Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my sister should think carefully about her wedding date?

256 replies

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 07:14

My sister (28f) just got engaged. (or rather, they are just waiting for the ring and will then make it public/announce it, but her bf has gone round to chat to my dad)
My sister and whole family live in a different continent. Myself, DH and 2 children live in the UK.

We (me, DH, kids) have flight tickets to go back home for Christmas. But we fly out end of November and are only returning in the middle of January. (+- 7 weeks) We especially made our trip home that long because we were kind of expecting an engagement and wanted to give my sister ample time to plan the wedding if they wanted us included.

My sister phoned me crying yesterday explaining how she and bf had been wanting to get married in October, but obviously really want us there, but really do not want to wait till December. Besides, she argues that December is a hard time to get married.
{for context, we are a large close-knit family, having a big Christmas get together)
She does not want to miss Christmas with us and family, to be on her honeymoon if she gets married December. ( we have another family wedding 15th of December so she argues with another wedding and Christmas, when is she going to fit in her wedding? )
I get that, really, she wants to feel special not pushed in somewhere, she wants a nice long honeymoon, but not have to miss family events and get married sooner rather than later.

But we make things difficult. To add to that my mom has apparently said the's intentionally being difficult by not just having the wedding when we are there.

Realistically best choice would be to get married in January (after Christmas and everything) and I can help with arrangements etc or then October and we miss out.

I do not want to influence my sister either way as I think it is her choice, but don't want her to regret it down the line. ( the photos I have of my wedding with my sisters helping me get ready are special to me)

What would you do? Is it reasonable to expect November, December or Jan or should they just do October.
Thanks for reading this far!!

OP posts:
Annipeck · 20/06/2023 12:44

Ultimately I'll be sorry but cannot be responsible for her feeling sad that we're not there.

I meant like to have a think about it and not just choose a date and then be sad we can't come. I meant weigh up what is more important to her, october wedding or us being there

I get that English isn't your first language, OP, but these are quite odd, passive-aggressive statements. Who has suggested that you are responsible for your sister feeling sad you can't attend her wedding? It does seem to me that you are the one who is suggesting she will be sad -- it's not coming from her? I mean, it seems as if you would in fact like her to be sad, but surely if she chooses a date when you aren't in the country, then that suggests she's OK with your absence?

I don't know if you've already addressed this in a comment I haven't noticed, but I'd echo a pp in asking if there's some cultural element in this dash to get married in October when your sister hasn't yet announced her engagement? It seems very rushed.

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:41

MargotBamborough · 20/06/2023 12:36

OP, the details about your sister's engagement give me a really weird vibe.

Taking you and the fact that you live on another continent out of the equation for a minute. It's actually super weird that your family was anticipating an engagement to the point where you were basically saying, "Are you engaged yet? Any dates we need to work around?" before the couple were actually engaged.

How did this situation come about? Was she putting pressure on him to get engaged? Was he dangling engagement in front of her like a carrot on a stick? Why all this pre-engagement discussion, particularly given that she's only 28? And now they actually have got engaged, they've decided to get married super quickly, and will probably be engaged for less time than your sister has spent talking to all her nearest and dearest about the fact that she might be getting engaged.

What's the tearing hurry? Is she worried that if they have a long engagement he might change his mind? Because it would be perfectly normal of her to say, "Hey, you know my sister is coming out for Christmas so let's do it then" or alternatively, "Yes an October wedding will be fantastic, let's do it next October though because this October is pretty short notice, especially for people like my sister who will need to buy flights for the whole family."

What is her relationship with her fiance like? Because this sounds a bit weird and maybe you'd be better off having a conversation with her about whether she's really sure this is what she wants.

Its funny that half of the poster's are like "you should have chatted to her before hand" and you're like "why did you chat about dates".

SA is still pretty conservative, i got married at 22 for example. It wasn't weird, they started dating and he seemed like the one. We just sort of thought "oh it looks like they fit well together, do we hear wedding bells'. It is not common to date for ages in our culture.
And how they spoke, for example. 'Oh once we live in x city' or 'we thought about this house etc.
And we didn't want to jump the gun and ask outright but we wanted to hear if she had dates in mind, so we just asked. Hey is there dates to work around.

I don't find it odd,

OP posts:
Caramelatt · 20/06/2023 12:40

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 11:56

Thanks for being a bit more objective! We put off buiyng the ticket, but bought about a month ago to avoid prices going even higher. In the back of my mind I reasoned that if they haven't gotten engaged by now, they would struggle to hold the ceremony anyway befor end of the year.

So the other who didnt side with you were not objective given your strongly worded OP??

You are not going to listen to objective posts, you will only find those objective which say what you want to hear.

What is your sister's reason for eantimg to get married in October knowing it is inconvenient to her local siblings due to exams and for you and your family? There must be a reason she wants October knowing it does not suit so many people or is it she is on purpose making it hard for you all?

LAMPS1 · 20/06/2023 12:38

With the info in your updates OP, I think you have done everything you can to find out when the wedding might been before booking your flights.
The flights are booked now and non-refundable. And you can’t afford to go twice. Your sister knows this but still wants to get married in October when you aren’t there. And your mum wants the wedding when you are there.
I would quietly wait and not get involved in the wrangling between them. Hopefully, someone else will persuade your sister that a New Year wedding would be worth waiting for, but it shouldn’t really be you who tries to persuade her one way or the other.

MargotBamborough · 20/06/2023 12:36

OP, the details about your sister's engagement give me a really weird vibe.

Taking you and the fact that you live on another continent out of the equation for a minute. It's actually super weird that your family was anticipating an engagement to the point where you were basically saying, "Are you engaged yet? Any dates we need to work around?" before the couple were actually engaged.

How did this situation come about? Was she putting pressure on him to get engaged? Was he dangling engagement in front of her like a carrot on a stick? Why all this pre-engagement discussion, particularly given that she's only 28? And now they actually have got engaged, they've decided to get married super quickly, and will probably be engaged for less time than your sister has spent talking to all her nearest and dearest about the fact that she might be getting engaged.

What's the tearing hurry? Is she worried that if they have a long engagement he might change his mind? Because it would be perfectly normal of her to say, "Hey, you know my sister is coming out for Christmas so let's do it then" or alternatively, "Yes an October wedding will be fantastic, let's do it next October though because this October is pretty short notice, especially for people like my sister who will need to buy flights for the whole family."

What is her relationship with her fiance like? Because this sounds a bit weird and maybe you'd be better off having a conversation with her about whether she's really sure this is what she wants.

SlightlyJaded · 20/06/2023 12:30

I also wondered if she might be pregnant which would explain the rush.

You have to be clear about what you can and can't do with her and just let her make a decision with all the facts in hand.

Your DMum is the problem - guitling her. Tell her to stop.

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:30

darkmodeon · 20/06/2023 08:23

Do you always try to make these things all about you?

ouch. I wouldn't mind if the wanted it so. But how do i accomodate her and our Christmas plans. It's not about me. I want to make her happy on her wedding day?

OP posts:
ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:27

autieawesome · 20/06/2023 09:02

Op you don't look good in this. It reads like you assumed they would get married while you were there so you have limited their options. If they want to marry in October can you change your flight

Yeah I feel bad after all the comments. We booked an annual Christmas trip home. (if we had more notice of this wedding we would probably have missed out on Christmas and came for the wedding) But then we decided that in stead of going for the usual 3 ish weeks, lets stretch it out to 8 week so that IF my sis and them wanted to get married around the end of the year and want us there, they have a bit more time. But yeah, maybe you are right we pushed her into a date?? I don't feel like we have though we tried to book as we thought best

OP posts:
OwlRightThen · 20/06/2023 12:22

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/06/2023 08:06

We especially made our trip home that long because we were kind of expecting an engagement and wanted to give my sister ample time to plan the wedding if they wanted us included

This is the weirdest bit. They decide when they want to get married and you fit around that.

This. You've made an assumption and assumed wrongly. It's odd you would do this.

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:22

planthelpadvice · 20/06/2023 08:53

Also guessing southern hemisphere where Christmas isn't quite the same as is it is in the UK so I expect it's much more common to have December/January weddings - same as having June/July weddings in the northern hemisphere.

Anyway - doubt the OP is coming back, but if this is real and she's still reading - I think you need to tell your sister to make the best plan for her and you'll do your very best to be there. It isn't reasonable to expect her to work around your dates. Could you go on your own ahead of the rest of your family or stay longer?

I could potentially go back home earlier, but we have no family in the UK, so if I were to go I would have to take the kids as well because my husband works full time, so no-one could look after them.

OP posts:
ZiriForEver · 20/06/2023 12:21

Yeah, the thread title wasn't the best.
Reading the updates, it sounds just like a normal tricky situation with a distant family.

Had they decided for October earlier, it would be a hard choice for you once again - whether to go for wedding or for Christmas.

Don't try to evaluate, whether your sister would regret more adjusting to the family schedule and getting married in January, or going on with October. There are tradeoffs and compromises in all choices.

Just go ahead with her plans, support her and be happy for her.

MargotBamborough · 20/06/2023 12:20

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:07

I feel somewhat unfairly criticized, but guess that's on me. I love her and would love to make the effort to be there, but we've spent almost 2k on flights and wouldn't be able to afford another 2k (which would be more because flight prices are higher). We did have multiple conversations of "hey any preferred dates if you were to get engaged." and she kept saying she doesn't know, they're not engaged yet. I really hope I am not making this time sad for her.

This is really annoying. I would be upset.

You left it for as long as possible before booking your flights, you're going to be out there for 6 weeks, and she decides to get married on short notice, a few weeks before you're due to be there.

I don't think you would be unreasonable to say you did keep asking her about dates and she said there was nothing to work around so you made plans to come for Christmas, and now suddenly she's getting married in October whether you can make it or not? What gives? If she's got her heart set on an October wedding for some excellent reason then why not next October so you have time to save up another two grand for tickets?

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:15

MichelleScarn · 20/06/2023 11:33

Yes! "Think carefully before you...".always sounds ominous and really means "don't dare do that!"

Carefully was deffo the wrong word, english isn't my mother tongue so sometimes translating is hard. I meant like to have a think about it and not just choose a date and then be sad we can't come. I meant weigh up what is more important to her, october wedding or us being there

OP posts:
TerfIngOnTheBeach · 20/06/2023 12:13

Just read the full thread and my response is the same. I correctly guessed the OP was coming home for Christmas and the dates were because that is the summer and summer holidays from school for the country in question. I wrongly guess Australia, but that's irrelevant.

Knowing the cost to travel, distance and how far ahead you have to book and plan such a visit I am somewhat surprised at the sister to be honest. One month later isn't going to make any difference to them, let's face it, in the bigger scheme of things January next year is still only just over six months away.

I feel sorry for the OP who is being rather rational in my opinion and for mum who is understandably upset that both her girls won't be there along with 2 of her grandchildren.

I think the sister is being a bit bridezilla tbh.

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:11

Batalax · 20/06/2023 10:23

Don’t get emotional about it. Stay neutral and say
”it would be lovely if we could see you get married whilst we are there, but completely understand if October suits you better. Let us know what you decide to do”

Then it’s her choice. Personally I think the November, first week that you are there, sounds better than post Xmas.

Yeah i think this is what I'm going to stick with. Ultimately I'll be sorry but cannot be responsible for her feeling sad that we're not there. She has all the info, it really is her choice

OP posts:
BinkyBeaufort · 20/06/2023 12:11

OP, I've only read your posts and a few others.
I absolutely don't understand why some posters are piling on you and making out you are somehow unreasonable.
Your sister sounds as though she's looking for drama, insisting on a time when you can't be there. And with all the hassle of planning a wedding so quickly (although I always think that's much less stressful - consolidate all the aggro into as short a time as possible) you'd think she'd try to avoid conflict over dates. Especially when it doesn't sound as though she has a good reason for making it October other than that she just wants to.
Is she normally difficult/demanding?

WillyLows · 20/06/2023 12:10

Have you asked her why she is so set on October? I can see your side more after your updates.

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:09

waltzingparrot · 20/06/2023 11:52

My solution would be ....get married on Christmas Eve, have a wonderful family Christmas and go on honeymoon when they've all gone home.

haha love this, but no! I'd like my sis and bf to be celebrated and feel special! and christmas is special on it's own. don't want to share christmas with your wedding

OP posts:
ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:07

LadyJ2023 · 20/06/2023 10:22

So so wrong expecting your sister to adapt plans to suit yourself. You wouldn't have liked that but you expect her to like it. If you love her you make the effort to be there when she decided not on your terms. So sad you've made it complicated for her should be a happy time

I feel somewhat unfairly criticized, but guess that's on me. I love her and would love to make the effort to be there, but we've spent almost 2k on flights and wouldn't be able to afford another 2k (which would be more because flight prices are higher). We did have multiple conversations of "hey any preferred dates if you were to get engaged." and she kept saying she doesn't know, they're not engaged yet. I really hope I am not making this time sad for her.

OP posts:
standardduck · 20/06/2023 12:07

Could she be pregnant? Maybe she is very early on, but doesn't want to be heavily pregnant in January at her wedding?

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 12:02

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/06/2023 08:19

Presumably the criticism is more that the OP booked the dates she did, before her sister is even engaged, planning for the fact that she would have her wedding then, even though she wasn't even engaged or had set a date!

It's a bit batshit.

Thing is December holidays are the slow days in SA. Thats when everyone takes leave. Schools are closed etc. So we went home for a family Christmas knowing in the back of our minds that sis might get engaged and then tried to make the holiday as long as possible to see if she could fit in a date. I mean if she only got engage next year and married next year august, no biggie. I think everyone (parents, siblings) is just feeling that you're going to get engaged in June, and that NOv/dec/jan is a reasonable time when everyone is home/off uni and schools. They're saying why have the wedding 4 weeks before your sister is home and right in the middle of exams. That is why she phoned, to get my opinion also. And i was very neutral and wanted to come on here to see what everyone feels. ie were you said you missed a siblings wedding in hindsight or was it a non-event?

OP posts:
Mirabai · 20/06/2023 12:02

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 20/06/2023 11:59

OK so the issue really is your mum putting pressure on your sister to do it when you are there. Please have your sister's back on this and support her getting the wedding she wants even if it means you missing it.

The wedding sister wants, if you read the thread, is to have her sister present.

Mirabai · 20/06/2023 12:01

ThroughGraceAlone · 20/06/2023 11:56

Thanks for being a bit more objective! We put off buiyng the ticket, but bought about a month ago to avoid prices going even higher. In the back of my mind I reasoned that if they haven't gotten engaged by now, they would struggle to hold the ceremony anyway befor end of the year.

You’ve done everything you possibly could. It’s now up to sis as to whether her priority is the date or her sister.

(I just knew it was going to come down to your sister pressurising you to come twice - all the posts saying she has a right to a wedding without you are beside the point).

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 20/06/2023 11:59

OK so the issue really is your mum putting pressure on your sister to do it when you are there. Please have your sister's back on this and support her getting the wedding she wants even if it means you missing it.

Mirabai · 20/06/2023 11:59

Caramelatt · 20/06/2023 11:52

January is not just bad weather month in the UK. Australia has summers but OP hasn't specified it is Australia. Given her username, I think it is north America.

Also, early Jan is not that great time for anniversary celebrations each year right after Christmas period. Let sister plan what is best for her, she will be celebrating this date every year, not OP.

It’s SA. Her sister wants both an October wedding and the OP present.