Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My husband has bought a car behind my back

290 replies

PinocchiosWife · 20/06/2023 22:14

My husband seems to think that this is perfectly reasonable behaviour and I should actually be delighted.

Sorry for the length, didn't want to drip feed!

For context, we have been really struggling with money for a number of years. We had an old banger to get around in, and it was due it's MOT and supposedly booked in for it on a Monday a few weeks ago. I went away for a week working on the Friday before this.

When I returned I was surprised (to say the least) to find this lovely plush car picking me up. My first question was "where did this come from?“ to which he replied really sarcastically "a garage". I then asked where he'd found the money to pay for it, and he said a loan. He was obviously getting really angry so I didn't ask any more initially.

When he was calmer he told me that our car had failed it's MOT, and that he'd borrowed the money for this new car from some friends. He told me how much the car was, but refused point blank to tell me how much he'd borrowed. Apparently it wasn't like that in his family growing up - his dad would just buy a new car and his mum would just say oh that's lovely dear. Because of this he's unable to tell me about big financial decisions. 😂

Anyway a little while later, I discovered that not only that the car was more than he'd said, but also that he'd borrowed much more than the cost of the car. I also found out that the previous car had never even been for it's MOT, but had been traded in for the new car. The biggest shocker to me was that the new car had arrived on the Saturday (a day after I'd left on the work trip). He'd not mentioned any of this at the time despite speaking to me on the phone every day.

When I asked him about this, he said he didn't have to tell me how much he'd borrowed, and continued lying about the cost of the car. Then he said that I didn't trust him, didn't communicate, and proceeded to be horribly angry at me for another week.

So, if you've read all of that malarkey, congrats!
Aibu to expect that spouses should share this kind of information? Or am I not?
Over to you, wise mumsnetters!

OP posts:
PinocchiosWife · 22/06/2023 15:35

@Testina possibly, tbh that hadn't crossed my mind. Not sure he's thought further than, want a shiny new car, how do I get shiny new car.
Am intending to speak with them both again and raise these concerns, also with a mutual friend who may be able to make them see differently. Not sure it'll make much difference though.

OP posts:
Testina · 22/06/2023 15:12

“He does a lot of unpaid stuff for them too, lifts to hospital appointments, making them meals when they can't manage for themselves etc.”

Those are very nice things to do, but done by what sounds like a not very nice man. Who you say has no moral compass. It’s a bit of a leap (but maybe not an enormous one) to wonder if he’s hoping to inherit. Not outright scamming, but calculated actions.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 22/06/2023 15:03

PinocchiosWife · 20/06/2023 22:14

My husband seems to think that this is perfectly reasonable behaviour and I should actually be delighted.

Sorry for the length, didn't want to drip feed!

For context, we have been really struggling with money for a number of years. We had an old banger to get around in, and it was due it's MOT and supposedly booked in for it on a Monday a few weeks ago. I went away for a week working on the Friday before this.

When I returned I was surprised (to say the least) to find this lovely plush car picking me up. My first question was "where did this come from?“ to which he replied really sarcastically "a garage". I then asked where he'd found the money to pay for it, and he said a loan. He was obviously getting really angry so I didn't ask any more initially.

When he was calmer he told me that our car had failed it's MOT, and that he'd borrowed the money for this new car from some friends. He told me how much the car was, but refused point blank to tell me how much he'd borrowed. Apparently it wasn't like that in his family growing up - his dad would just buy a new car and his mum would just say oh that's lovely dear. Because of this he's unable to tell me about big financial decisions. 😂

Anyway a little while later, I discovered that not only that the car was more than he'd said, but also that he'd borrowed much more than the cost of the car. I also found out that the previous car had never even been for it's MOT, but had been traded in for the new car. The biggest shocker to me was that the new car had arrived on the Saturday (a day after I'd left on the work trip). He'd not mentioned any of this at the time despite speaking to me on the phone every day.

When I asked him about this, he said he didn't have to tell me how much he'd borrowed, and continued lying about the cost of the car. Then he said that I didn't trust him, didn't communicate, and proceeded to be horribly angry at me for another week.

So, if you've read all of that malarkey, congrats!
Aibu to expect that spouses should share this kind of information? Or am I not?
Over to you, wise mumsnetters!

Ah well at least you will get half of it in the divorce..

Rosscameasdoody · 22/06/2023 14:58

Aprilx · 21/06/2023 14:35

So they didn’t purse your friend then. 🤪

No, but she was still affected as a financial order was placed on the marital home and the strain led to the break up of the marriage.

NotBotheredAnymore · 22/06/2023 12:25

Manthide · 21/06/2023 14:36

Sounds just like my ex dh who seems to think its fine to get 2 credit cards and put thousands of pounds of debt on them without saying anything. Even now I know he has moved one balance to the other as it was a good deal but he hasn't said anything - and he refuses to get a job ( or leave our house) so I'm the one paying them off ( very slowly )

Please make your own thread as what you are going through is not normal. Did you get a financial consent order done at the same time as the divorce? If not then get one sorted asap. Your exH is conning you.

OP - I rarely use the voting system but please use this post as another vote for you to leave.

PinocchiosWife · 22/06/2023 12:22

Phoenix1Arisen · 22/06/2023 08:28

I cannot agree with Nanaof1 at all.

I'm in my 70's and recently lent a grandchild a couple of thousand to buy a replacement vehicle, vital to get to work in this rural district, after his car unexpectedly and expensively broke down. He is paying me back at 100 a month, all with the full knowledge of other members of his/my family.

Where is the manipulation, grasping or questionable honesty in that?

Too big an assumption going on, in my view, to label the OP as "just as bad". I'd also say that if we're into 'it looks like...' territory, it looks like Pinocchio'sWife has a perfectly competent standard of conduct and a moral compass that's working well.

Thank you for this. I believe that he's being paid about £20 ph for his time so it's a reasonable rate given that a lot of his work has been clearing a jungle! He does a lot of unpaid stuff for them too, lifts to hospital appointments, making them meals when they can't manage for themselves etc. I don't think he should have borrowed this money, but I don't think he's scamming them - he just hasn't thought about how it might be perceived by outsiders.

@Nanaof1 I do wish you'd read my posts. I DO NOT CONDONE THIS AT ALL. That is why I am divorcing him. Getting a bit miffed as it should be very clear by now that I'm angry not only because of the deceit but because also I think taking this loan is morally wrong.

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 22/06/2023 12:10

My dad was a grifter con man-well still is really

dont let your child grow up with this it fucks youup

Cucucucu · 22/06/2023 09:58

I think you need to consider leaving him now before he drags you down .
This reminds me of a good friend whose husband drove around in a Porsche but they once returned form holiday and their house had been repossessed and they where homeless . Turns out he lied for years and was up to his neck in debt .

Codlingmoths · 22/06/2023 09:31

Manthide · 22/06/2023 09:19

If you get the car you'd probably have to take over the loan too! Our car is in my name, fully paid off but as I'm losing my sight and can't drive anymore ex dh is welcome to it.

The loan is just a neighbour lending him money. There would be no legal link to the car, the car is just an asset of the marriage and the loan an informal debt that can’t be included in the financial summing up. Too bad for him.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 09:26

Manthide · 22/06/2023 09:19

If you get the car you'd probably have to take over the loan too! Our car is in my name, fully paid off but as I'm losing my sight and can't drive anymore ex dh is welcome to it.

I am so sorry you are losing your site. Mine is fading too, though I take vitamins that are supposed to "help".

I hope you can get your finances moved over to just your name and let your exh find a job to pay off his debts.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 09:20

Phoenix1Arisen · 22/06/2023 08:28

I cannot agree with Nanaof1 at all.

I'm in my 70's and recently lent a grandchild a couple of thousand to buy a replacement vehicle, vital to get to work in this rural district, after his car unexpectedly and expensively broke down. He is paying me back at 100 a month, all with the full knowledge of other members of his/my family.

Where is the manipulation, grasping or questionable honesty in that?

Too big an assumption going on, in my view, to label the OP as "just as bad". I'd also say that if we're into 'it looks like...' territory, it looks like Pinocchio'sWife has a perfectly competent standard of conduct and a moral compass that's working well.

That's a grandchild. My children both borrowed money from their DGM. There was a contract written up with how much would be paid per month and for how many months. Each payment was recorded and they both paid it off in full.

The fact that the OP saw nothing wrong with the other times her NVDH "borrowed" money from the couple, paying it back in "gardening", tells me she is lacking something, whether it be common sense or morals.

Would you have lent your DGS money if he told you he would pay it back by taking out your garbage once a week and not paying any $$?

The fact that you are in your 70's and think your situation and OP's situation have any similarities makes me scratch my head.
I am also about that old and would lend my grandchildren money, and they would have a contract (their parents would insist). They are family, something the OP's NVDH is not to the people he is using as his personal loan department.

Manthide · 22/06/2023 09:19

PinocchiosWife · 21/06/2023 20:44

My thoughts exactly!

As it is the only car we have, would it be a marital asset when we divorce?
I do hope so....

If you get the car you'd probably have to take over the loan too! Our car is in my name, fully paid off but as I'm losing my sight and can't drive anymore ex dh is welcome to it.

Manthide · 22/06/2023 09:15

Phoenix1Arisen · 22/06/2023 08:28

I cannot agree with Nanaof1 at all.

I'm in my 70's and recently lent a grandchild a couple of thousand to buy a replacement vehicle, vital to get to work in this rural district, after his car unexpectedly and expensively broke down. He is paying me back at 100 a month, all with the full knowledge of other members of his/my family.

Where is the manipulation, grasping or questionable honesty in that?

Too big an assumption going on, in my view, to label the OP as "just as bad". I'd also say that if we're into 'it looks like...' territory, it looks like Pinocchio'sWife has a perfectly competent standard of conduct and a moral compass that's working well.

My parents aged 80 and 81 would do the same for one of their grandchildren if necessary but not next-door's husband! Thankfully dd1's dh is giving his old car to my 20 year old ds and dd2 is paying for his first year's insurance but I know my parents would have helped him get on the road.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:55

Phoenix1Arisen · 21/06/2023 14:24

"Strong religous principles". Really? Which verse of the bible applauds/supports her actively colluding with your husband (not some vague part time boyfriend-ish bloke) to keep secret financial dealings which have the power to wreck your life.

One wonders what stories of your 'cruelty' she has been fed or is she just not bothered about another woman's welfare.

In your shoes, I would not be describing her as a friend.

ITA! I think the elderly lady has been baited and swallowed it hook, line and sinker. That's why she is keeping it confidential. She has been told something nasty about the OP and probably thinks she is "saving" the NVDH, not even realizing she is being scammed.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:52

Dogscanteatonions · 21/06/2023 12:17

What the fuck?! Have you even read the OP's posts in the slightest?

I doubt if they cared. They just wanted to brag and get a medal.

Here is their medal🎖. 🙄

19lottie82 · 22/06/2023 08:49

As his spouse you're jointly
responsible for debts either of you
incur.

not true.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:45

Phoenix1Arisen · 21/06/2023 10:19

I wouldn't be worrying too much over the 'poor old lady'. She and her husband have quite happily lent the money, this time and on at least one previous occasion.

Far more worrying is the Old Lady actively colluding with the OP's husband to keep concealed from a wife facts about matters which could swamp the marriage.

I also find it hard to understand just how a woman with long experience of this world can justify keeping an innocent party in the dark about the potential disaster (in all its many aspects) rolling swiftly towards her!

A sneaky little corner of me half hopes the husband defaults on the loan as a kind of heaven sent pay back.

We have no clue what the OP NVDH has told this couple. He might have made the OP out to be a disaster, so while they are nice to her face, he has thrown her under the bus and begged them not to tell OP because (insert whatever lie seems to be NVDH's forte).
I really don't believe that they have just lent him this money through truth. I believe he has sold them a dog and pony show and they are still paying admission.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:40

ChittyBangabang · 21/06/2023 10:03

Sounds like a rich couple dote on him and he'll work it off so not really a loan?

I am betting he plays upon their sympathy and makes himself out to be so down and out and of course, no fault of his own. He butters them up and ingratiates himself into their little circle. Then he borrows a little and works it off, a little more and works it off and then boom, gets them to "lend" him tens of thousands, and now he will sit back and hope they kick off before he has to pay it back. Or he won't sit back and wait....

He is cheating the couple, cheating the government and the taxpayers and neither he nor the OP seem to think anything of it.

I have to wonder what type of job has someone travel for a week for work, yet pay so little they are almost on the breadline?

I always thought those jobs paid at least a decent middle income.

PuzzledObserver · 22/06/2023 08:29

Manthide · 21/06/2023 18:40

The credit cards are in his name but he doesn't have his own bank account just the joint one. I do have my own bank account and my wages and child benefit are paid into it but uc is still in joint names (though I have told them we divorced almost 2 years ago). I put money from my account into the joint one as all the bills go out of it. At the moment we are paying about £130 a month off his credit cards.

You’re actually divorced, but still living together because he refuses to move out?

I’m no expert, but I would have thought there were legal remedies you could use. Why are you paying anything into the joint account? Just stop. Pay the bills out of your sole account. Cut off his finance.

Phoenix1Arisen · 22/06/2023 08:28

I cannot agree with Nanaof1 at all.

I'm in my 70's and recently lent a grandchild a couple of thousand to buy a replacement vehicle, vital to get to work in this rural district, after his car unexpectedly and expensively broke down. He is paying me back at 100 a month, all with the full knowledge of other members of his/my family.

Where is the manipulation, grasping or questionable honesty in that?

Too big an assumption going on, in my view, to label the OP as "just as bad". I'd also say that if we're into 'it looks like...' territory, it looks like Pinocchio'sWife has a perfectly competent standard of conduct and a moral compass that's working well.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:21

Starseeking · 21/06/2023 07:50

You're married to him, he's just saddled you both with a huge debt and refuses to talk about it. Of course it's your business!

There are significant communication issues if this is how your DH treats you, I'd be concerned about the long-term future of your relationship.

He hasn't saddled her with any debt, nor himself. If there is no contract, he has no duty, especially since their "agreement" is that he will work it off doing gardening. I doubt the Buckingham Palace grounds need THAT much gardening.

That's how grifters operate.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 08:17

Someoneonlyyouknow · 21/06/2023 02:58

Have you calculated how long this loan will take to to be repaid? The previous loans and repayments sound like softening her up till he could get a significant amount

He's never repaid the "loans". He has "worked the debt off", if you are inclined to believe that BS.

If he had had the elderly couple draw up a "contract", with all the details spelled out about repayment, how long before paid, his "hourly rate" (who wants to bet it's exorbitant for them?), terms for default etc., that would be one thing. But to just be able to talk them out of the money? I don't care if the elderly man was a lawyer and they seem "fine with it".

Something stinks and everyone sees it but the OP.

My DGM and DU both had intact minds, but they were still able to be talked into giving my DF's cousin money, over and over again.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 07:47

PinocchiosWife · 20/06/2023 22:58

So he has borrowed hundreds from her before, and paid it all back through working it off, so it's not like he's not going to be paying it back. As to telling her family, her husband is fully aware of it and doesn't seem to think it's a problem. The lady is definitely in full possession of her faculties too. Also we've known them for years. I did speak to her about it, and she said that she wouldn't tell me how much the loan was for as it was between the two of them.

It doesn't MATTER if her DH is "okay" with it. It doesn't MATTER that you think she is in control of her mental acuity. It is still way too easy to manipulate older people into doing what you want them to do.

The fact that he has borrowed hundreds before and "worked it off", just shows that he knows an easy take when he sees it. Since you knew/know about it, makes you just as bad.

If either one of the couple has to go into a care home, that will be tough to explain how they "lent" over $50K (between all the times) to a "gardener" who works 4-6 hours a week at the house.

WonderingWanda · 22/06/2023 07:46

Op this is horrendous. Of course he should have discussed it with you and he has clearly lied and gone behind your back in a very deceitful way. He has also swindled the money form an old lady and he clearly has no intention of paying it back. I personally would be close to ending the relationship over this. The only thing which would redeem him is if he could accept the error of his ways. Sell the new flashy car and return the money to the elderly friend. Then have a sensible grown up married conversation about how to afford a new car.

Nanaof1 · 22/06/2023 07:41

Throwncrumbs · 20/06/2023 22:56

That could be seen as elder abuse, taking money off an elderly woman and paying it off with gardening. She could die next week (which he prob thinks will let him off paying it back), if he does 4/6 hours a week he must be laughing. He’s a con artist and aside from the car I would be thoroughly ashamed if this was my husband.

I could never, ever, EVER stay in a relationship where my DH is a grifter, con artist, scammer, thief. It is elder abuse.

I am betting he really has no plan to pay her back at all, and it makes me wonder how much other money he has stolen from her or other elderly people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread