Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hatching chicks and ducks at nurseries/schools.

68 replies

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 20/06/2023 20:14

AIBU to really hate this activity and I wish it was banned? Toddlers nursery is doing it currently and my heart sank when I saw it.

I just feel it’s so wrong for them to be created for no reason and not even have a mum to keep them safe and cosy and comforted.

The reasoning behind it is to teach the kids about wildlife but we can do that for our child without this, I think it’s old fashioned and mean and not very forward thinking. 😭

I’m probs a massive hypocrite as I’m not vegan but this just seems so pointless.

OP posts:
Goballistic · 20/06/2023 21:03

NuffSaidSam · 20/06/2023 20:30

And dairy products from free range cows where all the male calves are living their best life too?

Dairy industry has been using sexed semen for years

CampCroc · 20/06/2023 21:01

MeowOnceForOffended · 20/06/2023 20:55

It was an amazing experience for all involved.
Did you survey the chickens afterwards then?

They were my own chickens, who lived free range on my own smallholding, apart from those we sold to private customers who I knew through the specific breed group.

They had/have amazing lives.
So as much as my chicken language skills are limited, going by their health, behaviour and longevity, the survey was positive for all involved. If I was a chicken I’d want to live with me.

MeowOnceForOffended · 20/06/2023 20:55

It was an amazing experience for all involved.
Did you survey the chickens afterwards then?

CampCroc · 20/06/2023 20:53

Children learn far more from hands on experience than by looking at life cycle books.

I was always interested to hear feedback from children, and sometimes afterwards from families, and it was only ever positive. Talking about the reality of hatching chicks (which I was doing anyway whether it was in a school or not) brought up interesting conversations, more than learning from a board or a book, and the teachers always commented on how engaged the children were.

CampCroc · 20/06/2023 20:48

I used to hatch chicks at primary schools and nurseries regularly.

All resulting chicks were looked after by me, were handled under my supervision, and after a few days would return to me. Using the same equipment I used to hatch at home. My chickens were a specific breed, so we’re reared on for sale or to keep, and the males would be reared for meat for our own consumption (obviously not everyone’s cup of tea, but if you keep chickens this is as humane as it gets).

The whole process (for primary school) started with an egg talk, showing different types of eggs and how to tell if they’re fertile or not.
I’d set the eggs and explain about why they need to turn and about humidity. I’d return weekly to candle the eggs with the children, then be handy in case of hatching issues (which were rare), then back twice daily for the rest of the week to take care of the chicks.

It was an amazing experience for all involved. Nursery age is a little young I think, they loved the chicks but lost interest in the incubation phase. The best hatches I did were for yr 4+, they always had great questions and got so much out of it. I was always very honest about what happens to the chicks, and during the time I did this only ever had excellent feedback.

CoconutDrunk · 20/06/2023 20:47

Brefugee · 20/06/2023 20:38

it never ceases to amaze me how people start to try to pick holes with posts like mine.
As it happens i live in a village with a farm that sells milk from their herd of dairy cows.
They keep the young ones for a while then they are either sold to be raised for beef (2 villages over) or kept for dairy stock. As it happens they bring them in from the field twice a day to milk them. (it has already been pasturised when we get it)

I have been known to buy milk from supermarkets and it does bother me. But the more people who put pressure on the chicken farms and dairy farms the better it will be.

I’d be interested to know if the people who usually pick holes in posts like this actually have experience living rurally or just accept what they hear about industrial farming as “every single farm ever”

because smallholdings with people that genuinely look after their animals with kindness exist. - I fundamentally disagree with killing something that doesn’t want to be killed but there’s a big difference between an animal that is well looked after during its life and one that isn’t

ActDottie · 20/06/2023 20:47

Yep it’s horrific… it says to the kids look at these cute fluffy chicks and then they get sent off and killed or raised for meat. It’s horrible. My brothers school (that he is head teacher of) currently have chicks and I was so shocked that they have them. Also was shocked to at as head teacher he felt it was okay!!!

HangingOver · 20/06/2023 20:46

But it's all cute hijinks when it comes to animals you like to eat

But flips to bad again with pets...

Puppy Farm = Bad
Dairy Farm = Good

The recent uproar about octopus farming baffles me though. People bleating about how intelligent they are and the poor pigs are just like... What about us?

NuffSaidSam · 20/06/2023 20:44

Brefugee · 20/06/2023 20:38

it never ceases to amaze me how people start to try to pick holes with posts like mine.
As it happens i live in a village with a farm that sells milk from their herd of dairy cows.
They keep the young ones for a while then they are either sold to be raised for beef (2 villages over) or kept for dairy stock. As it happens they bring them in from the field twice a day to milk them. (it has already been pasturised when we get it)

I have been known to buy milk from supermarkets and it does bother me. But the more people who put pressure on the chicken farms and dairy farms the better it will be.

It amazes you that in a thread where we're discussing the ethics around using animals for our own purposes to the massive detriment of the animals someone mentioned dairy farming?! Really? You were amazed? Blimey.

Brefugee · 20/06/2023 20:44

tbh if it makes more people think more about the meat/dairy industry, that's good, isn't it?

HangingOver · 20/06/2023 20:43

And if they’re not going to be killed then what gives us the right to not let them have a mum in the first few weeks of their life?

Chicken is just the tip of the shiteheap, OP. 🥛

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:42

I'm sure she is a lovely lady @CoconutDrunk. But multiple drakes in a flock of ducks is not great either. Being lovely means making hard decisions for the benefit of all the animals and that means killing the males.

NuffSaidSam · 20/06/2023 20:39

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 20/06/2023 20:31

I suppose even though I’m not vegan, I think that if the chicks are going to be killed afterwards then it’s hypocritical for the kids to be all gooey eyed and loving about them without the real truth. Seems a bit sick!

And if they’re not going to be killed then what gives us the right to not let them have a mum in the first few weeks of their life? What does that teach children?

I stopped taking toddler to a local farm because it was one of those ones where a huge crowd of noisy screeching kids can handle tiny baby animals and frighten the living daylights out of them.

I’ll be telling my child the truth about our food and then it’s his choice what to eat and when.

So tell him the truth about the nursery ones. Let him tell his classmates, that'll probably be the end of the scheme!

CoconutDrunk · 20/06/2023 20:38

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:32

If you believe the nice lady on the farm takes all the male chicks and gives them a happy healthy life, you're very naive

they are ducks usually… she has a large pond in the farm grounds

I’ve met her, she is a nice lady.

its a small nursery so they don’t usually have many - this year it’s two. I think it was three last year

I am not saying this doesn’t happen, but this nursery genuinely have a good relationship with a nice family in the village… you don’t need to try and pick holes in what I know to be true

nice people do exist!

Brefugee · 20/06/2023 20:38

NuffSaidSam · 20/06/2023 20:30

And dairy products from free range cows where all the male calves are living their best life too?

it never ceases to amaze me how people start to try to pick holes with posts like mine.
As it happens i live in a village with a farm that sells milk from their herd of dairy cows.
They keep the young ones for a while then they are either sold to be raised for beef (2 villages over) or kept for dairy stock. As it happens they bring them in from the field twice a day to milk them. (it has already been pasturised when we get it)

I have been known to buy milk from supermarkets and it does bother me. But the more people who put pressure on the chicken farms and dairy farms the better it will be.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 20/06/2023 20:36

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 20/06/2023 20:31

I suppose even though I’m not vegan, I think that if the chicks are going to be killed afterwards then it’s hypocritical for the kids to be all gooey eyed and loving about them without the real truth. Seems a bit sick!

And if they’re not going to be killed then what gives us the right to not let them have a mum in the first few weeks of their life? What does that teach children?

I stopped taking toddler to a local farm because it was one of those ones where a huge crowd of noisy screeching kids can handle tiny baby animals and frighten the living daylights out of them.

I’ll be telling my child the truth about our food and then it’s his choice what to eat and when.

Reminds me of the episode of Mongrols with the petting zoo!

MeowOnceForOffended · 20/06/2023 20:36

Hoppinggreen · 20/06/2023 20:34

Oh yes, the old “go to live on a farm” story

Funny how when farm is applied to humans: baby farm, funny farm we all know it's describing something horrific.

But it's all cute hijinks when it comes to animals you like to eat.

NuffSaidSam · 20/06/2023 20:36

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:30

Breeding things to kill them isn't the same as breeding to eat them

Or don't you think there's any difference?

It's not the same.

But it's not better. They've had a terrible life and been killed. I'm not sure they much care that they're then eaten. Do you?

If they serve up the nursery chickens for lunch would that be ok?

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:36

No of course it doesn't @GiraffeDoor. I think breeding an animal just to kill it is pointless. Breeding it to eat it isn't.

Obviously I'm not a vegan.

But I'm not sure what lesson this is teaching children. Chicks are cute! Eggs turn into chicks! Eggs turn into chicks and then we kill them!

Kind of weird

GiraffeDoor · 20/06/2023 20:36

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 20/06/2023 20:31

I suppose even though I’m not vegan, I think that if the chicks are going to be killed afterwards then it’s hypocritical for the kids to be all gooey eyed and loving about them without the real truth. Seems a bit sick!

And if they’re not going to be killed then what gives us the right to not let them have a mum in the first few weeks of their life? What does that teach children?

I stopped taking toddler to a local farm because it was one of those ones where a huge crowd of noisy screeching kids can handle tiny baby animals and frighten the living daylights out of them.

I’ll be telling my child the truth about our food and then it’s his choice what to eat and when.

If you don't like baby chicks growing up without their mummy, wait til you hear about human surrogacy......

Hoppinggreen · 20/06/2023 20:34

CoconutDrunk · 20/06/2023 20:30

I think it depends on where they go afterwards!

my DCs nursery does this, and it backs on to a farm so the lady that lives there takes them and apparently has done for years … I also know the nursery manager and she has been known to take them home over night because she doesn’t like leaving them 💛

if that were not the case I would definitely be questioning it.

& FWIW our family are mainly plant based/ vegetarian… and although I agree that these chicks have a much better life that the ones you eat, I actually think it’s good that you are questioning it. Everyone who became vegan/vegetarian started somewhere and maybe this is a good place to start thinking about how your lifestyle may impact the wellbeing of other species?

Oh yes, the old “go to live on a farm” story

MeowOnceForOffended · 20/06/2023 20:34

I’ll be telling my child the truth about our food and then it’s his choice what to eat and when.

Not being funny, but having presumably fed your child meat for years this isn't a neutral message your sending is it.

Either they'll agree that yes, I like the taste of animal suffering so I will keep that up.
Or they'll resent you for making them complicit in animal cruelty unaware.

The only neutral way is not to eat animals and then let them decide.
Just saying.
Obviously I know you won't do that.

TucSandwich · 20/06/2023 20:33

Where I worked, the Deputy Head ended up killing the cockerells as they got too noisy and destructive. I was disgusted

GiraffeDoor · 20/06/2023 20:32

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:30

Breeding things to kill them isn't the same as breeding to eat them

Or don't you think there's any difference?

Once the animal is dead, I'm pretty sure it doesn't care whether it gets eaten or not!

Clymene · 20/06/2023 20:32

CoconutDrunk · 20/06/2023 20:30

I think it depends on where they go afterwards!

my DCs nursery does this, and it backs on to a farm so the lady that lives there takes them and apparently has done for years … I also know the nursery manager and she has been known to take them home over night because she doesn’t like leaving them 💛

if that were not the case I would definitely be questioning it.

& FWIW our family are mainly plant based/ vegetarian… and although I agree that these chicks have a much better life that the ones you eat, I actually think it’s good that you are questioning it. Everyone who became vegan/vegetarian started somewhere and maybe this is a good place to start thinking about how your lifestyle may impact the wellbeing of other species?

If you believe the nice lady on the farm takes all the male chicks and gives them a happy healthy life, you're very naive