Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 20/06/2023 10:53

inappropriateraspberry · 20/06/2023 04:28

I think you'll find yourself in the minority here, and likely in your home country as well. You seem to have a very skewed view on this.
What country/culture are you from? I think the U.K. is one of the most uptight places regarding children on their own etc.

OP's reluctant to say where she's from but the use of CPS implies North America. I would say that children here are under the direct control of parents for far too long, there are posts on here panicking that an11 year old will be walking to school without parental supervision in September. By Year 6 an 11 year old should be able, other conditions allowing, to walk to school or travel on a bus if needed, if they can't then their parents have been neglectful.

Bromptotoo · 20/06/2023 10:53

Old timer here, 63 amd born/raised in a realtively urban but partly rural bit of the West Riding. Subsequently had my own kids born/raised here in West Northants.

At age 7 (probably) I found my own way, on foot, the mile or so home from school after missing the neighbour who was walking a group of us home. Bit of a fuss at the time but was subsequently allowed to do my own thing. Mum was at home.

At senior school (age 11 on) we all walked or bussed home. Sis and I both had keys and let ourselves in. By that stage Mum was working so we were alone together with TV etc for an hour or more.

Left on my own overnight from around 14 and for a week or so while parents/sis were on a holiday I wanted not to go on at 16. Youth Hostelling on my own at 16/17 - but at that time it was allowed from 12.

None of that was exceptional, indeed it was the norm.

Pretty similar with my two. The dangerous part wasn't being on their own in the house; it was crossing a couple of estate roads where people drive too fast.

Son flew home alone from France at 14 - we met him at the airport.

WhosAfraidOfVirginalWolves · 20/06/2023 10:53

LadyJ2023 · 20/06/2023 10:32

I live in uk and baffles me also. The amount of 9-10 year olds that leave my sons school alone, let themselves in and wait till parents come home several hours later I will never understand. The comment about minority well that also isn't what I see either. And the 16 being left for 4 days yep not happening in our family

I'd hazard that probably all of my friends (and myself) had been left for about a week or so at least once by age 16 if parents were going on holiday or going to see family. It was completely normal.

I was walking to and from school in Year 4. By year 5, I'm pretty sure all my class were (bar a couple of children with special needs, or who lived beyond walking distance). My parents worked funny hours so it was a bit hit or miss whether they'd be there when I got back.

If they weren't, I'd make myself a cup of tea and something to eat, have the TV to myself, read, do homework and any chores I was supposed to be doing. I loved it and there were never any issues.

I was born in 1995, so not exactly the days of yore. There's no reason, really, why children today should be utterly incapable of it.

Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 10:52

@Turfwars 11 is a tricky age isn’t it. That is a great set up with your friend.
We live rurally too and work 20-25 minutes drive away plus have nice neighbours that DS would happily call into if he ever needed an adult. 90 minutes commute is very far if he needs you.
I am on maternity leave and eldest DS has just finished 1st year so happily so need to be left alone all day for him although he usually wants to stay home alone when I run errands unless I am going somewhere he wants to go.

CornishGem1975 · 20/06/2023 10:52

I actually find the opposite. People are crazy over-protective.

Horizabel · 20/06/2023 10:51

Goldenbear · 20/06/2023 10:22

So it is a 'legal' stipulation to be 14 in ROI as there is no such stipulation in England, unsure about the other countries that make up UK?

No, there's no law relating to this, just as there isn't in England. The only document I've seen the age of 14 mentioned as an age under which children shouldn't be left unsupervised for more than a short time in is a guide from Tusla (Child and Family Agency) aimed at immigrants newly arrived in Ireland, which is as much about transitioning to new cultural norms as about legal things like marriage ages etc. But DS's class (11 and 12 year olds) are from a variety of ethnic and national backgrounds, and I think would virtually all have considerably more freedom than this.

ZebraDilemma · 20/06/2023 10:49

That’s a rather unfounded generalisation OP.

horseyhorsey17 · 20/06/2023 10:49

The idea of a 16 year old being a 'child' who can't look after themselves is just weird. Where is the OP actually from?

Natsku · 20/06/2023 10:48

And at 15/16 children might go to high school in a different part of the country and live in student accommodation. My local vocational school owns a few flats that it rents out to those who live too far away to commute to school.

Jetstream · 20/06/2023 10:48

It says 16 year olds can be left alone depending on the maturity of the child. It is not recommended. I think all this overkill is due to lack or no rights of children in the past. Ireland’s record on advocating child welfare was shockingly bad and partially non existent until recently.

user1477391263 · 20/06/2023 10:46

I'm honestly starting to wonder if the OP is actually "Irish-American" with a vivid imagination. The States is the only country I know that is more paranoid about child safety than the UK, and the Irish parents I know are relaxed and give their kids plenty of independence.

Natsku · 20/06/2023 10:44

People in the UK are quite the opposite of lax about children being left alone, they wait much later to allow them independence than many other countries.
I'm in Finland, its very normal for 7 year olds to go out and about alone, and stay home alone for an hour or two, so normal that the national child protection country gives advice on how to prepare your 6/7 (the age they start school) for this.

horseyhorsey17 · 20/06/2023 10:42

It's always been the norm here - in fact, it's less of the norm now than it ever was in the past. I was babysitting and looking after my younger brother and sister on my own from the age of 11. That wasn't considered odd in the 70s. Depends on the child and what they're capable of handling. Obviously there are some kids you wouldn't leave on their own, but my son at 14 is over six foot and more capable of dealing with eg an intruder than I am. A 16 year old is a young adult and more than capable of looking after themselves for a few days. I went on holiday with my mates on my own at that age. It seems odd that people would think this too young.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 20/06/2023 10:40

I think it’s the opposite, many teens and young adults are babied beyond belief these days.

A 16yo is perfectly capable of staying in their own home for 4 days. Bemused as to what OP thinks changes between 16 and 17 to be so shocked that a 16yo would be left alone.

I stayed home alone at 16 got a week while the rest of my family went on holiday and LOVED it. Nice, safe way to get used to looking after yourself (in your own environment)

fireflyloo · 20/06/2023 10:40

@StarmanBobby people in NI aren't all British. I'm not. I'm Irish.

Turfwars · 20/06/2023 10:39

Irish here as well OP. We live rurally, and in some respects, like playing out until dark, it's very safe.

But the rural roads are too dangerous without a hard shoulder or path for teens to cycle - even if you plaster them head to toe in flashing lights and high-vis. It's just not done in our locality. It's a shame, if there were safe cycle lanes, DS would love to cycle to school (about 6km from the house) and back with his friends.

During the summer you've got agricultural machinery bombing down the road often driven by a 16yo at speed thinking he's in the Fast and the Furious 🙄and in the winter it's too dark with no street lights to walk or cycle.

There's a school bus. One trip to and one trip back from school. No other public transport option. A fuck up by Bus Eireann in Sept 2022 meant that loads of people who didn't need tickets got them "just in case" and left the ones who depend on a bus fucked for a few months at the beginning of the school year. And if he misses the only bus that evening? fuck all good if I'm 50km away at the office. It's not like the bigger towns where there will be another bus along in a half hour.

DS is 11. He could get off the bus at the top of the road, and let himself in during term time, but Tusla recommend that under 14s don't spend extended time alone at home, so that's a pain for the summer. I've also got a neighbour who would report you for anything, so they would be on the phone to Tusla the first week. And I'm rather too busy to have to sit through a malicious SS assessment.

If I worked locally and could be there in 20 mins in any emergency it might be different but my commute is 90 mins one way. Myself and another mum have dovetailed our WFH days for the summer and if it goes well, we might keep it going next year too. It means that he's got company too for the summer.

Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 10:36

ApplesForMe · 20/06/2023 10:33

I think legislation was passed in Ireland a few years ago saying anyone 14 and under are not allowed to be left alone, but most people here either don’t know about it or think it’s overkill. It depends on your child, some are capable and some not.

Is it actual law though because if it is then nobody knows about it.

Quinoawoman · 20/06/2023 10:36

I stayed home on my own for 4 days aged 16 while my parents were on holiday because I had a job and I had to work. I guess there are some 16 year olds who would not be responsible enough but I absolutely was.

onlywayissussex · 20/06/2023 10:35

House fires and abductions?

Where do you come from? Sounds awfully dramatic

Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 10:35

Goldenbear · 20/06/2023 10:22

So it is a 'legal' stipulation to be 14 in ROI as there is no such stipulation in England, unsure about the other countries that make up UK?

No it’s a recommendation not a law. Recommendation comes from Tulsa who are our social services. In the real world my son and his friends who are 13 have been slowly built up spending time alone in house over last couple years so they would be used to it as kids get home from school before parents get home from work.

Once kids are too old for childcare they get left home alone. Summer holidays are longer here. Nine weeks in summer for primary and about 12 weeks for secondary school. There aren’t summer camps etc for 12/13/14 year olds.

Jetstream · 20/06/2023 10:34

I live in Ireland OP, in the countryside where older siblings drive their younger siblings to school.

In Dublin my teenage nephews can safely walk home from school including navigating busy junctions.

It should be noted that Ireland has one of the highest rates of obesity including in children and young people. Young adults entering 3rd level education don’t know how to cook and are ordering take aways because mum always cooked dinner.

ApplesForMe · 20/06/2023 10:33

I think legislation was passed in Ireland a few years ago saying anyone 14 and under are not allowed to be left alone, but most people here either don’t know about it or think it’s overkill. It depends on your child, some are capable and some not.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/06/2023 10:33

I’d say the opposite, OP - a lot of people are IMO over-protective of their children, certainly compared with previous eras. People are much more conscious of dangers such as paedophiles nowadays, though I do well remember being warned about getting into a car with anybody, or talking at all to strange (as in unknown) men.

When I was still only 5 and yet to start school, so unable to read, my DM would send me, with the money and a list, a good 15 minute walk to the shop - albeit a quiet area with no roads to cross. To be entirely fair, she had a young baby and a toddler at home, at a time (1950s) with no car, no central heating (coal fires only) no automatic washing machine, etc..

But who on earth would even dream of doing this this nowadays?

Swipe left for the next trending thread