Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people in the UK are very lax generally about children being left alone?

582 replies

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

OP posts:
Crunchingleaf · 20/06/2023 09:13

What a bizarre thread. Ireland is not massively different to UK. Maybe OP lives somewhere where only one parent works. Around me nearly all households have two working parents or else a single working parent so there is no one home after school once the kid is too old for childcare.

In Ireland most kids are 18/19 finishing the leaving certificate, but there are still 17 year olds doing it and going off to university (I was 17 myself starting university). So really can’t see issue with leaving a 16 year old for a couple days.

IME in Ireland and I have lived in a few places most kids go to local primary school so wouldn’t need public transport. Loads of kids when we were in Dublin walked the last couple years of primary school. There are dedicated school buses for those living a few kilometres from the school.
Once secondary school starts then it’s very standard to go to and from school by yourself on public transport if you live in a city or large town. Rurally again there is dedicated school buses for those living too far to walk to school. There is no childcare for children of secondary school age so they are going home to empty houses because their parents are still at work…. So is very standard in Ireland that kids are home alone for a couple hours before they turn 14. At primary school level once they finish second class the options for after school care are reduced.

Go to any town or village in Ireland and there will be 9/10 year olds hanging around for hours with absolutely zero adult supervision

echt · 20/06/2023 09:08

Caramelatt · 20/06/2023 09:05

If UK is lax in your opinion, then let me guess you are not from Europe either

OP has:
already said they live in RoI
has left the thread
is probably laughing their hairy head off about this furore.

Nolongera · 20/06/2023 09:08

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:52

‘It's really not hard. UK is England, Scotland And Wales. GB is UK and NI. Ireland is a separate country so Irish not British. Scots, English and Welsh are British.’

Not quite - the U.K. is made up of the 4 countries of England, Wales, Scotland AND N Ireland
Great Britain is England, Wales, Scotland only

People in Northern Ireland are British ( being part of the U.K.) but can also have Irish passports and dual nationality if they choose to.

The Republic of Ireland is a separate country, and not part of the British Isles despite Northern Ireland being part of the island of Ireland.

The British isles is a geographical term, not a political one, and what is now the ROI is, geographically, part of the British isles.

Although I understand why citizens of the ROI wouldn't agree with that.

aSofaNearYou · 20/06/2023 09:06

Completely disagree. I don't think Ireland is a very strong example of what different cultures do as it's so close- but I get the impression that on the scale of things, the UK is pretty uptight about these things. I can't imagine there are many other places where a 10-11 year old wouldn't be capable of a couple of hours alone, or walking alone.

Caramelatt · 20/06/2023 09:05

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 04:07

Not from the UK. Some of the threads on here baffle me when it comes to leaving children alone. Children as young as 10 and 11 getting themselves home from the school, bus etc and letting themselves into an empty house. Being left for a few hours on their own. Have just read a thread about a 16yr old being left for 4 days... because she has to mind some cats?!? WTF? I just don't understand. This is not something that's done in my country at all. Is it a cultural thing? Do people not worry about house fires, accidents, abductions etc.? I just really don't understand it. But here on MN it seems totally acceptable?

If UK is lax in your opinion, then let me guess you are not from Europe either

willWillSmithsmith · 20/06/2023 09:05

I grew up in the 70s. A sixteen year old was pretty much treated like an adult (and I felt like one). I left home at 17 and was perfectly capable of living independently at sixteen.

Nolongera · 20/06/2023 09:04

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:53

‘Back in the day, 16 and 17 year olds were running their own households, some even with children.’

fuck me, were they? House prices really were cheap back in the day.

It was very easy at one time to get a council house, they were desperate to get people in them to stop them going to rot.

I knew girls who had a child at 16 and were given the keys to their council house before the child was born, anyone over 16 could get a council flat of they wanted one.

Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 20/06/2023 09:04

Op, you're shocked and appalled at the idea of a 16 year old being left alone gor a few nights, yet you then state you think 17 is about the right age?

Surely it depends on the child?

One 16 year old may be alot more sensible than another 17 year old. This is why there are no set rules on this. It's down to parental judgement (within reason).

That makes more sense, surely?

Blossomtoes · 20/06/2023 08:59

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:53

‘Back in the day, 16 and 17 year olds were running their own households, some even with children.’

fuck me, were they? House prices really were cheap back in the day.

She didn’t say they owned those houses.

Hbh17 · 20/06/2023 08:59

I used to walk to and from school (about 20 minutes) from age 9.
I spent a week in the house on my own at 16.
It was a long time ago, and it was absolutely fine and completely normal. What shocks me now is how over-protective some people are about their children - kids need to learn to do things for themselves, they can't be wrapped up in cotton wool.

Lcb123 · 20/06/2023 08:54

You sound very judgmental. It’s healthy for kids to have increasingly independence, and not be sheltered. If they’re walking or taking public transport to school most likely they’d be with friends

Sigmama · 20/06/2023 08:54

I'm sure I've read a few novels over the years set in Ireland, young people trying to escape the clutches of their over bearing families

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:53

‘Back in the day, 16 and 17 year olds were running their own households, some even with children.’

fuck me, were they? House prices really were cheap back in the day.

schnubbins · 20/06/2023 08:53

I'm from Ireland but live in Germany.Nothing of what you write seems in any way familiar to me from living in any western country and we also lived in the States when our kids were younger.

I have never driven my kids to school here in Germany .kids here all walk to school with their friends /siblings or later in high school take the bus , bike or underground

My kids could navigate the whole public transport from the age of 10/11 years and did so without any problems .They knew the timetables of the buses off by heart and travelled alone to and from their friends and to and from sport.

They both flew unaccompanied from age 14 either to Ireland to their grandparents but also to the US.

They most certainly were left alone to mind the cats at age 16 years and I only came home to a bit of a mess and an empty fridge.

They are now young adults and fully able to manage their own lives but do take advice from us on navigating the more complicated aspects of life but their everyday lives are their own responsibility.

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:52

‘It's really not hard. UK is England, Scotland And Wales. GB is UK and NI. Ireland is a separate country so Irish not British. Scots, English and Welsh are British.’

Not quite - the U.K. is made up of the 4 countries of England, Wales, Scotland AND N Ireland
Great Britain is England, Wales, Scotland only

People in Northern Ireland are British ( being part of the U.K.) but can also have Irish passports and dual nationality if they choose to.

The Republic of Ireland is a separate country, and not part of the British Isles despite Northern Ireland being part of the island of Ireland.

Anoushkaka · 20/06/2023 08:51

I've lived in Dublin my whole life. I have three kids, 11,13 and 15. My 11 year old walks to and from school, its a 15 minute walk. My two girls did the same from age 11. My 13 and just turned 15 year old regularly get public transport together to go shopping in the city centre or to shopping centres. I live 3km from the city centre.

I don't recognise what you are talking about. It's definately just you because all my kids friends are the same with regards to using public transport and going to and from school.

Catspyjamas17 · 20/06/2023 08:51

WTFAreYouForReal · 20/06/2023 08:44

Back in the day, 16 and 17 year olds were running their own households, some even with children.

The dumbing down of the ages that has resulted in the state of young people today is not a good thing in my opinion.

Absolute ageist crap. 16 and 17 year old today are extremely capable and sensible. I'm really fucking glad that most of them in the UK are not running households and are continuing education, training and enjoying their youth instead, as they bloody well should be.

Perhaps the OP could spend their time more productively donating to charities who help girls stay in education beyond the age of 11 in parts of Africa and Asia, instead of them being married off to old men.

SlatternIsMyMiddleName · 20/06/2023 08:49

I’m from Northern Ireland and was “navigating” 2 trains and a bus through Belfast city center (during the days of Thursday bomb scares in Castle Court), with no mobile phone to update my parents where I was from 15.

My own kids regularly let themselves in after school and I’m home later. This is because I work. Something a fair few adults have to do. The idea that my teenage kids need adult supervision until I get home is laughable. Mind you it might mean more supervision of the snack cupboard so there’s a thought ……..

heartofglass23 · 20/06/2023 08:49

In the 90s 16yo mums got their own council house.

Blossomtoes · 20/06/2023 08:49

And I'm sorry, a 16 yr old being left for 4 days to mind some bloody cats is just irresponsible IMO.

I had a job and left home when I was 17. You’ll find people here who had babies when they were 16.

Travelban · 20/06/2023 08:48

I am from a Mediterranean country and I was walking 2 kms to school age 7, on my own, then later with my much younger brother. At 11 I was taking 2 buses to school and looking after my brother when my parents were out.

I have friends who work all day and children finish school, walk home, make lunch and do their homework from.about 11 with no parents around until late afternoon (as many schools finish at noon).

In general I would say people are way more protective here than where I come from.

2023forme · 20/06/2023 08:48

@Toxicityofourcity YABU. My DC used to thank me for trusting them when I started to leave them overnight as young adults.
my friend is a teacher in a rural part of Australia. She was asking her class to do an activity which involved them saying positive things about their partner. The kids were 8 -9 years old. One boy said of his partner “she’s a really good driver”. Friend (from the U.K.) was like “eh????”

turns out this little girl drove her and the boy (neighbouring farms) to the bus stop which was about 2 miles from the farmhouses. Private/dirt track type road but essentially the girl was driving an automatic car with literally blocks on the pedals! Like a big go cart. this was totally normal in their area.

so I guess the point is that people do things we wouldn’t necessarily do, to fit in with their situations and needs.

inappropriateraspberry · 20/06/2023 08:48

I think OP meant to say 'this is not something done in my HOUSE at all' rather than 'in my country.' Thinking that everyone in Ireland keeps their children at home and supervised until they're 18.
Love how she thinks Ireland and the U.K. are so culturally different as well.

Cailin66 · 20/06/2023 08:48

LakeTiticaca · 20/06/2023 08:39

This is about the 3rd post on as many days I have read criticising the people of the UK. Substitute "UK" for any other culture/nation and their would be howls of racism . Why is it only deemed acceptable to pick the British, specifically English?

I don’t not think that’s the issue here. It’s a typical Irish mammy who has no clue that other Irish mammies don’t think the same way she does. I had an Irish Garda threaten me with social services for my child flying alone. Because in his view (like the bus driver) it couldn’t be allowed, but it is. I got the train to Dublin at age 10 or 11 with my 5 year old sister to visit my grandparents in the summer. I had to navigate two buses then to get to her street. It wasn’t easy but it made me independent.

Many children heading to Irish and UK universities have a bas time because they’ve never been alone, can’t cook, have no clue about laundry, parents are doing their own children no favours.

The OP should also know that many UK families used to send their children back to Ireland, alone on the ferry, to be minded by granny in the summer holidays. It was very common.

There is zero difference between the UK and Ireland unless you are living in Ballygobackwards not realising what is the reality for many children.

StarmanBobby · 20/06/2023 08:47

Dog without an adult that should be