Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids wearing cycling helmets, parents not

89 replies

Faveusernamewastaken · 20/06/2023 18:21

Sorry but this is such a bugbear whenever I see it - a child on the back of their parent’s bike rightly wearing a helmet but the parent cycling isn’t. What if there is an accident, yes the child will be safe but their parent is risking their child seeing them with head injuries or worse. Please, please, please, from an ex-A&E nurse, wear a cycling helmet (cycling with a child or not)! No one thinks it will happen to them until it happens to them. Looking after your child means looking after yourself too!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
OttoGraph · 21/06/2023 19:43

You do you, I'll do me (with a helmet).

thats what many are already doing 🤷‍♀️

OttoGraph · 21/06/2023 19:39

Usernamenotavailab · 21/06/2023 08:53

Head injuries sustained in car crashes at far greater speeds than a bicycle can go, plus the whiplash aspect, are a different kettle of fish to a bike fall.

at the speeds bikes go, a helmet may make the difference between a headache and concussion, a concussion and a skull fracture, a skull fracture and death. It may just absorb enough of the impact to make a difference.

So rally drivers are wasting their time wearing helmets?

Usernamenotavailab · 21/06/2023 08:53

OttoGraph · 21/06/2023 03:01

49% of head injuries are sustained in car crashes
do you think car occupants should wear helmets?

Head injuries sustained in car crashes at far greater speeds than a bicycle can go, plus the whiplash aspect, are a different kettle of fish to a bike fall.

at the speeds bikes go, a helmet may make the difference between a headache and concussion, a concussion and a skull fracture, a skull fracture and death. It may just absorb enough of the impact to make a difference.

Bikingwithbabies · 21/06/2023 08:36

Oysterbabe · 21/06/2023 06:57

Because they already hate cyclists and are trying to find some justification for that.

I categorically do not hate cyclists, don't be daft. And no one is offended, that's just you being dramatic. It's incredulity that you wouldn't take every precaution available to keep yourself safe on the road.

Bikingwithbabies · 21/06/2023 08:34

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/06/2023 00:04

"Lots of misinformation" indeed.

I am sick of reading ill-informed people saying they "don't understand" why so many cyclists - having studied and assessed the risks for themselves - choose not to wear helmets, and saying things like "it should be illegal" to ride without one.
You are still far more likely to suffer a major head injury as a driver or passenger in a car than you are on a bike.
How many of you wear a protective polystyrene helmet when you're travelling in a car?
If not, why not?

Please rest assured that those of us who ride bikes (on a daily or near-daily basis) are very used to assessing the risks involved. I have used a bicycle as my main form of transport for almost 40 years, and have NEVER had a branch magically get stuck in my front wheel and cause me to fall off (or heard of this happening to anyone else - and I spent 20+ years working in bike-related jobs/ as cycling instructor, so have spent a LOT of time around regular and professional cyclists). I have never heard of anyone falling off as a result of a "sudden puncture" either. I'm sorry to hear about your dad's (extremely rare) misfortune, but don't think such anec-data is helpful here.

I know that if I were to fall off my bike my natural reaction is to put my arms out to break my fall. The chances of my head making contact with the ground is virtually zero. I'd be more likely to graze my hands and/or break my wrists (and have one friend who managed to break both wrists in this scenario). This is why I often wear gloves when riding, because they actually protect me against a real risk.

There is plenty of evidence that the heads of those who wear helmets are more likely to hit the ground, and various theories about why this is <ranging from (a) subconsciously if someone feels their head's protected they let it happen to (b) that the helmet adds extra weight, and there's gravity involved>.

When I've had a child riding on the back of my bike, strapped into a child seat, or in a trailer, I have put a helmet on them, because they're strapped in. There is a higher chance of the trailer tipping, or the bike tipping due to the extra weight of the child+seat, and because they're strapped (and could even be asleep at the time) they're far less likely to be able to react and put our their arms to break their fall.

Those of us who don't wear helmets aren't stupid. We've all given the matter a great deal of thought, and most cycling parents have given it even more thought since their children arrived, and the last thing any of us need is kneejerk judgement from people who don't have any experience of riding a bike/ towing a trailer, but as car-drivers, are directly responsible for the conditions we find ourselves cycling in.

I'm not sure how much of your post was addressed to me, but I just wanted to say that your experience as cycling instructor/ cyclist is just as much anecdata as my dad's story. There's also an unpleasant assumption that I don't know what I'm talking about. I've had 20 years of cycling in the Netherlands followed by over 10 years in the UK. I have a bike trailer for my two young children. No need for your superior tone.

You might not have heard of branches getting stuck in wheels, or of a child falling off their bike and sustaining permanent facial scarring, or of someone being found unconscious next to their bike after a unilateral accident, or of people landing awkwardly when falling over and sustaining permanent brain injury, or of people hitting some debris and going over the handlebars and into a lamp post and dying. I have, and not from news stories, these are all people I know. All these accidents took place in the Netherlands. In none of them the cyclist was wearing a helmet, and in all of them a helmet would have made a consideration difference to the outcome.

I am starting to find this thread upsetting. It is full of whataboutery and insulting comments by people who choose not to wear helmets. Let the statistics speak for themselves. You do you, I'll do me (with a helmet).

OttoGraph · 21/06/2023 07:33

Regardless of the data other posters have shared as nurses we have seen the ones where a helmet has made all the difference

so you will have seen vehicle crashes where a helmet will have made a difference, but where is your call for children and adults to wear car helmets? Seems very odd perspective you want to save cyclists lives but don't give a shit about drivers and car occupants

Heyheyitsanotherday · 21/06/2023 07:01

it drives me crazy too op. Regardless of the data other posters have shared as nurses we have seen the ones where a helmet has made all the difference. But worse than a parent not wearing a helmet… the other day I saw a parent wearing the helmet and a baby (around 12months) in the baby seat WITHOUT a helmet. I felt physically sick. What utter morons

Oysterbabe · 21/06/2023 06:57

Sigmama · 21/06/2023 06:55

I've never understood why the helmetless head offends so many people, that it has literally nothing to do with, most of whom have never cycled. Why does the smoker, the over eater, the drunk, the skate boarder, the pedestrian crossing roads whilst looking at phones, the list could go on, why do these 'risk takers' cause much less ire?

Because they already hate cyclists and are trying to find some justification for that.

Sigmama · 21/06/2023 06:55

I've never understood why the helmetless head offends so many people, that it has literally nothing to do with, most of whom have never cycled. Why does the smoker, the over eater, the drunk, the skate boarder, the pedestrian crossing roads whilst looking at phones, the list could go on, why do these 'risk takers' cause much less ire?

OttoGraph · 21/06/2023 03:01

49% of head injuries are sustained in car crashes
do you think car occupants should wear helmets?

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 21/06/2023 00:04

"Lots of misinformation" indeed.

I am sick of reading ill-informed people saying they "don't understand" why so many cyclists - having studied and assessed the risks for themselves - choose not to wear helmets, and saying things like "it should be illegal" to ride without one.
You are still far more likely to suffer a major head injury as a driver or passenger in a car than you are on a bike.
How many of you wear a protective polystyrene helmet when you're travelling in a car?
If not, why not?

Please rest assured that those of us who ride bikes (on a daily or near-daily basis) are very used to assessing the risks involved. I have used a bicycle as my main form of transport for almost 40 years, and have NEVER had a branch magically get stuck in my front wheel and cause me to fall off (or heard of this happening to anyone else - and I spent 20+ years working in bike-related jobs/ as cycling instructor, so have spent a LOT of time around regular and professional cyclists). I have never heard of anyone falling off as a result of a "sudden puncture" either. I'm sorry to hear about your dad's (extremely rare) misfortune, but don't think such anec-data is helpful here.

I know that if I were to fall off my bike my natural reaction is to put my arms out to break my fall. The chances of my head making contact with the ground is virtually zero. I'd be more likely to graze my hands and/or break my wrists (and have one friend who managed to break both wrists in this scenario). This is why I often wear gloves when riding, because they actually protect me against a real risk.

There is plenty of evidence that the heads of those who wear helmets are more likely to hit the ground, and various theories about why this is <ranging from (a) subconsciously if someone feels their head's protected they let it happen to (b) that the helmet adds extra weight, and there's gravity involved>.

When I've had a child riding on the back of my bike, strapped into a child seat, or in a trailer, I have put a helmet on them, because they're strapped in. There is a higher chance of the trailer tipping, or the bike tipping due to the extra weight of the child+seat, and because they're strapped (and could even be asleep at the time) they're far less likely to be able to react and put our their arms to break their fall.

Those of us who don't wear helmets aren't stupid. We've all given the matter a great deal of thought, and most cycling parents have given it even more thought since their children arrived, and the last thing any of us need is kneejerk judgement from people who don't have any experience of riding a bike/ towing a trailer, but as car-drivers, are directly responsible for the conditions we find ourselves cycling in.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 23:08

OK, I see where you're coming from. I am very unlikely to ever cycle on a 50mph road, and most definitely not with my kids, no amount of (not) wearing helmets and safety gear would make that feel safe to me. think that's where our situations differ.

EnthENd · 20/06/2023 23:07

In the scenario of a helmeted child passenger and a helmetless rider, which I think is fairly common, I wonder if the fear is dropping the bike while dismounting? A child in a seat probably can't protect themselves very well.

EnthENd · 20/06/2023 23:06

I normally wear a bike helmet, but if I forget it I don't turn around, and if I don't have it (ie, riding a hire bike), I still ride.

I think the jury's still out on overall safety impact because of the bad behaviour of drivers. It's car drivers that are the main threat and I won't cycle on busy roads. I figure the helmet will take the brunt off the impact if I misjudge a low branch or have a skid and fall, which are accidents that can happen on a cycleway.

Qazwsxefv · 20/06/2023 23:00

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:38

Definitely an interesting point. Is there any information on how much the risk of a crash increases if you wear a helmet?

I'm not sure that I agree it's in your child's best interest to increase the risk of you getting badly injured if you crash or fall by not wearing a helmet, even if this means that your child is less likely to be in a crash at all. I think it is important for my child to have a healthy mother. It's going to be scant consolation to them if I end up with a brain injury or dead because I was not wearing a helmet if things do go wrong, surely?!

Also, the combined likelihood of injury for you both must be lower if you're both wearing helmets, even if it slightly increases the risk of something happening in the first place? As in: both wear helmets, 1 % chance of permanent brain injury for both in a crash, 1% chance of a crash. Only child wears a helmet, child has 1% chance of brain injury in a crash, parent has 10% chance of brain injury in a crash, 0.8% chance of a crash.

In the first scenario, both parent and child have a 0.01% chance of brain injury. In the second, the child has a 0.008% risk of brain injury, but the parent's risk is 0.08%. I've made these figures up, but intuitively I'd say that the increase in risk to the parent from not wearing a helmet is much bigger than the reduction in risk to the child from the reduced risk of a crash due to the parent not wearing a helmet. I suppose your choice depends on whether you value your child's safety alone, or your own as well. As I've argued, I think my own safety matters for my child too.

Also, what are you basing the assumption that your child will be injured or possibly killed in a crash/ fall, even with a helmet on, on, whilst you only risk a head injury, whilst not wearing a helmet? Surely the comparison is.

Lastly, has any research been done on drivers' perceptions of people cycling with children? I imagine that might influence their attitudes and therefore the risks to cyclists as well.

I’m basing the assumption that in general being squashed by a HGV going at 50mph is going to be fatal to both of us but falling off the bike at 15mph is likely to break some limbs or get a head injury.

the accident that’s going to kill me or passenger - going under a lorry that got too close overtaking -a helmet isn’t going to help either of us survive that, I can’t prevent it that much by safe defensive cycling in primary position (we do a short stretch 3x week on a busy rural 50mph A road near a quarry that just can’t be avoided by taking a different route so are passed by quite a few tipper trucks) No helmet anecdotally and statically means we are passed wider and so less risk of being squashed.

the type of crash were we fall off the bike due to wobble/ice/leaves/water/random happenstance is much more likely to be at 10-15mph and so cause anything from grazes to broken bones to head injuries to yes death but it’s less likely. It’s already a very low slow stable cargo bike - no speed wizzing round corners going on here. I can modulate the risk of an accidental fall by safe cycling (not that I’m perfect at all) so less of a concern than the HGV squash scenario.

put me alone on my drop handle road bike, or both of us off road on a trail and it’s a totally different equation and the helmet goes on.

the amount of posters on her saying they think the no helmet wearing parent in this situation is an idiot is making the point - car driver thinks your a non helmet wearing idiot so they pass slow and wide, put on Lycra and a helmet and they think your safe and experienced so pass quick and close. I’m happy to be thought an idiot if it stops us being run over.

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:57

Incidentally it really seems to rile drivers if I'm in the middle of the carriageway, so whilst I've read it's safer, it doesn't always feel it.

MojoMoon · 20/06/2023 22:55

justgettingthroughtheday · 20/06/2023 22:24

Helmets should be compulsory. As should hi vis and reflective clothing.

But most cyclist seem to act in a very arrogant manner and don't bother with either.

Ok, as long as we make wearing helmets mandatory in cars and require all cars to be decked out in hi Viz?

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:54

TreadLight · 20/06/2023 22:52

And moving to the middle of a lane if there isn't room for a car to overtake so they aren't tempted, making eye contact with other vehicles joining a roundabout so you know they have seen you. Always assume someone will pull out in front of you. Never go on the nearside of a lorry or bus. Overtake rather than undertake. Assume every parked car will open their door just as you pass. Don't cycle in the gutter to avoid punctures and to give yourself room to move/fall off if someone gets too close. Clear signals so drivers know what you are doing. Ride a "sit up and beg" bike rather than a drop handle bar bike so you aren't leading with your head etc. Etc.

I do all of those. I also wear a helmet though🤷🏼‍♀️ I've also fallen off my bike despite these precautions

TreadLight · 20/06/2023 22:52

Oysterbabe · 20/06/2023 21:38

I avoid things like this by not riding into branches. It's about being very alert to your environment and ready to stop.

And moving to the middle of a lane if there isn't room for a car to overtake so they aren't tempted, making eye contact with other vehicles joining a roundabout so you know they have seen you. Always assume someone will pull out in front of you. Never go on the nearside of a lorry or bus. Overtake rather than undertake. Assume every parked car will open their door just as you pass. Don't cycle in the gutter to avoid punctures and to give yourself room to move/fall off if someone gets too close. Clear signals so drivers know what you are doing. Ride a "sit up and beg" bike rather than a drop handle bar bike so you aren't leading with your head etc. Etc.

blankittyblank · 20/06/2023 22:48

I've fallen off my bike twice. One I slipped on an invisible patch of oil, and once some bloke walked right out in front me when I was in the cycle lane. Both times the front of head hit the road, breaking my helmet both time. I dread to think what state my head would have been in had I not been wearing one.

My friend also told me a story about a woman who was cycle and fell off her bike, and hit her head on the kerb. Not hard, but in such a way it completely brain damaged her.

When people trot out the whole "it makes no difference in a major accident" trope, it really annoys me. You don't need to have a big accident to see the benefit of wearing one

elderflowerandpomelo · 20/06/2023 22:45

I’m so encouraged by the messages here. I’ve been on MN for years, and until recently there would have been mass agreement w the wrong (see all sorts of research quotednhere) opinion in the OP. Now, FINALLY, lots of posters seeing sense.

now, as it happens, after 20 years of not wearing a helmet, I’m back to wearing one - I think my reactions have got slower, and my risk of a self-inflicted slow fall/crash has increased. But when it comes to anything involving another vehicle, it’s absolutely clear that helmets almost never help… certainly didn’t help me when a driver hit me head on (he was turning, looking the other way, and on the wrong side of the road).
to keep cyclists safe we need to keep them away from cars. It’s really simple…

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:45

TallerThanAverage · 20/06/2023 22:30

If you’re hit by a drunk driver the chances are that they are going to mow you down, a helmet isn’t going to help.

Possibly, but I was taking issue with the claim that defensive cycling could deal with all the scenarios I listed. It evidently can't. I'd still rather be wearing a helmet if I'm going to be knocked down

Bikingwithbabies · 20/06/2023 22:42

Yes, they did. That doesn't prove anything though. You need to look at overall percentages of cyclists wearing hi Viz and compare likelihood of death in this group to the likelihood of deaths for cyclists not wearing this protective gear.

People die in car crashes whilst wearing seatbelts. That doesn't show that seatbelts are not the safest option though.