Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
SchoolShenanigans · 21/06/2023 14:44

I wouldn't. You lose your identity on top of your financial independence.

I agree it makes sense practically, in the moment. But in the long term it leaves you very vulnerable.

Heartofglass12345 · 21/06/2023 14:44

I've done both and it is so much easier not to have to worry about child care. Summer holidays are so long and holiday clubs near me are non existent so I don't know how we would manage! When they were little I would go to work as soon as my husband got home, then wfh during the pandemic and that was a nightmare. It's just so much easier not to have to worry if they're ill etc. but obviously worry about money instead Confused

CheshireCat1 · 21/06/2023 14:39

Yes, I did come to a point for me when my oldest was born, I gave up work. 13 years and two more children later I started back going to work. During those 13 years I did voluntary work, went to night school, retrained and had the best time of my life with the kids. When I eventually did go back to work it was in a completely different career and I absolutely love it. My NI contributions are all covered for the 13 years at home, so I will get full state pension and since I’ve started back in work I contribute quite a bit into a private pension, I’ll probably be able to retire quite soon. I have a fantastic relationship with all my children and their partners, we’re all very close. My oldest has just started his family and even though him and his wife have good careers they’re both only going to work part time because they want their children to have a similar upbringing that my children had.
I understand it’s not for everyone and sacrifices have to be made, but looking back it was absolutely fabulous.

FirstTimeNameChanger · 21/06/2023 14:37

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 13:45

Feminism means being able to raise your children yourself if you want to. (many people prefer to work and that’s fine also) Just because the system is so messed up at the moment that very few people can run a home or family without two full time incomes doesn’t mean the system is right or makes sense in terms of meeting our wider needs as humans.

It doesn't mean that though.

Every time this topic comes up someone wheels out the "feminism is about choice" line. (Or my other favourite bit of bollocks, that being a SAHM is a "valid choice" -- which means absolutely nothing. Of course its "valid").

Of course it's everyone's right not to work if they have sufficient money coming into the home that they don't have to. That's fine and understandable. But I really wish people would stop presenting it as "feminism". It's not feminism, by any stretch of the imagination.

Feminism would mean equality. Equality would mean equality of income or equity or financial security. It would mean that a man is just as likely to be at home as a woman. It would mean a woman is paid on par with a man for doing equal work. And it would mean that in couples where both parents work, the man and the woman are both doing their equal share of childcare and domestic tasks.

The reality, where in nine out of ten cases its the woman who downgrades her career to favour the man's is manifestly nothing to do with feminism. And the more women choose to do this (or have it forced on them), the less feminism there is because the harder it is for those of us who have to do it to support our families.

So please by all means take career breaks or stop work altogether if you want do. But be honest enough to admit that you do it because want to do it and stop whitewashing it as feminism.

Yup. We can have countless 30 page threads where countless posters decide that giving up work is the best choice for them and their family. It may well be. But feminism it ain't!

Why don't men (in equal numbers to women) give up work and becoming financially dependent on another adult? Why do men have the higher paying career most of the time? Why is it the easier option for a woman to step away, even temporarily, from earning money?

It's not feminism because it's not equitable, and generally men come out better than women when these choices are made. This isn't to say it's the wrong choice for you OP. But I agree that 'deciding' to lose financial independence is not feminism. Possibly it's not even a real decision we make, and might even be something that is often decided for us.

Kingfishersperch · 21/06/2023 14:36

I was in a similar position. We had kids and I outearned my partner by approx 60k a year. He reduced to part time and then focused on increasing his skill set to earn more money and become self employed. He still earns significantly less than me (if you calculate our hourly rate) but he is paying into a pension and he has a career. His hours have increased over time.

I have made sure I pick up 2 days a week (he does the rest) to ensure he can work late etc. Yes this is a pain but I need to set an example at work too to junior staff who have kids.

The danger with being out of the work force is if you split up or he becomes sick or if he died. If any of these happen your world will be turned upside down financially as you will likely only get minimum wage. This is a large risk and is why Dh and I felt it was important for him to increase his skills. For a year or two increasing his skill was our priority. I felt it was crucial to ensure I didn’t just make childcare my dh issue each day. Also tax wise it’s crazy for me to earn more when he wasn’t utilising his full allowances.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 14:32

footballdramas · 21/06/2023 14:00

I don't think it's anti-feminist to do what's best for your kids and your family.

I gave up my office job when I had a baby as I moved away from the area where the jobs were. But I established a freelance career, very small at first but it has grown as I have had more time now after 12 years is probably close to paying what I earned at my old job.

Giving up work entirely is fine if you know there will be a job to go back to, or if you don't want to. Personally I am glad I kept my career ticking over now that my kids need me less. But I don't regret staying home for their early years.

It's not anti-feminist to do what's best for your kids and family. That's what the vast majority of people do (and ought to do).

But positioning being a SAHM as a "feminist choice" is disingenuous. It may be many things: practical, sensible, helpful, life-enhancing etc. But anything which has the effect of making it harder for women in general to be financially independent is not a feminist choice.

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 14:30

everyone’s situation is different and what works for you works for you. I couldn’t bring myself to stop working, I trust my husband but who knows what could happen and couldn’t fathom not having my own income. I also hate housework. A lot of SAHM miss out on full pension benefits too. It’s appealing but wasn’t enough for me.

CandlelightGlow · 21/06/2023 14:23

For me yes this was the best solution, it was for my mum too. We both kept working as our jobs are more stable and flexible.

I don't know how I'd manage with 3 young DC with sickness, holidays, events like parties and clubs, household running and both of us working full time. I don't know how I'd be able to progress in my career and pursue opportunities. I know people do! But I'm not in a high earning job and am just at the beginning of my career now DC are all born and no longer babies.

grimmers44 · 21/06/2023 14:21

I think you have to do what suits you and your family, but only if YOU are happy with that choice. My DH had way higher earning potential than me, so I worked P/T to fit around the family but I had no ambitious career plans anyway.

Notthefoggiest · 21/06/2023 14:11

I spent a decade following my husband round the country and doing peacemeal jobs around the kids so that his high paying career could be prioritised. He's now decided he's had enough of me and is off to spend his three figure salary on himself while I work full time and manage two kids. It would be a lot easier for me right now if my earning power hadn't been decimated by the time spent facilitating his career.

anouskita · 21/06/2023 14:10

OP, you will no doubt get the usual intense projecting now from people who, for their very own reasons, seem to think the very concept of a SAHM is an affront to their parenting or to their concept of feminism or whatever.

Their family is not your family, Their personality / motivations are not yours. Their job is not yours. Nor is their husband! It doesn't matter one bit what anyone else thinks. Ask 100 women and you will get 100 different scenarios.

Fwiw, I was in your position and never went back to work. As a family we have been more financially secure into the medium / long-term as a result. I could not have imagined us both working with three children. It's not compulsory! Far from it.

You know better than anyone else your financial circumstances and risk. Being a SAHM is absolutely fine. It's a personal choice only you can make.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 14:10

Grumpyfroghats · 21/06/2023 14:05

I am sometimes stressed by working and having young children - of course there are stressful moments! - but I honestly don't feel all that stressed.

I wouldn't feel happier giving up work. For a few reasons but mainly:

I like my job and find it intellectually stimulating

I don't like the idea of being everyone's facilitator - I think I would end up quite depressed which is different to being stressed but not better..

I think I would be much closer to burnout if I was a SAHM to be honest.

I feel the same way.

I'd find it boring and tedious. I'd be miserable as a SAHM, honestly.

Hugasauras · 21/06/2023 14:10

Also I would just wait till nearer the end of your mat leave, OP, before making any decisions. At home with two full time can be very different to being at home with one older child. You might get to the end of maternity leave and really need to go back to work for your own wellbeing, or you might have loved it so much you wanted to stay off.

I've recently gone back to work after having DD2 and although I did enjoy maternity leave, I was absolutely ready to go back to work by the end of it.

Hugasauras · 21/06/2023 14:07

Also the illness thing really is child dependent, unfortunately. I've been called once to collect DD1 in three years of nursery - when she developed scarlet fever. She's maybe missed four or five days in that time to illness, but it was a sick bug we all had so we weren't really up to working either. And because I work part-time, luck dictates that at least some of the times a kid is unwell falls on one of my days off. Other than that, she's rarely ill other than colds, and our nursery rule is 'snotty but happy is fine'. So it's not a given you will spend your life picking up ill children and having to take time off. Some kids are more suspectible and harder hit by bugs than others, though, so if you get unlucky, it could make life substantially more difficult.

Watchinghurling · 21/06/2023 14:07

One of us will take a year's career break when I finish mat leave - probably DH. It is a sacrifice because it means we'll be over a year on one salary only but we can just about manage it. We want to look after our youngest at home til she's two. Then she'll go into childcare. However one of us giving up full time work on a permanent basis just isn't on the cards at all. If we did that, we would be condemning ourselves to poverty for the rest of our lives. I like working too and would feel very strange not going out and earning my own money. If we receive an inheritance over the next few years, we might be able to pay the mortgage and then both go part time. I would want to share with my husband. No way would I ditch work and still expect him to be full time! If you're a team, you share the wealth.

Grumpyfroghats · 21/06/2023 14:05

newstart1234 · 21/06/2023 13:47

I have a decent pension (paid into without any breaks - my DHs improving salary covered this for years) so I do think it's sensible now to focus on the present not live for the future.

I admire the woman people who manage to make it work with little children, but it's not for everyone, and the stress is not worth the extra pension payments or career progression for many. Kudos to those who don't experience stress or burnout throughout this time working full time with a family but ime they are in the minority, amongst both mothers and fathers. In fact I've never met any (maybe my circle is exceptional in this way).

I am sometimes stressed by working and having young children - of course there are stressful moments! - but I honestly don't feel all that stressed.

I wouldn't feel happier giving up work. For a few reasons but mainly:

I like my job and find it intellectually stimulating

I don't like the idea of being everyone's facilitator - I think I would end up quite depressed which is different to being stressed but not better..

I think I would be much closer to burnout if I was a SAHM to be honest.

haoiu · 21/06/2023 14:04

I stopped working when I had my first dc. I have a passive income stream so I'm quite well protected financially and DH is a high earner so we pay the max into a private pensions, ISA and LISA in both our names. One DC at school now and a young toddler at home. Life is definitely more relaxed for us as a family compared to other families at school who are mostly 2 f/t earners. Weekends are just for for fun family time rather than dealing with chorses or fitting in clubs, as I can ferry mine to after school clubs. I'm looking forward to the summer holidays because I can spend quality time with both dcs instead of worrying about finding decent childcare.

DH does his fair share with the dc and housework when he's home, so we're very much a partnership. I would just make sure all the financial side makes sense and you're secure enough there.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 14:01

It would be easier for me not to work, I don't have to financially and it isn't easy but is the easy option always the right option? I don't think so.

I work because I have a son and I'm determined that he will grow up seeing that women can have careers and they aren't just there to cook, clean and do the laundry as well as him seeing that men aren't just providers, they can cook, clean and care for children. There's no better way to do that than by actually doing it and setting that example.

I refuse to be the default parent just because I have a vagina. Fuck that.

footballdramas · 21/06/2023 14:00

I don't think it's anti-feminist to do what's best for your kids and your family.

I gave up my office job when I had a baby as I moved away from the area where the jobs were. But I established a freelance career, very small at first but it has grown as I have had more time now after 12 years is probably close to paying what I earned at my old job.

Giving up work entirely is fine if you know there will be a job to go back to, or if you don't want to. Personally I am glad I kept my career ticking over now that my kids need me less. But I don't regret staying home for their early years.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 13:59

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/06/2023 13:54

But I do think life was a lot simpler and people were more content when the man worked and the women did the house and kids.

Try telling that to women like my mother who were desperately unhappy at home because they were so bored and unfulfilled. Being a SAHP destroyed my mum's confidence and mental health, and she hasn't ever properly recovered. Not going back to work is her single biggest regret.

It's fine for families where it suits the SAHP to be at home and the WOHP is happy to be the main breadwinner, but it certainly doesn't work for everyone. Lots of people aren't suited to being at home. Lots of people don't want to be the sole breadwinner.

Indeed. My mum was exactly the same. She gave up a stellar career to have kids (because it was the 70s and that was what you did) and basically never worked again. It contributed to mental illness, high levels of anxiety, financial insecurity and nearly cost her her marriage. She was never herself again and she made me promise that I would never ever give up work.

We really need to fight back against this rose-tinted view of non-working women. The reality for a lot of women who didn't work after having kids was financial insecurity, boredom and a general feeling of lack of purpose.

It's fine if people want to do it and can afford it but presenting it as idyllic or aspirational is very problematic.

Hugasauras · 21/06/2023 13:58

But I do think life was a lot simpler and people were more content when the man worked and the women did the house and kids.

I'm not really sure that's the case though. A lot of women historically ended up trapped in unhappy marriages, and separation wasn't really an option back then. Many led incredibly small and restricted lives, were financially abused, domestically abused, unvalued, treated as skivvies. I don't think people were any happier back then, just nobody spoke about it.

By 'people' being more content, I generally think that just means 'men' were more content, and of course they were.

newstart1234 · 21/06/2023 13:58

yut · 21/06/2023 13:48

@newstart1234 so you do think about the future then 🤷‍♀️

Yes of course I think about the future. But I don't have any plans for retirement though in that I don't have something I plan on doing that is not possible to do whilst working. You said you don't want to work into your 70s because 'I have plans'. That position doesn't fit with my preferences and that's fine.

lifehappens12 · 21/06/2023 13:57

Not going to lie but we have just reduced down to one parent working. We have a 2 year old and 5 year old. 2 year old in nursery and 5 year old in reception. School and nursery fun is 40 min each way twice a day.

My kids are out of the house from 8am till 5.30pm.

I commute and my partner worked from home. I am out from 7am till 6.30pm each day. Walk through the door straight into bath time, bed time, then clear the kitchen, laundry, make dinner and eventually if I am lucky sit down to relax at 9pm before it stays all over again.

The first year back after mat leave I used to feel physically sick when the phone rang from school or nursery as to who could collect, who had to cancel work stuff, working till midnight once sick child had gone to bed.

Now my partner is going to take 6 months off so that we can recover - so our children can do less childcare while they are little and be home for the summer.

We can get fit again

I don't see a short term break to be a disaster to help when they are smaller

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/06/2023 13:55

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 13:53

Well said.

I also want to add that working parents also raise their children. Nurseries/nannies etc care for children but they don't raise them.

Indeed.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/06/2023 13:54

But I do think life was a lot simpler and people were more content when the man worked and the women did the house and kids.

Try telling that to women like my mother who were desperately unhappy at home because they were so bored and unfulfilled. Being a SAHP destroyed my mum's confidence and mental health, and she hasn't ever properly recovered. Not going back to work is her single biggest regret.

It's fine for families where it suits the SAHP to be at home and the WOHP is happy to be the main breadwinner, but it certainly doesn't work for everyone. Lots of people aren't suited to being at home. Lots of people don't want to be the sole breadwinner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread