Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Accidental” pregnancy. Has it ever worked out?

158 replies

Definitelynotagoodidea · 21/06/2023 08:23

Had a fallout with one of my closest friends who let it slip after a couple of drinks that she’d stopped taking the pill without informing her partner of 6 years. Her reasons are that they’ve discussed having kids and he definitely wants them but he just wants them to be in a perfect financial/home situation before trying. She thinks he will be fine with an accidental pregnancy but won’t discuss it upfront with him as she knows he will tell her “not right now”.
She’s in her early 30’s and he’s 10 years older and my view is that he actually doesn’t want kids at all which is why he’s employed numerous delaying tactics over the last couple of years so this has disaster written all over it. However, apparently I am wrong and loads of people do it and have happy outcomes.

YABU - yes, loads of women do this and it all works out.
YANBU - terrible idea. Friend is deluded and will likely all end in tears.

OP posts:
Goldencup · 22/06/2023 07:41

Back to the situation in the OP, it has so many flags he might as well be a lifeguard. The age difference, his attitude and her being afraid of a Frank conversation. Unfortunately I have intimate knowledge of a few relationships with this dynamic- it does not end well.

yadeciN · 22/06/2023 07:39

MintJulia · 22/06/2023 06:38

He's leaving the decision making and effort to her rather than dealing with the issue himself. His laziness will cost him dear!

Can you imagine the uproar if couple decides on pill as contraception and the the man will come up with "you know, I will use condom as well just in case".
The threads on here would be massively full of LTB.
"he is cheating and doesn't want to infect anyone with anything"
"he doesn't trust you!"
"he is controlling and doesn't trust you"
"he is lying about something, probably prostitutes"
It would NEVER be hailed as positive thing to do since both agreed on pill.
Tbh I would not be pleased either if DH came in with using condoms as well after we agreed different contraception.

Would you call woman lazy if the couple agreed on condoms and the man making sure they are stock up? I bet the answer would be no.

The fact that people on here actually don't even realise that they are arguing for men to not to trust women is weird.
"well, his own fault, he should have not trust her" is what all these are doing.

GrumpyPanda · 22/06/2023 07:35

Definitelynotagoodidea · 21/06/2023 08:43

I think it’s the constant shifting of goalposts. Firstly, it was the “we need a house with more space”, then it was “let’s get the house renovated first” and this has continued with all sorts of excuses and the latest is that he wants to have at least six months worth of savings in the bank before trying. He’s in his 40’s and has a highly paid job and a number of rental properties. They appear to be in a great financial position so I’m not sure why he is so reluctant to give my friend what she desperately wants. I can only assume he doesn’t actually want kids and is stringing her along but I could be wrong.

Starting to sound like he's just as deceitful. So maybe they deserve each other.

Goldencup · 22/06/2023 07:29

It seems to me in my Hagdom that this issue is one of the last vistages of internalised misogyny. Young women have been so stripped of their autonomy that they feel the need to deceive, simply to take control of their own reproductive health. Men believe they have the right to insist that their sexual partner take endogenous hormones and these women don't feel able to say no. And we blame the women ? Really ? Because a man's right to do exactly as he pleases trumps everything. This is all in the past for me, I am 47 and at times have been very clear that the risks of hormonal contraception (blood clots) far outweigh that of unintended pregnancy. What DH chooses to do with that information is his lookout.

Dinobore · 22/06/2023 07:28

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 07:12

I'm a strident feminist but that means equality - not seeing something a woman does as 'okay' when the male equivalent would be abhorrent.

IMO there's no difference between this and a man putting pin holes in a condom (and this man being one you're in a supposedly loving, committed relationship with!).

It's quite clearly the same.

Consent given to sex on a specific condition does not hold if the other person knowingly removes that condition.

It's like the recent cases where women have pretended to be men to have sexual interactions with other women...

If the other person wouldn't have had sex with you had they known the full circumstances then it's at the very best morally disgusting and at the worst, criminal.

I don't believe you can make it criminal in every case (I wouldn't have had sex with him if I'd known he was married) but given the outcome of this type of behaviour is lifelong emotional and financial commitment to a child I believe it should be criminal.

Men can wear condoms though if they want, sure in a trusting relationship you should be able to trust your partner, but they do have tools at their disposal to also bear some responsibility. They are not quite clearly the same, and how you'd police or prove womens bodies to make it illegal is scary. Again, I believe it is abhorrent and not something I'd ever consider and there's no circumstances its okay, but still it's not equivalent. Especially as a man can never get pregnant, a woman being at risk of pregnancy against their knowledge is different to a man.

Dinobore · 22/06/2023 07:24

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 07:04

I don't think that negates any of the comparison TBH.

The vast majority of STIs can be dealt with in a week with antibiotics.

Children are a lifelong commitment.

Assuming I wanted neither an STI nor a child - I'd take any STI except HIV over the child.

I agree it's morally corrupt and an awful thing to do, personally I don't think both actions are equal. For one pregnancy adversely affects the female by a long shot, and I don't think introducing laws around women taking body altering contraceptives is aspirational.

comingoat · 22/06/2023 07:16

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

Turnthelightoff · 22/06/2023 07:15

I think you should encourage her to tell him. Tell her to say that since now all they need is the cushion of some savings, they have the time TTC and the pregnancy to achieve that, plus she’s not as concerned about that aspect especially now with the recent announcement of more free childcare so she’s taking the first step towards preparing for that and stopping taking her contraceptive. It’s not being dishonest like she currently is but giving him a bit of an ultimatum.

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 07:12

I'm a strident feminist but that means equality - not seeing something a woman does as 'okay' when the male equivalent would be abhorrent.

IMO there's no difference between this and a man putting pin holes in a condom (and this man being one you're in a supposedly loving, committed relationship with!).

It's quite clearly the same.

Consent given to sex on a specific condition does not hold if the other person knowingly removes that condition.

It's like the recent cases where women have pretended to be men to have sexual interactions with other women...

If the other person wouldn't have had sex with you had they known the full circumstances then it's at the very best morally disgusting and at the worst, criminal.

I don't believe you can make it criminal in every case (I wouldn't have had sex with him if I'd known he was married) but given the outcome of this type of behaviour is lifelong emotional and financial commitment to a child I believe it should be criminal.

Goldencup · 22/06/2023 07:10

BananaSpanner · 21/06/2023 08:34

I was about to answer yes to your question as we had an accidental pregnancy and all was fine and happy (and still is 12 years and another planned child later). However, whilst we were careless, we both knew we were being careless, there was no deceit.

Me too he is 19 and a wonderful young man, we are both so proud of him.

LondonSouth28 · 22/06/2023 07:06

I know so many women who have done this. One in a marriage who desperately wanted a third, husband didn't but she took matters into her on hands.
Recently heard of one - she tells boyfriend she is coming off pill as she wants 'a break' from it, she says let's use rhythm method, he leaves the tracking to her... and he finds out she is pregnant when he finds a + pregnancy test in a drawer. He is happy about it, and when he told me this it's like he hadn't quite done the maths yet...

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 07:04

I don't think that negates any of the comparison TBH.

The vast majority of STIs can be dealt with in a week with antibiotics.

Children are a lifelong commitment.

Assuming I wanted neither an STI nor a child - I'd take any STI except HIV over the child.

Florissante · 22/06/2023 07:03

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 06:56

If I'm completely honest I feel like this is as close as women can get to raping someone.

The courts have been clear that if a man says he will wear a condom, and then he takes it off without the woman realising...that is rape because her consent was only given on that condition.

I don't see how that doesn't apply the other way around?

If a man is only consenting on the condition that the woman is taking contraceptives, that consent isn't there if she has secretly stopped.

Agreed.

Florissante · 22/06/2023 07:03

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 06:59

Would you have the same opinion of a woman who got pregnant because she trusted the man to use a condom and he secretly took it off or put pin holes in it?

I agree. Deceitful, inexcusable behaviour.

Dinobore · 22/06/2023 07:00

YeahIsaidit · 21/06/2023 08:42

A guy removing a condom during sex without saying is "stealthing" and AFAIK is illegal, in my opinion doing this is exactly the same thing and should be treated the same. I think that is deplorable and I'd question my friendship with this person

I agree it's awful to be deceitful but condoms do more than protect against pregnancy. A woman stopping contraception isn't opening the other party up to STIs etc against their will and knowledge.

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 06:59

DeeplyMovingExperience · 21/06/2023 08:47

"Accidental" (on purpose) pregnancies are very common. Men who think all women are honest about using contraception are stupid. If they don't want to cause a pregnancy, they have to take responsibility for containing or disabling their sperm.

ALL unplanned pregnancies are caused by men. They seem not to be able to grasp this.

I have a very low opinion of women who deliberately get pregnant without a man's consent. However, the men are totally culpable for not taking care of their own contraception.

My brother has FOUR children that were unplanned, and seems not to be able to grasp how it happened. Fucking idiot.

Would you have the same opinion of a woman who got pregnant because she trusted the man to use a condom and he secretly took it off or put pin holes in it?

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 06:56

If I'm completely honest I feel like this is as close as women can get to raping someone.

The courts have been clear that if a man says he will wear a condom, and then he takes it off without the woman realising...that is rape because her consent was only given on that condition.

I don't see how that doesn't apply the other way around?

If a man is only consenting on the condition that the woman is taking contraceptives, that consent isn't there if she has secretly stopped.

MintJulia · 22/06/2023 06:38

Florissante · 21/06/2023 19:19

has sex without taking responsibility for contraception.

His partner is / was taking the Pill.

He's leaving the decision making and effort to her rather than dealing with the issue himself. His laziness will cost him dear!

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:23

So what? He's a grown up. If he wants to avoid pregnancy he needs to take steps to ensure it doesn't happen.

Florissante · 21/06/2023 19:19

has sex without taking responsibility for contraception.

His partner is / was taking the Pill.

MintJulia · 21/06/2023 18:49

So he tells her he wants children but uses stalling tactics to delay until they are too old, and has sex without taking responsibility for contraception.

And she has come off the pill because she believes he's only worried about the finances of the moment, and so intends to fall pregnant 'accidentally on purpose'

They sound as bad as each other I wouldn't get involved.

Orban · 21/06/2023 18:20

Sounds like they're both pissing each other about. Not your business though. I'm sure you don't know everything that goes on in their relationship.

SchoolShenanigans · 21/06/2023 18:18

I've known a few women who have admitted to doing this. They're all split up now. I think it's indicative of poor communication and a poor relationship really, so if she does it, that's on her. But I would imagine she'll be a single mum at some stage, although maybe she's willing to take that risk as she's early 30s.

User135644 · 21/06/2023 18:16

I couldn't be friends with a sociopath.