Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
hettie · 21/06/2023 15:57

Well presumably by asking the question on an open forum you are looking for a range of answers? I am coming from a few years down the line and I can tell you that in in your late 40's, 50's and 60's the decision you make now may have big consequences. I know far too many couples where relying on one 'big' wage has become really problematic. Sickness and poor health can hit anyone and its a killer if its the high earner. Thats before you get into the whole divorce stats (and yes I know I know no one thinks it will be them but the power/money dynamic can have an impact). Both things can leave the SAHM spouse buggered, it is really really hard to get back into well paid work after 5 or more years away. There is work but not of the kind to support a family. It an 'all your eggs in one basket' risk. Why would you take such big risks with your and your kids financial future. If you can keep your hand in with your role/profession by being part-time/not pursuing big promotions then if you needed to you could step up if it became important.

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 15:56

I’ve tried to be fairly clear I don’t think women should do anything, or men. But if you get to a point where the pressure on one person is such that things aren’t working too well, it’s the lower earner. I know that was badly worded but if someone has a disciplinary because of time off then it’s sensible for the lower earner to take that rather than compromise the higher earners career. That’s obviously a fairly drastic sort of scenario but can happen!

OP posts:
footballdramas · 21/06/2023 15:54

@Thepeopleversuswork Agree. I have seen enough marriages to fail now to believe that you should never depend on a man's money. It's the "while I wish I could be very feminist about it" that I was responding to.

FirstTimeNameChanger · 21/06/2023 15:49

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 15:20

No of course not.

But for some people in some circumstances it can be really difficult to work. I am one of them. That’s all, really. There’s no judgement of anybody else.

I mean, at different times it can be really difficult for most people to work. Everyone finds it hard sometimes.

Generally you don't have to give up work. You may prefer not to work and find it easier not to. But it's a choice.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 21/06/2023 15:48

My NDN and friend did this when her DC 2 was about 2 years old. It was getting too busy for her juggling childcare and a demanding secondary teaching job. Then she had DC3 so this cemented her decision. As far as I’m aware she pays into a private pension and NI contributions and her job is such that she can return later. She’s currently with her family on another continent sort of temporarily where she cannot work as a teacher without retraining. Her DH is a big earner though and she’s very good with finances eg not spending much.

It really depends on you, I do know some parents who pause their careers whilst having second children and then restart when both kids are at school. Childcare costs are prohibitive so that affects decisions too.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 15:47

Nordicrain · 21/06/2023 15:27

I am answering your thread title.

It's difficult for many, for many reasons. If you want to stay home with your kids then do, taking into account what's best for you and your family, long term and short term. Or just because you fancy it. That's your choice. But don't make out that women - generally - don't have a choice in this. That there aren't other options.

I agree.

If you want to be a SAHM, be a SAHM but it is almost always a want not a 'have to'.

CheshireCat1 · 21/06/2023 15:41

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 14:56

I’m all for women having tons of choices and I genuinely don’t care about the SAHM vs working mom debate on a personal level but I find this type of comment so aggravating. Are you saying you wouldn’t be close to your kids if you’d worked during those 13 years? It’s great it was fabulous. I’m genuinely happy for you. But it sounds deep down like you really think mums who work cannot be good mums.

Deep down I think most mums are great mums, I work with mums who have young children and they are also fabulous and close to their children. I just wanted to post something positive about my experience and how proud I am of my children. If I had put my full life story in the post you may have read something different in it, but I genuinely wanted to keep it positive. We’re all different with varying circumstances and we all have to make choices throughout our lives.

JudysGardenClub · 21/06/2023 15:34

I am through all of this on the other side so I will give you my take. My youngest child is now in year 12 so just finishing first year of sixth form. I became a sahm when Ds1 was 2 having previously been part time. My disability became worse so it made sense to give my body a break, it was meant to be for a couple of years.

It is absolutely the best thing we ever did, it completely worked for us, Dh was able to concentrate on his career enabling me to stay home and have a lifestyle that doesn't involve scrimping and scraping in fact far from it. We didn't have any family around to provide any childcare for us and I had friends with older children who I watched pour over calendars with their husbands working out who was taking time off when, when they could get a 2 week overlap over summer to go on holiday, working out summer club schedules etc. School holidays are 13 weeks of the year, unless you work term time only no one has that much leave from their paid job.

I was able to clean, cook, shop, do all the school runs, all sick children pick ups or have them at home without worrying about a boss being pissed off. Dh made it to every sports day, was a completely involved hands on Dad who relished his parenting role. He has a very strong loving bond with both our sons. He literally finished work and came home to a meal prepared for him. All the housework was done in the day by me when the children were older, none on weekends leaving us both free to spend time together as a family, one on one with each child and time on our own too with no resentment. But he also did bath times, bed times, came home and rolled his sleeves up and got straight into any parenting duties, it wasn't all left to me, when he was here he was available.

Dh's Mum had been a sahm, mine had worked full time, we used to get ourselves ready for school and walk there ourselves. I was 8 with a sibling to take with me as my Dad worked away a lot like your Dh does. Our relationship has worked, we are incredibly happy but there has to be respect from your Dh for the job you do (seems appreciated if you pay someone to look after your child but if a parent does it somehow it is lazy or easy) you need to have the same thoughts on spending money and you need to pay into a pension for yourself.

It can also be mind-numbing and dull, repetitive, the drudgery of housework is endless (thank god for Podcasts/streaming radio you can rewind if you miss something) and incredibly lonely. Only myself and one other person have stayed home with children in secondary school and beyond. We both believe it was the best decision we made. I am very happy in my own company.

Nordicrain · 21/06/2023 15:27

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 15:20

No of course not.

But for some people in some circumstances it can be really difficult to work. I am one of them. That’s all, really. There’s no judgement of anybody else.

I am answering your thread title.

It's difficult for many, for many reasons. If you want to stay home with your kids then do, taking into account what's best for you and your family, long term and short term. Or just because you fancy it. That's your choice. But don't make out that women - generally - don't have a choice in this. That there aren't other options.

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 15:20

Nordicrain · 21/06/2023 15:16

Well, no, you don't have to. Millions of parents don't. Millions of mums don't. I don't.

No of course not.

But for some people in some circumstances it can be really difficult to work. I am one of them. That’s all, really. There’s no judgement of anybody else.

OP posts:
Teamladybirdladybird · 21/06/2023 15:20

Personally I would have loved to have given up work but we couldn't quite afford for me to and in the back of my mind I was worried about worst case scenarios (death of spouse, divorce, serious illness etc etc where 2 earners gives a bit of financial protection). What we did agree to do was - I switched out a stressful FT job for a lower paying part time one (same industry), and had a nanny. Nanny ate up nearly all of my wages at the time but she was worth it - the local wonderful Grandma we didn't have (her own child was in her 20s by this point). She moved on to another family once my youngest went to school and then I switched back into career mode (but still part time). It has worked out really well for me and I really enjoy the balance. The stable primary school years allowed me to really progress (use of school wrap around on my working days and sharing pick ups with husband). Kids are now teenagers and need our time more than ever. Somehow we've just about managed to keep all the balls in the air. My advice would be don't worry about what hasn't happened yet e.g pension (because you might never get there, to be blunt) but deal with the situation immediately in front of you.

DownWithBreadsticks · 21/06/2023 15:18

IMO, if you want to work with young children, you have to suck it up and dig deep. Both of you - not just the mother.

Nordicrain · 21/06/2023 15:18

CheshireCat1 · 21/06/2023 14:39

Yes, I did come to a point for me when my oldest was born, I gave up work. 13 years and two more children later I started back going to work. During those 13 years I did voluntary work, went to night school, retrained and had the best time of my life with the kids. When I eventually did go back to work it was in a completely different career and I absolutely love it. My NI contributions are all covered for the 13 years at home, so I will get full state pension and since I’ve started back in work I contribute quite a bit into a private pension, I’ll probably be able to retire quite soon. I have a fantastic relationship with all my children and their partners, we’re all very close. My oldest has just started his family and even though him and his wife have good careers they’re both only going to work part time because they want their children to have a similar upbringing that my children had.
I understand it’s not for everyone and sacrifices have to be made, but looking back it was absolutely fabulous.

Oh here we bloody go. Same old thread.

I have a fabulous relationship with my kids. We are very close. I also work and am financially independent. The two are not mutually exclusive.

Nordicrain · 21/06/2023 15:16

Well, no, you don't have to. Millions of parents don't. Millions of mums don't. I don't.

Hugasauras · 21/06/2023 15:11

I think quantity of time is not always quality of time. There are plenty of people who are SAHP who probably shouldn't be, just as there are working parents who do a fantastic job of parenting because they use that time well. There are good parents and bad parents, and whether you are at home all day or aren't has very little to do with where you fall on that scale.

BMrs · 21/06/2023 15:10

Honestly I would. In a similar position but I work part time 2 days a week. I like the balance and worked really hard to get my career so didn't want to give it up and fortunate to have a great employer who is really flexible. I would give up my job though it got the option.

I know some say the bulk of things shouldn't fall to you regarding childcare but I love to care for the children and I'm grateful my DH takes the bulk of the financial responsibility for our family. We're a great team and both happy with our respective contributions to our family.

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 15:07

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 15:02

I'm sorry I know it probably wasn't intended this way but this sounds horribly smug and judgemental.

The clear (if unspoken) implication of this is that your children turned out well because you didn't work. You might want to think about how that lands with some of us who don't have this choice.

Totally agree. Being close with your children has nothing to do with working. I only have one but we are incredibly close and I have worked her entire childhood. If you want to be a SAHM, be one. But don’t you dare tell me I am doing my kid a disservice by working. No one says this about dads.

Abouttimemum · 21/06/2023 15:06

I wouldn’t be a SAHP.
You need to make sure you can survive and thrive independently without your DH.

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 15:03

BarbaraofSeville · 21/06/2023 11:17

Why does all the 'rushing and hassle' fall on you?

Why does your DH get to concentrate on work and nothing else?

Why has becoming a parent changed your life but not your DHs?

Why isn't your DH doing half of nursery runs, arranging wraparound care etc if he's not willing/able to adjust his working hours to accommodate his parental responsibilities?

That's what you need to be discussing with your DH rather than jumping straight to 'well I might as well give up work, my independence and my pension'.

THIS.

Thepeopleversuswork · 21/06/2023 15:02

CheshireCat1 · 21/06/2023 14:39

Yes, I did come to a point for me when my oldest was born, I gave up work. 13 years and two more children later I started back going to work. During those 13 years I did voluntary work, went to night school, retrained and had the best time of my life with the kids. When I eventually did go back to work it was in a completely different career and I absolutely love it. My NI contributions are all covered for the 13 years at home, so I will get full state pension and since I’ve started back in work I contribute quite a bit into a private pension, I’ll probably be able to retire quite soon. I have a fantastic relationship with all my children and their partners, we’re all very close. My oldest has just started his family and even though him and his wife have good careers they’re both only going to work part time because they want their children to have a similar upbringing that my children had.
I understand it’s not for everyone and sacrifices have to be made, but looking back it was absolutely fabulous.

I'm sorry I know it probably wasn't intended this way but this sounds horribly smug and judgemental.

The clear (if unspoken) implication of this is that your children turned out well because you didn't work. You might want to think about how that lands with some of us who don't have this choice.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 15:02

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 14:56

I’m all for women having tons of choices and I genuinely don’t care about the SAHM vs working mom debate on a personal level but I find this type of comment so aggravating. Are you saying you wouldn’t be close to your kids if you’d worked during those 13 years? It’s great it was fabulous. I’m genuinely happy for you. But it sounds deep down like you really think mums who work cannot be good mums.

and only mums of course.

Dads who work full time are never told they can't be good dads.

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 14:58

I wouldn't. You lose your identity on top of your financial independence.

Sorry but this is not true as a blanket statement. My identity is far more than my job title. I never felt I wasn't me any more - well, I did a bit when I had kids compared to before, but that was when I was working, so nothing to do with being a SAHP.

pollykitty · 21/06/2023 14:56

CheshireCat1 · 21/06/2023 14:39

Yes, I did come to a point for me when my oldest was born, I gave up work. 13 years and two more children later I started back going to work. During those 13 years I did voluntary work, went to night school, retrained and had the best time of my life with the kids. When I eventually did go back to work it was in a completely different career and I absolutely love it. My NI contributions are all covered for the 13 years at home, so I will get full state pension and since I’ve started back in work I contribute quite a bit into a private pension, I’ll probably be able to retire quite soon. I have a fantastic relationship with all my children and their partners, we’re all very close. My oldest has just started his family and even though him and his wife have good careers they’re both only going to work part time because they want their children to have a similar upbringing that my children had.
I understand it’s not for everyone and sacrifices have to be made, but looking back it was absolutely fabulous.

I’m all for women having tons of choices and I genuinely don’t care about the SAHM vs working mom debate on a personal level but I find this type of comment so aggravating. Are you saying you wouldn’t be close to your kids if you’d worked during those 13 years? It’s great it was fabulous. I’m genuinely happy for you. But it sounds deep down like you really think mums who work cannot be good mums.

Heartofglass12345 · 21/06/2023 14:46

And the only reason I was the one who stopped working was through choice. I wanted to.

Beezknees · 21/06/2023 14:45

Lone parent here, absolutely no input from DS's dad and very little family support, I work and always have.

So no, there is never a point where you "have" to give up work. If you really want to work, you can always make it so.

If giving up work makes life easier for you, go for it, it's your choice. But it can be done.