is lifelong really. And you're putting all your eggs in one basket to rely on DH to earn.

I wrestle with this but do 3 days in 4 so I finish at 3pm each day and can get the kids. I'm restless and bored but it's still probably the best option for now. I have DC at school-hours, term-time nursery and DC in year 1.

Tudorfish · 21/06/2023 13:52

Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels!

I think staying home to look after your children is a feminist choice. I watch women exhaust themselves with full time work, pick ups/drop offs, arranging holiday cover etc whilst The Man with the Big Job just concentrates on being Busy and Important.

If all wives/partners stopped being so accommodating I'm sure that - with a few exceptions - the Big Man would find out he didn't really need to be in Swindon at 8pm - he could be home putting his kids to bed instead.

Weal · 21/06/2023 13:49

I think making the choice for one person to stop paid employment is fine, so long as they are equally considered in terms on finances (eg a pension is being paid into and same access to savings as the employed person). Also some thought given to how the person giving up employment can keep up skills etc to be able to renter work force. also the person working should recognise that they don’t get to opt out of parenting completely.

I would never NEVER give up work and no have any savings, or pensions etc and take on ALL of the parenting 24/7.

yut · 21/06/2023 13:48

@newstart1234 so you do think about the future then 🤷‍♀️

MrsAvocet · 21/06/2023 13:47

Shinyandnew1 · 21/06/2023 12:56

I lost my job tomorrow we wouldn’t really notice; if DH did, it would be catastrophic.

What would you do for housing/income if your DH left you for someone else tomorrow? I think giving up work completely is a scary prospect, even if you think your relationship is rock solid.

Indeed. And whilst everyone tends to think this kind of thing will never happen to them, it can, and does. A "blissfully happily married" friend of mine has just been dumped for another woman. She had only intended to take a few years out of work when they had their first baby, then they had more, then everyone was used to it and she never went back. Her STBXH waited until the youngest child had started University so he has no child support obligations and there's no reason why she can't work so he walks away basically scot free. She is now a middle aged woman who despite having a decent degree is working long hours in a minimum wage job to keep afloat. With no recent work experience there is zero possibility of her returning to her pre children career and whilst she could in theory still retrain in something else, she has bills to pay in the meantime so she's stuck.
And its not just infidelity. Partners get ill, injured or even die unfortunately. I left work some years ago after a perfectly normal day. There were documents open on my desk ready for the next morning. Except someone hit me head on on the wrong side of the road on my way home and I never went back to work again. That was never in my life plan! Shit happens, and it doesn't care who it happens to. In my opinion everyone should maintain as much financial independence as they can, because none of us knows what's round the corner (literally in my case!)
Of course if people choose to take that risk that's there business, but don't pretend it's not a risk or assume that nothing could happen to you.

newstart1234 · 21/06/2023 13:47

yut · 21/06/2023 13:10

I like making plans for then next few weeks or months but it doesn't occur to me to plan for something in 30ish years. I could well die before then.

Ok....sounds sensible...

I have a decent pension (paid into without any breaks - my DHs improving salary covered this for years) so I do think it's sensible now to focus on the present not live for the future.

I admire the woman people who manage to make it work with little children, but it's not for everyone, and the stress is not worth the extra pension payments or career progression for many. Kudos to those who don't experience stress or burnout throughout this time working full time with a family but ime they are in the minority, amongst both mothers and fathers. In fact I've never met any (maybe my circle is exceptional in this way).

Surprisedbysummer · 21/06/2023 13:47

I also have seen a significant proportion of the older Stay at home forever women develop dementia which women are far more likely to get than men and which some studies suggest is caused by isolation and not having a job. Jobs protect your brains.

JustMarriedBecca · 21/06/2023 13:46

I kept my job but "leaned out" aka went part time and was prepared to be the one to take unpaid parental leave.

It was frustrating when incompetent men were promoted above me but I shut my eyes to it and reminded myself the job was about keeping my hand in for when the situation would be more manageable.

I know too many women whose husband's started shagging their secretary or taking them for granted and they were stuck because they had elected to be a SAHP to take the risk.

Until the kids were at school I
(1) was always the one to take days unpaid to cover sickness
(2) took unpaid parental leave to cover the school holidays
(3) Did the majority of childmin.

The kids are now older. I'm back at work full time, although from home with compressed hours around after-school and before-school childcare two days a week. My husband and I both classify as "high earners".

I think it depends on the industry you're in. In law, it's almost impossible to get back in if you stop completely. A lot of friends have qualified into teaching as a route back into work but that obviously isn't without its pressures (they say less than full time corporate law incidentally)

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/06/2023 13:46

Well, I wouldn't, personally, but it's your choice.

I would never willingly make myself financially dependent on another person. I wouldn't sacrifice my own earning potential, career progression and pension. I wouldn't want to lose my professional skills, confidence in my abilities and my opportunities for ongoing growth and development. And I wouldn't want to give up the aspects of my identity that are associated with my career, or the sense of achievement and purpose that I get from what I do, or the social contact that I enjoy through work.

But that's me. If none of those things are important to you and you think you would be happier at home, then fair enough. There is no one "right" way to live. Just make sure that you plan to protect yourself as best you can in case things go wrong.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 13:45

Feminism means being able to raise your children yourself if you want to. (many people prefer to work and that’s fine also) Just because the system is so messed up at the moment that very few people can run a home or family without two full time incomes doesn’t mean the system is right or makes sense in terms of meeting our wider needs as humans.

It doesn't mean that though.

Every time this topic comes up someone wheels out the "feminism is about choice" line. (Or my other favourite bit of bollocks, that being a SAHM is a "valid choice" -- which means absolutely nothing. Of course its "valid").

Of course it's everyone's right not to work if they have sufficient money coming into the home that they don't have to. That's fine and understandable. But I really wish people would stop presenting it as "feminism". It's not feminism, by any stretch of the imagination.

Feminism would mean equality. Equality would mean equality of income or equity or financial security. It would mean that a man is just as likely to be at home as a woman. It would mean a woman is paid on par with a man for doing equal work. And it would mean that in couples where both parents work, the man and the woman are both doing their equal share of childcare and domestic tasks.

The reality, where in nine out of ten cases its the woman who downgrades her career to favour the man's is manifestly nothing to do with feminism. And the more women choose to do this (or have it forced on them), the less feminism there is because the harder it is for those of us who have to do it to support our families.

So please by all means take career breaks or stop work altogether if you want do. But be honest enough to admit that you do it because want to do it and stop whitewashing it as feminism.

Surprisedbysummer · 21/06/2023 13:43

So many women give up work for a few years but never actually go back. Or they go back very part time. It is a significant percentage of the unemployment total. Some women just get out of the habit of working and stay at home throughout their children's time at secondary. Then they start to look after their elderly parents ( not their husband's parents, just their own Mum and Dad. Then they hit retirement. I have seen so many of my friends give up work in their early fifties or simply never return after being a SAHM.
The early fifties can be a time when some husbands get fed up of being the sole breadwinner and walk out which can lead women to be stuffed with regard to coping alone.

OhForFucksFuckingSake · 21/06/2023 13:42

I did this. DH is a highly-skilled massive geek in a niche industry and I was a generic Jack of all trades middle-management type in a jib I didn't particularly love and which paid me a third of what DH was earning.

After our second child I thought 'fuck this'. Quit my job and retrained in something else lower paid that would let me fit around childcare.

DH pays into a pension for me so I don't lose out on that. I also own half our house despite not paying anything towards the mortgage. My money is our 'fun money'. He pays the bills and I pay for the holidays and treats.

I realise the only way we're able to do this is because DH is one of those fabled Mumsnet High Earning Husbands (TM) and by most standards we're very privileged. But there was no way I was going to burn myself out doing a 5 day a week, 8-6 job, and do everything at home as well, just so I could keep my pension contributions up.

Fuck that. If DH wants to be such a big swinging dick at work that he can't take a day off to look after the kids when they're sick, then I'll take the career hit but he can keep my pension contributions up instead!

PucketyPuckPuck · 21/06/2023 13:40

I have a very strong, happy marriage but I would never put myself in a position where I was unemployed and dc and I were solely dependent on DH, for many reasons. We have 3 dc between 5 and 15 and I've been continuously employed throughout. I've dabbled with dropping hours for a while when dc were babies but only because my employer was flexible and I had a guarantee of being able to return to FT hours when I was ready (which I did). If they'd not been in agreement i'd have stayed full time.

I understand why some women want to be SAHMs but unless you have substantial personal wealth it's an extremely risky move...and what your husband earns is irrelevant to that level of risk.

If your dh dumped you or had a MH crisis and chucked in his job or an awful accident or illness you'd be absolutely fucked. I'm always surprised at the amount of women who are willing toaccept that level of risk for both themselves and their dc.

Sosejbrechdan · 21/06/2023 13:39

If women don’t want to work then I wish they’d just own that fact instead of turning it into ‘I can’t afford to work’, ‘it’s too hard for me to work around my husbands job’.

If we are serious about equality then we need to force men to equally parent (& do household stuff) we need to force their employers to allow them flexible, family friendly working. That will only happen if we keep demanding it.

yutu · 21/06/2023 13:36

OP, I understand where you are coming from, unfortunately if you are like us, who do not have any help from famlies (both DH and mine are abroad), then it can be very hard.

Wether becoming a SAHM depends on your personal circumstances. Will you be financially secure if you drop your job? Is you DH supportive? Will he expect you to do everything? Will he appreciate you sacrificing your career for.family? A lot of people will tell you no, dont do it or why is it you who have to sacrifice etc, but they forget you are not only two individuals but also a team. You dont have to share all the duties half and half, it is up to you to work out whats the best for your family.

I am a SAHM with two primary school kids. When our younger one started school, I considered to go back to work, but if I really wanted a career, Id have to be full time. Otherwise, it will be some low paid part time jobs.

We discussed about this, getting a low paid part time job is not ideal, becuase we dont need that bit extra money to be honest, we have enough on one salary. If I go back to full time, that means we need to put kids to after school clubs. That means we need to drop their specific music lessons and sports trainnings. I will no longger have time to make sure they practice at home and learn a bit of my language. We will have to take annual leaves separately to cover school holidays and can no longger thake a long holiday to see grandparents abroad. Of course some people will say thats what most parents do, but we have decided it is better for us to have the lifestyle we have now.

We looked at our finances and made the decision together. My DH is the most wonderful hubby I must say, even though Im a SAHM, I dont do everything! When DH is not working he does as much as he can. I dont ever feel Im left to do everything. I take a lot of the mental load, but hubby is aware of that and he appreciates what I do. I am not ambitious either.

Finacially I also feel secure, we own a house which is under both names. He bought life insurance so if anything happens to him I will get a lot of money. I have access to all accounts and can spend money as I please. We are in the position to buy a second house so by the time we retire, there will be extra rental income to top up his private pension.

I wouldnt have made such decision if hubby is not supportive or of I am finacially vulnerable though.

Pinkdelight3 · 21/06/2023 13:35

*That's not a regular occurrence though

When I was working I used a huge proportion of my annual leave on looking after sick child. It doesn't need to be regular, but it's frequent.*

In your experience sure, but again not inevitable. It was occasional for us, definitely not frequent. Hugely depends on the kids and the work set-up, but unless a DC has a serious illness/condition, I don't think 'kids might be ill' is a good enough reason for a woman to give up work just in case.

MidsummerNightsDream · 21/06/2023 13:35

Why not? If you can afford to do it, then do it. I did and I loved it. Had a couple of 1 day a week jobs at times. Went back to work part time when youngest started infants. Went back full time just over a year ago (kids are 16 and 18 now). No regrets whatsoever.

DizzyRascal · 21/06/2023 13:32

BarbaraofSeville · 21/06/2023 11:17

Why does all the 'rushing and hassle' fall on you?

Why does your DH get to concentrate on work and nothing else?

Why has becoming a parent changed your life but not your DHs?

Why isn't your DH doing half of nursery runs, arranging wraparound care etc if he's not willing/able to adjust his working hours to accommodate his parental responsibilities?

That's what you need to be discussing with your DH rather than jumping straight to 'well I might as well give up work, my independence and my pension'.

Thats all that needs saying really. ^^

Callipsi · 21/06/2023 13:32

I did the very thing you’re thinking of when my eldest started school and it’s been wonderful tbh.

NoTouch · 21/06/2023 13:31

My mum was a SAHM, and dad brought home the bacon supported her as young naïve them discussed and agreed. As the dc flew the nest, she became redundant, her outdated skill set and lack of confidence for new technology in the workplace meant returning to work was difficult and dad ended up resenting her "doing nothing" and not contributing to the household budget. Without dc at home she became very needy and depressed.

They stayed together, but it was not happy for them. She couldn't leave and he felt a duty to stay and they both resented each other.

dh and I went down the route of no prioritising either of our jobs and shared childcare load equally. Mainly due to personal experience with my mum. One of us could have had a high flying career but the cost might have been too high for the other.

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 13:29

If you do give up, make sure your wills are in order, and consider life insurance for both of you in case you can't work/ do the childcare.

AperolWhore · 21/06/2023 13:29

I think in your position, if you can comfortably afford to give up work then I 100% would. Why struggle if you don’t have too?

Take a long hard look at your finances, can you keep your current lifestyle, what changes would you need to make. Consider your NI contributions to ensure it doesn’t impact your state pension.

VinoVeritas1 · 21/06/2023 13:28

Also don't forget - for many women, work gives them a sense of self-identify beyond being a mother, and also a bit of a break from being around baby All.The.Time. It is quite important for your mental health TBH

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 13:28

That's not a regular occurrence though

When I was working I used a huge proportion of my annual leave on looking after sick child. It doesn't need to be regular, but it's frequent.