Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
Abra1t · 20/06/2023 07:32

🍪

Shivermytimber · 20/06/2023 07:31

Very odd thread. I grew up in N Ireland late 80s early 90s and we had to walk ourselves to school , navigate public transport ,get home and wait for parents to arrive back from work after school etc. Totally normal. Someone’s mum would be home, all the children would play out after school and if you fell and scrapped your knee etc you would go to the house of the child who’s Mum was in that day.
Certainly none of the molly coddling mine have now.

EvelynBeatrice · 20/06/2023 07:29

In Scotland 17 year olds are often away on their own at university ( and do fine). It would be very odd if a parent didn't think they were safe to be left alone the year before!!

TheCheeseTray · 20/06/2023 07:27

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:24

Building independence is one thing, and should absolutely be encouraged. Exposing them to unnecessary dangers at 10/11 by being alone for long periods, using public transport and navigating changes etc is very confusing for me. It's really not the done thing where I'm from. I could genuinely have CPS or the equivalent called for allowing a child of that age use public transport on their own, be alone for hours on their own etc.

Which country.

In the US they can drive at 15 and many walk to the school bus stop etc

My children are safer at home 16 and 10 without me then out with a load of children on their own but their own age eg 5 x 16 year olds together.

We have a huge house, elderly but active neighbours on both sides. Both have mobile phones but they live a 5 minute walk from a police and fire station.

we have a fully enclosed garden

we have two dogs and cctv and a ring doorbell

they can phone me at any time

they might use the oven if I’m not here - but other than putting a pizza in - they won’t do much.

we have huge first aid kits - burns etc and eldest is a scout leader and first aid trained

younger one has also done a survival course, first aid and started using the kettle aged 6.

We live in a quiet town in Somerset. They both have at least 10 phone numbers of adults they could ring if I didn’t answer who would come at 2 am. We have a fire extinguisher etc

by aged 8 I was roaming the countryside round here alone - and I mean alone no phone etc

eldest with regularly roam the countryside but they take their hiking stuff, water, phone, charger, map, compass and a first aid and survival kit - I honestly think it’s an overkill but as a gold D of E person - that’s what she does …..

Hugasauras · 20/06/2023 07:27

What a very odd thread Confused

PyjamasToMyLeft · 20/06/2023 07:26

Oh OP please go to Switzerland… it will blow your mind

KrisAkabusi · 20/06/2023 07:24

When I was 16 I had a summer job. I stayed home when the rest of the family went on holiday for a week. I was glad if the independence and the novelty of having the house to myself.

inappropriateraspberry · 20/06/2023 07:23

Oh, and what about babysitting? At 14 I would be responsible for other younger children for an evening/night. I would even sleep over at my next door neighbours when babysitting so I didn't have to stay up late!

knittingaddict · 20/06/2023 07:23

Wasn't there a person from Ireland who used to post anti British stuff on mn? Haven't seen it for a long time now, but this thread is triggering some memories.

In any case, your life experience seems very limited op.

BooksAndHooks · 20/06/2023 07:23

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:40

@ItsBritneyBitchhhh I was saying that I would view it as irresponsible where I'm from, because it's not what we see here.

And I'm from Ireland, closest neighbour to the UK, nowhere too far flung, but the views on this seem so different. My DC would have been left for an hour here and there from the age of 13, when starting secondary. But absolutely not left for 4 days at the age of 16 to provide cat care. That's just not something that would be done where I'm from.

And I'm actually a pretty liberal parent, but the views on this seem so different from what I read here? But maybe that's not reflective of the UK population as a whole tbf

If they don’t start secondary and this is when they start independent travel, this is where the difference is. They start at 11 here, hence being travel trained for high school. Nobody would accept a parent walking them to school at Highgate school or having a childminder at high school.

MockneyReject · 20/06/2023 07:22

At 16, I was working full time, and living in a shared house with other youngsters, 17-19.
I'd been regularly babysitting, so in charge of 3 younger kids, since I was 11.
My eldest once asked if he could sleep at his friend's (parent's) house. I pointed out that, at 19, he didn't actually have to ask!
I think we're much more cautious/less lax, now.

Friends in Sweden/Austria don't walk their little ones to school, at all. They all walk together in a 'walking bus' - no adults.

My own 13 year old is home alone EOW and frequently during school holidays. Not because I'm lax, but because I have to go to work. He doesn't like it - I don't like it - but I have to go to work. He's too old for the forest school he used to go to in the school holidays, but not, in my view, old enough to be alone as often as he is.
The world is less than ideal, for many of us.

inappropriateraspberry · 20/06/2023 07:21

OP, you're talking like all children are left for hours every day, and 6 year olds have to spend the holidays alone whilst parents work.
You have seriously misrepresented the U.K. and Ireland.
There is a difference between giving children responsibility and independence, and child neglect

Blogswife · 20/06/2023 07:21

I certainly agree that younger children of primary school age should not be left alone but 16 is plenty old enough ! I had a responsible f/t job at 16 & my MIL was married with her first child ! It’s all about how responsible the individual is.
I don’t think nationality has much to do with it . My overseas friends are happy to trust their 16yo in the same way .After all a couple of years later many of them will be living independently at Uni - they need to know how to look after themselves!!

Kilorrery · 20/06/2023 07:20

Cakeandcardio · 20/06/2023 07:12

Are you from the US OP? I find the attitudes there so unusual where parents go for college tours with their young adults. The 18 year olds have such little responsibility. In this country it would be absolutely frowned upon to turn up to college with your child.

The OP is Irish. As am I, but I don’t recognise her incomprehension and version of the Irish ‘norm’ at all. Certainly Tusla (child services) would not be involved in children being home alone for an hour or two aged 11, or walking themselves to and from school. Completely normal here in a city. And I can think of numerous fifteen and sixteen year olds spending a few nights solo at home.

I lived in the UK for years and if anything, think the UK norms on children being left alone were (slightly) more conservative.

Twiglets1 · 20/06/2023 07:20

Cakeandcardio · 20/06/2023 07:12

Are you from the US OP? I find the attitudes there so unusual where parents go for college tours with their young adults. The 18 year olds have such little responsibility. In this country it would be absolutely frowned upon to turn up to college with your child.

They're from Ireland and have to say, I went to Uni Open Days with my kids and there were loads of other parents there so it's hardly unusual in the UK.

Mainly because the kids still appreciate a taxi service at 17/18 and may want a second opinion on different unis though it is ultimately their decision of course.

SistersNotCisters · 20/06/2023 07:18

I'm in the UK and I lived on my own at 16! I worked and paid my bills, got financial aid with guidance from my college to help with my rent and was in full time education til 18. All from my own two bedroomed terraced house with a dog, two cats, a parrot and my goldfish.
Didn't need mummy or daddy making my dinner or washing my clothes. I didn't have mum sending me to bed. I tidied my own bedroom without being told to.
I had a part time job washing up at 12 and was earning up to £120 a week as Mmmmmm min the 90's at 12.
You can bet your arse my children are responsible enough to be left for periods at 13 and 11. I'm not even counting my eldest who is more than capable of running her own home if she had to.

Nowdontmakeamess · 20/06/2023 07:17

Cakeandcardio · 20/06/2023 07:12

Are you from the US OP? I find the attitudes there so unusual where parents go for college tours with their young adults. The 18 year olds have such little responsibility. In this country it would be absolutely frowned upon to turn up to college with your child.

Absolute nonsense, it’s completely normal for parents to visit universities with their children.

whatkatydid2013 · 20/06/2023 07:16

My two are in Y2/Y4. When youngest had recently turned 4/eldest was 6 I’d have let them play in garden while I worked in house (was still covid so 100% wfh, no wraparound care, various points they were off due to contact & second lockdown). This next school year with them being 5/7 if one was poorly I would let them stay at home while I took the other to school or I’d leave one to drop other at a local activity or them both alone to pop to corner shop or drop off/pick up something at a neighbour (less than 15 min alone). This school year my eldest who is 8 (9 in a few weeks) is picked up from school but then walks home ahead with her friends from
the street while I wait and collect her sister. She also stays at home alone for 30-45 mins between when I leave to take youngest to swimming and when her dad get home. Next year she will walk to/from
School with friends and likely be home for up to an hour on her own on occasion and we will slowly work up. I think when is appropriate to let them do things will vary by child but most 8-9 year olds can surely manage on their own for a short time and understand to call you/go to a specific neighbour/call 999 for help as appropriate if there is an issue. As they get bigger it should be possible to manage for longer periods. By around 14 I’d think they’d be ok left to sort themselves out in the evening if we were out for dinner and by 16 I would imagine they could manage a few days on their own. Honestly when I was 16 I flew to Germany and backpacked between various family friends & a couple of hostels on my own/with the niece of the school exchange coordinator in Germany that swapped with my mums school (she was also 16). I’ve always seen it as a hugely positive thing that was facilitated by me being allowed a fair amount of independence

MAREMCKENNA · 20/06/2023 07:16

FeeFiFoFumble · 20/06/2023 07:10

I am also not from the UK.

I think a lot of the time in the UK, parents' hands are forced by eg how incredibly low their salaries are compared to living costs. They simply can't afford to supervise their children going to school as they need to be at work to make ends meet. And in general, jobs here aren't as flexible as in lots of other countries so even if they could afford to work fewer hours, their employers won't allow it.

Things like after school clubs in the UK tend to also be very expensive - ours charges £12 per child for two hours, which would bring it up to 5.30pm and that's still too early for a lot of parents with full time jobs to be able to collect their children. As a result, children are taught from a relatively young age to be more independent.

I expect I'll get lots of replies saying I'm talking utter nonsense, but this is my take on the situation anyway.

I don't think you're talking nonsense at all.

Cakeandcardio · 20/06/2023 07:12

Are you from the US OP? I find the attitudes there so unusual where parents go for college tours with their young adults. The 18 year olds have such little responsibility. In this country it would be absolutely frowned upon to turn up to college with your child.

Cafog · 20/06/2023 07:12

Hi OP, NI here so maybe a foot in both cultures if you like. I have DS just turned 12 who has been letting himself in for half an hour after the school bus drops him off (after navigating public transport to get to the school bus, we are quite rural) for a year now since turning 11. I think the turning point here is the move to secondary which for many children happens a year younger than in ROI. I have many friends over the border with children of a similar age heading to "big" school on September who will only be getting the freedom mines has had for a year already.

FeeFiFoFumble · 20/06/2023 07:10

I am also not from the UK.

I think a lot of the time in the UK, parents' hands are forced by eg how incredibly low their salaries are compared to living costs. They simply can't afford to supervise their children going to school as they need to be at work to make ends meet. And in general, jobs here aren't as flexible as in lots of other countries so even if they could afford to work fewer hours, their employers won't allow it.

Things like after school clubs in the UK tend to also be very expensive - ours charges £12 per child for two hours, which would bring it up to 5.30pm and that's still too early for a lot of parents with full time jobs to be able to collect their children. As a result, children are taught from a relatively young age to be more independent.

I expect I'll get lots of replies saying I'm talking utter nonsense, but this is my take on the situation anyway.

Denimdreams · 20/06/2023 07:10

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 05:04

Totally with you, and your viewpoint! My DC are at that weird age where they're in secondary school, it's Summer, too old for camps or childcare and too young for little Summer jobs... but I still wouldn't leave them home all day on their own. It's just too dangerous. What if someone clocked they were coming home by themselves every day to an empty house? What if they tried to cook something (DC are very competent in the kitchen) and forgot to turn the stove off? I just don't understand how 10 or 11 year olds can be allowed in an empty house by themselves? But again, maybe it's because that's what they're taught and what's expected of them?

You are the only one suggesting 10/11 year olds are left all day alone.
I don't know anyone who does this.

It's perfectly normal at 11 years old or 12 if they are autumn born, to either walk, cycle or bus to school.
At 12/13 they start to meet friends in town etc.
It's about enabling gradual independence and them learning how to cope in certain situations.
Perhaps is dangerous where you live?

Twiglets1 · 20/06/2023 07:10

AuntieMarys · 20/06/2023 07:03

Indeed they are now independent adults who travel the world and navigate South London successfully 😀

Which do they find harder? 😉

Twiglets1 · 20/06/2023 07:09

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 20/06/2023 06:38

@Twiglets1
She says she's Irish. Though possibly living somewhere not in UK/Ireland timezone as has posted all night on this thread.

Oh yes, I've read all her posts now (apologies, should have done it before asking). Think she's just being goady tbh. Just because one person started a thread about a 16 year old looking after cats for 4 days she thinks she can judge the whole UK? I thought that thread was a bit odd myself, would not have left my children alone at 16 to go on holiday. But you can't judge a whole country on the actions of a few individuals who have different attitudes to child rearing to yourself.
Neither would I think it safe for a 16 year old to drive a tractor which apparently happens where she is from.

Swipe left for the next trending thread