Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Putting pictures of other parents teenagers on FB

35 replies

SeaSnakes1 · 20/06/2023 22:20

People in my area are posting pics of unruly teenagers (aged about 13 -15) in the area on FB asking if anyone ‘knows them’ as they are trouble makers.

I totally get the frustration and reasoning but surely this is a safeguarding issue? I’m surprised admin allow this?

OP posts:
VeterinaryCareAssistant · 20/06/2023 23:28

If they weren't acting feral they wouldn't get posted online.

JaniceBattersby · 20/06/2023 23:23

Ilovetea42 · 20/06/2023 22:57

The thing is the Internet is permanent. So forevermore there will be a video of them at 13 making poor choices. I think everyone has the right to make mistakes as they're growing up and becoming better people. Would probably have been better this be dealt with by community police who could have intervened, caused the same reaction from the parents but then let everyone go about their business. I've seen young people get hammered in court cases because court of public opinion negated their right to a fair trial, what wasn't shown in the video is that they were exceptionally vulnerable and it wasn't then taken into account in court. I always felt that was because there was a public baying for blood. There was also a significant impact on the young person when they got online and got to see lots of people saying they should have killed themselves, that they deserved to die that they were scum etc etc etc. Of course its a safeguarding issue. What if those kids were in the care system and weren't allowed their image online incase people who exploited them in the past tracked them down. The other problem is that context is everything. I know anther person who was filmed being violent- what wasn't shown was that her partner was forcing her and was highly abusive. Surely people are allowed to make mistakes and grow and become better without having everything immortalised, especially when they're that young?

Most court cases for teens are dealt with in the youth court by specially trained JPs and I’ve never seen a situation where negative publicity has been brought up in court because it would be totally inappropriate for a prosecutor to do so. I’ve never seen a child get ‘hammered’ in court. Kids are so very rarely given harsh sentences these days because we’ve learned that out of court disposals are often more effective.

If you’ve seen someone given a harsher sentence because of bad publicity, and the mitigation that they were ‘exceptionally vulnerable’ has not been taken into account, then they’d have a great case to appeal their sentence.

I’ve only ever seen negative social media coverage brought up in mitigation - because it’s had a dreadful effect on the defendant. Most judges discount it.

Underminer · 20/06/2023 23:22

ohjeesus · 20/06/2023 23:13

Why do people always throw this “safeguarding” into every argument? If your kids are naughty take responsibility for it!

I thought the same of you until I worked in education and realised that more children and teenagers than we know are in the care system. Some have been removed from parents or fled with a parent from abusive relationships. Posting their photo can and does compromise their safety: hence safeguarding. It can seriously jeopardise the safety of their placement.

ohjeesus · 20/06/2023 23:13

Why do people always throw this “safeguarding” into every argument? If your kids are naughty take responsibility for it!

TheOutnetReturns · 20/06/2023 23:11

In the past when people lived in actual communities, rather than this so-called global village, they would have been “corrected” within their community.
Now we don’t live in the same way so everyone just does whatever the hell they like, to whomever they like, with no consequences.

You only have to look on here to read about inconsiderate neighbours, kids riding up and down the street on electric scooters, people shouting at each other in shops and so on.
There’s just no consequence to any of it.

TheOutnetReturns · 20/06/2023 23:04

upping the ante - that should have said. Am tired.

TheOutnetReturns · 20/06/2023 23:03

CheeseandTrees · 20/06/2023 22:49

I think it can be a good thing.

I saw one about a month ago on a local Facebook group about two 13 year old boys. They had been harassing a shop keeper that week and a customer took photos of them swearing and threatening the poor man. One mum responded within an hour to apologise to the poster and say how mortified she was. She said she'd spoken to him and detailed how he was being punished. His father had already been round to the shop with the son in tow to make him apologise and his savings were left on the shop counter as an apology. Then the second mum popped up 10 minutes later with another profuse apology. Her son was also brought to the shop. Both mum's were horrified and said they'd never have expected it of their children.

It was no doubt a good lesson for the boys. I doubt they expected their parents could find out from Facebook posts written by a stranger. It was also good for everyone else on there to see parents being parents. The number of positive comments and sympathy the mum's received was very heartwarming too. If it hadn't happened that poor shop keeper could have faced months of abuse.

God this is so heartening to read. People actually taking responsibility for their kids and doing a spot of parenting.
Not defending indefensible behaviour so that the teenagers get cockier and up the ante.

Stigma and shame do serve some purpose in society and if people (of any age) are going to behave shamefully then they should expect to be embarrassed at some point in the future.

Ilovetea42 · 20/06/2023 22:57

CheeseandTrees · 20/06/2023 22:49

I think it can be a good thing.

I saw one about a month ago on a local Facebook group about two 13 year old boys. They had been harassing a shop keeper that week and a customer took photos of them swearing and threatening the poor man. One mum responded within an hour to apologise to the poster and say how mortified she was. She said she'd spoken to him and detailed how he was being punished. His father had already been round to the shop with the son in tow to make him apologise and his savings were left on the shop counter as an apology. Then the second mum popped up 10 minutes later with another profuse apology. Her son was also brought to the shop. Both mum's were horrified and said they'd never have expected it of their children.

It was no doubt a good lesson for the boys. I doubt they expected their parents could find out from Facebook posts written by a stranger. It was also good for everyone else on there to see parents being parents. The number of positive comments and sympathy the mum's received was very heartwarming too. If it hadn't happened that poor shop keeper could have faced months of abuse.

The thing is the Internet is permanent. So forevermore there will be a video of them at 13 making poor choices. I think everyone has the right to make mistakes as they're growing up and becoming better people. Would probably have been better this be dealt with by community police who could have intervened, caused the same reaction from the parents but then let everyone go about their business. I've seen young people get hammered in court cases because court of public opinion negated their right to a fair trial, what wasn't shown in the video is that they were exceptionally vulnerable and it wasn't then taken into account in court. I always felt that was because there was a public baying for blood. There was also a significant impact on the young person when they got online and got to see lots of people saying they should have killed themselves, that they deserved to die that they were scum etc etc etc. Of course its a safeguarding issue. What if those kids were in the care system and weren't allowed their image online incase people who exploited them in the past tracked them down. The other problem is that context is everything. I know anther person who was filmed being violent- what wasn't shown was that her partner was forcing her and was highly abusive. Surely people are allowed to make mistakes and grow and become better without having everything immortalised, especially when they're that young?

CheeseandTrees · 20/06/2023 22:49

I think it can be a good thing.

I saw one about a month ago on a local Facebook group about two 13 year old boys. They had been harassing a shop keeper that week and a customer took photos of them swearing and threatening the poor man. One mum responded within an hour to apologise to the poster and say how mortified she was. She said she'd spoken to him and detailed how he was being punished. His father had already been round to the shop with the son in tow to make him apologise and his savings were left on the shop counter as an apology. Then the second mum popped up 10 minutes later with another profuse apology. Her son was also brought to the shop. Both mum's were horrified and said they'd never have expected it of their children.

It was no doubt a good lesson for the boys. I doubt they expected their parents could find out from Facebook posts written by a stranger. It was also good for everyone else on there to see parents being parents. The number of positive comments and sympathy the mum's received was very heartwarming too. If it hadn't happened that poor shop keeper could have faced months of abuse.

Alittlesummeroasis · 20/06/2023 22:23

It’s not great, I wouldn’t do it. But ‘safeguarding’ is probably pushing it a bit.