Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 21/06/2023 18:32

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:18

Probably about 17 feels right, final year of secondary school before going to uni? Depends on the child obviously

But a 17 year old could only be a few months older than the 16 year old you said was too young! I mean there is a big difference between a v mature 16yo and a reckless 17yo. I would never leave mine alone for 4 nights at 16, however I don't think it's a child safety issue.

In northern Ireland kids travel to school alone too. I am English and have lived in Belfast and the country with family down south and it seems to be the norm across the board, or so I thought.

nopuppiesallowed · 21/06/2023 18:31

Nicecow · 20/06/2023 04:22

What country are you from as if anything the UK is too strict (this generation, probably not previous generations). Most 16 year olds are having sex, so they should be perfectly capable of being home alone for a few days. Of they're not, you've probably failed as a parent. Think back to when you were 16.

I know this isn't going to be a popular opinion, and obviously some 16 year oolds do have sex, but I don't think they should. They are still children. They might want to have sex, but it doesn't mean to say they should.
And imho 16 year olds shouldn't be left on their own for days. Their brains are still developing. They are still at the stage of not always seeing dangers and still need direction, albeit less advice and direction as time goes on. And I say this having raised 3 adventurous and intelligent children who lived abroad (one in an Eastern country for 6 months straight after leaving school and one for 2 years in a European country straight after university.) Aged 16, they are fine - unless something scary happens....

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 21/06/2023 18:23

It's ~20 years ago now, but from 17 I was regularly staying home while the rest of my family were away abroad on holiday for 10/14 days. I was perfectly capable of feeding myself, getting myself where I needed to be and had people I could call if I needed help in any way. Mid/late teens if raised properly should be able to look after themselves for a few days no problems.

CauliflowerBalti · 21/06/2023 18:14

My parents left me alone every weekend from the age of 13. I was more than capable of looking after myself and my younger sister, but I have issues relating to it now.

i wouldn’t leave my 16-year old alone for more than a night, and even then very reluctantly. He’s 15 now and doesn’t really like being alone anyway.

Blueink · 21/06/2023 16:22

Just because we were younger, doesn’t make it ideal now. There does need to be a balance.

I was coming home on my own and left for hours from age 8. Also expected to be in charge of younger sibling.

I was also own my own the evenings from age 11.

I don’t look back on it happily, it was often quite lonely and stressful.

I don’t think it’s ideal for a 16 year old to be left alone for 4 nights, let alone live by themselves or join the bloody army.

celticprincess · 21/06/2023 10:57

I think this point the OP makes is interesting. From the age of 13 when they start secondary they get more independence. I green up in first middle and high and it was more like 13 for us to be out and about more independently at that age. But our county was different and neighbouring counties were two tier so started secondary at 13. Now I have my own children and our county is now two tier I was hesitant at the leaving home alone thing from age 11 but we’ve had the two tier for many years and no real childcare provision has existed for the 11-13 year olds that might have gone to middle schools and had more childcare available. So we’ve just gone with it. 11 still seems young to me to start high school. I’ve one in y6 about to go and one in y9 which is when I would have started high school back in the late 80s. There’s a huge difference between their maturity but we’ve had to make do. Eve introduced the independence earlier.

celticprincess · 21/06/2023 10:46

The problem is that once they’re 11 and start secondary school the government stop supporting childcare unless you have a child with a disability I lift. You can claim a childcare allowance on your tax credits/UC, not sure if they’re still around but also childcare vouchers which are tax free. But once they get to secondary those parents that needed that financial support can’t have it. Also secondary schools don’t provide the same type of breakfast and after school care that primary schools often do. So you have a child of 10/11 in y6 who is going to be faced with the prospect of secondary school and being left in the house when the parents go to work - possibly from 7am like mine does - so they need to get themselves up and out and lock up. And then they return to the empty house after school until parents return from work - often between 5-6pm and later. So you have to start them at 10/11 to slowly get them used to it. So my 10 year old walks to school most days herself now when I’m not at work. On my work day I still drop her at breakfast club for 7:30. Some days she stays til 5 at after school club but I’ve started to ask that she can leave after school club at 4;30 with a key to walk home and let herself in where o won’t be far behind her. My 13 year old had had to do this since y7 but didn’t have the practice at y6 due to lockdown!! My 13 year old is autistic so I can claim for childcare for her still but actually getting someone who takes a secondary child is impossible where we love. She’s got used to being home alone.

Then you have secondary schools where if they suddenly close halfway through the day due to maintenance issues, they would likely just send all the kids home. So from age 11. On strike days most of the secondary pupils at my daughters school were left home for the day rather than parents taking time off.

I guess you know your own child and can train them up. My kids when home alone aren’t allowed to use the gas hob and gas cooker for example. They can use the toaster, microwave and air fryer though because I’ve shown them how to safely use them. And the kettle to make a hot drink.

Our primary school brought on a stupid rule recently for wrap around that it had to be booked a week in advance. So alot if families who were using it more as hoc, or weren’t sure on their exact travel times due to traffic and work patterns decided to give their children a key to go lock up and get home themselves. Y5 is common for walking home alone (age 9/10) so many introduced the letting themselves on the house for a couple of hours.

I was a paid babysitter by 14.

ExcitingTimes2021 · 21/06/2023 09:57

I left home at 16! I’m pretty sure majority of 16 year olds are capable of caring for themselves and a cat for a few days 😂😂

Stompythedinosaur · 21/06/2023 09:37

If it was truly the norm where you are across the country that dc of 10-16 couldn't be left alone, there would be childcare available for that age group, it would be profitable for people to provide it.

The fact that your dc are too old for the available childcare tells me that most people are beginning to leave their dc for certain periods.

The idea that a 16 yo can't be alone for a few days seems particularly strange - dc can live independently at that age.

Comtesse · 21/06/2023 09:08

If a 16 year old can join the army they can stay at home by themselves for a few days.

echt · 21/06/2023 09:08

The OP left the thread on page 4.

JazbayGrapes · 21/06/2023 09:06

16yo alone for 4 days isn't irresponcible, but quite unwise, unless the said teenager is super trustworthy and reliable.

Secondary aged children going to school and staying home for a couple of jours - totally normal. Unless they have special needs, they don't need to be babysat. They aren't babies.

DeanElderberry · 21/06/2023 08:51

I first heard the term 'latchkey kids' in the late 60s on a BBC schools programme (I lived in the UK with my Irish parents until my early teens). It baffled me - I walked home from school (literally round the block, scores of other children walking home 'alone' at the same time) from the age of 8 if not earlier and let myself in the door with my key. My mother (secondary teacher a couple of miles away) was home within an hour, The TV programme's horror of there being no-one home to give latchkey kids 'tea' baffled me because tea was a drink that I didn't particularly want. Family dinner was at about 6.

I think I vaguely realised, even then (I was probably 10 or 11) that it was a criticism of women working outside the home - a very repressive class-based narrative.

I used to go to the library on my own too (similar distance to the school), and by the age of 10 or 11 used to sometimes take a load of sheets and stuff to the laundrette a few streets away and wash and dry them - had other friends who did the same thing (automatic washing machines at home hadn't come in). That final year of primary school I was let go into the city centre with a pal if I wanted to - luckily the museums let unaccompanied children it - I loved them. The one place I wasn't allowed alone was the local recreation ground beside the school - not sure whether that was because it had a reputation of because of a bad experience my father had with a dodgy man when he was a child (he repressed that memory - his brother told me about it). Before I was 14 I was let go by bus to the swimming pool.

None of that was regarded as negligent or odd by anyone.

alloutofluck · 21/06/2023 08:48

I was working full time from 16 and was expected to be a responsible employee. The idea I could not have been left alone at home for four days would have been alien to me.

wendyjoy · 21/06/2023 08:47

You kept saying " Where I'm from" as if you were in some restricted country..
And l have friends in Dublin and you must just be one of a few because they and their family/ friends don't share your view.
Every child is different, some are more than capable than their peers at the same age.
When my daughters got to the age of 15, they were like adults, seemed to old to still be attending school. Age 16 they were going to London with their friends to see concerts and theatre shows.
Yet some of their peers in school seemed still very child like.. l think it's how they have been brought up etc... no two children of the same age are the same.

WhiteCatmas · 21/06/2023 08:34

I’m in NI. My children have taken public transport on their own since 11 as they had to get to secondary school.
When they started secondary school they were home alone for a couple of hours.
They are smarter and more capable than you give them credit for.

ApplesArmClock · 21/06/2023 08:31

You sound quite mad OP.

Catsmere · 21/06/2023 08:25

And I'm sorry, a 16 yr old being left for 4 days to mind some bloody cats is just irresponsible IMO.

That “bloody” about the animals who are totally reliant on a human says a lot about the OP, none of it good imo .

I’m in Australia and was walking home from school alone by the time I was nine (mid 70s) and would be home for a couple of hours alone from my early teens because my mother was at work. This was before the era of “latchkey kids” as they were called, but there was nothing eyebrow-raising about it.

I’d be pleased that a sixteen year old was responsible and knowledgeable enough to care for animals for a few days.

DeanElderberry · 21/06/2023 08:07

Like the OP (allegedly[1]) I'm Irish and live in Ireland and don't see it as a 'slag off the UK' thread, more as an 'isn't the UK great for encouraging independence and self-reliance in children' thread.

That may not have been her intention, but it seems to be the general response.

Sympathy to anyone caring for a child or adult who can't be left alone - I've done a bit of that with the elderly, and know it's tough.

[1] Not that I recognise the Ireland she describes, with 'large towns' (not cities, she admits cities are different) in the south west where child abduction is a threat and 16 year olds can't take responsibilities for a few days.

Hobbesmanc · 21/06/2023 07:14

At 16 I was working weekends and evenings in a DIY store and navigating a late evening bus home. Three of us went camping for a week to Alton Towers. I was often home alone for a few nights as my mum was a single parent who was a nurse. From 11 I had a key and made my own tea. Depends on each child of course.

Laurama91 · 21/06/2023 07:06

Was left at home from a young age. Not 100% sure what age. My mum passed when I was 6 and I had to grow up quickly. Maybe made me more responsible.

gamerchick · 21/06/2023 07:05

Ah another slag the UK off thread. Lot of them lately. Seems like we're fair game atm

gemstoneju · 21/06/2023 07:02

@Honeymud your situation was the same as mine, exactly, but 12 year old girls are more mature. I have three sons and would leave them alone for up to an hour, maybe two, but certainly not all day. I think boys are different and take longer to grow up. I would be afraid they'd egg each other on to do something daft.

firef1y · 21/06/2023 06:49

First, please those of you saying that if you can't leave an (in my case) 13yo for a couple of hours you've done something wrong, please remember some of us would give anything to be able to safely allow that 13yo the independence. My 13yo is years away from being able to be left for more than a couple of minutes.

His 9yo brother though, even though he also has SEN is far more capable of being independent. Thankfully his school seems a lot more willing to allow the children independence than seems the norm nowadays. They allow children to walk/cycle home by themselves from year 4 and this is something we've built up over the last year, steadily increasing the distance between where we leave/meet him and the school (which he cycles to/from after doing a cycling course which is kind of pre-bikability). He can also go to the shop on his own and is happy to be left for 20min in the house while the dog is taken for a walk.

Unfortunately I seem to be a bit of an outlier here, possibly because I'm an older parent and grew up in a time when it was very common to spend hours on my out of the house. We actually had one busybody report us to the school for leaving the 9yo for 20min while the dog was walked. Good thing the headteacher is the sensible sort who encourages independence in the pupils. (And that we'd had discussions with her on how we were going to start building that independence over this year).

As for my childhood, I was walking to the park, shop etc with my similarly aged cousins (London so lots of traffic) from around 7. Moved out of London at age 8 and then was walking to/from Junior school, picking up my younger sister and her friend from Infants on the way. Come senior school I was walking the 3 miles to/from school in all weather's from day 1, and we finished a lot later than most schools finish now, in the middle of winter it would be dark by the time I got back, especially I had had detention. At the same age I was cooking roast dinners on a Sunday.
As soon as I turned 13 and 9months, I got a paper round plus working Sat/Sun in the newsagents (for the princely sum of £1/hour). Around the same time I started babysitting for local families, including overnight (for police officers no less)
The day I turned 16 I applied for a part time job in the local supermarket (and started about a week later). By about 16 and half I was working 30hrs/week as well as going to college full time. I was contributing to my families household expenses, buying my own clothes, paying for my nights out.
At 18 I lived in my own flat with a baby, thanks to being taught to do the things needed to be independent, despite having undiagnosed ASD and ADHD, I was capable of running my own household. Of working full time, and being a parent.

Leapintothelightning · 20/06/2023 21:29

This thread is hilarious.
You can't leave a 10/11 year old home alone for an hour because you'd be reported? You can't leave a 16 year old alone for a few nights in case they forget to turn the stove off? But at 17.5 you will start to let them, to prepare them for full independence at age 18?!
You sound batshit OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread