Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think pricing these houses the same amount is unrealistic and which would you buy!?

136 replies

Yorkshirebornand · 19/06/2023 17:42

So there are 2 houses in an area I’ve been looking in, they are both sides of a semi detached. One is ready to move in to, quite neutral and doesn’t appear to need much work. The other is INCREDIBLY dated, needs everything doing, the only advantage I can see is that it is the ‘end’ plot and as such would have room to extend. The estate agent has put them both on at the same price, which is actually quite high for the area anyway. Is the potential to extend worth that much money? Im torn, I don’t need to extend tbh but would probably be looking to move again in about 5 years so thinking of resale price etc. WWYD?

OP posts:
FeliciteFaff · 19/06/2023 20:26

Extra land. Buy it it’ll be a labour of love. Oh I’m v jealous!! Don’t buy the done up one. It’s boring AF.

Trying2understand · 19/06/2023 20:23

A house is only worth what someone is willing to pay. Just because it's listed at a price it doesn't mean buyers think it's worth that.

I also think sometimes there's reasons it's hard for a seller to admit theirs isn't worth as much based on factors like how updated etc. Case in point near me a semi recently sold for more than a detached by about 100k. But the semi had really lovely features and a good layout, plus longer garden space and a closer walk to transit. The detached was a very in your face property, set closer to the road, smaller garden and just more difficult to update with features a family would want.

Out of the two I think the one needing updating has a far better layout, room type than the updated one. Far better.

WonderingWanda · 19/06/2023 20:00

The doer up just needs decorating and a new kitchen bathroom, it's hardly full scale renovation. It also has the huge advantage of space to extend and significantly improve it's value.

Retrain12345 · 19/06/2023 19:52

I really dislike the done one, I would have to rip everything out. It’s certainly not recently done, more like 20 years ago.

I love the doer upper.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/06/2023 19:36

I'd snatch up the doer-upper as fast as possible. The "done" one isn't that great -- that horrid fireplace and kitchen, ugh, and the bathroom is naff.

Those old doors and other features in the non-renovated house are very charming, and the staircase seems nicer on that side. I would want a downstairs loo at some point though. Looks like there is room for one.

I'd get hard flooring throughout and use big area rugs. Those partial glass doors between the living and dining are charming.

For the toilet closet upstairs, get one of those cistern things that have a handbasin built in, or knock it all together when you can afford it.

Thatbloomindog · 19/06/2023 19:36

Oh wow. The doer upper for sure. The ‘done one’ isn’t to my taste and not high spec so would have to be ‘done’ again anyway.
the doer upper has a fab plot.
blimey you’d add £200k to the price where I am. I need to move to Bradford

BackAgainstWall · 19/06/2023 19:35

My view is completely different.

Generally ex-authority houses on estates usually have a price ceiling.

Never under estimate the cost of high quality building work. Material prices have gone up by 25% and a skilled builder (not a have a go Joe), will also be very expensive.

If you want to move in 5 years because of the area - option 1 is definitely better. A few easy cosmetic changes and a hassle free 5 years, without spending tens of thousands of pounds and only breaking-even (due to economic crisis).

If you want to stay in the area very long term, and don’t mind a long term project (money depending), then I would go for the doer upper with potential. To realise your asset, you would have to wait for an up-turn in the economy, but so what it will happen eventually (there’s always a cycle), and you will gain in the long term.

SunscreenCentral · 19/06/2023 19:35

Not everyone wants a mahoosive garden and all the work/time it would take to manage it.

That said, this is a no brainer for me.

OhmygodDont · 19/06/2023 19:32

Could both be up because the done one lives next door to elderly parents who needed care. Elderly parent dies so selling both to get something bigger or just away.

AlbertaAnnie · 19/06/2023 19:26

Much prefer the doer upper! So much nicer!

NotLovingWFH · 19/06/2023 19:24

I much prefer the doer upper it’s just brighter and the plot is huge in comparison. Unless there were significant reasons why I couldn’t do the work it’s definitely property one for me.

LindorDoubleChoc · 19/06/2023 19:22

Even without the advantage of the plot and the chance to extend in this case, doer-upper houses are not "worth" that much less than done-up houses unless they are really derelict or have structural issues. Many buyers want to do their own work on a house and so they attract a premium of their own.

BreadInCaptivity · 19/06/2023 19:22

The fixer upper -assuming you have the budget to fix it (even if you don't want to extend).

Much better plot and if you do want to sell in the future you could do so with planning permission for a huge extension that would add further value (though I'd be looking to extend anyway).

Personally I don't think the "done" property is that "done" and you'd spend a lot more on it than you think - money you won't really get back.

Yorkshirebornand · 19/06/2023 19:20

madeinmanc · 19/06/2023 18:20

Any possible reason why they're both selling at the same time? Hopefully not a new development planned nearby etc.

Nothing that I’m aware of- though maybe the dated one could be from an elderly person. I wondered if they are selling now due to the possible drop in the market coming

OP posts:
HunterHearstHelmsley · 19/06/2023 19:18

The more modern one is more 'hun' than 'done'.

Most people would want to re-decorate anyway, to be fair.

Loads of extra space in the more dated one and both need a spruce up

Doggymummar · 19/06/2023 19:17

Definitely the empty one, the other is grim

Yorkshirebornand · 19/06/2023 19:17

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/06/2023 18:22

Plots say it all tbf.

Wow! You’ve marked out what was staring me in the face (but I failed to grasp! 🤦‍♀️) thabk you!!

OP posts:
HotdogCat · 19/06/2023 19:17

Curlygirl06 · 19/06/2023 18:21

Blimey, we've done up a lot of houses over the years and nearly every one has had that kitchen! They must have been churning them out in bulk.

I have a kitchen very much like that 😂 we have painted the doors bright white and the handles black though! Also replaced the worktop and new tiles and new Lino. We just couldn’t justify the cost to replace the whole thing when we moved in a couple of years ago. Did the worktop and tiles ourselves. Think we paid less than £500 all together. The cabinets are rock solid though, they just won’t die! Hopefully have enough saved to rip it all out and redo the lot next year

Yorkshirebornand · 19/06/2023 19:14

OhmygodDont · 19/06/2023 18:13

Plot twist ops selling the done one 😬😂

😂 I’d be moving next door judging by the replies on here!! 😂

OP posts:
KnickerlessParsons · 19/06/2023 19:13

There's nothing actually wrong with the doer upper, it's in good nick, but some people would want to modernise it.
I don't like the done up one either. I'd want to redo it all anyway, so I'd go for the one with the bigger garden.

MuchTooTired · 19/06/2023 19:09

The fixer upper for sure for me!! Huge plot, that bathroom suite is amazing (to my eyes!) and it looks bright and airy.

The ‘done’ one looks to be tired and a bit gloomy to me. Could just be terrible photos by the agents.

DoeRayMe · 19/06/2023 19:08

Can't believe those prices but then I'm in London!

So jealous 🥺

User19844666884 · 19/06/2023 19:07

Wow that plot is AMAZING. I think it will go for a lot more than the asking price.

saraclara · 19/06/2023 19:06

I can't imagine why you're questioning this at all. It's absolutely clear that the one with all that land is worth more.

There must be some backstory that we're not aware of?

IhearyouClemFandango · 19/06/2023 19:05

The 'done' one is very dated!

Other one has a lovely plot with a big garden, that'd be my pick.