Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel a bit annoyed that this woman tried to tell me my own nationality?

171 replies

threelegdonkey · 20/06/2023 22:32

I'm not sure of the correct phrasing so apologies if I've gotten it wrong!

Basically, I was not born in the UK but have lived here most of my life as my parents moved here when I was very young. I do look and sound typically British.

Met a client at work today, recognised her accent as being from my 'home country' and started chatting to her about where we were both from. She said I didn't have much of an accent and I said I'd lived in the UK for X amount of years and she very obviously scoffed at me, rolled her eyes and said 'Oh, well you aren't really [insert country] then are you. You're British'.

Aibu to be a bit offended by her dismissiveness? Not that being British is a bad thing at all it's just that despite the fact I grew up here I don't consider myself to be particularly British. I had no British family members around me growing up so most of the culture, art, food, music, customs etc I was surrounded by at home were from my home country. I was badly bullied as a child because of the fact I was 'different', because I wasn't born here. So it did feel very hurtful to have my whole life experience completely dismissed by this person just because I've developed a British accent.

Aibu? Was she rude and insensitive or am I being over sensitive?

OP posts:
blauera · 21/06/2023 10:21

Ah OP. I can really identify...

This has happened to me.. she was a bit arsey about it, that's for sure. I've found that women tend to reject my ' birth nationality ' whereas men tend to accept it, as a general rule. In fact, men encourage it. ' but your blood is XYZ. You were raised in XYZ household. So you're XYZ !'.

When someone asks me where I am from, I no longer say ' I am from XYZ '. I say my family are from XYZ. It's much easier. Because people would always ask ' oh where abouts ? How long have you lived in the UK ? Your accent is really not there. ' etc.

I'm of southern European heritage so I don't look British, which may be different.

It is what it is. We never fit in anywhere 100 percent. I enjoy surrounding myself with second or third culture people, because only they can really get you. I do have friends that are just from one culture, but I usually prefer people of a mixed background who have also lived in the UK for ages. I feel like they understand.

AdoraBell · 21/06/2023 10:11

I think she was being rude.

Bromptotoo · 21/06/2023 10:06

Journalist Afua Hirsch who is of mixed African and UK Jewish heritage - paternal grandfather was a refugee from Nazism.

In her book Brit(ish) she writes at length about not fitting in either UK culture or that in Ghana from where her Mother hails.

An interesting and illuminating read for those of us with singular UK roots.

JenniferBarkley · 21/06/2023 09:15

sashh · 21/06/2023 08:38

Jimmy Carr refers to himself as a 'plastic paddy' ie he has the passport but not the accent.

Yeah plastic paddy is a common term but I don't think it's seen as acceptable any more. One you'd only use about yourself or in jest with someone you're very close to and know it won't offend.

sashh · 21/06/2023 08:38

JenniferBarkley · 21/06/2023 07:01

It is complex. Lots of people with Irish citizenship are in your shoes. As someone who grew up in Ireland, I'd consider them legally Irish but culturally British (although I wouldn't be so rude as to say it). An Irish woman my age would have grown up with Bosco, the Den, the Leaving Cert, the Gaeltacht, learning Irish and then forgetting it the second they left school. Grin Someone who grew up in GB would have different cultural touchstones.

Jimmy Carr refers to himself as a 'plastic paddy' ie he has the passport but not the accent.

TakeMyStrongHand · 21/06/2023 08:20

I think the reality is that you're both. You wouldn't be you without all the influences and experiences of your childhood. Both are important and you don't have to pick one but if you do, that's for you. Not some random lady.

This lady doesn't know you or your heart or how much home influence you had growing up. She sees what she thinks from a short conversation and instead of choosing to bond over the similarities has chosen to separate over the differences.

Brefugee · 21/06/2023 08:01

DrGoogleMD · 20/06/2023 23:29

I think your kids are probably quite the exception? If all of their schooling was in France for instance do they know the games that are played in the schoolyards in Britain, what they have for lunch, the annoying poem that everybody is forced to learn and remembers word for word 20 years later, the ice lollies people would buy on a hot day, the school uniforms or the million other small things that make up our childhoods and our cultural references? Like if I mention the guy on the news who slipped on the ice I can pretty much guarantee that everyone in the country I live in now will know what country I live in and what news segment I am talking about. I don't have those same references for the country I was born in and to me it is small things like that that make up your cultural identity. I think it would be really unusual to know those inside out the same way as someone who has lived somewhere all of their life would.

It's subtle.
My DCs are like that posters but German. They tell me that even though they have never lived there they feel more culturally British than German.
And a lot of that is how they consume media, in particular social media - mostly in English (but not necessarily British)
I have spent more of my life in Germany than the UK. I went to school in England. I feel culturally British, but if anyone asks? I'm from Yorkshire. Nobody can tell because my accent is SSB

KvotheTheBloodless · 21/06/2023 07:46

Are you Irish, OP? As I've heard that before from Irish people - if you'd been brought up in France it'd be fine and they'd consider you Irish still, but being brought up in Britain seems to carry a stigma.

If she's Irish I understand where the prejudice comes from, the UK has been awful to the Irish for so long that it'll take a long, long time for prejudices to fade from memory.

She was still wrong though, it's hardly your fault you were brought up elsewhere, and her attitude is both rude and unacceptable.

Mother87 · 21/06/2023 07:44

Yes I love it when people tell me I don't really look this/look more that/must be more this/must be confused/not really this or that - grew up in Chinese/English household in the UK - look Eurasian & identify far more with the Chinese side as dad had far more impact culturally/in every way - but didn't teach us the language. Earliest memories are from visiting people "back home" - but it will be ME who decides what I am/what I feel...

Rewis · 21/06/2023 07:25

Of course she was rude. Anyone who says " you're not really" or "where are you really from" are rude. She should have kept her thoughts to herself.

Simplelobsterhat · 21/06/2023 07:24

It does seem a bit rude and dismissive - generally when meeting new people you look for things in common, not shut those down and look for the differences. And I think anyone being critical of how you describe your nationality is very personal and bound to put you on edge a bit - I get similar when people get into (usually probably well meant and just interested) 'Why don't you speak Welsh then?' conversations if I don't know them well. I know that's not the same but sometimes end up with a feeling that I'm being criticised for doing my nationality wrong!

I can see a few reasons she might be a bit sensitive about you claiming to be 'the same ' as her though. Depending on the country, are there hardships someone growing up there would have faced that you wouldn't have? Or, is she struggling to adapt to bring new in the UK / facing discrimination and feeling it's ok for you as you have settled, pass as British? I'm not saying she's right to correct you in these cases but could understand her feeling a bit sensitive in those cases,and very aware of the difference between you.

Seymour5 · 21/06/2023 07:08

Ethnicity and nationality can be different. You can be an ethnic African, Swede, Chinese, Canadian or whatever, yet hold British nationality.

HelloHandsome · 21/06/2023 07:04

Sounds like she was being very clumsy. Could she have met people at home who had foreign passports but identified as the nationality of the country they grew up in? Sometimes when people meet some people with a particular viewpoint they assume everyone in that situation shares that position.

JenniferBarkley · 21/06/2023 07:01

It is complex. Lots of people with Irish citizenship are in your shoes. As someone who grew up in Ireland, I'd consider them legally Irish but culturally British (although I wouldn't be so rude as to say it). An Irish woman my age would have grown up with Bosco, the Den, the Leaving Cert, the Gaeltacht, learning Irish and then forgetting it the second they left school. Grin Someone who grew up in GB would have different cultural touchstones.

Karwomannghia · 21/06/2023 06:54

It doesn’t matter how long you’ve lived here etc she was rude and dismissive to you, someone she’d only just met! Of course that’s unacceptable! I wonder how many people she ‘puts right’ a day?

PuttingDownRoots · 21/06/2023 06:54

Nationality (and race) are complex.

Theres "legal" nationality... so pretty much what your passport says.
Theres "cultural" nationality... your influences growing up
Theres "where you are from" I.e. your home town/country growing up (not necessarily where you were born.)
And where you were born
And all that adds up to how you feel.

Its clear you feel more strongly about your birthplace and felt your family background was stronger than your other influences. (No idea about your legal nationality).

My elder DD feels British but has no feeling of "home". She has no affinity to her home country. Has moved around a lot. But in a few years she will probably feel more towards the place we've settled in. (Been here two years, she's turning 12).

Marchitectmummy · 21/06/2023 06:50

It's the downside of generations moving around, i can give you a scenario that will blow your mind!

My friends for the past ten years or so move frequently for work, since marrying they have lived in easily 10 countries. They own a place in UK and one in Germany. They plan to return to the UK one day

My friend is German, married to an English guy at present they live in Spain, they have 4 children. One child was born in Belgium, one in Switzerland, one Italy and their youngest in Spain their ages range from 10 to 1. What nationality are their 4 children?

They laugh about it and identify as Europeans 🇪🇺

Mamaneedsadrink · 21/06/2023 06:33

yadeciN · 21/06/2023 06:21

You are both and neither.
It's very annoying and sometimes confusing state for immigrants. Sometimes even second gen has this crisis of who they are.
Not British enough in many Brit's eyes, not native enough to many people in country of origin.

Yes, exactly this.

yadeciN · 21/06/2023 06:21

You are both and neither.
It's very annoying and sometimes confusing state for immigrants. Sometimes even second gen has this crisis of who they are.
Not British enough in many Brit's eyes, not native enough to many people in country of origin.

FourTeaFallOut · 21/06/2023 06:05

I think you are being over sensitive. She thought she had bumped in to someone who has a shared experience of your birth country and was disappointed that you hadn't lived there since you were a preschooler. And so that changes the conversation that you may have had otherwise. I wouldn't worry about it.

Mortimercat · 21/06/2023 04:36

narrichi · 20/06/2023 23:30

Her words seem insensitive and dismissive. But at the same time I can kind of understand her point of view. For example I'm Irish and I'm not sure I would regard someone who's lived in Australia or America since childhood and doesn't speak with an Irish accent as being Irish in the same way as myself. It's just a cultural thing. That said, it doesn't excuse her rudeness and I certainly wouldn't express my thoughts in the same way as her.

I was thinking of Irish too. My sister is Irish nationality, born there to an Irish father and British mother at the time did not convey British citizenship. Sic months after birth they moved to the UK, 50+ years ago now. I think if my sister met an Irish person and tried to chat about their shared home country she might come across as a bit odd.

Mamaneedsadrink · 21/06/2023 03:33

I'm third generation. I don't fit in either place (hard to if you're brown). It's annoying, but I don't think they meant anything bad by it. Funnily enough I also get this about the city I am from as I moved where I am now when I was 8, that's a weirder one for me as I feel I am from the city I was born in but also I don't. Guess I'm screwed either way!! 😅

Dintananadinta · 21/06/2023 03:24

My cousin from back home didn't consider me as one of them. It's pretty common for people to think like that.

Hoaryragwort · 21/06/2023 03:20

DrGoogleMD · 20/06/2023 23:29

I think your kids are probably quite the exception? If all of their schooling was in France for instance do they know the games that are played in the schoolyards in Britain, what they have for lunch, the annoying poem that everybody is forced to learn and remembers word for word 20 years later, the ice lollies people would buy on a hot day, the school uniforms or the million other small things that make up our childhoods and our cultural references? Like if I mention the guy on the news who slipped on the ice I can pretty much guarantee that everyone in the country I live in now will know what country I live in and what news segment I am talking about. I don't have those same references for the country I was born in and to me it is small things like that that make up your cultural identity. I think it would be really unusual to know those inside out the same way as someone who has lived somewhere all of their life would.

Mmmm I’m quite amused by this because in effect you have done the same thing as the op’s client but far more politely! 😃

I understand your point, you are saying my dc probably can’t properly identify as being culturally British if they aren’t aware of the poem everyone had to learn in school in uk or didn’t watch a certain episode of Eastenders etc but the world has moved on and I would argue that my dc are not so exceptional nowadays:

~like many expat dc with access to fast modern travel, as younger dc they have been able to experience virtually every school holiday and important cultural event from pancake day through to Christmas , with their British cousins of the same age, and now as older dc prefer to experience the same in France with their French friends

~and during term time with the help of modern technology and satellite tv as little kids they had British culture beamed in to our “foreign”’home every day after school in addition to the tv their French friends were watching

~ with the help of modern tech and British children’s books and music me and my dh were able to introduce them to
British nursery rhymes, songs and poems jokes etc and we have made a point of learning the same things in French and of course they have at school too

~ And now as teens with so much of cultural life on-line, they are able to access pop music, streamed tv, social media in both language worlds in microscopic detail!

~ This doesn’t apply to my children but many expat dc nowadays have access to educational immersion in two cultures in bilingual schools which make a point of exploring the things you are talking about in two or more languages

~And many families with one parent of each different culture practice OPOL at home so the dc reach the same advanced language level in both languages and there are a raft of supporting materials on line to facilitate this.

So of course there will be little differences and little things in both cultures they have missed out on but I would argue that dc can be immersed in to two cultures nowadays much, much more easily and in greater detail than when I was a child in the 1970s, and it’s easier now than say even ten or twenty years ago, with more on-line resources available than ever before , when distance and the lack of internet made it far more difficult.

TimesRwo · 21/06/2023 01:02

It’s never about how you feel and what feels right for you, but what others think you should be, as evident by pp on this thread.

For British people, you will never truly be accepted because you’re not from here. And clearly, for your home country, you are now being told you don’t belong.

It’s painful - where do you belong? Surely where you belong is what feels right to you, which is who you are and where you are from. Not what others say you should be.