Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 23/06/2023 09:46

@Bluewatersummer

I just don’t want my children’s overriding memories of me to be wrung out because that’s what I assumewill happen.

But being "wrung out" because you're tired from working/juggling is a temporary thing which will ease after a couple of years. Being "wrung out" because your husband has left you penniless and you have to work way into your retirement is several leagues of magnitude more severe. And you will still be wrung out if you don't work, just with less variety and less money. You're not comparing like for like. I'm sorry if this sounds melodramatic but in the scheme of things the sacrifice you make now will more than pay off in the event of the worst-case scenario.

I sympathise with the situation you're in at the moment because I've been there: there's a period when you're exhausted, stressed, you don't feel you're there for your children etc. But this is just intrinsic to having small children. Being a SAHM won't magically alleviate that.

It's a bit shit but it will pass, it doesn't last that long and it will pay massive dividends to you over the long term. It isn't just the insurance policy of keeping your hand it. It's the protection of your own autonomy and power in the marriage and your right to have a life outside of child-rearing.

If the marriage doesn't fail (and there's nothing in your posts to indicate that it will), you won't be in a worse position for having kept your skills and financial independence up. In fact you'll probably find your life will be better in many ways.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 09:37

This might sound unnecessarily argumentative and I really hope it doesn’t but if I assume my marriage will fail, I would need to do the following.

I would need to work full time, because I can’t just snap my fingers and change my contract in the event of my marriage failing and I wouldn’t be able to live on a part time salary. So even more rushing around and even more stress, in case we split.

I think one of the issues I see time and again on MN and maybe in RL too, I don’t know, is there is a lot of ‘what if.’ And I don’t want to sound flippant about this but so many times in my life I’ve ended up in a situation where I don’t think I’d have known what I’d do but when you’re in the moment, you do, you just get on with it and cope because that’s what we do. So our worst case scenario is DH leaves and isn’t paying any maintenance and I’m left destitute - and I know that does happen - but I also know I’d cope and id get on. I just don’t want my children’s overriding memories of me to be wrung out because that’s what I assume will happen.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 23/06/2023 09:29

@Bluewatersummer

I do think you have to be sensible. But equally going through life and making all future plans on the assumption that a marriage isn’t going to work isn’t sensible, it is paranoid.

Respectfully, I disagree.

Nearly half of marriages fail. So it's not paranoid to plan for a scenario that affects just under half of us.

Also the marriage failing isn't the only scenario in which being financially dependent is a problem. Being wholly dependent on someone else changes the dynamic in a relationship and leaves the dependent person very powerless. Even if the marriage doesn't fail, you are choosing to diminish your own standing and autonomy in the marriage. That's probably fine for a couple of years but over time it definitely changes things. I saw this happen to my own mother. My parents marriage survived but she never really worked after having children and while she didn't want for anything material she felt disempowered, increasingly irrelevant and increasingly bitter as she got older.

Also you have said yourself you fundamentally don't want to be a SAHM. There are women who embrace this. You are, by your own admission, not one of them, and it's reckless to wilfully put yourself in a situation where you reduce your bargaining power to avoid this.

It's not a zero sum game. It doesn't have to be a balls out high flying corporate job versus doing absoluting nothing but looking after children and doing housework. It's perfectly possible to take two/three years out and then inch back in. There are an infinite number of ways to keep your hand in, keep some economic autonomy and just keep yourself moving and relevant without completely stepping off. Part time work, volunteering, education etc. It's a mental thing as much as anything. Maintaining a commitment to keeping yourself engaged with things outside of the children.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 09:19

Yes, absolutely. And it is sensible to make some plans for old age and to make some plans in case the house burns down or you suddenly lose your job. But there is a difference between a backup plan and living a half life expecting doom.

OP posts:
Shinyandnew1 · 23/06/2023 09:10

making all future plans on the assumption that a marriage isn’t going to work isn’t sensible, it is paranoid

When over 40% of marriages fail, it’s only sensible to think about how you would cope financially if you were to end up alone.

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 09:08

Everyone brings their own experience and perspective and that's what's so valuable about this forum. You will find your own balance but people sharing their perspectives isn't just about people being on the extremes for the sake of an argument. The women who do value financial independence very highly (myself included) do most likely because they saw the 'extreme' scenario play out in real life and want to absolutely make sure they avoid it. So they're not attacking you by sharing it, they're hoping you won't replicate their/their mother's/aunt's experience etc. You can apply that insight to your own life as you see fit of course, but it's definitely not being paranoid and therefore worth dismissing. You are being given the gift of insight into situations you had not considered so that you can make a good decision for yourself.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 09:01

@hettie no one is dismissing part time, I am part time! But staying part time will mean I’m looking for promotion in my early fifties where in all honesty I’m unlikely to progress and if I do it won’t be very much.

There is a lot of ‘don’t rely on a man!’ replies but in all honesty, who doesn’t rely on someone? Husband / partner, mum / dad, nanny / nursery? Anyone can let you down. A mortgage and nursery fees on a part time salary would be beyond me anyway so in that sense I already do rely on DH.

I do think you have to be sensible. But equally going through life and making all future plans on the assumption that a marriage isn’t going to work isn’t sensible, it is paranoid, and there can be a fine line between the two to be honest that I do often see on here.

OP posts:
Katey83 · 23/06/2023 08:24

My partner has given up work now we have a baby (and his daughter from a previous relationship). Makes life simpler, and more stress free.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:18

Depends on what you do. Taking a few years out can be fine in some professions eg teaching they will bite your hand off

hettie · 23/06/2023 08:18

@Bluewatersummer
Don't dismiss part time because it's not well paid/won't give career progression now. It's the long term strategy you might want to think about. There was a point where I/the household was actually financing me eyeing working. But it wasn't for long and it kept me in the career I was qualified in. This meant that years later when the kids were in secondary I was able to go full time and pursued promotion. Just as body well I kept that option as dh because seriously unwell and went from training for a marathon to being a blue badge holder. If you can keep a foot hold in work so. It's so not worth the risk. You might be in a shortage career that would have you back at a similar level after 3 or 4 years out, but if not what would you do if dh could not work in his highly paid job or god forbid left you.

Mothwingdust · 23/06/2023 08:16

Well my friends DH walked out on her for a younger woman after 30 years together and marriage of 25 years a year ago.

The actual heartbreak is horrific but her financial situation is dire and she finds herself aged 53 with FA pension.

A couple of years off would be great but do not risk it long term. I went PT well it was dropping one day that was perfect and my pension is quite healthy.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/06/2023 08:06

@Bluewatersummer

One thing I have noticed and whether this is a MN thing or not I am not sure but no matter how many times I repeat some things some people don’t seem to hear or accept it.

You're right: these sorts of threads tend to turn into a bunfight between women who have taken different routes and feel defensive about what they've done. An awful lot of the content on these SAHM vs WOHM threads is people projecting. But you have correctly identified that other people's views are not the same as yours and you need to find your own path through this.

I believe strongly there are objective reasons, backed by hard data, to feel that making oneself totally dependent on a man for money is usually a bad idea. But I think there is often more nuance to this than sometimes comes out in these discussions and it is entirely possible to take some time off at a time when things are stressful and reduce the load a bit as long as you build in some optionality to get back into the workplace when your children are older.

It sounds like you have your head pretty well screwed on: you know you need to make life easier for yourself but you know you don't want to be an SAHM. It sounds like you can feasibly reduce your hours without abandoning your career altogether.

I think the next step is probably to sit down with your DH and have a frank discussion about what you need and how he can support you.

Mumarrama · 23/06/2023 08:03

The constant illnesses do stop and when they in year 1 of school it (usually) becomes a rarity for them to be ill.

We had a nanny and that really worked when they were little. Having worked at a nursery before she'd had all the bugs and was rarely ill, unless children were really poorly she'd look after them when they were ill. Covering illness when your nanny is sick and you just have a nice bonus day with your child is actually a nice thing!

It's obviously up to you, I can see the benefit of both. I really enjoy working and value the independence. However, there is a lot of juggling with kids that makes life stressful and if you're lone parenting when your partner is away that's hard too! I can see that it may be good to have a break from work until both kids are at school and see how you feel then.

AmenAmin · 23/06/2023 07:57

Yeah, I don’t have the same career label… but I give no shits. I’m treated with respect and I’m happy. As I was in the 5 years of not working

AmenAmin · 23/06/2023 07:55

I gave up work (teaching) and I’ve never regretted it. My lifestyle is squire stress free. In time I also discovered the work of flexible work. With (higher) hourly paid work I only give up the time I want to, I could quite easily convert to full time, I’m flexible and taking childcare into account we have far more money to play with as a family. I don’t know anyone, working or not, who regrets it on a personal level. I’ve only read it online

RosesAndHellebores · 23/06/2023 07:52

@bluewatersummer what a noble, well written and measured post.

It sounds as though part-time would suit, do something you like for you rather than for the money. Choice is a marvellous thing as is getting out of the house and relief from tinies.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 07:17

It’s interesting that so many have decided that what I want is to be a SAHM and I have come here for validation for that choice. I actually don’t - not to preschool children, anyway! I wouldn’t mind much if they were at school during the day …

I think so many posts have started to focus on the minutiae of my particular situation they don’t really seem to grasp the overall situation. I genuinely don’t think this is about feminism, either. It is more about the fact that I have always been shit at subjects that lend themselves to highly paid professions - maths mainly, but also science, tech, ICT. Meanwhile, DH was brilliant at them. That combined with a certain amount of luck for him (right place and right time) meant he had a very lucrative career before him. I have been more ‘middling’ in my achievements and in my career. I do have things I am good at, very good at. They just don’t tend to pay as well.

So the replies tend to focus on:

a) DH should be doing more. If this means changing jobs to a low paid one then be it so.

b) Be a SAHM; that’s clearly what you want but be honest about it. (No, I don’t!)

c) I managed so why the hell can’t you - I am managing, but we had a rough old trot just before my maternity leave with lots of being sent home from nursery and it was that which had me thinking. It is very guilt inducing when work won’t let you go and the other parent is the other end of the country and there’s no one else Sad

d) I loved being a SAHM - which is good some people do. <whispers> I have two solo days with my toddler and that’s probably enough!

e) I get it.

One thing I have noticed and whether this is a MN thing or not I am not sure but no matter how many times I repeat some things some people don’t seem to hear or accept it. I don’t mind being part time but the pay is not very good and realistically I probably won’t have a ‘career’ as such.

OP posts:
Whyisegg · 23/06/2023 06:46

Hate to burst yr tiny bubbles but having the freedom to do what you want is not feminist. Unfortunately most people have limited choices and women certainly shouldn't be judged or blamed for having to make difficult (or less than ideal) choices - but why do you think that is??? Because society is engineered so that women take care of men from cradle to grave. And yet we keep falling for the same bullshit. Feminism is the belief that women deserve equal treatment - not to be treated like lesser men, but to receive genuine equal rights, not too demanding considering women make up 50% of the human race.
Real social change requires sacrifice. Imagine if a generation of women chose not to have children - actively chose this regardless of the impact on their own emotions and individual lives - with a goal to influence an actual change. But that won't happen because anyone with any kind of agency wants to believe 'oh it won't hurt if I just do what I want, little old me, other people will make things happen and I don't have to sacrifice any of the things I really want in life' and everyone else is too poor to have any real choices about how their life turns out. Men don't and never will care about issues which affect women - why would they when it doesn't affect them. And yet women still believe a romantic relationship with a man - someone who sees you as a lesser human - is the most important relationship they will ever have, to the extent they give up their independence, spend their time worrying about someone else's wellbeing, do chores which are never noticed or appreciated, so why should men take us seriously? Make peace with your choices because life is short but at least be real about it.

vixencomet · 23/06/2023 06:17

I think in your heart you know what you want/need to do. You've had very good advice on here. Only you and your DH will know what will work with your family. Besides, you are not stuck in the option you made, you can change it if you find doesn't work. Sometimes, I toss a coin making these decisions, not because I am taking it lightly, but because if I was disappointed in what comes up, then I know what I actually want to do. Good luck whatever you decide.

TheaBrandt · 22/06/2023 23:28

Your career is likely to be 40 odd years. Taking 4-6 years out shouldn’t torpedo it. Not in this day and age. Anecdotally know lots of professional women who took a career break then go back. Especially at the moment. Several sahms I know got head hunted.

Peppadog · 22/06/2023 23:17

Meh! Mumsnet is so anti women giving up work. Just take a few years out, enjoy a less stressful existence, and enjoy your kids. The fact you can afford it means you are in a fantastic and very fortunate position.
You can always go back to work later. Only you know if your role means returning would be a struggle. I would love to give up work.

TheaBrandt · 22/06/2023 23:07

Nothing wrong with taking a few years out. Ignore the doom mongers. If you are professionally qualified nice and normal you can get back into decent work. Then you have the best of all worlds.

MeridaBrave · 22/06/2023 22:29

I saw my mum not working as a child for the reasons you set out (my dad earned a lot more, and couldn’t get the right sort of childcare). For that reason I decided I’d get a well paid job, and so I became an accountant. It also meant I could afford a nanny when DC were very little (before youngest started primary, then had series of au pairs until youngest started secondary).

I earn similar to my DH, on a pro rata basis (I work 4 days but when DC younger I did 3 days). I could easily do full time now as DC at secondary but I like the flexibility.

I think if earn a lot less a career break makes sense; it’s just the reality.

hot2trotter · 22/06/2023 18:45

I know it's an unpopular opinion on here but I love being a SAHM to my 4 DC's. It's not for everyone, and it is incredibly draining, but I realise how fortunate I am to be in this position. I continued to work part time after my eldest was born but with the others it just wasn't feasible. I also have no outside help either, no family willing to help etc, if that makes a difference.

Mamabear48 · 22/06/2023 17:43

My second is coming up to 2 now and my older is in reception. I really considered not going back to work I didn’t know how I was going to handle all the drop offs timings etc. I was part time 3 days a week in the office an hour away from home so I changed my hours 10-4 so I could do the school and childminder drop off and then pick youngest up then older from after school club. Did it for a month and went to hand my notice in it was so stressful and not getting home with traffic till about 6 - no time with the kids dinner bath and bedtime was a mess and the kids were horrendous. My work compromised and I changed my hours to 9-3 so daughter goes to breakfast club which is 100% easier and youngest to the childminder so I don’t need to worry about feeding them and I’m home to pick her up from school and I get to work from home 2 days a week now. I would just go with it and see how you get on. I just push through because I don’t want to be jobless when they are both at school!

Swipe left for the next trending thread