Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Question for English teachers

168 replies

WinterCarlisle · 19/06/2023 18:36

This is something that’s been bugging me since I was at secondary school.

WHY are so many of the set texts so bloody depressing? When I was at school (mid to late 80s) we did A Kestrel for a Knave which was pretty tragic swiftly followed by Z for Zachariah which was utterly terrifying. They were no fun AT ALL to real and tbh I’m still a bit traumatised <dramatic>.

My DS is 13 and has just finished The Boy in The Striped Pyjamas and they’ve now moved onto A Monster Calls. He’s quite a sensitive boy and he’s really not liking the second one at all, especially as a family friend recently died of cancer in her mid 40s.

Obviously I understand that they need to explore different themes and life isn’t all jolly but AIBU that maybe a few cheerful books might encourage them to read a bit more rather than DOOOOOOOMMMMM??

So:

YABU - Buck up kids, stop being Wet Hens and just read about life’s depressing abyss

YANBU - There’s enough doom and gloom already in this world. Let’s read some cheerful, yet literary books while we’re at school

OP posts:
Quinoawoman · 20/06/2023 07:00

@KTheGrey how on earth is Once funny? A toddler found shot dead in it's high chair is the scene that sticks out in my mind.

Can someone please explain why they think The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas shouldn't be taught? It must be 10yrs plus since I read it so I can't remember much about it besides the basics.

I've had to withdraw Beowulf from our primary curriculum as during covid the children started to find it too scary. Was fine for years before that so I'm not totally sure what changed - probably the general climate of fear wasn't helpful.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 06:53

Can I protest enid about you saying Christmas Carol is dull as ditchwater?

I adore it, I adore teaching it. It's the ne book I have taught that got a round of applause when I finished the last page.

If a teacher loves a book it will shine through.

I taught all about the sexism in OMAM.

I think you are doing lots of English teachers a bit of a disservice enid.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 06:48

I only taught OMAM to KS4 , never younger ones - I campaigned against that at my school. We do Coram Boy and Medusa at KS3.

I hate Jane Eyre, to - hated teaching it. The kids found it drippy tbh.

It is possible to get through the entire AQA A level spec without teaching anything (one or two poems aside ) by a woman, or a person of colour, if you choose the war route. That's on the exam board and is properly shit.

My DS has read lots of books. He is a lovely soul and the tow books thta made him come home and cry were Animal Farm and OMAM - but they have stayed with him and are his favourite ever books.

Longwhiskers · 20/06/2023 06:43

God we did some awful books for GCSE - DH Lawrence’s The Virgin and the Gypsy. I’d probably enjoy it if I ever read it again but 15 yr old me hated it. Also disliked Waiting for Godot.

Halpmer · 20/06/2023 04:28

YANBU, and I agree (as an English teacher). However, I would say when I've given my kids options as far as their reading choices they're most put out if most of those options aren't dark, gloomy or about some murderous plot line. I thought they'd appreciate some more jolly options to read in their spare time but they were fuming - and this is across multiple classes!! Thinking about it, dystopian topics are some that I find most interesting to read so I can't really blame them.

Wilburisagirl · 20/06/2023 04:16

YANBU. As a counsellor, I've had students with anxiety start avoiding school and dropping/ swapping classes due to the nature of some texts or lesson topics. Obviously we can't shield them from the world but it's important we don't just completely shatter their innocence and hope for the future at what is already a time of great personal change and adjustment.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 01:04

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:51

Certainly not! I don't think it's our job to just teach sunshine and rainbows! But I don't think Of Mice and Men has any place on a KS3 curriculum. I would only teach it at KS4, because I do think to teach it properly you need students mature enough to really grapple with the implications of its portrayals. In my experience, it's a rare KS3 pupil who can do that. Personally I wouldn't teach it at all anymore because I'm bored of it and have taught it too many times - there are better books out there I'd rather teach - but I can see why a lot of people do like teaching it, and the children do always seem to enjoy it. It's a matter of personal preference, I suppose. We've all had different experiences of teaching texts to varying groups of children, so we're always going to have differing views - and debating those views is the enjoyable part!

I'm glad you've seen balance. Unfortunately in many schools it's not the case and there's a lot of work to be done. I do a lot of teacher training across schools and at ITT providers and honestly, in so many schools, the lack of imagination when it comes to text choices, and the lack of thought when it comes to diversity, are terrible. Often nothing by a woman, nothing by a writer of colour, and in many schools, the same texts taught twice - I've been in several where they teach A Christmas Carol in Year 7 and then again for GCSE.

Persepolis is a great text - I've taught that at sixth form before - and it could be taught younger, if we weren't constrained by the piss poor text choices at GCSE. Funnily enough, I LOVE Jane Eyre and love teaching it! 😁Why don't you like it?!

I just hate it 😂 I don’t actually know why. I think it’s because Jane annoys me so so so much. I also hate Mansfield Park and I sort of bunch them up in my head as what Enid Blyton would call ‘too pi for words.’ I don’t know why I hate them particularly though. I shamefully hate A Christmas Carol too. I couldn’t teach it once never mind do it twice. I think I’m a bad English Lit graduate!

I’d be really shocked to see a syllabus with nothing written by a woman on it. Not even Shelley, or the dreaded Jane Eyre? No writing by a person of colour, I’d be less shocked because I have actually seen whole classes with no text assigned by any person who isn’t white. Personally I think by GCSE something like Chinua Achebe or perhaps even a short passage from Toni Morrison (maybe not a full text as some of them could be too much at that age) would be appropriate. I believe I read Their Eyes Were Watching God around that age but I think now looking back some of the subject matter would perhaps be too graphic.

Yes, I do feel Persepolis could be taught younger. Perhaps GCSE year. However, I’ve never seen a graphic novel as part of the curriculum until sixth form/uni. Maybe they use them in other schools. Perhaps it’s because a foray into a completely different genre like graphic novel would be too out there while kids are still getting to grips with literature.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 20/06/2023 00:57

I should say it was all taught well — I remember acting out scenes from The Crucible, we did little witch interrogations in pairs, learned about McCarthyism etc.

It was just the combination of the four texts meant there was never anything "nice".

(And actually, there is quite a bit of humour in Oliver Twist and you have the porter etc in Macbeth. But those bits weren't really discussed, presumably because the exam questions focus more on betrayal/greed/ambition rather than wordplay.)

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:51

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:41

Oh ok, I thought you were suggesting problematic texts should be removed from the curriculum, since you said they had no place on the curriculum! You also seemed to think that there was no way to reach a text like Of Mice and Men without agreeing with Curley’s attitude towards his wife. So you can see why I thought that.

For me I find there often is balance. Of course it depends on the school and the texts taught there. I saw a lesson a while ago on ‘Persepolis’ which I thought was fantastic, although that was in a sixth form class! I’ve seen a lot of balance in texts that are taught. I would love to see Jane Eyre swapped out but that’s that I suppose! It seems to prevail no matter what.

Certainly not! I don't think it's our job to just teach sunshine and rainbows! But I don't think Of Mice and Men has any place on a KS3 curriculum. I would only teach it at KS4, because I do think to teach it properly you need students mature enough to really grapple with the implications of its portrayals. In my experience, it's a rare KS3 pupil who can do that. Personally I wouldn't teach it at all anymore because I'm bored of it and have taught it too many times - there are better books out there I'd rather teach - but I can see why a lot of people do like teaching it, and the children do always seem to enjoy it. It's a matter of personal preference, I suppose. We've all had different experiences of teaching texts to varying groups of children, so we're always going to have differing views - and debating those views is the enjoyable part!

I'm glad you've seen balance. Unfortunately in many schools it's not the case and there's a lot of work to be done. I do a lot of teacher training across schools and at ITT providers and honestly, in so many schools, the lack of imagination when it comes to text choices, and the lack of thought when it comes to diversity, are terrible. Often nothing by a woman, nothing by a writer of colour, and in many schools, the same texts taught twice - I've been in several where they teach A Christmas Carol in Year 7 and then again for GCSE.

Persepolis is a great text - I've taught that at sixth form before - and it could be taught younger, if we weren't constrained by the piss poor text choices at GCSE. Funnily enough, I LOVE Jane Eyre and love teaching it! 😁Why don't you like it?!

User9779 · 20/06/2023 00:51

We had Cider with Rosie. What about Cold Comfort Farm?

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:41

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:31

I don't disagree. I'm not suggesting problematic texts should be taken off the curriculum entirely. But what I don't agree with is the prevalence of these types of texts and how they dominate the curriculum in many schools. The fact is that for many children, every single text they study while at school will have women and/or people of colour portrayed as victims. There needs to be some balance. At the moment, in many schools, there isn't any. If you're a girl in an English classroom, and you study one of each of the most popular texts in Year 7, 8 and 9, you'll never get to read about or talk about a female character who's inspiring in any way. You'll either never talk about a female character at all, or if you do, you'll be talking about how terribly she's treated by everyone else and what a victim she is. Likewise if you're a child of colour. I find that problematic - it's exclusive and frankly quite emotionally draining for anyone who's not white and/or male in a classroom to constantly have to think about people like them as being victims. While we can and should of course teach challenging texts that do portray problematic views and depictions, I think it's really important that curricula balance those texts carefully so that there's light and shade.

Oh ok, I thought you were suggesting problematic texts should be removed from the curriculum, since you said they had no place on the curriculum! You also seemed to think that there was no way to reach a text like Of Mice and Men without agreeing with Curley’s attitude towards his wife. So you can see why I thought that.

For me I find there often is balance. Of course it depends on the school and the texts taught there. I saw a lesson a while ago on ‘Persepolis’ which I thought was fantastic, although that was in a sixth form class! I’ve seen a lot of balance in texts that are taught. I would love to see Jane Eyre swapped out but that’s that I suppose! It seems to prevail no matter what.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 20/06/2023 00:38

I really enjoyed English literature up to GCSE. Sometimes our teachers would to pair books, so we did A Midsummer Night's Dream along with King of Shadows (boy time travels and swaps places with a boy who would have given Shakespeare the plague), and we did Arthurian legends, the Lady of Shalott and The Turbulent Term of Tyke Tyler together. We definitely did Sherlock Holmes short stories as well.

Sadly at GSCE I ended up doing Lord of the Flies, The Crucible, Macbeth and Oliver Twist. It was just too much misery for me! The poetry wasn't exactly cheerful either...

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:34

Pieceofpurplesky · 20/06/2023 00:25

@EnidSpyton it will change - two jobs in a local, good school - one applicant 😫

It's awful isn't it? And will only get worse in future when you see how low the numbers are taking Literature at A Level and at university 😔

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:31

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:22

Again, if the texts are taught properly, you will be helping the students challenge those narratives. If you teach it poorly then of course it problematic, but then if you teach any subject poorly it’s problematic.

Like a history teacher - they will have to teach about racism, genocide, war, murder. If they teach it as ‘wow wasn’t this great’ of course that’s poor. I imagine they’re intelligent and capable of helping students learn to study history critically. Most English teachers should also be capable of this.

I don't disagree. I'm not suggesting problematic texts should be taken off the curriculum entirely. But what I don't agree with is the prevalence of these types of texts and how they dominate the curriculum in many schools. The fact is that for many children, every single text they study while at school will have women and/or people of colour portrayed as victims. There needs to be some balance. At the moment, in many schools, there isn't any. If you're a girl in an English classroom, and you study one of each of the most popular texts in Year 7, 8 and 9, you'll never get to read about or talk about a female character who's inspiring in any way. You'll either never talk about a female character at all, or if you do, you'll be talking about how terribly she's treated by everyone else and what a victim she is. Likewise if you're a child of colour. I find that problematic - it's exclusive and frankly quite emotionally draining for anyone who's not white and/or male in a classroom to constantly have to think about people like them as being victims. While we can and should of course teach challenging texts that do portray problematic views and depictions, I think it's really important that curricula balance those texts carefully so that there's light and shade.

Pieceofpurplesky · 20/06/2023 00:25

@EnidSpyton it will change - two jobs in a local, good school - one applicant 😫

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:22

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:20

I think we're going to have to agree to disagree!

I think it's hugely problematic to only teach children negative depictions of one sector of the population. If you look at the stats about the most popular texts taught to children, women and people of colour are either entirely invisible, or victims. I don't think that's a helpful narrative to keep reinforcing.

Again, if the texts are taught properly, you will be helping the students challenge those narratives. If you teach it poorly then of course it problematic, but then if you teach any subject poorly it’s problematic.

Like a history teacher - they will have to teach about racism, genocide, war, murder. If they teach it as ‘wow wasn’t this great’ of course that’s poor. I imagine they’re intelligent and capable of helping students learn to study history critically. Most English teachers should also be capable of this.

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:20

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:12

I think if it’s taught correctly then yes, students can understand the position that Curley’s wife was in, and it can open a conversation about what the world was like for women at that time. An ‘empowered’ version of Curley’s wife would just be fake.

Literature isn’t there to provide positive role models for the idealised world the way it should be. It’s there to show the world as it is and was. And unfortunately ‘doesn’t John make GREAT decisions all the way through this book’ doesn’t make a wonderful essay.

I think we're going to have to agree to disagree!

I think it's hugely problematic to only teach children negative depictions of one sector of the population. If you look at the stats about the most popular texts taught to children, women and people of colour are either entirely invisible, or victims. I don't think that's a helpful narrative to keep reinforcing.

Winniewonka · 20/06/2023 00:16

When I attended a state run girls' grammar school in the early Seventies we had a wonderful English Literature teacher.
In the equivalent of today's Year Nine, we had a few copies of the following books which we had to swap between us.
Catcher in the Rye
Cry the Beloved Country
Grapes of Wrath
Kes
Midwich Cuckoos
Tess of the D'Urbervilles
The only stipulation being that you must read all of them and then write a report of of each novel and your thoughts on them and discuss the books amongst us.
I think she was quite clever as she was prepping your critical thinking for later O levels as well as creating anticipation for the more popular titles.

We also had to put on a production of Macbeth which is far more memorable than just sitting in class reading 'dry' text.

We didn't sit a test for the subject either for that year.

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 00:15

Pieceofpurplesky · 19/06/2023 23:58

Oh believe me @EnidSpyton I would love to be more inventive but there is no budget for new books. We have to share around sets between classes. There are so many books I would love to teach - reading time is cut due to the way we now have to teach.
I also don't know any English teachers who are not English graduates - and I have met and worked with many in my 23 years

Oh I know money is short. There are many barriers to change. It's not an easy fix.

And lucky you for never coming across non English graduates. In London it's very common. The NEU has just announced that 20% of children are being taught English by non specialists due to a chronic shortage: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/jun/17/schools-across-england-face-unprecedented-struggle-to-hire-english-teachers-as-recruitment-crisis-grows

Schools across England face unprecedented struggle to hire English teachers as recruitment crisis grows

Headteachers say situation is critical as they try to fill vacancies for September

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2023/jun/17/schools-across-england-face-unprecedented-struggle-to-hire-english-teachers-as-recruitment-crisis-grows

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:12

EnidSpyton · 19/06/2023 23:52

Do you really think an 11 year old is capable of thinking deeply and meaningfully about the reality of sexism, male violence and patriarchy means and why the portrayal of Curley's wife in OMAM is problematic? You might teach them the theory of it, but that doesn't mean they have the maturity to truly get it.

If we want to challenge sexism, we shouldn't be teaching books where women are constantly portrayed as victims of male violence. It's just like teaching books that always depict non white characters as victims of racism. If we really want to challenge sexism and racism, we need to teach texts with positive, empowering depictions of female characters and characters of colour. Not keep reinforcing stereotypes that get us nowhere towards change.

I think if it’s taught correctly then yes, students can understand the position that Curley’s wife was in, and it can open a conversation about what the world was like for women at that time. An ‘empowered’ version of Curley’s wife would just be fake.

Literature isn’t there to provide positive role models for the idealised world the way it should be. It’s there to show the world as it is and was. And unfortunately ‘doesn’t John make GREAT decisions all the way through this book’ doesn’t make a wonderful essay.

Pieceofpurplesky · 19/06/2023 23:58

Oh believe me @EnidSpyton I would love to be more inventive but there is no budget for new books. We have to share around sets between classes. There are so many books I would love to teach - reading time is cut due to the way we now have to teach.
I also don't know any English teachers who are not English graduates - and I have met and worked with many in my 23 years

NeverendingCircus · 19/06/2023 23:56

YANBU. I loved all the texts I taught at GCSE but they were all really depressing for teens with no light relief. There should be a far better mix of upbeat and funny work as well as dark, dramatic stuff.

echt · 19/06/2023 23:53

To answer the OP's OP: Happiness writes white. Attributed to De Motherlant.

You've got to have a problem to make the narrative work.

Maybe kids should be asked, eg 'this year we need to study books on x,y,z you have 2 weeks to come up with 3 suggestions and we will discuss and pick'

When I taught in the UK, school book supplies were based on what was in the stock cupboard, patched up with sticky tape. In secondary such books were on a rota so had to be be done and dusted, ready for the next class. The books never went home.

EnidSpyton · 19/06/2023 23:52

Kanaloa · 19/06/2023 23:43

Like, people do care about the sexism. If it’s not coming up at all/nobody cares then the text isn’t being taught properly.

Do you really think an 11 year old is capable of thinking deeply and meaningfully about the reality of sexism, male violence and patriarchy means and why the portrayal of Curley's wife in OMAM is problematic? You might teach them the theory of it, but that doesn't mean they have the maturity to truly get it.

If we want to challenge sexism, we shouldn't be teaching books where women are constantly portrayed as victims of male violence. It's just like teaching books that always depict non white characters as victims of racism. If we really want to challenge sexism and racism, we need to teach texts with positive, empowering depictions of female characters and characters of colour. Not keep reinforcing stereotypes that get us nowhere towards change.

WandaWonder · 19/06/2023 23:46

Maybe kids should be asked, eg 'this year we need to study books on x,y,z you have 2 weeks to come up with 3 suggestions and we will discuss and pick'