Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
Poppetsss · 20/06/2023 11:29

Not all parents have the privilege to drop off and collect their late primary/secondary age children but there's a reason chicken shop grooming is a thing. It focuses on parents who are not able to be present. Especially at an age where children and more independent and move away from the family unit more to form their views of the world.

That being said, leaving it too late is just as harmful in the long run as you get children who are not streetwise and cannot access risk.

dancinginthesky · 20/06/2023 11:27

I find it weird the OP is from Ireland bc when I was 15 I remember being taken on holiday by a friend who's family was Irish and we were allowed to hitchhike everywhere- she was 16, me 15 and it's only about 22 years ago.

We hitchhiked everywhere and roamed free and every car you got in it was "what's your surname?" And then you figured out how you were related and they seemed to know everyone's granny, mum, auntie etc whatever car you got in and be of some relation vaguely to my friend

At the time I thought it was crazy bc it was unheard of to hitchhike by then in the UK and certainly not the ages we were would have been encouraged in the UK - but there, we were. It was somewhere close to Tralee as I remember that name

MRSBoredsome · 20/06/2023 11:21

I'm originally from Japan. I started going to school without my parents at the age of 6. The school was 30mins away from home on foot. It is also normal for children from 6yo to clean classrooms as well as the toilets after school everyday.

16yo should be old enough to be alone for a week if the person is independent. I started living with my sisters alone when I was 15yo due to my parents had to move where my nan lived and look after her. I came over to England for 2 weeks alone when I was 16yo.

Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 11:21

Jetstream · 20/06/2023 10:48

It says 16 year olds can be left alone depending on the maturity of the child. It is not recommended. I think all this overkill is due to lack or no rights of children in the past. Ireland’s record on advocating child welfare was shockingly bad and partially non existent until recently.

Now we have gone way way too far tbh. Young people starting work have very poor life skills and social skills. They lack basic problem solving skills and really are only comfortable when they have detailed instructions on what to do. Kids starting university can’t even cook or use a washing machine.
A generation of anxious adults who are afraid to make mistakes has been created because they have subconsciously gotten the message they aren’t capable because their parents were over protective.

Tetchypants · 20/06/2023 11:21

Natsku · 20/06/2023 11:03

Might be talking about me, my daughter did ski to school alone through the forest at 6/7, during the brief winter when she actually liked skiing Grin

I assume she survived!! 😁I remember feeling a bit envious of your lifestyle and freedom, as I trudged through freezing rain to get my kids to school. I think you were pregnant at the time and struggling to walk, let alone ski?

EvilElsa · 20/06/2023 11:20

Well at 16 I was at work full time, paying rent to my parents and looking after myself. I certainly would have been more than capable of looking after cats for 4 days. I always came home to an empty house at 11 as my parents both worked. I also managed to get to school and back by myself negotiating public transport.
If anything I think we baby children far too long now. There have been posts on here recently that have blown my mind with very late teens/early adults incapable of doing the very basic tasks in life alone. If my 17 year old can go out in her car alone she is absolutely capable of looking after a pet for a few days in her house. The most common little job loads of the kids at my secondary had was babysitting from the age of 14!!!

SuperSuperDry · 20/06/2023 11:18

I’m funny about 10-11 year olds being left, but I lived alone at 16 🤣

Gardendad · 20/06/2023 11:17

I'm from Ireland but lived in Europe quite a bit. Irish people absolutely over parent, hand feed, police, helicopter parent. I have Dutch and French freinds here that think its insane. I'm going to a wedding next week for one night and my 13 and 16 year old are alone. Thats completely fine. When I look around how Irish kids are parented it baffles me. They literally cannot go get an ice cream without being phone tracked, dropped off in a car... I think you are probably very cautious. You mention abduction in your thread and I thought you lived in Somalia or Iran or somewhere. Friends in University asnd Graduate positions trell me of the complete inability of kids to do basics in college and work - a lot of falling down academically because of the points race for college.

MrsMorrisey · 20/06/2023 11:16

I left home at 15. No reason, just thought I'd grown up.
Realise now as a 50 year old how bad that was.
Not sure what my parents were thinking but they allowed it 🤷‍♀️

Yerroblemom1923 · 20/06/2023 11:16

I've left mine on their own for periods of time since they were 9/10 as they're too old to go to a childminder and didn't always want to come to work with me. What are you supposed to do during the school holidays?! They're in their teens now and if I have to work a full day they have to entertain themselves. I know they're sensible enough not to burn the house down, can feed themselves, will lock up the house if they go out to meet friends etc and can phone me in an emergency or knock on a neighbour's door.
I'm not sure where people live whose houses are prone to bursting into flames and people on the lookout for home alone children to abduct (they'd soon return mine in a jiffy!)?!

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 20/06/2023 11:14

In Scotland occasionally you do have sixteen year olds starting university (a friend of mine did) and seventeen year olds in Halls of Residence is quite usual. It seems utterly mad to me that anyone would want their child to go from "never left alone overnight" to "living independently" in a single step. Surely it's saner for teens to be left overnight for one night, then a few more etc.

The rule my family had with me and I followed with mine was that from the age of about 10 I was allowed to walk home from school with friends/alone, but there was someone at home so it was basically a ten minute walk through the village. I was also being sent out and about to run errands at that age and I think was allowed to go cycling with friends alone and have a picnic in the fields (very rural upbringing).

Once I started secondary school, I got the bus home alone and was in the house by myself for an hour or so until parents got home from work. Then I think when I was 13 or 14 I would be left alone for longer - so, they would go out for an evening. Alone overnight from 16. It felt like a reasonable slow transition to adulthood.

TiredandHungry19 · 20/06/2023 11:12

You sound like a helicopter parent whose kids will struggle when they have to live alone tbh. This is no better parenting than those who are neglectful or expect too much independence too soon.

Lilifer · 20/06/2023 11:09

I am from Ireland. I have lived both in Dublin and rurally and I have no idea what on Earth the op is on about and to be honest from the tone and tenor of her posts I think there is an element of goading going on here.

aSofaNearYou · 20/06/2023 11:09

Where are all these threads about 10 and 11 year olds coming home to an empty house? I don't think I've ever seen one.

When my sister started secondary school she used to come home and nobody would be there until 5:30ish when our parents got home. When I started, it was just the two of us, so 11 and 13. It was never an issue, seemed totally normal. We watched a DVD and ate snacks on the sofa.

Turfwars · 20/06/2023 11:06

Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 10:52

@Turfwars 11 is a tricky age isn’t it. That is a great set up with your friend.
We live rurally too and work 20-25 minutes drive away plus have nice neighbours that DS would happily call into if he ever needed an adult. 90 minutes commute is very far if he needs you.
I am on maternity leave and eldest DS has just finished 1st year so happily so need to be left alone all day for him although he usually wants to stay home alone when I run errands unless I am going somewhere he wants to go.

Yes, really hoping it'll work for us. I'll do M-T at home and take her lad, and W-T-F she'll take mine. I do the Saturday sports run for them so it evens up. I might even see if other parents are interested in joining our pool, the back up might be handy!

We do have brilliant neighbours that we can call on in an emergency, but a couple of dodgy ones too!

When they are in secondary, he'll take himself to the top of the road for the bus and back - and I'd have no issue with him letting himself in and having a couple of hours alone a few times a week but for the 12 weeks of the summer if I'm gone from 7am to 7pm even if he's totally capable, fwho's too far from a friend's house to hang out, it's a lot of solitude for a young person.

SparkyBlue · 20/06/2023 11:06

I think I'm in the same part of Ireland as the OP and my ten year happily walks home from school by herself and so do her friends. One person has recently moved house so now catches the bus across town and it's not a school bus it's the normal bus. My DD and her friends have started going together to the shopping centre every now and then after school. The world OP talks about is alien to me.

Saoirse82 · 20/06/2023 11:05

I'm in Ireland and what you are saying isn't my experience at all. Maybe things are done differently out in the sticks but in the city its perfectly acceptable for an 11 year old who is in secondary school to make their way to and from school and even (shock) let themselves into an empty house for an hour. We have to teach our children to be independent and I know it's difficult to cut the apron strings but I was doing similar at 11 and my 11 year old nephew makes his way to and from school most days and meets friends at the weekend and spends the afternoon with them.

Natsku · 20/06/2023 11:03

Tetchypants · 20/06/2023 10:58

Years ago there was a thread here about a woman in Scandinavia somewhere, asking if her 6 or 7 year old was fine to ski to school alone through a remote forest. Wish I could find it!

Might be talking about me, my daughter did ski to school alone through the forest at 6/7, during the brief winter when she actually liked skiing Grin

Tophy124 · 20/06/2023 10:59

I find a lot of children in the US have waaaaaaay more freedom than my children will have. But that’s a huge sweeping statement about a country where obviously a lot of parents will be stricter or the same as me. Same as the UK stop bloody generalizing based on a few things!! But I do see American children getting the bus alone aged 5 and it’s not something my children will be doing. I don’t allow my children to play out unsupervised but will once they get to 10/11 as long as they check in with me. Here I see children age 6-7 playing out alone.

KnottyAndPistey · 20/06/2023 10:59

My brother lives in Tokyo. His twins were expected to walk themselves to and from school at 6. Busy roads. Traffic. Etc. Societal norm. Young children not much older run errands too. Pop to the shops etc.

My brother’s boys used to take themselves to football, 45 mins each way on the train from about 8.

it’s different. But it was the norm. And they are super independent and confident kids.

TheCyclingGorilla · 20/06/2023 10:59

First time DD went home from school without an adult but with friends: 10. Her dad was usually home from work by the time she got home.
First time she went home alone from school: 11, Yr 6.
First time she was left alone for a few hours: 10.
First time she was left alone all day: 11/12, start of Year 7. I work shifts and her dad earlies, so she sometimes wouldn't see an adult until about 4pm.
First time left overnight: 16
First time left for three nights: 16.

I am NOT a liberal parent, and neither is her dad.

You can't get childcare for teenagers. It's unheard of in London. You can encourage them to join after-school clubs but chances are they'll be abandoned so, there's nothing else.

Tetchypants · 20/06/2023 10:58

Years ago there was a thread here about a woman in Scandinavia somewhere, asking if her 6 or 7 year old was fine to ski to school alone through a remote forest. Wish I could find it!

dickheed · 20/06/2023 10:58

Where are all these threads about 10 and 11 year olds coming home to an empty house? I don't think I've ever seen one. Please quote the relevant threads.
I saw the 16 year old one looking after the cats but I haven't seen anything else similar.

Stop saying "where I'm from". Surely it must be clear to you by now, after 16 pages of thread, that it isn't the same in the UK as "where you're from" and it isn't the same in Dublin as "where you're from". You do things differently "where you're from". You can decide what is appropriate for your children but stop with all the faux-shock about kids using public transport and being left alone for a couple of hours.

I think kids in the UK are more babied than when I was growing up in the 80s. I was going to the shop at 6. Getting the bus and train to school in a major city every day from the age of 10. Going to the park alone at a similar age. Meeting friends in the city from 13. Long train journeys alone to relatives during the summer holidays from 14.

Children need to learn to be independent. It doesn't happen by magic at 18.

Justhereforaibu1 · 20/06/2023 10:55

I was about to go to university aged 16

ditalini · 20/06/2023 10:55

JudgeJ · 20/06/2023 10:53

OP's reluctant to say where she's from but the use of CPS implies North America. I would say that children here are under the direct control of parents for far too long, there are posts on here panicking that an11 year old will be walking to school without parental supervision in September. By Year 6 an 11 year old should be able, other conditions allowing, to walk to school or travel on a bus if needed, if they can't then their parents have been neglectful.

She's said she's from Ireland.