Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Question for English teachers

168 replies

WinterCarlisle · 19/06/2023 18:36

This is something that’s been bugging me since I was at secondary school.

WHY are so many of the set texts so bloody depressing? When I was at school (mid to late 80s) we did A Kestrel for a Knave which was pretty tragic swiftly followed by Z for Zachariah which was utterly terrifying. They were no fun AT ALL to real and tbh I’m still a bit traumatised <dramatic>.

My DS is 13 and has just finished The Boy in The Striped Pyjamas and they’ve now moved onto A Monster Calls. He’s quite a sensitive boy and he’s really not liking the second one at all, especially as a family friend recently died of cancer in her mid 40s.

Obviously I understand that they need to explore different themes and life isn’t all jolly but AIBU that maybe a few cheerful books might encourage them to read a bit more rather than DOOOOOOOMMMMM??

So:

YABU - Buck up kids, stop being Wet Hens and just read about life’s depressing abyss

YANBU - There’s enough doom and gloom already in this world. Let’s read some cheerful, yet literary books while we’re at school

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 20/06/2023 20:16

I'd not call A Wizard Of Earthsea feminist, but the later books in the series become increasingly so. Particularly from Tehanu onward, when she starts picking apart the concepts of the first book

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 20:14

@Kanaloa Yes, I see what you mean. Books should try to present their subjects truthfully without telling you what to think. It's part of the pleasure of fiction to make your own mind up.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 20:07

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 20:03

@Kanaloa I had forgotten those descriptions! It must be 20 years since I read it. My abiding impression was that the author was a clever woman but a bit of a cold fish.

I just felt like it was written specifically for somebody to pick out fertility and feminism symbolism and write an essay on it. I’m not keen when an author bashes you over the head with the themes. I much prefer books or short stories or whatever that allow you to find the themes and message by yourself rather than literally spelling it out. I always think the very best authors trust their reader, and clumsy writers often treat their reader as if they’re too stupid to get their very clever concept. To me the whole novel reads like a feminist wanted to write her feminist manifesto and make a point but in novel form. I felt just the same about Surfacing. It felt like it was written to teach young English uni students how to write an essay on eco-feminism, rather than to be a good novel.

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 20:03

@Kanaloa I had forgotten those descriptions! It must be 20 years since I read it. My abiding impression was that the author was a clever woman but a bit of a cold fish.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 20:03

When I say a Korean novel - it was written by a third generation American but all about a Korean family who had just come to America. Really interesting and actually quite well written about the struggles of trying to keep your hand on your culture/your parents’ culture while assimilating to the culture where you live. But that one obvious mistake of a younger brother constantly calling his sister by the name a girl would call a sister rather than a boy just spoiled it for me.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 19:59

My issue with The Handmaid’s Tale wasn’t the prurient thing though - I felt like it was excessively clumsy. All the detailed descriptions of the Martha people cutting into the fruit and flowers and describing the juices and seeds etc. Felt like a some English teacher’s wet dream as they frantically scribbled down symbolism notes. Not me obviously, some other English teacher.

MadeInChorley · 20/06/2023 19:57

Remembering back to Y7 English at my school we did Mrs Frisby And The Rats of Nimh. The vivisection theme was topical with the Body Shop’s campaigns against animal testing.

The English teachers produced a huge reading list by year group with suggestions for literary books we might like to try at home. I devoured the books on there. It had a lot of mid-century woman writers - Ursula Le Guin’s fantasy A Wizard Of Earthsea, The L Shaped Room by Lynn Reid Banks, A Taste of Honey by Shelagh Delaney and Beryl Bainbridge’s The Bottle Factory Outing. All very feminist texts. Are these ever studied now?

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 19:55

Pieceofpurplesky · 20/06/2023 19:47

@user9630721458 we do Gaiman's The Graveyard Book - the kids love it.

Oh fantastic, I think Gaiman is great. Macabre but funny. I haven't introduced my children to this one, but I think I will now you have recommended.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 19:54

SerafinasGoose · 20/06/2023 18:52

I'm laughing at Enid Blyton's 'too pi for words!'

Someone upthread asked: Can someone please explain why they think The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas shouldn't be taught? It must be 10yrs plus since I read it so I can't remember much about it besides the basics.

A variety of reasons.

It's a variation on the theme of 'Holocaust for the masses'; the monetization and romanticisation of an atrocious historical event. This in the eyes of quite a number of Jewish critics, in particular. 'A comforting fairytale that saves us from confronting the truth of history', said Phyllis Lassner.

Another variation on the theme of anti-Semitism: the presence of the lice. Too close to the polluting presence of the Jew? Awful.

It's fantasy. Fantasy fiction and the Holocaust are not easy bedfellows, and at university the reasons for this might be unpicked, but at Level 3 and below this is quite a challenging task. Ie. no boy would be sitting beside the perimeter fence, or likely alive inside the complex at all, because children/pregnant women were taken immediately to the gas chambers.

The 'different but the same' narrative - even down to the boys' sharing of the same birthday. They were really not.

'Lines will divide us, but hope will unite us', says the movie strapline. Not really. If Bruno is entirely ignorant of the purpose of 'the farm', as readers are led to believe, there's not really much of a lesson to be learned. Plus ... the ending.

The two-dimensional, lazily stereotypical characters (good doctor, maternal women, genocidal men) which all cluster around the themes of 'good Nazi, bad Nazi'. In fairness to the film, it did a better job of complicating these oversimplifications a bit: it's one of the occasions where IMO the film was better than the book. But most of the problems still persist. As for the novel, it shies away from any suggestion that the Nazis were 'just like us' (imagine?) - they have to be an evil 'other'. The problems with this are obvious.

Aside from this, there are other, better Holocaust texts that are less patronising to their readers - even to a child reader. Solomon Perel's Europa Europa would be a much better choice.

Also, and I know this is a random nitpicky thing, the writer obviously did only the most basic research. Silly things like Bruno mishearing the word ‘Fuhrer’ as ‘fury.’ Obviously it’s supposed to be a cutesy/poignant mishearing of a young child, but why would Bruno, who presumably is speaking German as his mother tongue, mishear a German word meaning ‘leader’ for an English word which means ‘anger?’ Fury is ‘wut’ in German. Or ‘zorn.’ Why would Bruno hear the English word ‘fury?’ And it is presented as the word meaning anger, I think to encourage the reader to associate Hitler with anger/fury. But it makes no sense in the context.

It’s such a small thing, but I think if you’re writing about huge issues belonging to another culture or country, you simply have to get it correct. I had a similar experience reading a Korean novel where the Korean narrator is using incorrect Korean words. It was cringey and put me off the whole book because it felt like it wouldn’t be so taxing to do the very basic research into a language you’re using.

Pieceofpurplesky · 20/06/2023 19:47

@user9630721458 we do Gaiman's The Graveyard Book - the kids love it.

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 19:42

@SerafinasGoose I love The Road, but was haunted for weeks. Interesting what you say about Handmaid's Tale, it's years since I read it. Can you say a bit more about the prurience if you don't mind? On modernists - Langston Hughes comes to mind. For fantasy there is also Neil Gaiman, though I don't know how suitable he is for KS3.

salmonlinguineplease · 20/06/2023 19:13

I understood OP, I think it's just that these themes make thought provoking books. I always looked at " love reading for kids" when buying English books for my children. ( lived in Europe so couldn't use the library) It's a running joke, that they say, good book mum, but really sad and somebody died.

SerafinasGoose · 20/06/2023 19:12

V for Vendetta might be a good one, too! Why not graphic novels if they want to study dystopia, they are a pretty subversive genre. There's also 'Maus' on the Holocaust, or The Watchmen.

SerafinasGoose · 20/06/2023 19:10

Agree with the points about Shirley Jackson, she's having a bit of a resurgence lately. 'We have always lived in the castle' is a better book than 'I capture the castle', which is a variation on the typical privileged white marriage plot novel, although I confess I quite like reading the latter.

Ulysses - the 'Cyclops' episode from Homer works well in the corresponding one from Ulysses with the Citizen and Bloom having an argument in the pub. I don't like teaching just extracts but it seems to be more the common practice these days.

The sadly recently late Cormac McCarthy is wonderful - The Road is a masterpiece although happy it ain't - I also love the dystopian work of Octavia Butler. I'd teach these, Burdekin's Swastika Night and Atwood's Oryx and Crake, or even Cameron's The Terminator before I'd ever touch The Handmaid's Tale, which is an offensively prurient text that I hate.

Harper Lee has problematic connotations with white saviour narrative. I'd ditch her in favour of Toni Morrison, Arundhati Roy, or Yvonne Battle-Felton's Remembered which was recently nominated for the women's prize.

Instead of Dickens, (or the Great Gatsby yet again), I might be tempted by a bit of Evelyn Waugh. NOT Brideshead, but his commentary on the bright young things and the cynical media age is good fun and pretty topical too. Scoop! might be good for this, otherwise Vile Bodies is a great novel with a not-too-bad film adaptation.

World War I texts - Helen Zenna Smith's Not So Quiet, or Anand's Across the Dark Water for me.

Poetry - the Out of Bounds anthology covering regional areas of multicultural Britain, or the modernists might be good here. Not Mina Loy - she's too difficult for that level.

We definitely do need some decolonization, I think.

PlatBilledDuckypuss · 20/06/2023 19:05

An Inspector Calls put both our DCs (who did the damn thing 5 years apart) off Eng. Lit for life and I can't say I blame them.

SerafinasGoose · 20/06/2023 18:52

I'm laughing at Enid Blyton's 'too pi for words!'

Someone upthread asked: Can someone please explain why they think The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas shouldn't be taught? It must be 10yrs plus since I read it so I can't remember much about it besides the basics.

A variety of reasons.

It's a variation on the theme of 'Holocaust for the masses'; the monetization and romanticisation of an atrocious historical event. This in the eyes of quite a number of Jewish critics, in particular. 'A comforting fairytale that saves us from confronting the truth of history', said Phyllis Lassner.

Another variation on the theme of anti-Semitism: the presence of the lice. Too close to the polluting presence of the Jew? Awful.

It's fantasy. Fantasy fiction and the Holocaust are not easy bedfellows, and at university the reasons for this might be unpicked, but at Level 3 and below this is quite a challenging task. Ie. no boy would be sitting beside the perimeter fence, or likely alive inside the complex at all, because children/pregnant women were taken immediately to the gas chambers.

The 'different but the same' narrative - even down to the boys' sharing of the same birthday. They were really not.

'Lines will divide us, but hope will unite us', says the movie strapline. Not really. If Bruno is entirely ignorant of the purpose of 'the farm', as readers are led to believe, there's not really much of a lesson to be learned. Plus ... the ending.

The two-dimensional, lazily stereotypical characters (good doctor, maternal women, genocidal men) which all cluster around the themes of 'good Nazi, bad Nazi'. In fairness to the film, it did a better job of complicating these oversimplifications a bit: it's one of the occasions where IMO the film was better than the book. But most of the problems still persist. As for the novel, it shies away from any suggestion that the Nazis were 'just like us' (imagine?) - they have to be an evil 'other'. The problems with this are obvious.

Aside from this, there are other, better Holocaust texts that are less patronising to their readers - even to a child reader. Solomon Perel's Europa Europa would be a much better choice.

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 15:00

Sorry OP, my comment wasn't very relevant. I do think books and the media generally have taken a depressing and vacuous turn. I believe it would be healthier for children to have a mix of inspirational and funny texts.

user9630721458 · 20/06/2023 14:58

I reckon you could get away with short passages from Ulysses, which had my 12 year old in stitches. I am all for eclectic, and happy for them to read Hunger Games, Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde and Wimpy kid for comfort reading. As a parent I am happy my children love to read and they learn so much from even a lightweight text. There are some fabulous suggestions from teachers on here, Shirley Jackson is great @viques! I think the main thing is that kids enjoy reading, which may/or may not lead them to explore more challenging reading later on.

Piggywaspushed · 20/06/2023 12:46

When we did have a lovely comparative unit (20?) years ago, I paired Jane Eyre and Paddy Clarke HaHaHa which worked really well. Rites of passage stories work well on the whole. That's why R and J remains popular, why The Crucible works and why P'Tang Yang Kipperbang made them laugh.

clary · 20/06/2023 11:35

This is a fascinating thread and it is really really brilliant to read everyone's opinions, both those of Eng teachers and those like me who just love reading!

Apols for my Little Women suggestion - agree that no 14 yo boy would enjoy that, I was just trying to think of cheery books I enjoyed in my teens Grin

Celeste Ng is a great suggestion; is there any place for a memoir? I have recently read I am I am I am by the fabulous Maggie O Farrell and while it is about all the times she almost died (!) it is genuinely life affirming. Also read a memoir by a heart surgeon which made me cry, it was so moving and powerful.

Katherine Mansfield short stories is another one i thought of - lots to analyse but reasonably happy (at least, no death). At The Bay and The Garden Party for example. Or Bliss.

Kanaloa · 20/06/2023 11:19

@CoffeeCantata

Why was Enid Blyton banned? I mean to be fair I was shocked when reading Malory Towers to DD at how bloody awful those girls are. I wanted to be Darrell and be best friends with Alicia and on a reread I thought they were rude and mean little madams. Maybe I noticed it more because in real life I would very much be a Gwen 😂

I agree with the idea that students should be allowed more freedoms. It’s difficult to balance but for some students I think a different type of English could be taught. Wading through complex literary themes just isn’t necessary for everyone. But then at the same time you don’t want to start cutting down people’s options when they’re 13/14 and leaving them not able to change or develop. But it’s very difficult to balance a class with some students who are incredibly passionate about all and any literature and some students who are barely literate and hate reading. It would be nice if the students that struggled got a more supportive curriculum rather than complex and difficult texts to read.

CoffeeCantata · 20/06/2023 11:10

I think one thing many people (especially those who are great readers themselves) don’t really understand is that, when you teach English, maybe 4 or 5 kids in the class are readers. Maybe. Probably half the class won’t be. Or if they are, they’ll be readers of YA series or manga novels. A lot of people (I noticed this in training) kind of think teaching English will be like a uni seminar or something from Dead Poet’s Society, with passionate discussions of Dickens and poetry. But in fact, it’s a core subject which is mandatory for all students. That means a huge number of them won’t really be interested in literature or English as a subject. Setting a text like Great Expectations or Thomas Hardy novels, which are really hard to read, would be almost impossible, because more than half the class would be instantly turned off by the difficult language and sheer length.I think one thing many people (especially those who are great readers themselves) don’t really understand is that, when you teach English, maybe 4 or 5 kids in the class are readers. Maybe. Probably half the class won’t be. Or if they are, they’ll be readers of YA series or manga novels. A lot of people (I noticed this in training) kind of think teaching English will be like a uni seminar or something from Dead Poet’s Society, with passionate discussions of Dickens and poetry. But in fact, it’s a core subject which is mandatory for all students. That means a huge number of them won’t really be interested in literature or English as a subject. Setting a text like Great Expectations or Thomas Hardy novels, which are really hard to read, would be almost impossible, because more than half the class would be instantly turned off by the difficult language and sheer length.

I agree, Kanaloa.

I love literature and went to an academic grammar school, so yes, finding out that my classes in a big inner-city comprehensive weren't always like that was a learning experience!

But I'm passionate about the pleasure that reading can give to everyone at the level they want to access it. When I worked in a school library I was very much against the policing of children's personal choices (stopping non-academic boys from taking out 'Wimpy Kid', for example). Yes, there are set texts which you have to read but other than that, as long as youngsters are getting pleasure from reading, I'm with Neil Gaiman on letting them make their own choices. We're not all aiming to be literary critics. I remember from my own schooldays being forbidden to read Enid Blyton when everyone loved her books.

(In fact (a whole nother subject...) I wish students who don't enjoy academic work were still allowed to leave school earlier and start training or studying for what they actually want to do. I don't see the point of forcing every child through the canon of English literature, much as I love it myself. But that's off topic...)

Wilburisagirl · 20/06/2023 10:55

@Quinoawoman to be honest I'm not really sure. In general I think there is less resilience in young people these days. But also more awareness and chatter about mental health. Once perhaps such students simply dropped out of school and we never truly knew why?

I also think the increasing globalisation of the news cycle brought on by social media has made the world seem scarier. We now don't just hear about the local bad news, but we're bombarded constantly about war, famine, violence all around the world. I think for many young people who are just starting to become more aware of the world, things can seem really overwhelmingly negative and that is very draining.

Personally, I prefer to turn off the news and keep reading psychological thrillers Grin

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 20/06/2023 10:45

I think the pairing a classic book with a more modern one (maybe more children's/YA) one is good, but it does mean more work if you study them both. I think we might have read The Merrybegot alongside The Crucible (I don't think we did witch trials twice, but maybe we did).

I remember one piece of homework when we did R&J in Year 9 was to find another book with the same themes — I know I chose The Magicians of Caprona (I love a bit of Diana Wynne Jones!) but I think across the class only a handful of books were picked by more than one person.

Winniewonka · 20/06/2023 10:36

@Viques - Yes, Midwich Cuckoos was one of the popular choices. It encouraged us to look at his other works whereas I wouldn't have dreamed of reading anything apart from Agatha Christie or Jean Plaidy in my spare time😀