Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband has bought a car behind my back

290 replies

PinocchiosWife · 20/06/2023 22:14

My husband seems to think that this is perfectly reasonable behaviour and I should actually be delighted.

Sorry for the length, didn't want to drip feed!

For context, we have been really struggling with money for a number of years. We had an old banger to get around in, and it was due it's MOT and supposedly booked in for it on a Monday a few weeks ago. I went away for a week working on the Friday before this.

When I returned I was surprised (to say the least) to find this lovely plush car picking me up. My first question was "where did this come from?“ to which he replied really sarcastically "a garage". I then asked where he'd found the money to pay for it, and he said a loan. He was obviously getting really angry so I didn't ask any more initially.

When he was calmer he told me that our car had failed it's MOT, and that he'd borrowed the money for this new car from some friends. He told me how much the car was, but refused point blank to tell me how much he'd borrowed. Apparently it wasn't like that in his family growing up - his dad would just buy a new car and his mum would just say oh that's lovely dear. Because of this he's unable to tell me about big financial decisions. 😂

Anyway a little while later, I discovered that not only that the car was more than he'd said, but also that he'd borrowed much more than the cost of the car. I also found out that the previous car had never even been for it's MOT, but had been traded in for the new car. The biggest shocker to me was that the new car had arrived on the Saturday (a day after I'd left on the work trip). He'd not mentioned any of this at the time despite speaking to me on the phone every day.

When I asked him about this, he said he didn't have to tell me how much he'd borrowed, and continued lying about the cost of the car. Then he said that I didn't trust him, didn't communicate, and proceeded to be horribly angry at me for another week.

So, if you've read all of that malarkey, congrats!
Aibu to expect that spouses should share this kind of information? Or am I not?
Over to you, wise mumsnetters!

OP posts:
Phoenix1Arisen · 21/06/2023 10:19

I wouldn't be worrying too much over the 'poor old lady'. She and her husband have quite happily lent the money, this time and on at least one previous occasion.

Far more worrying is the Old Lady actively colluding with the OP's husband to keep concealed from a wife facts about matters which could swamp the marriage.

I also find it hard to understand just how a woman with long experience of this world can justify keeping an innocent party in the dark about the potential disaster (in all its many aspects) rolling swiftly towards her!

A sneaky little corner of me half hopes the husband defaults on the loan as a kind of heaven sent pay back.

RecycleMePlease · 21/06/2023 10:18

Is there a specific reason its so bad? Like is it a £100k, 2 seater, convertible, mid life crisis sports car that doesn't fit the kids in? or are you always just controlling?

He part-exed a shared car and bought a new shared car without even mentioning it.

That's not controlling. If you DH took your car, sold it, got you a new one while you were away for work and got you in debt to do so (when already struggling), wouldn't you be a bit cross?

Spirallingdownwards · 21/06/2023 10:17

justasking111 · 20/06/2023 22:21

Who exactly did he borrow from. As his spouse you're jointly responsible for debts either of you incur.

This is simply not true

user1471538283 · 21/06/2023 10:17

I would be very worried if he borrowed the money off an elderly lady and I would tell her family. Who does that?

Even if this were true he will be working it off so that deducts from the money coming in and you cannot afford this car!

I would separate finances with him immediately. You can both contribute the same to the bills etc, half each. Then I would think about untangling myself from him for good.

Conkersinautumn · 21/06/2023 10:16

4-6 hours a week for gardening , £250. Only needed for about half the year (max) is around 6k a year and being generous there.

You said he'd borrowed way more than the car (guessing car is around 20k).
If I was related to that woman and found out I'd be pursuing it as financial abuse.

RecycleMePlease · 21/06/2023 10:15

Then he said that I didn't trust him, didn't communicate, and proceeded to be horribly angry at me for another week.

Well that's manipulative. Also accusations are admissions.

He didn't communicate he was thinking of buying a car, and can't be trusted if he arranges it all and secretly buys one, then won't tell you how much he's borrowed or how much it cost!

JusthereforXmas · 21/06/2023 10:14

My DH just bought a new car last week, I didn't see it until after he bought it. Same with all his previous cars.

I bought both my cars without his input too, I fact I bought my first spur of the moment in an auction.

I buy older cars outright cash up front, he gets newer cars via loans... I have never known the details of his loans thats his financial burden that he pays with his wages.

Is there a specific reason its so bad? Like is it a £100k, 2 seater, convertible, mid life crisis sports car that doesn't fit the kids in? or are you always just controlling?

catzrulz · 21/06/2023 10:11

PickledPurplePickle · 20/06/2023 22:49

What!?!

He borrowed thousands of pounds from an elderly lady that he does a few hours gardening for

i bet she felt like she couldn’t say no

Poor lady - this is unacceptable

Absolutely, does this old lady have capacity to make a decision like this?
This is a massive red flag for me even if she is of sound mind.

Rosscameasdoody · 21/06/2023 10:09

So. He’s borrowed money for a car when you’re struggling financially. He won’t tell you how much the car cost or how much he borrowed. He waited until you were out of the way before he did it, knowing that when you got back it would be a fait accompli. He’s proved himself financially irresponsible and yet he still expects you to trust him and accept his behaviour without question. And I call bullshit on ‘borrowing’ what sounds like a substantial amount of money from an elderly acquaintance on the promise of ‘working it off’ doing a few hours gardening every week.

You need to find out what’s really going on before he gets you both into serious trouble - if he hasn’t already, because it sounds like he’s manipulated an elderly person into giving him money, and as his partner, you’re involved. This should be your wake up call to get out of what sounds like a doomed relationship.

MsRosley · 21/06/2023 10:09

Anybody who lies to you and then gets angry the moment you start to ask questions is not someone you need in your life, OP. The trust has gone. Without trust, the relationship is dead.

witchmcgee · 21/06/2023 10:05

This happened to me a few years ago. We had been discussing buying a new car and had whittled it down to a few models (think VW Golf, Ford focus etc) and had a budget in mind. This went on for a few months then I eventually found out he had put a deposit down on a brand new Tesla - which was quite new at the time and very expensive. He had ordered it months before, and kept it quiet even when we had been looking at other cars. He couldn't understand why I was upset as it was "his car, his choice". completely missing the point that he had lied to me for months about it and undertaken a huge financial burden without consulting me.

He is now my ex husband.

ChittyBangabang · 21/06/2023 10:04

But he's an arse regardless

Eddielizzard · 21/06/2023 10:04

This isn't a working relationship. You can't trust him. That would be it for me

ChittyBangabang · 21/06/2023 10:03

Sounds like a rich couple dote on him and he'll work it off so not really a loan?

BarbaraofSeville · 21/06/2023 09:56

That's fine @Whenisitsummer if the spending from personal money is affordable after all joint household costs are covered.

However, the OP has said they are short of money so are unlikely to be in a position to be borrowing a lot of money to buy an expensive car. She's also said that he doesn't earn very much, so not applying himself to making a success of his self employment.

Aprilx · 21/06/2023 09:55

PinocchiosWife · 20/06/2023 23:02

I don't think it's OK. At all. But at the moment I have two people that I have highly respected and admired for over a decade basically acting as though it's perfectly acceptable. I think even the first few replies to my post have concreted my resolve to head for the exit ASAP.

Your thread title should have been “I am married to a scumbag who has conned an elderly lady out of a considerable amount of money”. Not “husband bought a car behind my back”. You didn’t even think it was worth mentioning that he got this money from an elderly lady in your OP.

The only reasonable thing to do now, is insist that your husband sells this car and repays this money immediately or you will start divorce proceedings. Otherwise, yes you do deserve each other. And I hope her relatives go to the police.

Whenisitsummer · 21/06/2023 09:50

I think it depends on how finances in your household work. We have a joint account for mortgage, household bills etc and we both pay a salary percentage into that. What is left in our own personal accounts after that is not part of the pot. So I would get a new car without discussing it with oh , I’d just tell him in conversation I was upgrading. He’d do the same. Anything we are purchasing with our own money doesn’t need discussed.

NotTerfNorCis · 21/06/2023 09:46

The lies would bother me. You are definitely not being unreasonable.

amyds2104 · 21/06/2023 09:43

All of this is shocking. I’d be concerned he had put your name to something which is why he is lying so much about it. Sounds like a financially abusive idiot so please protect yourself and find out as much as you can about this shady deal.

Undisclosedlocation · 21/06/2023 09:39

So to pay this dodgy as f”ck loan back, he will be bringing in £100-£150 less money to the family pot EVERY WEEK!
In effect, you will be the one paying back this loan too OP, you do realise that don’t you?

Sounds like an absolute master stroke of a great con man. He’s fleeced an old woman out of the money and YOU will be the one paying it back. If you put up with this, I’m afraid it’s YOU who will be the village idiot, not him

skyeisthelimit · 21/06/2023 09:36

OP, YANBU, any large financial decisions like buying a car should be made between you, plus you should have a choice in the model etc if you are driving it too.

Borrowing from an old lady is dispicable, even if she was happy to lend the money to him.

Is there a written loan agreement?

What happens if she passes away before he has repaid her? He might have to repay the entire balance into her estate at that point?

It doesn't matter what his childhood was like, he needs to live for now and deal with family finances like most people do now, which isn't with the big man making all the decisions while the little wife is grateful for his wonderfulness.

He is lying about what he borrowed and why and won't communicate about it.

What happens the next time he fancies a new shiny too, will he borrow more money off her?

Fruitjellies · 21/06/2023 09:35

I'd be reporting him to the police and kicking him to the kerb

JJ8765 · 21/06/2023 09:32

You are incompatible with your attitudes to money and responsibility and that will probably end your marriage at some point anyway. My ExH was ‘self employed’ and we always struggled financially as a result. We had dc so leaving was difficult when they were young but I often wished I could financially divorce him - before I reached the point of wanting to totally divorce him - because he was such a liability. I was actually better off financially after we split as I got more in UC than his net income, but more than that I finally had financial control of my life back and wasn’t living month to month never knowing how much he would contribute (or spend). And if the car had failed the MOT you would have come up with a solution. I’d be furious even my ExH who was hopeless with money wouldn’t have bought an expensive car behind my back.

Lcb123 · 21/06/2023 09:32

I'm sure what he's done is borderline illegal, he sounds very much like he's taken advantage. And I assume there's no written agreement.

ejbaxa · 21/06/2023 09:30

If you have no kids with this man, today is the day to set the divorce in motion.

I have to say I really doubt the elderly lady has enough work for him to do to repay the debt. Even if he does, it’s undeclared income. Low level swindling of the state/benefits etc.

he sounds like a low life. Half truths to everyone. Smoke and mirrors. I’d run today.

Swipe left for the next trending thread