Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
Curseofthenation · 23/06/2023 13:02

I became a SAHM after my first. It wasn't financially worth it to continue working and I wanted to be home with my DS. I'm pregnant with my second now.

I am worried about my career, but equally the pay was obviously not that great (circa 30k). I didn't see a good enough reason to go back. If wages were better then it would have been a different story. I worked my arse off and got multiple promotions to get to that salary believe it or not!

I did decide to set up a small side business to keep some of my skills up to date and to have something on my CV.

All this said, I would never have taken this financial risk if I was not married and on the property ladder. It's still a risk, but one I'm willing to take.

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 13:01

Brefugee · 23/06/2023 12:50

have only read most of OPs posts and frankly? if your DH wanted to make it work he could.

I was the higher earner but my DH couldn't really change his hours to suit. So we made sure that we had watertight childcare (paid through the nose). And then we arranged who was doing what, and who would sacrifice either a work day or some free time, to fit round what needed to be done around school or whatever.

And it's a struggle.

But blimey, even if i wasn't the higher earner, i would have insisted on the same. I wouldn't give up my financial independence for anyone without watertight financial arrangements to compensate.

I am the higher earner too. If my DH had given up work I could have really pressed ahead and shot up the ladder, into a ' big job'. But I didn't because I didn't want to miss out on so much family life. One uncomfortable truth I see (and maybe in this case I am bitter 😁) is that many of the 'big job' men I work with, both in my company and the professional services firms we work with, love working more than being with their family. They talk the good talk about how important their families are to them, but in terms of time and effort it doesn't stack up. It's not all of them but it's a lot! There are loads of us women in middle management and we're always side-eyeing each other when they bang on about things knowing there's a wife at home making it all possible.

Msxyz · 23/06/2023 12:59

What I am saying is that there is obviously a need to think long-term and take steps to financially protect yourself. However a) this is OBVIOUS and b) everyone's 'risk assessment' will be different. Make the point, by all means - it's an important point - but pages and pages of personal doom and gloom anecdotes just come across as 'overcooking the pudding' and verging on patronising. The OP is best placed to make her own assessment in HER circumstances. She doesn't need to hear about various husbands of today and yesteryear who did whatever. This is obvious! Of course women factor this in. And it is simply not true that being a SAHM means you are doomed to an unequal dynamic in your marriage; boredom or resentment. Not true at all. But, as I said, people tend to not post that kind of thing because they will be accused of being smug. So it's not a balanced perspective on here.

Teleguard · 23/06/2023 12:58

If you would have a good social life for yourself and your children and you enjoy home based crafts which could become a business in future then might be worth giving up work.

Otherwise a standing still career which gets you adult company while your children develop social skills at nursery might be better

Brefugee · 23/06/2023 12:57

i wonder how many new fathers with higher earning wives are having the same doubts and wondering the same things?

hmmm

Brefugee · 23/06/2023 12:51

Kilorrery · 21/06/2023 19:10

Because while absolutely, it’s easy to understand the exhausting mess of juggling a demanding FT job and a small child, why on earth does that mean you need to become a SAHM? Why do posters like you never conclude that what would be ‘best for the whole family’ would be DH taking a step back/becoming a SAHP/going part-time, or changing jobs to something that makes your juggling easier?

The ‘we decided it was best for our family for me to be a SAHM’ often seems code for ‘I couldn’t combine my job with doing the lion’s share of parenting, housework, household admin, childcare drop-offs and pick-ups, sick days etc and obviously DH couldn’t be asked to do half of this because (a) he’s a man and (b) he earns more, not unrelatedly, so I caved and quit and we’ll both pretend it was ever going to happen any other way.’

yy to this.

i was so stressed and burned out by being a SAHM when the DCs were tiny that my DH took over the 2nd 18 months of DC2s parental leave.

Best decision we ever made.

Brefugee · 23/06/2023 12:50

have only read most of OPs posts and frankly? if your DH wanted to make it work he could.

I was the higher earner but my DH couldn't really change his hours to suit. So we made sure that we had watertight childcare (paid through the nose). And then we arranged who was doing what, and who would sacrifice either a work day or some free time, to fit round what needed to be done around school or whatever.

And it's a struggle.

But blimey, even if i wasn't the higher earner, i would have insisted on the same. I wouldn't give up my financial independence for anyone without watertight financial arrangements to compensate.

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 12:48

Part time could be the magical answer! I went to 4 days for a year after each were born and it made a huge difference. I'd have done 3 if I could. Now I'm back 5 days and they are older primary school age and it's so, so much easier. One even has some additional needs and honestly having the cash for private therapies has been amazing.

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 12:46

You haven't acknowledged any wisdom from the women who are ahead of you in this and have said it's not inevitable, it gets easier. Or who have said, be careful, there may be more to this decision than it appears. Or have said, you know you don't have to structure your set up in black or white, there are lots of options in the grey. If you just wanted to (very legitimately) complain about the difficult juggle we would all have been in sympathising with you! But you asked the question and are putting a very negative slant on any answer that isn't encouraging you to become a SAHM.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 12:44

@BlurredVision but what I’m trying to explain is that everything everyone is cautiously warning me about re giving up work also applies to part time work. Therefore, in order to really ‘protect myself’ I would need to work full time and this is living my life assuming the worst will happen.

I am not suggesting that this applies to everybody but to my personal situation, it does. Part time isn’t a magical answer.

OP posts:
BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 12:42

We're not living our lives on the assumption that everything will go horribly wrong. That's a big leap! It's like saying if you have fire alarms in the house it's because you live on the assumption the house will burn down any moment. Anyone who exercises or eats well for future health reasons is not doing it because they go around all the time expecting to drop dead of a heart attack any minute. We're not all miserable women just working waiting for our husbands to die/leave us/get depressed. It's very possible to work (to whatever extent) and live a very happy, positive fulfilled life for yourself and your family. In fact the lack of worry two paychecks brings only makes that easier.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 12:35

I don’t think anyone is jealous or personally paranoid but I suppose what I’m trying to say is that living your life on the assumption that everything will go horribly wrong isn’t a life I want. I don’t think that means I’m overly cavalier in my approach to life, more that I recognise I can cope and I will cope if shit happens. But that’s different to expecting it to happen.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 23/06/2023 12:00

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 11:18

The OP asked a question wondering if there comes a point where you have to give up work. Many posters answered with 1. No, it's hard right now but you can make it work, try x,y,z and/or 2. Advising the OP of the risks of making herself financially dependent on her husband and taking on all the domestic duties. And they are being called paranoid, bitter, with complexes, etc. I think that is awful. The posters advising her to be cautious are actively supporting a woman by ensuring she doesn't make herself vulnerable and can consider those risks as part of her decision. Or reassuring her that it's hard now but it gets easier (which it does). And they're bitter and paranoid and living a half life? That's horrible.

@BlurredVision 'Twas ever thus.

If I had a pound for every time I'd been called "bitter" or "jealous" by posters for pointing out that becoming wholly dependent on a man was risky I would be a multi-millionaire.

TBH whenever someone accuses another poster of being "bitter" I discount their arguments out of hand. It's a sign of intellectual flimsiness.

The OP's situation is complicated and the solution is probably somewhere in the middle between working FT and stopping work altogether but I do find it aggravating that encouraging women to consider their long-term financial security always prompts accusations of jealousy.

Reasontoreason · 23/06/2023 11:53

I agree sometimes its to difficult for both parents to work. People's situations are different ,but if you can afford to be a SAHM for a few years. Which takes the pressure of you having to run around at work and at home. Making you life's easier for your husband your self and children . Go for it .

DistantSkye · 23/06/2023 11:29

I've only read the first couple of pages, and then just your posts...
Whilst I sympathise with your situation and acknowledge that it is hard, I'm not sure there comes a point where you have to give up work, more that you want to/would find it easier to?

It is a relatively short space of time that they're at different settings (school/nursery) depending on ages of your kids and then it gets easier. My youngest is starting school after the summer and I am very much looking forward to just one set of drop offs and pick ups! My husband works away a lot, we have no local family and I can't WFH so I do have some understanding of your situation, but I don't really identify with the "constant stress" and "charging/rushing about" that you mention. Maybe because I've been doing it for longer so am just more used to it than I was at the start!

I guess you just need to weigh up what's right for you and look into different types of wraparound care/childminder etc to figure out what will work and what is possible. I mean you seem adamant that your husband can't compromise at all and have a day set from home so it's hard to give much advice. My husband tends to have Mondays as a no travel day so he's available then.

BlurredVision · 23/06/2023 11:18

The OP asked a question wondering if there comes a point where you have to give up work. Many posters answered with 1. No, it's hard right now but you can make it work, try x,y,z and/or 2. Advising the OP of the risks of making herself financially dependent on her husband and taking on all the domestic duties. And they are being called paranoid, bitter, with complexes, etc. I think that is awful. The posters advising her to be cautious are actively supporting a woman by ensuring she doesn't make herself vulnerable and can consider those risks as part of her decision. Or reassuring her that it's hard now but it gets easier (which it does). And they're bitter and paranoid and living a half life? That's horrible.

Saracen · 23/06/2023 10:54

One small point which might be a bit helpful on a practical level: did you know you are allowed to make small contributions to a personal pension even if you aren't working at all? Even a non-taxpayer gets a top-up from government on pension contributions. I wish I had realised this earlier. I would have boosted my pension rather than putting all my money into less tax efficient savings for my retirement.

So if you give up work, assuming the family income allows for it, your own pension provision as well as your DH's can be increased. It's only a little (currently £3600 a year), and will undoubtedly be less than if you'd been working throughout, but it's something in your own name.

Saracen · 23/06/2023 10:40

OP, I've only read your own posts. You sound incredibly grounded and sensible. You know your priorities. Somehow I feel confident that you will find the right solution for you and your family.

I get the impression that the thread has been helpful to you in thinking it through, even though - as you say - there are people who don't seem to be grasping your perspective. But at least you have a chance to discover whether there are any potential issues you hadn't previously thought of, so you can take them into consideration too.

MaybeOneAndDone · 23/06/2023 10:39

OP, I see where you are coming from, and it's a similar line of thinking which has made me and my DH lean towards sticking at just one child.

I was totally unprepared for just how frequently our DS would be sent home from nursery with illness. We have zero family help, so it's been a juggle for both me and DH to deal with it. I just don't see how we could manage two children getting sent home sick (and probably at different times) without one of us giving up work entirely or massively scaling back.

When I look at friends or acquaintances with more than one child, there's always a parent (and it's not necessarily the mother) who has massively reduced their hours or become a SAHP.

I think people on this thread who are claiming to have managed two FT jobs and more than one child are either a) fabulously wealthy enough to afford a nanny b) have lots of nearby family support, or c) have unusually flexible jobs.

I don't know what field you are in OP, but is there any possibility of you freelancing? It would be a good way to "keep your hand in" if you do go the SAHM route.

Msxyz · 23/06/2023 10:27

OP, being a SAHM is absolutely fine. You know your life best. There will be people on here who speak with a lot of bitterness but ultimately, they are not you. People who are truly happy - whether it be as a SAHM or working mum - tend to not really post. So all you get are extreme views and people trying to project or work through their own personal complexes (or their mother's or whoever) via your scenario. You won't really get balanced or nuanced views that is relevant to you.

Honestly, loads if women are SAHMs and why wouldn't they be? What is unusual about having a child and wanting to be there for them, day to day? Not everyone has the means to do this, but it's a very natural thing to want to do. Life is so hectic these days. If you don't love your job, why on earth should you feel compelled to pay someone else to be with your children when you could do a much better job yourself? Not everyone can cope with being a SAHM, but it can be the best thing in the world. You and your DH will take care of the future and work it out in a way that suits you both. It's fine.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/06/2023 10:08

@Bluewatersummer

As a PP says it does depend on your tolerance for risk.

But the years of wraparound care and drop offs/pick ups: honestly this is how most parents live these days. Kids are fine with it: there will always people who will tip up here and tell you it's bad for children and "how could you do it to them" etc but in decades of discussion about this not one single piece of evidence has yet emerged to back up the idea that childcare is bad for children. Most children thrive in a well-organised childcare setting. And the drop offs/pick ups you would be doing anyway, right?

There will be a few years when you (or your DH) have to be pretty ruthless about time management and leaving on the dot for pickups etc and it can be stressful when you are running late etc. And your career may flatline for a bit. But it's no more stressful than spending your whole day looking after children.

Ultimately it's your call and you need to go with whatever you think is right for you and your family. No one else's views really matter, it's up to you and your DH.

But I do recognise the syndrome of the particular life stage you're in because I want through it myself and I promise you, it will pass and you will very likely get to a point where you think "thank God I kept my hand in".

hettie · 23/06/2023 10:07

Nah it's not years. Honestly.... When they're both in primary if you were part time you might need the odd breakfast club or after school. You also pull in support (dh does more domestic stuff or his big wage pays for it) and you're less run ragged because trust me the physical and emotional demands of a baby and toddler are full on. Two primary age kids are nothing like as demanding (unless you turn tiger mum and obsess about clubs/book bands/music exams and county level sports, but then that's on you and your poor kids).
So in primary it will be easier and you might find time/energy to pursue promotions. They are available to part time workers.
You say you don't want to live your life as if the worst will happen. Even if you are a statistical anomoly and there are no episodes of poor health or marital discord when the kids are in secondary on their way to leaving home what do want with your life? If you're happy to volunteer/bumble about and see to the domestic all well and good but unless your a teacher/nurse/medic it'll be nigh on impossible to return to work that you find rewarding.

Grumpyfroghats · 23/06/2023 10:04

You need to pick up and drop off your kids regardless of whether that's from wraparound or 9-3, there's no more frantic charging if it's wraparound!

In fact, I think wraparound is actually easier because it's not a precise time. I find the day I drop and pick up 9-3 more stressful because I have to time things more precisely

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/06/2023 09:53

I think that's fair enough, OP. We all have different levels of tolerance for risk. I wouldn't personally be willing to take the risk of quitting my career, but if you're OK with it, then that's your call.

Historically, the state has stepped in to support single parents, so there has always been a safety net that people can rely on, which has perhaps meant that they haven't needed to think too hard about personal risk. There used to be a kind of national consensus that innocent children shouldn't have to suffer because of decisions made by their parents. These days, I wouldn't want to rely on the welfare state if things went pear shaped, as the support has largely eroded by this Tory government. Foodbanks are full of people who are struggling to put food on the table for their kids.

Bluewatersummer · 23/06/2023 09:53

See I actually think it’s years - wraparound care and drop offs and pick ups and frantic charging around! Definitely throughout primary school years (surely?) And that’s not a ‘I will give up work’ - contrary as it might sound I’ll be more likely to increase my hours because then I can solve a few problems with the private school route. That’s got a lot of ‘ifs’ too though.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread