Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secularism in schools: how girls dress

56 replies

Chocchops72 · 21/06/2023 06:31

We live in France, DH and I both work in state high schools here. You might know that France has a strict rule of laïcité/ secularism in public spaces, particularly including schools. This means that no one is allowed to wear clothes or display ‘symbols’ that might have a religious significance.

we had a big lecture from the head last night, part of which was a government-mandated reinforcement of laïcité à l’école that is being put in place for the next school year. The particular focus this time has been a type of dress / over-garment that some female, presumably Muslim, students are wearing over their usual clothes, presumably for ‘modesty’ reasons. I’m sorry, I didn’t catch the proper name for it.

we’ve been told that this form of dress is a symbol of religion and, as such, falls under laïcité. Teachers are to challenge the students if they are seen wearing them, and they will be told to remove them or leave the school.

its always seems to focus on girls, never boys, and that really annoys me. None of the boys seem to have any restrictions - none of them even try to wear what might be described as traditional Muslim dress to school (my French colleague tells me it’s just not considered cool for boys) in the first place so they don’t fall foul of these rules. And other girls are allowed to wear whatever they want, often going too far in the opposite direction: no uniforms here, it’s boiling hot, a lot of them are basically wearing bikini tops to school. Which, while it isn’t exactly acceptable under the school rules, doesn’t have nearly the same weight of opprobrium going against it.

i don’t know what my AIBU is: I think everyone is being unreasonable!

OP posts:
Testina · 21/06/2023 14:16

“None of the boys seem to have any restrictions”

Yeah, that’s because mostly religions are only bothered about controlling women 🙄

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/06/2023 14:11

itshotontheplayground · 21/06/2023 13:59

as opposed to the UK where most schools have mandatory uniforms
and yearly debates about kids having to wear full winter uniform in a heatwave 😂

No school is forced to make uniform mandatory, but most do, probably because there's a cultural expectation, plus many parents favour it. As for the children themselves, whatever option offered there would be people who are unhappy. Having attended schools where uniform was both mandatory and optional, I know which I preferred. (interestingly enough, the uniform optional school has since switched to mandatory).

As for weather, that's the fault of schools for not adapting the uniform to the season. I have no problem with uniform so long as it's sensibly applied. I've mentioned on another thread that at my secondary school, blazers were strictly outdoor summer wear, never worn indoors. We wore short sleeved open necked blouses, no ties. Having pupils swelter in blazers and ties indoors in hot weather is, I agree, ridiculous.

itshotontheplayground · 21/06/2023 13:59

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/06/2023 13:51

I think that unless you're getting your tits out, the French are fucking fascists when it comes to policing people's clothing choices. Fuck that.

as opposed to the UK where most schools have mandatory uniforms
and yearly debates about kids having to wear full winter uniform in a heatwave 😂

itshotontheplayground · 21/06/2023 13:54

I don't understand

(boys) none of them even try to wear what might be described as traditional Muslim dress to school

so they are not allowed to break the secularity rules, but they .. don't?
The rules still apply to them. What's the problem?

If rules were no topless at school, and only boys were trying to take their tops off, would you complain about rules "focusing on the boys" when they are just rules... and apply to anyone.

You could complain if there were different rules for boys and girls, but .. there are the same?

UnctuousUnicorns · 21/06/2023 13:51

I think that unless you're getting your tits out, the French are fucking fascists when it comes to policing people's clothing choices. Fuck that.

DisquietintheRanks · 21/06/2023 13:46

Startofit · 21/06/2023 13:18

Most religions are not as concerned with controlling what men/boys wear as much as they are with women/girls, especially when it comes to "modesty".

Yes and no. Orthodox Jewish men and Sikh men are far more distinctively dressed than woman of these religions.

DisquietintheRanks · 21/06/2023 13:45

Chocchops72 · 21/06/2023 07:16

@Quiverer it’s everything: no religious symbols / clothing in any public venue, including public (state) schools.

So not always girls then?

sillysmiles · 21/06/2023 13:40

it just falls on girls, all the time

But that's because the religious expectation of modesty falls on girls. As you say, boys can rock up in jeans and hoodies - so can girls.

What are the numbers on girls dropping out of education because of this? Surely because it is a universal law, then all parents know this from the start and there is less family pressure ?

Startofit · 21/06/2023 13:18

Most religions are not as concerned with controlling what men/boys wear as much as they are with women/girls, especially when it comes to "modesty".

Lifescary · 21/06/2023 07:24

France makes men wear speedos in public pools. Horrendous.

Elleherd · 21/06/2023 07:21

It will always affect girls most as most religious or cultural dress is required to be worn by females.

Jewish boys aren't allowed to wear Kippah or tzitzit. I'm told that in the last 20 odd years it's apparently lead to two thirds of them leaving the French state school system.

OrwellianTimes · 21/06/2023 07:20

I believe strongly in the freedom of religion. This is archaic, and as others have said runs the real risk of certain girls missing out on education.

110APiccadilly · 21/06/2023 07:17

I sit on the fence so much on this that I get splinters!

I am not myself someone who would, for instance, be comfortable in a bikini. So if I imagine myself being forced to wear a bikini (i.e. a garment much less modest than I'd choose) to participate in society, I am very sympathetic to Muslim girls and women who want to wear more modest clothes.

On the other hand, I do think that very extreme versions (e.g. covered head to toe with even your eyes behind gauze) inherently seperate the wearer from society (and sometimes cause identity/ security issues). I also don't think they're appropriate for some jobs, such as teaching, because of the effect on communication.

So while I think the French go too far I don't think I can be against all restrictions.

Chocchops72 · 21/06/2023 07:16

@Quiverer it’s everything: no religious symbols / clothing in any public venue, including public (state) schools.

OP posts:
Quiverer · 21/06/2023 07:12

Is it always girls? Are boys prevented from wearing turbans and yarmulkes?

Chocchops72 · 21/06/2023 07:09

@LlynTegid and loads of catholic schools / universities !!! This is the bit that confuses me. Private Catholic schools are everywhere, they are state funded and are required to teach the national curriculum.

ironically Muslim families often send their children to catholic private schools as they are perceived to be stricter than state schools.

OP posts:
Srin · 21/06/2023 07:07

I don’t believe in policing what people wear at all. If someone wants to wear a bikini top or a burqa, that is a matter for them and, if they are young, their parents.

LlynTegid · 21/06/2023 07:04

Yet the French have Ascension Day, All Saints Day, the Assumption of Mary, Christmas and Easter as public holidays.

Chocchops72 · 21/06/2023 06:57

@Summerpetal

le port de signes ou de tenues manifestant une appartenance religieuse dans les écoles et établissements scolaires.

traslated… what is banned is « the wearing of signs or clothing showing religious affiliation in schools and educational establishments »

so everything is included, large crosses, turbans, headscarf’s etc. This is nothing new in France, the principle of the separation of church and state is very long standing (and I’m not against the principle).

it just falls on girls, all the time. That’s what pisses me off. Whether it’s family / religious pressure to confirm to ‘modesty’, social / cultural pressure to do the opposite and come to school in a bikini. The boys just rock up in jeans and a t-shirt / hoody year round - whatever their religion.

OP posts:
DutchCowgirl · 21/06/2023 06:52

Back in my days we had muslim girls getting on the bus to school in traditional dresses and as soon the bus was on the way, they would remove the outermost layer of their clothes and have a very modern western outfit to enjoy for the rest of the day. For those type of girls the French rules would be great.

But in England they’d also had to wear a school uniform isn’t it? So is it very different in the end?

TreadLight · 21/06/2023 06:52

When two cultures meet, sometimes they compliment each other and sometimes they clash. The difficult question to answer is which culture should take priority; the indigenous secular French culture or the alternative religious culture. There are strong arguements for the French to protect their culture just as their are strong arguments for them to welcome and assimilate other cultures. Ultimately it is a value judgement based on what is felt important.

Noicant · 21/06/2023 06:48

Are you talking about the abaya? Just a long cloak over clothes? I don’t see why that would be banned its like a long kimono, many young women with uncovered hair in the middle east wear then over t’shirts and jeans/leggings and leave them open. Like a long kimono, makes them look quite elegant if you ask me.

It’s more a national dress thing, like the kaftan. They may as well just ban any article of clothing that originated in any middle eastern country.

KimberleyClark · 21/06/2023 06:47

So is the wearing of crosses also forbidden?

Seashor · 21/06/2023 06:46

I’ve had problems with France and their lack of religious tolerance in schools for years. It creates an underclass of uneducated girls.

Simonjt · 21/06/2023 06:45

Summerpetal · 21/06/2023 06:43

How much of this is aimed at males ,I’ve not noticed males wearing much religious dress except a turban…is that off limits ..
or just women it’s aimed at ..
maybe some younger women ,are glad of the ruling ,some full covered clothing can’t be nice on a hot day ..
I was thinking ,though ,does their actual religion demand such strict dress codes ? Or has what is expected of these women ,just evolved over time to wear it is now ..
I also wonder the reasoning behind this ruling in France ,what is their actual policy on this,and how did they word it as necessary

You probably have seen religious dress but not realised, a shirt without a collar for example (so lots of t-shirts would come under this unless they have very very short sleeves and are very tight), shorts that almost come to the knee etc.