Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
RecycleMePlease · 20/06/2023 06:29

Yes, they do go a year later, but at our primary they're allowed to walk themselves to/from school from 3rd class - so around 9 (wide age spread - might be a year either way). I agree with the time table for times/ages PP had, and it's certainly what my friends also do.

In fact, my mate was quite amused (in a nice way, in a rub my shoulder and get me a cup of tea way) the first time my (then 8 and 5) boys played out on the street with the other kids and I kept hovering by the window - they'd never done it anywhere else we'd lived because those countries/places hadn't been safe, but scooting round, playing football on the green in the estate was totally normal for kids in Dublin.

Nicecow · 20/06/2023 06:28

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:27

Just because they're having sex at that age, doesn't mean they should be? 16 year olds can have children, drop out of school, take drugs etc at that age... doesn't mean they should be though?

Yes I agree with you, I'm just saying if they have the "maturity" for those activities I don't see the harm in being home for a few days. Tbh they really should be self sufficient by then. Look at the children who were lost in the Amazon for 40 days.

Flora56 · 20/06/2023 06:24

Am I right in thinking that children in Ireland go to secondary a year later than those in the U.K.? Could that be the difference?

Secondary schools here don’t have wrap around care and child minders aren’t really set up for older ones. People can’t just give up work in their child’s first year at secondary, so that’s generally when kids start being a bit more independent.

Parents often start building this up during year 6 (age 10/11) to get them ready for September.

Museya15 · 20/06/2023 06:24

I used to come home, cook, clean and have the dinner ready for when the others got home. I was 12.

lalalalalalaleeee · 20/06/2023 06:23

I was a latch key lid, as were my brothers, mum had to work so we'd get too and from secondary school ourselves. When the boys were younger I'd drop and pick them up on my way,

My 14 and 16 year old are both perfectly fine to be left for a few hours

HaddawayAndShite · 20/06/2023 06:21

trying to understand why outlooks are so different.

Are you actually? Because I just see a lot a faux wide eyed nativity and MN head tilting with references to culture and “eee we would never do that in my country”. When yes, in fact people do. You refusing to say the name of your large town (which isn’t outing in any way) speaks volumes too, why is that? In case someone is also from there and tells you you’re talking shite perhaps?

People parent differently. This isn’t hard to understand.

Motnight · 20/06/2023 06:20

Will noone think of the cats?

barms90 · 20/06/2023 06:20

If anything I'm shocked it's so late. I live I another European country and kids are allowed to walk home from school at 8 and many do. I see groups of 7/8 year olds in the park playing by themselves.

mrsplum2015 · 20/06/2023 06:18

I don't understand the logic about the plane at all!

My dd was far more mature (14) before I'd let her fly domestically alone than when she was left home alone (9) or get the bus alone (11).

As youve quite rightly said you have to be confident they are able to cope with worst case scenario. So house fire = understanding they need to get out immediately then contact me. Burglary the same. And or call 999 obvs.

Missed bus or wrong stop = call me and wait somewhere safe.

Plane crash/diverted to a different airport = a potentially very frightening experience when they would likely not be able to contact me at all

RosesAndHellebores · 20/06/2023 06:16

Quite the reverse. Mine were happy to be left at home for an hour from about 8. Probably two from about 10. Very safe area and super neighbours though.

From 9 DS came home from school on the public bus and the au-pair met him at the bus stop. DD took herself to the West End aged 12 rather than stay at home with cleaner. We stopped the au-pair when dd went to secondary school and she was perfectly capable of looking after herself for an hour.

At 17 they went to Reading, at 18 to a ghastly place in Crete - both rites of passage. Six months later ds was in NZ roughing it on a farm. By 16 both were capable of boarding a plane alone to stay with friends' families.

Motnight · 20/06/2023 06:16

Don't come to London then, Op.

Public transport chock-a-block full of unaccompanied school kids.

Thank goodness you have seen the error of the UK's ways 😬

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 20/06/2023 06:15

Oh OP you’d hate me. My DD was 16 when she first declared she didn’t want to come on holiday with us, she stayed home alone for 2 weeks. Her Nan was close enough by if she needed her but strangely she’s still alive!.

My youngest DS has been begging me to let him walk to and from school alone and the o ly reason I won’t is because it’s nearly 2 miles. But I’m certain when he starts senior school he will be.

TommyNever · 20/06/2023 06:11

The idea that the Irish have more protective traditions of child care than the rest of the world is pretty laughable. This is the land of the Magdalene Laundries and the "care homes" where mass graves of many hundreds of children have been found. Catholic clergy abuse of children was extremely commonplace and Irish priests took their nasty habits with them all over the world.

Perhaps in response to generally neglectful child-rearing traditions, the Irish are now over-compensating. But the same is happening in many countries and I see no evidence that UK parents are generally "lax" in regard to child care.

Bananarepublic · 20/06/2023 06:11

worriedaboutpoliceinmyhouse · 20/06/2023 05:43

Interesting responses on this thread.

I posted about this in legal for advice, but my post was hidden.

(Mumsnet, I'm not a troll, but I am a namechange - check my post history)

The consensus on this thread appears to be that its fine to leave a teenager alone for an hour or two.

I came home on Sun afternoon to find two police officers detaining my 15 year old daughter, after her (estranged and vindictive) father had reported her being home alone. (I had been shopping for about 2h).

She was told she could not deny them entry as she was a minor, and that she must be in their sight at all times until I or social services turned up. The whole sorry episode ends with me being arrested and charged with breach of the peace after demanding that they leave my house.

Well this is ridiculous if police officers can't manage to attend after burglaries, follow up CCTV after a crime has been reported etc because they are overstretched. How is it possibly a crime to leave a child of 15 for a couple of hours? And how can it be a breach of the peace to ask police officers to leave your house in such circumstances. They should be disciplined for over-stepping their authority. Have you complained?

Heatherjayne1972 · 20/06/2023 06:10

Oh no op I disagree

kids are far too babied in the uk - I walked alone to school from age 7ish ( 40 years ago yes but still did it) That wouldn’t be allowed now
at 16 I had a full time job and was allowed to come and go as I pleased .
it’s considered acceptable that a child in year 7 so age 11/12 would be getting themselves to school Besides there is no childcare post primary - generally it ends after primary school

my two age 13 and 15 get themselves home either by bus/ bike etc home from school and wait for me for 2 hours on a regular basis
kids need to learn independence. As soon as they can otherwise they can’t cope in the adult world.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 20/06/2023 06:06

Goldencup · 20/06/2023 06:03

My answers as a child protection professional and mother of 17 & 19 yo :

When is it okay to leave a child for 1 hour? 8 -10

When is it okay to leave a child for 2 hours? 10-12

When is it okay to leave a child for 6 hours? 12-14

When is it okay to leave a child overnight?
16, preferably after GCSEs are finished

When is it okay to leave a child for 4 days? I would only do this once I had ledt them overnight without incident. It would be about the state and safety of the house more than anything else. Probably upper 6th so 17 or 18.

DSL and agree with all of those timings.

DD is now 19 and away at university but those were more or less when she was mature enough.

ProfessorXtra · 20/06/2023 06:06

I am so confused you say it’s a uk thing. And compare it to Ireland.

Then say you never said your way of doing things goes for all Ireland. Yet we’re comparing countries.

If you are now just changing it to your area. Why are you comparing the whole of the UK, to just your area. Some of us live rurally, in cities, near schools far away from schools just like in Ireland.

You compares countries and when that was pointed out to be incorrect you changed. You have implied parents who do have independent kids just can’t be bothered parenting anymore.

You aren’t making an observation. You are making a judgement. Which is really odd given parenting, children and circumstances are all so individual every parent makes different decisions looking at these things. It not really about Ireland or the UK.

Surely parents in Ireland or just your area, are making parental decision based on what’s best for their families and circumstances. Not what next door but 3 will say.

I have family in Ireland, while I have observed they tend to treat their boys like young children for a long time, I can’t say I have noticed huge differences in when we allow our kids to do things. And I certainly wouldn’t make a huge sweeping statement that all Irish people tend to baby their male children because I know some Irish people who do.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 20/06/2023 06:05

Good lord @Toxicityofourcity

Anything you don't judge other people for?

Anything anybody does differently to you and where you come from that is OK?

Oddly (to help give the lie to a bit of what you're saying) two of my students recently spent 3 and 6 months in Ireland respectively and came back saying how surprised they were at how independent the children were compared to their own families.

But seriously, maybe get a hobby or a job or something and unclench about stuff? Or therapy because of your concern about other people doing normal and not dangerous things.

Though if you know lots of children whose houses spontaneously burst into flames while the children are inside then maybe start a campaign to give yourself something to do instead of twitching behind the nets.

sHREDDIES19 · 20/06/2023 06:04

I have family in Ireland and their attitudes towards their children and nurturing independence and self reliance are very different to mine. My 11 year old is used to being alone for awhile actually enjoys it and knows what to do in an emergency. He gets himself to the school bus stop alone, might go out with his mates for a bit after school. All completely and normal things for a child to do independently at this age. Compared to me when I was that age in the late 80s it’s like night and day so we have generally become a little more guarded that in the previous generation. I think some of their approach stems from living quite rurally and so would worry about intruders, emergencies etc whereas we live in a city with very close by neighbours. Either way, there is no right or wrong answer and as parents we make decisions with our children and let them grow at a pace that suits them. You won’t suddenly become well adjusted and independent having been wrapped in cotton wool up to the age of 17.

Goldencup · 20/06/2023 06:03

My answers as a child protection professional and mother of 17 & 19 yo :

When is it okay to leave a child for 1 hour? 8 -10

When is it okay to leave a child for 2 hours? 10-12

When is it okay to leave a child for 6 hours? 12-14

When is it okay to leave a child overnight?
16, preferably after GCSEs are finished

When is it okay to leave a child for 4 days? I would only do this once I had ledt them overnight without incident. It would be about the state and safety of the house more than anything else. Probably upper 6th so 17 or 18.

Namechanger1002 · 20/06/2023 06:01

Ireland? 😂
my exdh and family are from south west Ireland and they thought I was over protective not letting my then 5 year old go to the park on their own 😂

ChocChipHandbag · 20/06/2023 06:00

My brother went to University at 17 and the summer before he started, he and his mate went travelling in New Zealand!

I remember age 12 taking the train to the nearest big city (45 mins) to go shopping all day with my friend.

When I was 10 I was not only walking myself to school, I was also dropping my 5 year old brother in his class.

At 16 I was earning money babysitting other people’s children. We now pay our 16yo neighbour to do the same.

Normal middle class family in Scotland in the 80s.

Dazedandbemused0 · 20/06/2023 06:00

I think your observations are simply incorrect. I have lived and worked abroad and in the UK parents seems either AS strict, or far stricter, than other countries I’ve lived in when it comes to this. Obviously there will be one or two exceptions to the rule but on the whole I’d say you’re simply mistaken.

ContinuousProcrastination · 20/06/2023 06:00

Ipay a 16 year old to come look after my cats when i go on holiday!!!

x2boys · 20/06/2023 05:59

So when did it change then in Ireland ?
my Irish Dad tells me stories from his childhood of being able to roam for miles they would cycle to the nearest seaside town about ten miles away from his home ,this was in the 50 s and as his parents emigrated to England when he was 11 he must have been pretty young
Also you say parents in the UK ,so as Northern Ireland is part of the UK
I assume parents in Northern Ireland are also " reckless" until they step over the border?🤔