Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Getting toddler off to sleep - AIBU?

61 replies

mauvish · 20/06/2023 19:05

(Hello DD if you read this!)

I look after DGD one day/week; she's not far off 2 yo. Her mum (my DD) feels that on my day, DGD gets her nap too late in the afternoon - but I don't know how to change this!

Basically DGD is still BF so mum has an easy way to soothe that is unavailable to me. I managed, one time only, to get DGD to sleep in my bed, but usually it has to be in the buggy. That's fine but if I have to take her out for a walk to get her to sleep, that has to fit around other activities (mine more than hers, eg getting lunch ready for us!) It's not exactly ideal if the weather is terrible either. DGD always gets her nap, but it can be a good couple of hours later than DD would have liked me to "organise".

The usual day goes something like - toddler group in the morning, pop to the shops, lunch, out for another walk and then the DGD will fall asleep on the way home from the walk. (Surely, if she were tired, she'd fall asleep on the way there rather than on the way back?)

So, 2 q's:

  1. AIBU to carry on as we are? I'm not deliberately going against mum's wishes, but I can't easily comply with mum's preference - though I would if I knew how.
  2. Where's the button you press on toddlers to get them to sleep at a pre-set time? 😅
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mauvish · 21/06/2023 17:58

Update - DD and I have talked about this today, and I tried a different routine which worked (for today, whether it will work next week we'll have to see!).

Thanks to all for suggestions etc.

OP posts:
BodyKeepingScore · 21/06/2023 17:45

ApplesInTheSunshine · 20/06/2023 20:23

YABU and if you couldn’t follow the nap when I wanted I would stop unsupervised contact and use childcare if needed.

Jesus. Aren't you a peach. If someone is offering free childcare you don't just give orders that must be followed...

sandrene · 21/06/2023 16:21

OP's DD is doing nothing wrong by breastfeeding to sleep.

Lcb123 · 21/06/2023 09:38

If your DD wants to dictate anything, she should use professional childcare. You're doing nothing wrong - DD needs to be moving towards child self soothing to sleep.

museumum · 21/06/2023 09:37

I don't think it's normal for a toddler to sleep after an afternoon activity. Normally they'd be sleeping after a (very) early lunch so around 12-2ish. At nursery that age group are first lunch around 11:30 and then nap. It's not ideal that nap is kept till they're literally dropping off against their will, toddlers can push through and stay awake (like we all can if we're having fun at a wedding or something) but if you introduce a nice routine with snuggles and stories and dark space then in time she should relax into it.

Delatron · 21/06/2023 09:27

You can’t control when she sleeps but you can control when she wakes!

Delatron · 21/06/2023 09:27

I do think the best solution is to just let her have a shorter nap.

orchidsrock · 21/06/2023 09:08

Can't you just wake her up a bit earlier? So if she would usually have a an hours nap at 12, and she doesn't fall asleep until 2, then only let her have 30 mins and wake her up with a drink/some cartoons. Then she should be tired enough for bedtime. That's what I always did with my toddlers if they didn't nap at the preferred time.

BendingSpoons · 21/06/2023 07:26

What time is she sleeping until? Could you agree you won't let her sleep past a certain time? That might mean waking her after a shorter nap. Your DD is being a little bit U by expecting you to work miracles and get her to sleep at a certain time. However it sounds like sleep is a bit of an issue for them, so I understand they desperately want her to sleep at bedtime.

sandrene · 21/06/2023 07:10

mauvish · 20/06/2023 21:09

Sometimes I will try to get her to go to sleep on the way to the afternoon activity rather than afterwards. Into the buggy she goes, she'll lie down without complaint, footrest up, hood up to minimise light and off we'll go - and 20 mins later she will still be lying there, perfectly still and quiet, but still wide awake and staring at me. Hey ho.

If she's only woken up at 8.30 am, as is sometimes the case, then clearly she's not going to go back to sleep before lunch. But having written this out and read responses, it's made me think that perhaps I need to say to DD that if an earlier nap is important, then she needs to wake DGD up earlier to allow for that.

It often does take longer than 20 min - maybe you just need to persist a bit more? It might take you an hour or longer to get her to sleep, that's just how it is. I wouldn't call it quits after just 20 min, especially is she's actually lying there calmly and happily. If it takes very long (eg because she woke late in the morning) then don't let her nap as long as a result - say always wake her by 2.30/3pm at the latest (whatever your DD says).

I voted YABU not so much because you aren't able to magically get DGD to sleep at any time but because you sound a little defensive or as if you want to paint your daughter as in the wrong. Surely if you offered to have DGD, the onus is on you to make it work for your DD as well. Try to try a bit harder to find a solution. Experiment with different methods (walking earlier/for longer, putting her down in a darkened room, singing the same lullaby each time, going for a drive...) and if something works, be very consistent and persistent with it.

MooseBreath · 21/06/2023 07:06

I think you need to find out your DGD's routine at home so that you can replicate it. It's also not unreasonable to ask your DD to make sure your DGD is awake by 7 so that she will nap earlier.

Does she use a sleep bag at home? My DS wouldn't nap without one!

sandrene · 21/06/2023 06:50

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/06/2023 20:00

Dgd is nearly 2. Its not unreasonable to say "if you want her to reliably nap at mine without the crutch of breastfeeding then that's on you".

It's a fallacy, though. Why does everything always get blamed on breastfeeding! My breastfed toddlers have napped perfectly fine with other family members if I wasn't there. Mum breastfeeding them doesn't mean they can't go to sleep in other ways with other people.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/06/2023 22:42

Yes I think you’re right in your update OP- if your Dd wants the nap to be earlier, she’ll need to wake Dd up at (say) 7am. Then she’ll naturally want to nap earlier - or there’ll be a chance of it.

Alternatively, perhaps if her nap is later sometimes, it could be shorter?

When mine were at nursery I did ask that they weren’t asleep after a certain time, because their bedtimes were a nightmare if they did.

Shootingstar11 · 20/06/2023 22:09

Ive been off on holiday lately and my DD who is a similar age has been out of her usual routine and has been getting up closer to 9am- which means a 3/4pm nap and a 9/10pm bedtime 🙈 I’d say the morning wake up time needs to be earlier to achieve the earlier afternoon nap. Wish me luck for going back to 6:45am wake ups tomorrow!

BloodyCatArgh · 20/06/2023 21:58

Do you want to be helpful to your daughter or not? If so, move lunch earlier/try a pram nap before lunch. If not, and you're only looking after your dgc because you enjoy it, then don't bother.

Hollyppp · 20/06/2023 21:53

My son only napped via buggy or car between 1.5 and 2.5 yo. He’s now 2 yr 9 months and has dropped the nap hurrah!

just to say I think she sounds pretty normal and you can only do your best with buggy walks etc

user50316 · 20/06/2023 21:43

Mallory18 · 20/06/2023 20:12

YANBU my mum has my son twice a week (which I am incredibly grateful for!) and sometimes naps do happen later but that just means I adjust bedtime accordingly. In my eyes him going to bed an hour later than usual is far less stressful than finding alternative childcare!

^^ we were the same when my DD was this age, except she wouldn't nap at all and then be an overtired monster by 6pm 🤣

What is your daughter's routine? My mum kept the same routine as us pretty much (in those days, lunch at 12.30, nap 2-4 but my daughter was usually too excited and having too much fun to nap!!). However I was also mindful that my mum had other things in her day so it also had to fit in with what she had on.

boobyandacuddle · 20/06/2023 21:40

Echo what others say. Ask for guidelines from DD for the latest she wants to sleep. My mum and my MIL each do a day with my kids. They have their own methods of getting my son to sleep and while it isn't what I do (BF) I'm very grateful for the free childcare! I'd be annoyed if he was still asleep after 4pm, but appreciate that while watching 2 little ones things don't always go to plan and sometimes you need to suck up a late bedtime! If she's letting your granddaughter sleep in til 8.30 then she definitely can't be expecting her to go back down by 12. In fact maybe it's the late wake that sets the whole day back rather than the late nap!

Abouttimemum · 20/06/2023 21:18

Mine would only nap in his cot at home but if out and about the nap would be random in the car / pram - so if my mum was looking after him I’d just accept that his nap would probably happen randomly, suck it up and be grateful I had support with childcare.

Breastfeeding to sleep is not ideal at 2 imho but it is what it is. You can’t force your DGD to sleep.

mauvish · 20/06/2023 21:09

Sometimes I will try to get her to go to sleep on the way to the afternoon activity rather than afterwards. Into the buggy she goes, she'll lie down without complaint, footrest up, hood up to minimise light and off we'll go - and 20 mins later she will still be lying there, perfectly still and quiet, but still wide awake and staring at me. Hey ho.

If she's only woken up at 8.30 am, as is sometimes the case, then clearly she's not going to go back to sleep before lunch. But having written this out and read responses, it's made me think that perhaps I need to say to DD that if an earlier nap is important, then she needs to wake DGD up earlier to allow for that.

OP posts:
Oysterbabe · 20/06/2023 21:07

Do lunch earlier. It was always 11:30 at nursery.

thehonscupboard · 20/06/2023 21:04

Bring a packed lunch out when you go to toddler group and give it at the end of that, or else let her eat it in her buggy on your way to the shops? Then if she's tired enough she'll fall asleep after that in her buggy, and is she isn't then.. well, as you said, how do you force a non-tired person to fall asleep? Saying that, it might be that she's clinging onto staying awake because she enjoys your company. My dc does this if there's anyone more exciting than me around. Literally holding eyelids open. If we're out when I'd like dc to sleep, I make sure to never stop the buggy moving, so eg if we're waiting for the lights to change, I always move the buggy backwards and forwards while waiting.

Bugbabe1970 · 20/06/2023 20:53

ApplesInTheSunshine · 20/06/2023 20:23

YABU and if you couldn’t follow the nap when I wanted I would stop unsupervised contact and use childcare if needed.

Wow
Are your apples rotten?

Hazelnuttella · 20/06/2023 20:49

If her wake up time ranges from between 5-9am then I think they have sleep issues at home that you definitely can’t be held responsible for OP!

(And I say this as a mum of a toddler).

NoSquirrels · 20/06/2023 20:45

That aside, I don't know what the home routine is other than that DD would like DGD to sleep earlier in the afternoon than she normally does with me, and I understand that's what they strive for at home.

Bit weird this hasn’t come up in the general conversation about the issue!

Swipe left for the next trending thread