Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
LT1982 · 24/06/2023 08:37

I had pressed reply to a comment which said women going back to work is "anti-feminist"

The whole point of feminism is for women to be treated equally and have the choice to work so telling working mothers they are anti-feminist is ridiculous.

The same poster claims childcare isn't good for children so she is clearly against working mums 🙄

kikisparks · 24/06/2023 08:36

Anyway, we’re only having one child for many many reasons but this is one. We both work full time on compressed hours so that we can do equal childcare (we also alrternate lie ins on the weekend etc) and that I think is an amazing thing for my daughter to see. She spends 4 days a week with one or both of her parents (and sees us for a few hours a day on the other three). Sickness issues have been hard and we’re exhausted from the long days but it has worked out otherwise well so far and we will both have no pension or financial reductions.

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 08:28

Not sure who that was aimed at, @LT1982 but something I do know about feminism is that not all feminists think the same - something that is often lost on here amongst the ‘feminists think XXX’ sort of posts. Presenting as a lofty FACT that if you think X, you cannot be a feminist or indeed know anything about feminism is a very narrow view of what constitutes feminism.

I digress but there are plenty of disagreements amongst feminists - some of them pretty passionate.

OP posts:
kikisparks · 24/06/2023 08:24

Sarahtm35 · 21/06/2023 11:23

Personally I think it’s anti-feminist for a women to have to give birth and then go out to work, it’s also not very kind to the child either.
having worked in childcare, I can tell you these children who spend all day in a childcare setting are not happy and a lot of the parents refuse to acknowledge it as they’re too busy with work and life.
I understand many women have no choice but to work, but if you’re husband earns enough or you’re able to make cutbacks to stay home, then I think that’s the kindest thing to do for your child.

What about women who want to go to work? Why is it only women who should give up heir financial independence, career prospects, pension and life as something more than a parent? I really don’t see how you can dress up the concept that women should stay home with their children as a feminist one. Women should have the choice to do what’s best for them, as far as finances allow. Also just because the children in the childcare setting you were in were unhappy doesn’t mean that’s the same in all childcare settings!

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 08:15

Tell me you know nothing about feminism without telling me

Beautiful3 · 24/06/2023 08:11

I was in the same boat as you. I worked part time even my husband worked a rotating shift (including nights). Quite often my child was unwell. The nursery was close to me, my husband was miles away and unable to pick up (no phones allowed where he works. All calls would have to go through his switchboard). So it always fell to me, to collect said sick child and go home. This happened alot. Then I had another child. I was stressed and overwhelmed with the house stuff, and being alone eith the kids when he was working lates. I left my Job to be a sahm. I loved it, it became so much easier. My youngest will leave primary school soon, that's when I'll get another job as she'll be more independent.

Mamanch · 24/06/2023 07:40

I'm a sahm to 4dc under 7 and I can't really imagine going to work. I feel i don't have enough hours in the day as it is. But, i didn't have a career as such - I was only 25 when I had my 1st so had only been working a couple of years - and my job was by no means a passion. I fully intend to start working part-time once the youngest is at school and I sometimes worry that re-entry into the workplace will be a struggle, but I still think it's better than dashing around like a blue-arsed fly and feeling (I'm not saying other people feel this way, but I would) that I'm not giving my all to my children and my job. My husband earns enough that we can manage on just his salary for now, with the intention being that once the youngest is at secondary I'll be back full time. I have to say all of our thinking has been based around us being a family unit rather than 2 individuals with shared responsibilities. So if he takes up bodybuilding and cocaine I'm screwed ... 😂

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 07:30

It’s worth looking at but part time really isn’t always the answer. Sometimes it solves problems but other times it creates them!

OP posts:
Grumpyfroghats · 24/06/2023 07:27

And actually I didn't even mention national insurance contributions in there

Grumpyfroghats · 24/06/2023 07:26

@BertieBotts - it depends on your exact salaries and childcare costs but dropping a day or a half day if you're a higher rate tax payer costs less than you think because you only keep 60% of your earnings, take off two kids in nursery costs for that day and, for salaries in the 80-100k region, it doesn't end up costing much if anything to do it. We do it also to keep our salaries under 100k and so keep tax-free childcare. And to spend time with our children of course..

It's worth playing with the various PAYE calculators online

BertieBotts · 24/06/2023 07:17

Well maybe that works for people who aren't already stretched with one salary. But if you are at a stretched point then it does become a simple break even calculation generally.

However I agree that people should consider combining part time etc because this is hardly ever discussed/thought about. But if you're in a situation where the husband earns a lot more than the wife then it usually doesn't make any financial sense. It's different if earnings are fairly similar.

bussteward · 24/06/2023 07:10

BertieBotts · 24/06/2023 06:27

And it’s always the full cost of childcare accounted for, rather than 50%.

Well where do you want the other 50% to magically come from? People aren't saying "My wage is too low and also I'm the only one responsible for childcare" they are saying "If I work and we pay for childcare, the net effect is a loss"

Unless the DH's wage is massive they probably need all of it.

I’m saying why is it always calculated as the woman’s income covers childcare, and when it can’t cover childcare or comes at a loss, she quits work. Vs considering it covers 50% of childcare, and if the DH wants to continue working he needs to account for being able to cover 50% too, or take some responsibility for figuring out what to do: are there savings that can cover the loss until age two (when day rates go down), can both parents go to a four-day week using different days so the DC goes to childcare three days, can hours be juggled so daycare hours used are shorter (our nursery is miles cheaper 9-5 than for 8-6), can the family budget be squeezed to give up a football season ticket/outing hobby (cycling)/takeaways/whatever it is, some combination of all of the above.

On here people aren’t always saying the net effect is a loss: they’re saying the net effect is breaking even, or bringing in only a small amount. Yes, sometimes a loss – at which point you have to consider making a change. But the argument shouldn’t always be based on the woman’s income in isolation Vs the childcare cost: it should be “what is the household income, what is the childcare cost, and how can we adjust that to keep both parents working (if that’s what’s wanted) by adjusting both our hours/days/careers”. That’s where the other 50% magically comes from: dads doing some of the thinking and changing.

Parkandpicnic · 24/06/2023 06:45

If you think you would all be happier being at home for a while then go for it. Similar situation and I stepped back for a few years and loved it. No regrets at all, it’s too a huge amount of pressure off us and actually meant we could enjoy our family. Now back at work part time and loving that too, now that it’s the right time for us

Ameteurmum · 24/06/2023 06:33

So I have 3 under 7 - eldest two are at infant and junior school and the baby is at nursery. My husband and I both work full time but as he is the higher earner and I have a more understanding/flexible company I am able to do the default parent stuff. Not in a martyr way it just historically always made sense as I worked closer to home/school/nursery. Now we have three it’s a different ballgame and my husband does do a lot of the morning school runs and we have had a recent, terrible spate of chickenpox and then a sickness bug so he’s had time off to look after children and we have taken it in turns to work. It’s not easy. My brain feels like a scrambled egg most of the time but honestly I hold on to working for dear life - something that uses my brain, makes me feel useful in a way that just making snacks doesn’t and gives me an identity away from being ‘muuuuuuuuuuum’ all day long. I completely understand why so many women give it up though because in principle it’s the easier option but definitely discuss your options with your husband before you give up such a part of yourself x

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 06:28

X post @BertieBotts

OP posts:
Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 06:28

But the MN approved view is surely that all money is family money, so how does that work?

Let’s say total family income is £5000. Childcare is £1500, so total income £3500.

Parent A earns £3800, Parent B earns £1200. Without childcare, total income is £3800.

There are obviously a myriad of factors there that should be accounted for - does Parent B want to stop work, will they earn more in the future, and so on - but the family as a whole operate at a loss with Parent B working, even with everything split down the middle. That’s not the case for us: we make a good profit even with nursery fees although that will change with two! I will make a profit though, but not a huge one.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 24/06/2023 06:27

And it’s always the full cost of childcare accounted for, rather than 50%.

Well where do you want the other 50% to magically come from? People aren't saying "My wage is too low and also I'm the only one responsible for childcare" they are saying "If I work and we pay for childcare, the net effect is a loss"

Unless the DH's wage is massive they probably need all of it.

bussteward · 24/06/2023 04:23

I see so many women saying “I earned less so had to give up work” but unless you earn less than the cost of childcare it’s not that black and white.
And it’s always the full cost of childcare accounted for, rather than 50%.

CM1897 · 24/06/2023 03:19

Can you work from home part time? That’s what I do, my daughter goes to nursery and the older two go to school. My boss is flexible if I have to collect the children if they are ill. I only have to work in the office two days a month

CM1897 · 24/06/2023 03:13

Lcb123 · 21/06/2023 11:08

my concern has always been missing out on the benefits of work beyond salary, mostly pension and sick leave (which are both very generous at my employer), and keeping my hand in for when kids are older. Do you have the option for part time and/or WFH?

Pension (national insurance credits) would be paid while in receipt of child benefit

Thexwife · 24/06/2023 02:20

You’re lucky he didn’t take your money. Mine made me and the children homeless. Stopped paying mortgage so family home nearly got repossessed- I can’t get any credit now due the mortgage missed payments. And I had to give him money to clear his debts before the proceeds were split. There’s more - much more. Sometimes yes definitely worth working but if your ex is as bad as mine - he will want half of whatever you have, even though you would spend it on kids and he would spend it on …. Who knows car? Holidays? Gambling? Drugs?

Awkwardone · 23/06/2023 22:25

Deliberately awkward.

Hollyppp · 23/06/2023 21:58

Saracen · 23/06/2023 10:54

One small point which might be a bit helpful on a practical level: did you know you are allowed to make small contributions to a personal pension even if you aren't working at all? Even a non-taxpayer gets a top-up from government on pension contributions. I wish I had realised this earlier. I would have boosted my pension rather than putting all my money into less tax efficient savings for my retirement.

So if you give up work, assuming the family income allows for it, your own pension provision as well as your DH's can be increased. It's only a little (currently £3600 a year), and will undoubtedly be less than if you'd been working throughout, but it's something in your own name.

I didn’t know this! I’m SAHM and would love more detail - is there a specific name for this that I can google to get more info and set it up?

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 21:51

Awkwardone · 23/06/2023 21:42

To people. No discrimination. Just as it was thus.

So both parents should give up their careers if they want children?

Awkwardone · 23/06/2023 21:43

Nuts.