Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
PollyPeep · 22/06/2023 12:06

Sorry you're being piled on, OP. I totally understand where you're coming from. We're in the same situation.

We have two young kids and while we could manage with nursery because it ran 51 weeks a year, 7am-6pm, once the eldest started school and we had a younger child as well, it became obvious that having two full time working parents wasn't going to work for us as a family. No judgement on any other family.

We both have long commutes and would both be out the house 7am - 6pm. It would have been too early to use breakfast club so we would have needed a child minder before and after the before and after school clubs! Combined with the 13 weeks school holidays with no family support nearby it became very clear that it wasn't feasible.

We chose for me to stay at home for two reasons. Firstly, luckily my career can be continued as a freelancer whereas my husband's can't. And secondly he is the higher earner. Totally understand PP points about being financially dependent on your partner and I felt uncomfortable with this too.

You do what's right for you. I watched my full time working friends struggle to cobble together time off, childminders and holiday clubs to deal with school hours, and I knew that wasn't right for us. We're lucky we can just about make it work with me freelancing. Other people aren't so lucky, I know. Whatever you decide, it will be the right decision for your family, as long as you're both aware that if you're a SAHM you are actually contributing equally to the household - it's not all about financial contribution. Good luck!

StormShadow · 22/06/2023 09:50

thelinkisdead · 22/06/2023 08:52

I think it is very difficult to juggle family life and working when your children are small, but as they get older and are both in primary and secondary school, life does run more smoothly in a lot of ways. I’ve been part time since ours were small, and really have no need financially to return full time as my husband earns a lot, but since mine have got older, I’ve found myself able to focus far more on my career and - despite part time hours - have really progressed. Obviously there is a ceiling to this with my hours (in my profession) but my husband and I have discussed how we will make it work when I decide to return full time (which I will).

I like having something that is mine. My career gives me focus and helps with my self esteem and really stops me from getting bored - and I do find I rattle around the house a bit now on my days off. Yes, the house is run far better (for us) with me at home, but we’d make it work. I’m also happy that should something awful happen, I could financially support us.

Think very carefully before giving up work; I’ve found it to be worth it ploughing through the early years. Something we always appreciate too is that my husband’s earnings mean I get to be really picky about my own job: I won’t return full time to a position I don’t love; I will wait for the right one, and because we don’t need the money, I can bide my time.

Definitely, there really is a lot to be said for the short term pain, long term gain approach. Obviously some couples have no choice but to prioritise the immediate. But when you have the option, both parents having stayed in the workforce often pays dividends in terms of choices later.

Superdupes · 22/06/2023 09:38

Being a SAHM has definitely been the best job I've ever had but that's because I chose it whole heartedly. I don't know why it would be considered unfeminist - surely feminism is about women having choices. In comparison I've always found work incredibly stressful and unfulfilling, I can't say I've ever had a job I enjoyed.

It's different though if you feel you have to be a SAHM and leave a career you love. What do you want in an ideal world and what can you do/put in place/get help or support with to enable that?

stealthbanana · 22/06/2023 08:52

Hollyppp · 22/06/2023 08:19

Yeah because ironing shirts and cooking is really a life of leisure 😆

Well quite. To add to women working and doing all the domestic labour, the women who did stay at home were mostly running a household, not actively looking after kids. All the data are very clear on this point - today’s working mothers spend more time with their children than mothers of 40-50 years ago who were mostly at home. Labour saving devices and the pill have enabled smaller families and for time to be actively spent with kids.

thelinkisdead · 22/06/2023 08:52

I think it is very difficult to juggle family life and working when your children are small, but as they get older and are both in primary and secondary school, life does run more smoothly in a lot of ways. I’ve been part time since ours were small, and really have no need financially to return full time as my husband earns a lot, but since mine have got older, I’ve found myself able to focus far more on my career and - despite part time hours - have really progressed. Obviously there is a ceiling to this with my hours (in my profession) but my husband and I have discussed how we will make it work when I decide to return full time (which I will).

I like having something that is mine. My career gives me focus and helps with my self esteem and really stops me from getting bored - and I do find I rattle around the house a bit now on my days off. Yes, the house is run far better (for us) with me at home, but we’d make it work. I’m also happy that should something awful happen, I could financially support us.

Think very carefully before giving up work; I’ve found it to be worth it ploughing through the early years. Something we always appreciate too is that my husband’s earnings mean I get to be really picky about my own job: I won’t return full time to a position I don’t love; I will wait for the right one, and because we don’t need the money, I can bide my time.

BlurredVision · 22/06/2023 08:37

I think there is also a systemic nature to this. Our parents were growing up with more equality and urged their daughters to get educated, get a career, to be whatever they wanted. But forgot to teach their sons anything different from what went before. I think that's why so many parents today find themselves in this bind and it's presented as just the way it is, as opposed an issue arising because men won't take action to even the field. I work for financial security, my own self actualisation, etc. but a side bonus is that my kids see how an equal household works (it's not perfect of course, and has taken a while to figure out). While we all make individual decisions we make them inside a system which has paths of least resistance worn over time.

Nordicrain · 22/06/2023 08:22

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 15:56

I’ve tried to be fairly clear I don’t think women should do anything, or men. But if you get to a point where the pressure on one person is such that things aren’t working too well, it’s the lower earner. I know that was badly worded but if someone has a disciplinary because of time off then it’s sensible for the lower earner to take that rather than compromise the higher earners career. That’s obviously a fairly drastic sort of scenario but can happen!

well, depends.

I wouldn't give up my career for the sake of DH's, even if I earned less (which I don't). What if he died? Or left me? Or became unable to work? Then I/ we would have no fall back. Two ok careers give better security for a couple and no career for one person is super risky.

Hollyppp · 22/06/2023 08:19

Surprisedbysummer · 21/06/2023 23:38

I am always irritated by the inaccurate statements about women traditionally not having worked. Working class women have always worked. I am seventy and both my grandmothers worked. One ran a corner shop and the other worked as a dressmaker . One had five children, the other had three and they ran homes. Post the Second World War there was a movement to stop women working to provide jobs for returning servicemen. Obviously, during the same period in communist countries like Russia, women were expected to work alongside men and there were state nurseries. It is fiction born of the immediate post war that women did not work outside the home.
I remember forty years ago complaining that my NCT group had few meet ups because most women had gone back to work. It is romantic tosh to describe women in bygone ages as ladies of leisure who stayed at home to iron their husbands shirts and cook his meals. Women have always worked.

Yeah because ironing shirts and cooking is really a life of leisure 😆

RosesAndHellebores · 22/06/2023 03:58

I completely agree @Surprisedbysummer.

@Florencey I am sorry if things are tough.

Surprisedbysummer · 21/06/2023 23:38

I am always irritated by the inaccurate statements about women traditionally not having worked. Working class women have always worked. I am seventy and both my grandmothers worked. One ran a corner shop and the other worked as a dressmaker . One had five children, the other had three and they ran homes. Post the Second World War there was a movement to stop women working to provide jobs for returning servicemen. Obviously, during the same period in communist countries like Russia, women were expected to work alongside men and there were state nurseries. It is fiction born of the immediate post war that women did not work outside the home.
I remember forty years ago complaining that my NCT group had few meet ups because most women had gone back to work. It is romantic tosh to describe women in bygone ages as ladies of leisure who stayed at home to iron their husbands shirts and cook his meals. Women have always worked.

Florencey · 21/06/2023 23:17

RosesAndHellebores · 21/06/2023 12:16

Different things work for different people. I'm a planner and despite not getting married before my mid 30s, I had a strong maternal urge from when I was a child.

I had a career from 20 to 35 in the City, earnt a lot, bought my own house, stashed into a pension as part of the foundation for future security/choice re giving up work. By 34 I was burnt out, DH was earlier in his career and had excellent long term prospects. Therefore I could give up work and focus on the dc which I did for 7 years. It was marvellous and I got NI contrivutions for those years towards my state pension.

I went back to work part-time initially, in the public sector in my early 40s and was sponsored to do prof quals. 20 years on work at director level.

An au-pair sorted the DC after school, did the laundry, tidied their rooms and cooked their dinner. A cleaner cleaned.

It worked well for us and there has been little detriment regarding my pension. Full state contributions (35 years) and about 75% final salary occupational pension.

We took the decision jointly and could because of the pre marriage cushion I had. Also dh never questioned any household or child related expenditure and didn't for a second ever resent my personal expenditure.

Wow this sounds like the dream, you really are a planner. I'm in awe!

I like you had strong maternal instinct from a child but did the opposite and had my first at 18, went to uni, worked part time, went full time when they went to secondary school, then just as I was catching up financially from all of that and my first born became an adult I had another baby and now I'm reading this thread feeling like I'm fucked and have no idea how to navigate this.

Kilorrery · 21/06/2023 23:10

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 22:21

You really think in most cases where a woman is a SAHP, the driving factor is purely the attitude of the husband and not any of the practical issues I mentioned?

You think all jobs and situations are equal within a heterosexual couple and the only differentiating factor is what the husband thinks about women working?

Nearly everyone I've ever met makes decisions about employment factoring in health, accessibility, distance, time requirements, access to transport, earnings, industry, training requirements, existing qualifications.

And it’s pure coincidence that when someone ‘has to be’ a SAHP, it’s virtually always the woman, who earns less, and has, depressingly, still often been socialised to consider her career optional once she has a child and, quite ridiculously, to think her DH is doing her a favour by ‘enabling her to be at home’? Right. Nothing at all to do with patriarchy, entrenched sexism, gendered socialisation, the gender pay gap.

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 22:31

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 22:21

You really think in most cases where a woman is a SAHP, the driving factor is purely the attitude of the husband and not any of the practical issues I mentioned?

You think all jobs and situations are equal within a heterosexual couple and the only differentiating factor is what the husband thinks about women working?

Nearly everyone I've ever met makes decisions about employment factoring in health, accessibility, distance, time requirements, access to transport, earnings, industry, training requirements, existing qualifications.

The driving factor in most cases is sexism. Including the fact that the woman is seen as the default parent and anything relating to the child is her responsibility.

Childcare costs (usually only her salary is considered so it 'makes sense' to be a SAHM)
Flexible working (not always an option but men rarely bother even asking)
Changing jobs to facilitate more of a work/life balance
Going part time (again, not always an option but men don't bother asking)

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 22:27

anouskita · 21/06/2023 18:14

Well if women didn't want to be SAHMs, they wouldn't be would they? That's all you need to know really.

If your job doesn't pay enough to cover childcare then you don't necessarily have a choice. Often people do pay to work, they take the hit for the long-term gain, but not everyone can afford that.

AromanticSpices · 21/06/2023 22:21

SouthLondonMum22 · 21/06/2023 16:42

It's true in most cases though. It isn't a coincidence that it's largely only women who 'have' to stop working.

You really think in most cases where a woman is a SAHP, the driving factor is purely the attitude of the husband and not any of the practical issues I mentioned?

You think all jobs and situations are equal within a heterosexual couple and the only differentiating factor is what the husband thinks about women working?

Nearly everyone I've ever met makes decisions about employment factoring in health, accessibility, distance, time requirements, access to transport, earnings, industry, training requirements, existing qualifications.

chopc · 21/06/2023 20:47

This is not a new dilemma for couples. The lower earner would almost always take a back seat.
Do what works for you but I wouldn't ever stop having my own independence and money. Maybe when you are a SAHM you can learn skills that will enable you to get a better paid role so you are more even? I wish I did that .

Aggielera · 21/06/2023 20:13

@anouskita
My last post was for you. I tagged myself as I’m an idiot.

I know what I’m trying to say anyway.

Aggielera · 21/06/2023 20:10

@Aggielera I don’t think you get what I’m trying to say. At no point in her first post (I’ve not read the whole thread) does OP say she wants to be a SAHM. She just lists the reasons that she thinks make it sensible for her to be one. I read this time and time again.

She has started the thread to get strangers to justify her choice. She doesn’t need that justification. She wants to be a SAHM. That’s fine.

anouskita · 21/06/2023 20:08

I can't see what all the fuss is about either way. People post all sorts on here.

Aggielera · 21/06/2023 20:05

@anouskita

Say she wants to be a SAHM not trying to get people on the internet to tell her that it’s ok in her circumstances.

It’s perfectly valid as a choice (if you are lucky enough to be able to have that choice) to be a SAHM.

anouskita · 21/06/2023 20:05

Well some people don't want to work because they've had enough; some don't want to work because they prioritise being with their kids; some don't want to work because it's too much juggling / stress to have two parents working; some families don't need the extra money ... There are all kinds of reasons women may prefer to be a SAHM. It's individual to everyone.

Sosejbrechdan · 21/06/2023 20:00

@anouskita

Pretending she can’t afford to work when she clearly doesn’t want to. You don’t need to justify being a SAHM. Especially not to a load of strangers on the internet. Which is exactly what OP is doing.

Vettrianofan · 21/06/2023 19:55

I have been a SAHM for 15 years and won't go back to work due to health issues. It just isn't worth it. I have four children and probably not likely to live long enough to see a pension 🙄. It just isn't worrying about.

I organise everything at home, do all admin, enjoy having free time, cycling, reading, playing an instrument, visiting family if I can. There isn't time to fit in a job tbh.

anouskita · 21/06/2023 19:50

What is the OP not 'owning' exactly?

Aggielera · 21/06/2023 19:44

A lot of women don’t want to work/work much but they feel too guilty saying that so they make it out that they couldn’t work.

I have no issue with SAHM but for fuck’s sake just own it. There’s no shame in wanting to be a SAHM. There’s no shame in wanting/needing to work.

This financial independence/pension vs I love my kids too much to leave them (which is a fucking horrific thing to say when so many women HAVE to work, keep your smugness internally) bunfight isn’t doing anyone any favours.