Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids wearing cycling helmets, parents not

89 replies

Faveusernamewastaken · 20/06/2023 18:21

Sorry but this is such a bugbear whenever I see it - a child on the back of their parent’s bike rightly wearing a helmet but the parent cycling isn’t. What if there is an accident, yes the child will be safe but their parent is risking their child seeing them with head injuries or worse. Please, please, please, from an ex-A&E nurse, wear a cycling helmet (cycling with a child or not)! No one thinks it will happen to them until it happens to them. Looking after your child means looking after yourself too!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:38

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 22:01

Yes when riding with my child the reduced risk of a crash that would be dangerous/fatal TO HER is more important than the increased risk of a head injury TO ME if we crash or fall.

When riding without my child I wear a helmet as this changes this risk equation because I don’t have to factor her safety into the situation.

as a parent if you know you can take an action that reduces the risk of your child passenger being in a bike crash even if it slightly increased your risk of a head injury if you did crash wouldn’t you take it? Me not wearing a helmet reduces my child’s risk of being in a bike crash so I don’t wear one.

Definitely an interesting point. Is there any information on how much the risk of a crash increases if you wear a helmet?

I'm not sure that I agree it's in your child's best interest to increase the risk of you getting badly injured if you crash or fall by not wearing a helmet, even if this means that your child is less likely to be in a crash at all. I think it is important for my child to have a healthy mother. It's going to be scant consolation to them if I end up with a brain injury or dead because I was not wearing a helmet if things do go wrong, surely?!

Also, the combined likelihood of injury for you both must be lower if you're both wearing helmets, even if it slightly increases the risk of something happening in the first place? As in: both wear helmets, 1 % chance of permanent brain injury for both in a crash, 1% chance of a crash. Only child wears a helmet, child has 1% chance of brain injury in a crash, parent has 10% chance of brain injury in a crash, 0.8% chance of a crash.

In the first scenario, both parent and child have a 0.01% chance of brain injury. In the second, the child has a 0.008% risk of brain injury, but the parent's risk is 0.08%. I've made these figures up, but intuitively I'd say that the increase in risk to the parent from not wearing a helmet is much bigger than the reduction in risk to the child from the reduced risk of a crash due to the parent not wearing a helmet. I suppose your choice depends on whether you value your child's safety alone, or your own as well. As I've argued, I think my own safety matters for my child too.

Also, what are you basing the assumption that your child will be injured or possibly killed in a crash/ fall, even with a helmet on, on, whilst you only risk a head injury, whilst not wearing a helmet? Surely the comparison is.

Lastly, has any research been done on drivers' perceptions of people cycling with children? I imagine that might influence their attitudes and therefore the risks to cyclists as well.

NamelessNancy · 20/06/2023 22:33

I find the idea that the safety of cyclists depends on their visible vulnerability to motorists very troubling.

It shouldn't be for the cyclist to choose to reduce their protection so that drivers give them more space. The onus must be on motorists to see cyclists as human irrespective of how they are dressed!

Soapyspuds · 20/06/2023 22:33

Helmets aren't necessarily as effective at preventing injury as you might think. As PP said, some injuries can even be made worse if the rider is wearing a helmet

Most bike helmets are just polystyrene - if you're in a really bad accident they're not really going to make much difference if you fall and hit your head

People have died from being punched and their head twatting the pavement. Coming off a bike can cause a lot more impact than that.

Obviously if some muppet knocks you off at 50mph then it will probably not save you. But I have been in two situations where I have come off due to the actions of bonehead pedestrians or other cyclists and hit my helmet on the ground. In both cases I was very happy that I was wearing it.

Statistically the chances of you needing it are low. But it is not much of a hardship to put one on. Basically it is like an insurance policy.

TallerThanAverage · 20/06/2023 22:30

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:44

Oh well done you. It was a stick of the kind that a dog might carry in its mouth, not half a tree blocking a road! It was dark so he didn't notice it. I guess your reply would be not to cycle in the dark. I'd rather wear a helmet and be able to cycle normally (following all road rules and paying attention to the traffic) than only be able to go out in daylight when the roads are dry and visibility is 100%. I am still not convinced that you can avoid all scenarios in which you needed a helmet to keep you safe. What about the drunk driver?

If you’re hit by a drunk driver the chances are that they are going to mow you down, a helmet isn’t going to help.

justgettingthroughtheday · 20/06/2023 22:24

gogohmm · 20/06/2023 19:44

@MojoMoon

My brother had a serious bike accident. The hospital consultant said his helmet probably saved his life and definitely saved h from having any serious head injuries (his leg still is affected though, pedal into soft tissue ick).

Ideally they would toughen the regulations to ensure people wore the better standard ones

Helmets should be compulsory. As should hi vis and reflective clothing.

But most cyclist seem to act in a very arrogant manner and don't bother with either.

user50316 · 20/06/2023 22:15

gogohmm · 20/06/2023 19:44

@MojoMoon

My brother had a serious bike accident. The hospital consultant said his helmet probably saved his life and definitely saved h from having any serious head injuries (his leg still is affected though, pedal into soft tissue ick).

Ideally they would toughen the regulations to ensure people wore the better standard ones

Me too. I was wearing a very expensive racing helmet which was smashed and bore the brunt of the impact. Had it been my skull that hit the ground I'd almost certainly be brain damaged if not dead.

About 30% of the kids at school ride a bike to school and all wear a helmet, as do their parents. I don't really understand why you wouldn't?!

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 22:09

I feel I should add the kid wears a helmet all the time on my bike or hers as there is no benefit for her in not wearing a helmet. I wear a helmet when riding alone or when riding off road. I do want the protection, unfortunately while the stats show we are less likely to be squashed by a lorry with me not wearing a helmet I won’t wear one on the road with a passenger.

Endlesssummer2022 · 20/06/2023 22:08

I don’t get it too and think the parent looks quite silly when I see it.

Newuser75 · 20/06/2023 22:05

Oysterbabe · 20/06/2023 20:50

I fell off my bike the other day, some of my clothing got jammed in the chain, bringing it to a stop and causing me to topple sideways as I couldn't get my foot down. I didn't hit my head but the handlebar somehow jammed into my boob and I had a MASSIVE bruise. Do you think I could stick a helmet on each one? They're pretty big.

😂

Newuser75 · 20/06/2023 22:05

Danikm151 · 20/06/2023 20:35

When I took up cycling again my best friend made me promise to wear a helmet as the injuries she’d seen working in hospital scared her.
The only time I don’t wear one is when renting a cycle on dedicated cycle lanes in the city centre.

My 3 year old has a recently got a bike and he wears a helmet even with stabilisers. If he doesn’t want to wear the helmet he doesn’t ride the bike simple as.

A helmet is a safety device and a good quality one is an investment.

I know there are opinions on not wearing them but I couldn’t cope with a what if

I do the same. If they don't wear a helmet they aren't allowed on their bikes. When my eldest was about 3 he was riding along on his balance bike. He hit a pothole and went flying over the handlebars straight onto his head. His helmet was smashed in quite a lot. He didn't have a mark on him. I'd take some convincing to think that helmets don't really help that much. Even if just a little why wouldn't you want that protection, especially for your kids!

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 22:01

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:49

Crashes aren't the only danger that a helmet protects you against though! Unilateral accidents happen too! Is the slightly reduced risk of a crash enough to outweigh the risks from not wearing a helmet in unilateral accidents?

Yes when riding with my child the reduced risk of a crash that would be dangerous/fatal TO HER is more important than the increased risk of a head injury TO ME if we crash or fall.

When riding without my child I wear a helmet as this changes this risk equation because I don’t have to factor her safety into the situation.

as a parent if you know you can take an action that reduces the risk of your child passenger being in a bike crash even if it slightly increased your risk of a head injury if you did crash wouldn’t you take it? Me not wearing a helmet reduces my child’s risk of being in a bike crash so I don’t wear one.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:50

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 21:45

Bikingwithbabies, It's about lessening the risk, not eliminating it altogether. I'm not sure that's possible in most activities in life.

Exactly, you can't eliminate all risk. Which is why I don't understand why you'd choose to rely on cycling defensively alone, rather than (also) wearing a helmet.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:49

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 21:37

I agree the research isn’t definitive - there is also a suggestion that riders wearing helmets take more risks so that is also a factors. But I doubt you have read much of of the research - anecdotally I am passed much closer and more aggressively by cars when Lycra and helmeted up on my road bike than helmet less on my cargo bike.

My reading of the collective body of research suggests that if you have a crash you are generally better of having a helmet on but that you are less likely to crash in the first place wearing one, therefore when riding with a child I put a helmet on them to ensure they are safest if we crash but don’t wear one myself to reduce the risk of a crash happening in the first place. I’m really not anti helmet - I wear one daily, I just don’t wear one when my child is also on the bike as I believe this makes her safer.

Crashes aren't the only danger that a helmet protects you against though! Unilateral accidents happen too! Is the slightly reduced risk of a crash enough to outweigh the risks from not wearing a helmet in unilateral accidents?

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 21:45

Bikingwithbabies, It's about lessening the risk, not eliminating it altogether. I'm not sure that's possible in most activities in life.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:44

Oysterbabe · 20/06/2023 21:38

I avoid things like this by not riding into branches. It's about being very alert to your environment and ready to stop.

Oh well done you. It was a stick of the kind that a dog might carry in its mouth, not half a tree blocking a road! It was dark so he didn't notice it. I guess your reply would be not to cycle in the dark. I'd rather wear a helmet and be able to cycle normally (following all road rules and paying attention to the traffic) than only be able to go out in daylight when the roads are dry and visibility is 100%. I am still not convinced that you can avoid all scenarios in which you needed a helmet to keep you safe. What about the drunk driver?

Usernamenotavailab · 20/06/2023 21:43

OttoGraph · 20/06/2023 21:09

Op I wear a helmet due to people like you, you’ll not be able to berate my daughters if I have a crash.

I did have a crash and the helmet smashed up into pieces and I had concussion 🤕 so fat lot of good it was

tje the A&E nurse tried to blame my shoes 🤦‍♀️🙈

That’s precisely what a helmet’s supposed to do. It smashes to absorb the energy which would otherwise have been transmitted to your skull.

you had a concussion, yes, but ever thought it might have been much worse without the helmet to dissipate some of the force?

I was hit by a car. I remember my head hitting the ground and bouncing off, my helmet cracking in the process. Thinking thank god that could have been my skull.

having been to nl recently their cycling culture is completely different.

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 21:38

Less likely to crash NOT wearing one (urgh fat fingers)

Oysterbabe · 20/06/2023 21:38

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:33

But how is that possible unless you're going no more than say 10km/h? Seriously, my dad was cycling in the Netherlands at rush hour, so by no means racing. He got a branch stuck in his front wheel and next thing he knew he was in an ambulance being blue lighted to hospital. How would you avoid that happening? Or a sudden puncture? Or a drink driver knocking you off your bike?

I avoid things like this by not riding into branches. It's about being very alert to your environment and ready to stop.

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 21:37

I agree the research isn’t definitive - there is also a suggestion that riders wearing helmets take more risks so that is also a factors. But I doubt you have read much of of the research - anecdotally I am passed much closer and more aggressively by cars when Lycra and helmeted up on my road bike than helmet less on my cargo bike.

My reading of the collective body of research suggests that if you have a crash you are generally better of having a helmet on but that you are less likely to crash in the first place wearing one, therefore when riding with a child I put a helmet on them to ensure they are safest if we crash but don’t wear one myself to reduce the risk of a crash happening in the first place. I’m really not anti helmet - I wear one daily, I just don’t wear one when my child is also on the bike as I believe this makes her safer.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:36

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 21:26

If you have no idea what cycling defensively means, then are you not commenting on a subject you are not fully qualified to comment on?

I was being a bit goady, but I am yet to be convinced that it is possible to ride a bike in such a way that you are never at risk of a head injury that might have been prevented or lessened by wearing a helmet. Please explain (and that I do mean genuinely, not goady!)

Also, having relevant knowledge has never been a prerequisite to comment on MN. Sadly😅

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 21:33

TreadLight · 20/06/2023 21:12

It means riding in such a way that if any of those happen, you have not put yourself in a situation where you can't deal with it. It comes with experience and knowledge.

But how is that possible unless you're going no more than say 10km/h? Seriously, my dad was cycling in the Netherlands at rush hour, so by no means racing. He got a branch stuck in his front wheel and next thing he knew he was in an ambulance being blue lighted to hospital. How would you avoid that happening? Or a sudden puncture? Or a drink driver knocking you off your bike?

Confrontayshunme · 20/06/2023 21:32

I do this weekly for a very specific reason. I use a child seat on the back or have a small child alongside on their bike. There are three pinch points on our way to an after school activity that cars do NOT give enough space for. If I wear my hair down and no helmet, they give me bags of room and wait if another car is oncoming. If I wear a helmet, my elbows get bruised by wing mirrors and I have been close passed dozens and dozens of times.

I know it doesn't make sense, but on that particular journey, I am safer without a helmet.

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 21:27

Bromptotoo, great post

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 21:26

If you have no idea what cycling defensively means, then are you not commenting on a subject you are not fully qualified to comment on?

Swipe left for the next trending thread