Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
ProfessorXtra · 20/06/2023 05:32

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:21

See, 9yrs old is just totally bonkers to me to be left alone at home.

So maybe I should ask:

When is it okay to leave a child for 1 hour?

When is it okay to leave a child for 2 hours?

When is it okay to leave a child for 6 hours?

When is it okay to leave a child overnight?

When is it okay to leave a child for 4 days?

The answer to all those are different for each child. It depends on the child and circumstance.

My Dd (now an adult) never walked to and from school because there wasn’t a direct bus and it was a 3 mile walk on an unlit country lane. Because the buses went the other way it would have taken 3 buses and well over an hour. I worked for myself, so didn’t have to worry about work and took her.

DS started walking to school at 10, because I moved and the school gate is 30 feet from the house and I could still watch him go over from the upstairs window I could see him walk to the classroom. Ds has autism and less mature than his sister was. But he would see his friends coming, go out and walk with them. It helped give him some confidence. He is at high school and walks with friends to and from school. It’s entirely normal here.

Dd was rarely left alone until she was about 15. As we would be taking ds when we went out, she would want to come anyway. Ds gets left alone now for up to a couple of hours, if he doesn’t want to come where I am going.

if the circumstances were different it would have been at different ages.

There’s no exact ‘this is the right age’

echt · 20/06/2023 05:32

Just because they're having sex at that age, doesn't mean they should be? 16 year olds can have children, drop out of school, take drugs etc at that age... doesn't mean they should be though?

Leaving school at 16 is not dropping out. It is leaving school.
You can take drugs at any age - I take it you mean illegal ones - as there is guidance on this.
You can get married.
You can give consent to your own medical treatment.

lordloveadog · 20/06/2023 05:29

Is Ireland wildly more dangerous than we've all been led to believe?

I'm in Scandinavia; my children have been taking themselves home from school since they were 7. And looking after themselves until I get home.

The 12 year old sometimes spends nights at home by himself. He'll be going on scout camp this summer where they build all their own tents and cooking facilities (axes! Knives! Fire!) and plan and cook their own food.

This weekend the 16 year old took trains by himself for 8 hours to a weekend camp and then to another city to buy a surfboard off eBay equivalent and brought it home. It was the first time he'd planned a trip like that, so I showed him how to book, how the different carriage options work, what to watch out for, etc etc. And DH was ready on the other end of the phone through the surfboard buying and transporting process to troubleshoot.

The goal is surely to raise capable, well-judging adults. How can you do that if you don't let them learn?

orangecheddarisbetter · 20/06/2023 05:27

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/06/2023 04:28

Calling it irresponsible isn’t querying it though.

Querying it would be giving examples of the ages these things would happen where you’re from and pondering the difference.

a 16yo is potentially less than 3 full years from going to Uni - at what point should they stay home alone for a couple of days to prepare for being alone full time?

In Scotland many start uni and leave home age 17. I did and many others I knew were in the same position.

sashh · 20/06/2023 05:26

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:53

See that to me is 🤯 At the age of 7 they're still so small? That's why I'm wondering is it just a cultural thing and therefore children grow up faster, take on more responsibilities at a younger age because it's what is taught and expected?

There is a TV show in Japan, or was, filming children doing their 'first errand' the parent sends them to a shop and they go alone, usually buy something they want not what the parent has said, pay and go home again.

They are toddlers.

What you are not taking into account is the society around what children can do and are expected to do. Children in the UK generally get themselves to and from school at age 10 or 11.

My first day of school I was taken, the second day my mum walked me to the bus stop and I travelled alone. Yes it was a school bus but the only adult on the bus was the driver.

We moved house and my mum got a job when I was 6 or 7, I loved coming home to an empty house.

Netflix Japanese game show 'Old Enough' sparks social media debate over safety of young children

Old Enough is an unscripted series where parents send their 2 to 5-year-old children to run errands – grocery shopping to squeezing fresh juice.

https://youtu.be/ptLYEhJp9R0

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:26

Outofthepark · 20/06/2023 05:22

OP why are you obsessed with one kid who was left to look after cats, it's not like a weekly ritual that all Brits do, it was one story out of millions 😄

And I'm not seeing these endless 10 year olds left alone either, where are you reading that? Everyone I know is, if anything, more on the protective side of what they need to be.

And newsflash, 16 year olds shouldn't be having sex? Wow thanks you really taught us something new 😂

Finally stop being so judgemental - if it's in your culture good for you, do what makes you happy but stop gunning for others and stop trying to make out there's something wrong with the childcare culture here when there isn't, as you clearly don't seem to have an on point view of the facts.

Literally not gunning for anyone... trying to understand why outlooks are so different. And I see it here regularly, parents asking when is it okay to leave a child at home alone for x amount of time? The thread about the 16 year old just totally blew my mind though 😅

OP posts:
Outofthepark · 20/06/2023 05:24

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:18

Probably about 17 feels right, final year of secondary school before going to uni? Depends on the child obviously

I'm not leaving my kids alone at 17 for 4 nights personally, jeez OP what is wrong with you! 😄

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 20/06/2023 05:24

I'm in my 60s, and my feeling is that children are more protected now than they were in my childhood (in England). We used to walk around 1.5 miles to school. Young children were generally accompanied by their mothers, but from about age 7 we all tended to walk without an adult. We'd go with older siblings, or friends would meet up, so there would be small groups of 2-3 forming. But it was pretty common to be on your own. Weekends and school holidays I'd be out roaming the woods for hours on end: leave the house after breakfast, call on friends (who were sometimes in, sometines not) and return when I was hungry (no child had anything as cool as a watch!) Age 8-9 we'd catch the bus to the local town centre or just to go exploring - a bunch of friends, no adult. From age 11 I was travelling by train into London for school, and my siblings did solo travel to their schools too. My mother was a teacher, so was generally home by the time we arrived, but we had backdoor keys from about age 8. As her career progressed and she worked longer hours we would often be home alone for an hour or so - and we knew how to make ourselves a drink and a sandwich. All this was commonplace in my childhood, and I don't know of any kid who was murdered or abducted or who managed to burn their house down.

Your job as a parent is to make a child competent to navigate the world independently and safely by age 18, and you do that by letting them exercise their skills during childhood - starting off in small amounts that gradually increase as they grow. Over-protection of children is actually very damaging.

AuntieMarys · 20/06/2023 05:22

You'd hate me 😀
Children brought up in the Sodom and Gomorrah that is London, walking to school alone age 10, using public transport at 11. Spending Saturdays at 12 trying to visit every tube station. Going to away matches all over the country to support their football team at 14.
Staying at home for a week at 16 when we went on holiday.

Outofthepark · 20/06/2023 05:22

OP why are you obsessed with one kid who was left to look after cats, it's not like a weekly ritual that all Brits do, it was one story out of millions 😄

And I'm not seeing these endless 10 year olds left alone either, where are you reading that? Everyone I know is, if anything, more on the protective side of what they need to be.

And newsflash, 16 year olds shouldn't be having sex? Wow thanks you really taught us something new 😂

Finally stop being so judgemental - if it's in your culture good for you, do what makes you happy but stop gunning for others and stop trying to make out there's something wrong with the childcare culture here when there isn't, as you clearly don't seem to have an on point view of the facts.

booksandcats22 · 20/06/2023 05:21

Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF?

Cannot see what's wrong with a 16 year old looking after someone's pet for 4 days as long as they're responsible. Also isn't this referring and to previous threads quite a bit?

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:21

TheOpenRoad · 20/06/2023 05:18

I am from another country and have friends from all over, if anything I find UK parents restrictive rather than lax. It seems to be the norm in Europe at least that children get themselves to and from school from late primary.

Interestingly, a good friend is Irish and they let their child do this from 9, and he also goes by himself to football training.

So I don't agree that it's lax or irresponsible or unsafe parenting. It's perfectly normal to leave your 10/11 year old for an hour or so, and for 11 year olds to take the bus.

See, 9yrs old is just totally bonkers to me to be left alone at home.

So maybe I should ask:

When is it okay to leave a child for 1 hour?

When is it okay to leave a child for 2 hours?

When is it okay to leave a child for 6 hours?

When is it okay to leave a child overnight?

When is it okay to leave a child for 4 days?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 20/06/2023 05:18

At 16 one is an adult for working purposes.
Looking after a house and some cats is a job that should be easily done by any 16 year old without worry.
By age eight most kids could travel to school a short distance alone.
Being home alone for a few minutes, I think, is fine at age eight but if for more than fifteen minutes - not fine. It is legal to be minded by a 14 year old. Thus, a babysitter or older siblings can mind younger ones for a few hours. I would say for less than a day.
By 13 I would think that traversing local public transport would be normal during day light hours - and with an adult knowing their where abouts. At night - not on your nelly.

TheOpenRoad · 20/06/2023 05:18

I am from another country and have friends from all over, if anything I find UK parents restrictive rather than lax. It seems to be the norm in Europe at least that children get themselves to and from school from late primary.

Interestingly, a good friend is Irish and they let their child do this from 9, and he also goes by himself to football training.

So I don't agree that it's lax or irresponsible or unsafe parenting. It's perfectly normal to leave your 10/11 year old for an hour or so, and for 11 year olds to take the bus.

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:18

Mongoosesorry · 20/06/2023 05:17

What age do you think they could be left for 4 nights alone?

At 17 they can join the army. In Scotland you can go to uni at 17, I thought Ireland was 17 too but maybe I’m mistaken.

Probably about 17 feels right, final year of secondary school before going to uni? Depends on the child obviously

OP posts:
Mongoosesorry · 20/06/2023 05:17

What age do you think they could be left for 4 nights alone?

At 17 they can join the army. In Scotland you can go to uni at 17, I thought Ireland was 17 too but maybe I’m mistaken.

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:16

TowerStork · 20/06/2023 05:11

OP, I really don't think your views are typical of rural Ireland either. You are of course entitled to your views on patenting but you insist on blanket descriptions of UK parents being irresponsible and Irish parents being sheltered, which no body here recognises.

By the way, where I come from in rural Ireland 16 year olds drive tractors, train as life guards, and are absolutely left at home if the parents need to go away. It's true that neighbours and cousins are around to check in on them if needs be, but that's normal behaviour elsewhere too.

Genuinely, where I'm from (very large town in Southwest) this would be frowned upon. You don't leave 10 yr olds alone at home. And yes, 16 year olds drive tractors... I had the entire side of my car destroyed by one! So it doesn't mean they should! But yes, in more rural areas, you tend to have a more close knit community of family, friends, neighbours etc that would look after or look in on children.

OP posts:
Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:12

hoxtonbabe · 20/06/2023 05:09

@Toxicityofourcity

I can’t speak for Ireland but it’s done in London and I have done it.

Once my youngest son hit 11 and started secondary (he’s only 15 now so not so many moons ago) he had to trek back and forth to his school 3 miles and stay home for a few hours alone.. most families I know do that, it’s just the norm.

My other son had to do an 8 miles school trip ( from age 12) left home to get on public transport at 7.15am to get into school for 8.15am, and there were days I was in when he got home and days I was not, not once did he ever encounter any trouble or have any issues and as I said I’m in London 🤷🏽‍♀️

It's most likely done in Dublin here also, just not in most other areas. My DC were left alone for 30mins to an hour from 13, got off the bus at 4.30 and I was home my 5.15 latest. But the idea of 10 year olds doing this is alien to me.

OP posts:
TowerStork · 20/06/2023 05:11

OP, I really don't think your views are typical of rural Ireland either. You are of course entitled to your views on patenting but you insist on blanket descriptions of UK parents being irresponsible and Irish parents being sheltered, which no body here recognises.

By the way, where I come from in rural Ireland 16 year olds drive tractors, train as life guards, and are absolutely left at home if the parents need to go away. It's true that neighbours and cousins are around to check in on them if needs be, but that's normal behaviour elsewhere too.

hoxtonbabe · 20/06/2023 05:09

@Toxicityofourcity

I can’t speak for Ireland but it’s done in London and I have done it.

Once my youngest son hit 11 and started secondary (he’s only 15 now so not so many moons ago) he had to trek back and forth to his school 3 miles and stay home for a few hours alone.. most families I know do that, it’s just the norm.

My other son had to do an 8 miles school trip ( from age 12) left home to get on public transport at 7.15am to get into school for 8.15am, and there were days I was in when he got home and days I was not, not once did he ever encounter any trouble or have any issues and as I said I’m in London 🤷🏽‍♀️

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:09

Somethingneedstochange78 · 20/06/2023 05:06

They can get married at 16 with parents consent join the army at 17 and legally drink and smoke at 18. But they're too young to be left overnight at 16?🤔 That's if they are neuro typical of course. Mine aren't and never will do any of what you or I have mentioned btw before you come at me. I was doing all those you listed at a younger age. Most parents let they're kids walk alone to school to prepare them for secondary. It's not cool to be seen with mummy or daddy dropping them off. Unless you want them to get bullied.

I'd prefer them to be safe... the thought of them being bullied because Mum drops them to school doesn't trump safety in my eyes

OP posts:
Somethingneedstochange78 · 20/06/2023 05:06

They can get married at 16 with parents consent join the army at 17 and legally drink and smoke at 18. But they're too young to be left overnight at 16?🤔 That's if they are neuro typical of course. Mine aren't and never will do any of what you or I have mentioned btw before you come at me. I was doing all those you listed at a younger age. Most parents let they're kids walk alone to school to prepare them for secondary. It's not cool to be seen with mummy or daddy dropping them off. Unless you want them to get bullied.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/06/2023 05:06

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:06

@YetMoreNewBeginnings please take from my OP whatever you like if it makes you happy. I'm merely here out of curiosity, not to imply anything.

You didn’t imply anything, you outright called it irresponsible.

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:06

@YetMoreNewBeginnings and your cousins kids experience also isn't universal btw

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 20/06/2023 05:06

I also find this utterly illogical

Plenty of 16 year olds are left alone for the odd night... not for 4 nights!

If the worry is fires or an inability to cope alone why is the odd night ok but not four? When is two/three/four nights ok?

I actually think this is why so many students are utterly ill equipped when they start Uni now. Babied until 17.5 and then expected to fly completely solo at 18