Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Question for English teachers

168 replies

WinterCarlisle · 19/06/2023 18:36

This is something that’s been bugging me since I was at secondary school.

WHY are so many of the set texts so bloody depressing? When I was at school (mid to late 80s) we did A Kestrel for a Knave which was pretty tragic swiftly followed by Z for Zachariah which was utterly terrifying. They were no fun AT ALL to real and tbh I’m still a bit traumatised <dramatic>.

My DS is 13 and has just finished The Boy in The Striped Pyjamas and they’ve now moved onto A Monster Calls. He’s quite a sensitive boy and he’s really not liking the second one at all, especially as a family friend recently died of cancer in her mid 40s.

Obviously I understand that they need to explore different themes and life isn’t all jolly but AIBU that maybe a few cheerful books might encourage them to read a bit more rather than DOOOOOOOMMMMM??

So:

YABU - Buck up kids, stop being Wet Hens and just read about life’s depressing abyss

YANBU - There’s enough doom and gloom already in this world. Let’s read some cheerful, yet literary books while we’re at school

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 10:32

I mean something like Camus’ The Outsider or Bounjour Tristesse or The Old Man and the Sea is short but I think it would be short sighted (or poorly read) to say they’re ‘quickly read and soon forgotten.’ I mean maybe if all you’re reading is poor books, but there’s no end of modern classics that are brilliantly written while also being short.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 10:29

CoffeeCantata · 20/06/2023 10:12

winewolfhowls · Yesterday 22:37
The trouble is that curriculum time is limited and there aren't enough shorter yet still engaging and relevant texts. Perhaps the exam boards should have a competition and invite famous authors to write a shorter novel.

Yes, I agree. There are lots of good short stories out there. The short story is an overlooked genre, I think, which is great for the crowded curriculum nowadays. It's also a better model for children's writing in KS2 and KS3 than long novels. Or novellas such as Animal Farm would work - it's brilliant satire and superbly written. Also it allows for enjoyment on both a literal and an allegorical level so great for the whole ability range.

I used to teach English and I've also worked in a school library and I agree that the current fashion in set books seems to be very depressing and heavy. I've often thought that the subversive aim of the current English curriculum and exam syllabuses/syllabi/syllabub is to put youngsters off reading completely.

I don't know about the 'dead white men' moans. The novel was a genre which women really took up and excelled at, so please don't throw out the baby with the bathwater! My exam texts introduced me to Thomas Hardy, whose work became a lifelong pleasure for me. George Eliot's, the Brontes, Jane Austen, of course, Wilkie Collins - all wrote works which are panoramic in character, showing the times and social situation with a mix of tragedy and humour.

That's the problem with modern novels, I think. The novel was the 19th century genre, just as drama had been the genre of the Renaissance, Because we all have less time and inclination now to sit and read doorstop-sized Victorian novels, writers produce shorter (and frankly often lightweight) texts which, like the old joke about a takeaway meal, are quick to read but very soon forgotten. And they tend to try to make up for the necessary brevity by trying to be portentous...which often translates in practical terms as depressing and bleak.

I think with some introduction even 21st century youngsters would enjoy the brilliant story-telling, romantic settings and characterisation of Thomas Hardy. He was also brilliant at portraying women and the predicament of the poor in a rigid class-stratified society, so he didn't shy away from harsh reality, but leavened it with his humour and insight.

Possibly Dickens...Great Expectations is superb...but very dense for modern tastes. I wouldn't deny that Dickens is a genius but I loathe his twee portrayal of women.

I think one thing many people (especially those who are great readers themselves) don’t really understand is that, when you teach English, maybe 4 or 5 kids in the class are readers. Maybe. Probably half the class won’t be. Or if they are, they’ll be readers of YA series or manga novels. A lot of people (I noticed this in training) kind of think teaching English will be like a uni seminar or something from Dead Poet’s Society, with passionate discussions of Dickens and poetry. But in fact, it’s a core subject which is mandatory for all students. That means a huge number of them won’t really be interested in literature or English as a subject. Setting a text like Great Expectations or Thomas Hardy novels, which are really hard to read, would be almost impossible, because more than half the class would be instantly turned off by the difficult language and sheer length.

I will disagree with you on the modern novel though - I think there is much to be said for a lot of shorter modern novels. Lots of people sneer at them, but a lot of them are as well written or significantly better written than a Dickens tome.

LunaNorth · 20/06/2023 10:19

English teacher here, and I absolutely agree. I work with kids who have a range of mental health difficulties, and it really brings it home to you how triggering some of the texts are.

Lord of the Flies, Of Mice and Men, Power and Conflict poetry, An Inspector Calls…lots of murder, suicide, war…it goes on.

HollyGolightly4 · 20/06/2023 10:19

I hate Hardy @CoffeeCantata 😂. Seven pages to describe a blade of grass!

You make really interesting points about genre - I'd not actually considered that.

viques · 20/06/2023 10:15

Winniewonka · 20/06/2023 00:16

When I attended a state run girls' grammar school in the early Seventies we had a wonderful English Literature teacher.
In the equivalent of today's Year Nine, we had a few copies of the following books which we had to swap between us.
Catcher in the Rye
Cry the Beloved Country
Grapes of Wrath
Kes
Midwich Cuckoos
Tess of the D'Urbervilles
The only stipulation being that you must read all of them and then write a report of of each novel and your thoughts on them and discuss the books amongst us.
I think she was quite clever as she was prepping your critical thinking for later O levels as well as creating anticipation for the more popular titles.

We also had to put on a production of Macbeth which is far more memorable than just sitting in class reading 'dry' text.

We didn't sit a test for the subject either for that year.

An interesting choice to have The Midwich Cuckoos -which has been contemptuously ruined by so many film makers over the years but is a terrific story .

I love John Wyndham’s books, like the “sci fi” stories of Philip K Dick, and Isaac Asimov, they are remarkably prescient and thoughtful about how people respond to disaster, to conflict, to changing social situations. I would imagine them being quite accessible to many children. They are also quite short, often more novellas than novels. And a lot of short stories to tie into a bundle! The JW that I think would resonate is The Chrysalids where the main characters are teenagers, gifted or cursed with a genetic anomaly that in a post apocalyptic world where difference is frowned upon are targeted and threatened.

Another author worth considering is Shirley Jackson, her short stories are extraordinary, most people would recognise The Lottery, but she wrote many more, and several novels, I think my favourite is We have Always Lived in the Castle, which is very layered, perhaps more for KS4 than KS3 though. And the House on the Hill, to scare them a bit and show how language alone can unsettle us, we don’t need special effects or scarey music.

CoffeeCantata · 20/06/2023 10:12

winewolfhowls · Yesterday 22:37
The trouble is that curriculum time is limited and there aren't enough shorter yet still engaging and relevant texts. Perhaps the exam boards should have a competition and invite famous authors to write a shorter novel.

Yes, I agree. There are lots of good short stories out there. The short story is an overlooked genre, I think, which is great for the crowded curriculum nowadays. It's also a better model for children's writing in KS2 and KS3 than long novels. Or novellas such as Animal Farm would work - it's brilliant satire and superbly written. Also it allows for enjoyment on both a literal and an allegorical level so great for the whole ability range.

I used to teach English and I've also worked in a school library and I agree that the current fashion in set books seems to be very depressing and heavy. I've often thought that the subversive aim of the current English curriculum and exam syllabuses/syllabi/syllabub is to put youngsters off reading completely.

I don't know about the 'dead white men' moans. The novel was a genre which women really took up and excelled at, so please don't throw out the baby with the bathwater! My exam texts introduced me to Thomas Hardy, whose work became a lifelong pleasure for me. George Eliot's, the Brontes, Jane Austen, of course, Wilkie Collins - all wrote works which are panoramic in character, showing the times and social situation with a mix of tragedy and humour.

That's the problem with modern novels, I think. The novel was the 19th century genre, just as drama had been the genre of the Renaissance, Because we all have less time and inclination now to sit and read doorstop-sized Victorian novels, writers produce shorter (and frankly often lightweight) texts which, like the old joke about a takeaway meal, are quick to read but very soon forgotten. And they tend to try to make up for the necessary brevity by trying to be portentous...which often translates in practical terms as depressing and bleak.

I think with some introduction even 21st century youngsters would enjoy the brilliant story-telling, romantic settings and characterisation of Thomas Hardy. He was also brilliant at portraying women and the predicament of the poor in a rigid class-stratified society, so he didn't shy away from harsh reality, but leavened it with his humour and insight.

Possibly Dickens...Great Expectations is superb...but very dense for modern tastes. I wouldn't deny that Dickens is a genius but I loathe his twee portrayal of women.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 09:45

OMAM isn't part of GCSE anymore. Hence the discussion about moving it to younger children.

SunshinyDay1 · 20/06/2023 09:19

@EnidSpyton

Teaching is a vocation snd those curious teachers out there will always want to try and seek to improve, question and do things better.

Unfortunately those in it for a job won't.

NeverendingCircus · 20/06/2023 09:01

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 00:12

I think if it’s taught correctly then yes, students can understand the position that Curley’s wife was in, and it can open a conversation about what the world was like for women at that time. An ‘empowered’ version of Curley’s wife would just be fake.

Literature isn’t there to provide positive role models for the idealised world the way it should be. It’s there to show the world as it is and was. And unfortunately ‘doesn’t John make GREAT decisions all the way through this book’ doesn’t make a wonderful essay.

@Kanaloa I agree that it's perfectly possible to teach the portrayal of Curly's wife in a way that students understand Steinbeck was commenting on the invisibility of women's rights in the pursuit of the Great American Dream. But you could set that alongside a book like Sister Noon by Karen Joy Fowler - a massively under-rated author. Or Little Fires by Celeste Ng which is easy to read but says so much about the Great American Dream, female empowerment, racial inequality and male entitlement without being totally depressing. OMAM is a brilliant book, but when you have that and R&J and Inspector Calls and the Conflict poetry - all brilliant but all so depressing, it's no wonder they find English a joyless subject. There should be a balance.

Quinoawoman · 20/06/2023 08:58

@Skyblue92 thank you!

GrammarTeacher · 20/06/2023 08:50

Another Barbara and EMC in general fan.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 08:42

Yes, she is , definitely.

I no longer teach English, focusing on my other subjects and it is so much more fun. And the autonomy is fabulous.

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 08:38

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 08:21

As I said, I agree with you on doing the classics too early, and on OMAM. You won't get me to agree on Dickens. Morally and politically he has real lessons for us all. The only Dickens I teach in a school setting though are ACC and OT. My other DS did Great Expectations for GCSE and hated the experience. I also think Animal Farm is taught too early in a lot of schools. The simplicity of the language is belies its content and darkness.

What I mean by disservice was your (for want of a better word) tone, for want of a better expression - yes, there is a recruitment crisis. But lots of us remain who are enthusiastic, thoughtful and well read. My focus wasn't really on the fact that I love ACC but that the students loved its ending and its put the world to right message. Some of the books being dismissed here genuinely are adored (or at least enjoyed)by the majority of students.

My school begins at year 9, though, so I am cushioned a bit against what they do in younger years. Age appropriateness is a big concern of mine. 100% agree about that. Barbara Bleiman is quite vocal about this.

Mainly, what has changed is the obsessions with assessment, squashing out any reading for reading's sake. The joy ahs gone , and that can be found in gloomy texts too. It's led to kids only doing things is there is a test and teachers only teaching tings in such a way that suits an end of half term assessment. The creative approaches are sneered at by lots of school leaders and educationalists.

We don't have to agree! I am very happy for other people to love Dickens. I will never be persuaded to, but I respect other people's love for him!

That being said, your experience of teaching ACC to a GCSE set is going to be very different from teaching it to Year 7, which is where it appears in a large number of school curricula. I don't think many Year 7s genuinely find ACC engaging and there are much better books to read at that age that are also morally complex and provide scope for debate, but which offer more accessible language and a more contemporary feeling setting.

I apologise if you found my tone offensive. I think I am rather jaded from my experiences as a trainer across many, many schools where I see a lot of poorly qualified English teachers, a huge amount of uninspiring teaching, and a lack of engagement with and curiosity about the latest writing for young people. I know there are many, many fabulous and hard working English teachers out there who love literature and are inspirational for their students. I like to think I am one of them. 😂But most teachers have quite limited experience of what goes on outside the walls of their schools, so I do think it's important to be truthful about what is going on more widely in English teaching. I am lucky to be in a position to both teach and train, so I see much more than just the practice of my own department - and I'm sorry to say that it is a bleak picture out there for English teaching, and your own expertise and enthusiasm is sadly not echoed in many other settings. Academy schools are the worst - teaching resources created by Head Offices and rolled out to schools so that each class is taught exactly the same thing, with little to no creative input from class teachers, constant tests and assessments, an obsessive focus on either 'skills' or 'knowledge', with no room for creativity or independence, GCSE starting in Year 9 so kids are taught the same book for three years running to ensure they can parrot a grade 5 or above answer in their exam - I could go on.

However, thank you for reminding me that there are passionate and engaged teachers out there, too. Barbara Bellman is wonderful, isn't she? Such a brilliant advocate for what English teaching really should be.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 08:21

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 07:32

Sure you can! I find A Christmas Carol unbearably saccharine, simplistic, and, as with all Dickens novels (in my view), horrendously overwritten. Dickens was paid by the word and it really shows! If you want to teach 19thc literature, there are far better options out there, in my view. And if you want to teach children a moral fable, there are also far better options out there. I don't think it's a text that inspires children to develop a love of literature or makes them desperate to pick up the book to read the next chapter and find out what happens next. For me, it truly is dull as dishwater. But each to their own - you hate Jane Eyre, and I love it. I think it's a masterpiece and I love teaching it, and my students have all loved it, too. As you say - if you love a book, you transmit that enthusiasm to your kids.

And I know teachers teach the sexism in OMAM. I didn't say that they didn't. I just don't think it's taught to the right age groups to enable them to really understand the significance of that sexism or be able to truly engage with why the portrayal of Curley's wife is so problematic. I'm an English teacher, but I also have a wider role going into schools and ITT providers as a subject specialist trainer providing CPD. As such, I can tell you from experience of a lot of settings that OMAM is frequently taught at Year 7 and 8, and in many school settings, engaging 11 and 12 year olds with complex and challenging ideas around representations of women, sexual and domestic and violence and so on, is largely unsuccessful. Instead, students are left with very troubling notions about Curley's wife, which is evidenced in a lot of their written work. I've had so many conversations with teachers about this and why their students aren't able to see beyond the viewpoints of the male characters when it comes to Curley's wife, despite having lessons where they discuss sexism, and my response is always that they just don't have the maturity to do so. And why would they? They've got no life experience to draw on to be able to think about how and why such treatment of a woman can come about on an isolated cattle ranch filled with deeply lonely, damaged men.

I don't think I'm doing English teachers a disservice to raise these issues. I think it does us all good to sit back and reflect on what we're teaching and why, and whether what we're teaching really is appropriate for our students at the stage of life and intellectual development they're at. I think we teach a lot of classic texts far too early and there's a lot of room for debate about what makes a good KS3 text.

As I said, I agree with you on doing the classics too early, and on OMAM. You won't get me to agree on Dickens. Morally and politically he has real lessons for us all. The only Dickens I teach in a school setting though are ACC and OT. My other DS did Great Expectations for GCSE and hated the experience. I also think Animal Farm is taught too early in a lot of schools. The simplicity of the language is belies its content and darkness.

What I mean by disservice was your (for want of a better word) tone, for want of a better expression - yes, there is a recruitment crisis. But lots of us remain who are enthusiastic, thoughtful and well read. My focus wasn't really on the fact that I love ACC but that the students loved its ending and its put the world to right message. Some of the books being dismissed here genuinely are adored (or at least enjoyed)by the majority of students.

My school begins at year 9, though, so I am cushioned a bit against what they do in younger years. Age appropriateness is a big concern of mine. 100% agree about that. Barbara Bleiman is quite vocal about this.

Mainly, what has changed is the obsessions with assessment, squashing out any reading for reading's sake. The joy ahs gone , and that can be found in gloomy texts too. It's led to kids only doing things is there is a test and teachers only teaching tings in such a way that suits an end of half term assessment. The creative approaches are sneered at by lots of school leaders and educationalists.

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 08:01

SunshinyDay1 · 20/06/2023 07:15

@EnidSpyton great post and obviously add to that some teachers have no research skills.

However We loved a Christmas Carol.

What books would you suggest

Happy to suggest books!

Off the top of my head, I've found these to be good texts - both from my own experience and from seeing them taught by other people, for varying school settings/levels of ability:

For Year 7:
Pax by Sara Pennypacker
Apple and Rain by Sarah Crossan (anything by her is good)
Witch Child by Celia Rees
The Ruby in the Smoke by Philip Pullman
Coraline by Neil Gaiman
Rooftoppers by Katherine Rundell
Lightning Mary by Anthea Simmons
Wolf Hollow or Beyond the Bright Sea by Lauren Wolk
Chinese Cinderella by Adeline Yen Mah

Year 8:
A Gathering Light by Jennifer Donnelly
Salt to the Sea or Between Shades of Grey by Ruta Sepetys
The Ocean at the End of the Lane by Neil Gaiman
Uncle Montague's Tales of Terror by Chris Priestley
The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo
Where the World Ends by Geraldine McCaughrean
Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein (this is part of a fab series, so you can start them off by teaching the first book, then they can read the rest independently)

Year 9:
Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier
Clap When You Land by Elizabeth Acevedo
I Know Where the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou
The Way I Live Now by Meg Rosoff
Agnes Grey by Anne Bronte
We Have Always Lived in the Castle by Shirley Jackson
Roald Dahl short stories
Some of the more exciting Agatha Christies - Death on the Nile, Murder on the Orient Express, etc
Anita and Me by Meera Syal

I always try and teach texts the kids wouldn't pick up and read independently, so I'd never teach Northern Lights, The Hunger Games, Divergent, Harry Potter, Percy Jackson, etc - I know some schools do with much success, but personally I prefer to introduce them to texts they'd probably not otherwise come across.

A really good place to find inspiration is the Carnegie award shortlist/longlist. I always read a few every year and usually find something new to try.

GrammarTeacher · 20/06/2023 07:42

Currently in the process of trying to bring more joy in at KS3 because tbh the GCSE spec is relentless (and Language is stupid). A level also a bit much at times but they get a lot out of it.

Skyblue92 · 20/06/2023 07:42

Skyblue92 · 20/06/2023 07:37

Historically is completely inaccurate. Bruno would not have been able to get anywhere near the fence for the camp let alone sneak into it. Shmuel would have been murdered the moment he arrived. It also encourages the readers to feel sympathy for Bruno and his family (nazi camp commanders).

this link explains it better

hcn.org.uK/blog/the-problem-with-the-boy-in-the-striped-pyjamas/

https://hcn.org.uk/blog/the-problem-with-the-boy-in-the-striped-pyjamas/

with it actually linked now

The Problem with ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’

John Boyne's novel ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’ was first published in 2006 and adapted into a best-selling film two years later. It is an international best-seller and as of 2016 it had sold…

https://hcn.org.uk/blog/the-problem-with-the-boy-in-the-striped-pyjamas/

Skyblue92 · 20/06/2023 07:37

Quinoawoman · 20/06/2023 07:00

@KTheGrey how on earth is Once funny? A toddler found shot dead in it's high chair is the scene that sticks out in my mind.

Can someone please explain why they think The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas shouldn't be taught? It must be 10yrs plus since I read it so I can't remember much about it besides the basics.

I've had to withdraw Beowulf from our primary curriculum as during covid the children started to find it too scary. Was fine for years before that so I'm not totally sure what changed - probably the general climate of fear wasn't helpful.

Historically is completely inaccurate. Bruno would not have been able to get anywhere near the fence for the camp let alone sneak into it. Shmuel would have been murdered the moment he arrived. It also encourages the readers to feel sympathy for Bruno and his family (nazi camp commanders).

this link explains it better

hcn.org.uK/blog/the-problem-with-the-boy-in-the-striped-pyjamas/

EnidSpyton · 20/06/2023 07:32

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 06:53

Can I protest enid about you saying Christmas Carol is dull as ditchwater?

I adore it, I adore teaching it. It's the ne book I have taught that got a round of applause when I finished the last page.

If a teacher loves a book it will shine through.

I taught all about the sexism in OMAM.

I think you are doing lots of English teachers a bit of a disservice enid.

Sure you can! I find A Christmas Carol unbearably saccharine, simplistic, and, as with all Dickens novels (in my view), horrendously overwritten. Dickens was paid by the word and it really shows! If you want to teach 19thc literature, there are far better options out there, in my view. And if you want to teach children a moral fable, there are also far better options out there. I don't think it's a text that inspires children to develop a love of literature or makes them desperate to pick up the book to read the next chapter and find out what happens next. For me, it truly is dull as dishwater. But each to their own - you hate Jane Eyre, and I love it. I think it's a masterpiece and I love teaching it, and my students have all loved it, too. As you say - if you love a book, you transmit that enthusiasm to your kids.

And I know teachers teach the sexism in OMAM. I didn't say that they didn't. I just don't think it's taught to the right age groups to enable them to really understand the significance of that sexism or be able to truly engage with why the portrayal of Curley's wife is so problematic. I'm an English teacher, but I also have a wider role going into schools and ITT providers as a subject specialist trainer providing CPD. As such, I can tell you from experience of a lot of settings that OMAM is frequently taught at Year 7 and 8, and in many school settings, engaging 11 and 12 year olds with complex and challenging ideas around representations of women, sexual and domestic and violence and so on, is largely unsuccessful. Instead, students are left with very troubling notions about Curley's wife, which is evidenced in a lot of their written work. I've had so many conversations with teachers about this and why their students aren't able to see beyond the viewpoints of the male characters when it comes to Curley's wife, despite having lessons where they discuss sexism, and my response is always that they just don't have the maturity to do so. And why would they? They've got no life experience to draw on to be able to think about how and why such treatment of a woman can come about on an isolated cattle ranch filled with deeply lonely, damaged men.

I don't think I'm doing English teachers a disservice to raise these issues. I think it does us all good to sit back and reflect on what we're teaching and why, and whether what we're teaching really is appropriate for our students at the stage of life and intellectual development they're at. I think we teach a lot of classic texts far too early and there's a lot of room for debate about what makes a good KS3 text.

parietal · 20/06/2023 07:21

I guess that aren't considered great literature but there are lots of sci-fi short stories which are accessible to kids and not too miserable. Arthur C Clark and Philip K Dick for starters.

SunshinyDay1 · 20/06/2023 07:15

@EnidSpyton great post and obviously add to that some teachers have no research skills.

However We loved a Christmas Carol.

What books would you suggest

Quinoawoman · 20/06/2023 07:10

Wilburisagirl · 20/06/2023 04:16

YANBU. As a counsellor, I've had students with anxiety start avoiding school and dropping/ swapping classes due to the nature of some texts or lesson topics. Obviously we can't shield them from the world but it's important we don't just completely shatter their innocence and hope for the future at what is already a time of great personal change and adjustment.

Interested to hear your thoughts about why this has started happening recently. I started having complaints about Beowulf (the Michael Morpurgo version so not that bad) from primary parents in 2020 and had to withdraw it. The range of texts I feel I am 'allowed'to teach has really narrowed recently as more middle class parents complain.

Interestingly, I teach an intervention / reading for pleasure group for pupil premium kids, with no curriculum to follow. I have found that I have to choose really gritty texts for them otherwise they don't engage. They love murder, violence, curses, etc - stuff I could never get away with teaching my usual classes. It's my favourite time of the week teaching them as I love the freedom to go deeper with them and explore darker themes. They get bored with light hearted stuff and don't engage.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 20/06/2023 07:08

LizzieVereker · 19/06/2023 23:03

Most literature is doom and gloom because its function is to explore the human condition and unfortunately humans are pretty shitty to each other.

As a weird counterpoint to this, the GCSE language examiners are now not allowed to set any unseen texts, or set any creative tasks or stimuli which could be in any way triggering for students. So the lit paper is all Apocalypse Now whereas the language paper is all Pollyanna travel writing.

Except on the whole humans aren't. Take Lord of the Flies. A similar real life situation was totally different. They supported each other, even when one had a broken leg. Link

More times than not people are kind and help each others, even strangers and by putting themselves in danger.

But this doesn't make good novels.

The real Lord of the Flies: what happened when six boys were shipwrecked for 15 months

When a group of schoolboys were marooned on an island in 1965, it turned out very differently to William Golding’s bestseller, writes Rutger Bregman

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/books/2020/may/09/the-real-lord-of-the-flies-what-happened-when-six-boys-were-shipwrecked-for-15-months

SunshinyDay1 · 20/06/2023 07:07

My dd has been doing a book about murder and has calmed home talking about corpses s d how they disintegrate. She's 10

SunshinyDay1 · 20/06/2023 07:03

@FourEyesGood

I don't think the book has to be light hearted? Perhaps action based which can still include death if that's what you want but in a more action setting.

I got my teen dd some action books I Csnt remembered the name of the two authors.