Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong here? Stepchildren

321 replies

feghs111 · 19/06/2023 12:31

My partner has two children aged 18 and 16 from his previous marriage and they live with us 50/50 (week on/week off).

This week is our week, however two weeks ago my OH found out he had to go abroad for work this week. He thought he would turn it into a nice trip with the kids though (he would have to work a bit in the days but they could chill by the pool etc and they could all spend time together in between) and asked them along. SS16 said yes as he has just finished his GCSEs but SS18 said no as he works full-time (left school at 16) and recently went on holiday with his friends and therefore didn't want to take anymore time off. Fair enough, but I asked OH if his mum could look after him for the week rather than stay with me here as I'm super busy at work, don't really have time to be cooking meals in the evening etc (I can just do quick things for me but I would feel under pressure to make food for him when he is home from work etc). Selfishly I was also looking forward to the peace of the place to myself for a week as I never get that.

Unfortunately OH and his ex aren't on the best terms so OH asked SS18 two weeks ago to talk to his mum and see if it was OK he stayed with her the extra week. He said he had spoken to her and she said yes. We confirmed with him again on Thursday last week and he said it was all sorted.

Yesterday was change over day and it transpires SS hadn't asked her at all and just dropped it on her that he wasn't coming back to dad's for the week and was staying with her. She then sends OH a mean voice message saying how he's a terrible parent, always shirking his responsibilities (not true at all, he is a great dad), has no respect for her time etc etc. I do understand why she is put out as she obviously didn't know that the older son was staying with her longer, but we really did think it was all cleared with her as we checked twice.

Also she knew OH had asked SS18 to come with him but he had said no, so she would have known he wasn't in the country this week.

I just feel sorry for my OH as she says really harsh things to him but I think she is overreacting here. OH will send SS18 money for whatever he needs this week.

I have now offered to have SS here but I think that will just cause even more drama!

Do you think we are in the wrong here? Maybe OH should have confirmed with her too but SS is 18 not 8 after all so we should be able to trust him when he says he had cleared it with his mum.

OP posts:
Yousee · 19/06/2023 16:21

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 19/06/2023 15:55

18 or not, he's still alternating between his parents' 2 homes, and your DH should have made arrangements for him to stay elsewhere if you didn't want to watch him and ensured it wasn't an issue, or you were going to have to step up to cover your DH

YABU because your DH clearly didn't talk to his ex and that's on him and his ex has every right to be cross about it.

"Watch him"?
He's 18! Can you imagine the humiliation of being farmed out to a babysitter at that age because your own mother requires you to leave the home you are currently staying in?
Ex has a cheek to be "cross".

feralunderclass · 19/06/2023 16:20

Feel very sorry for the 18 year old 'child' who is viewed as a burden in both homes.

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/06/2023 16:12

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 19/06/2023 12:33

As an 18 year old surely he just comes and goes in either house as he pleases?

Why do you even need set weeks?

This - he's an adult.

Plus, can he not get his own food?

Behindthelines · 19/06/2023 16:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/06/2023 16:02

I imagine the kids thought it was "disconcerting" to have to bounce between households for many years.

Surely you can put up with the "uncertainty" about who will be home/food shopping for a couple of years until he gets his own place or a flat share?

I feel sorry for the young man.

CosmosQueen · 19/06/2023 15:57

PixieLaLa · 19/06/2023 14:07

Wondering how long the 18 year old man working full time will be ‘handed over’ each week to Mummy or Daddy and have his meals cooked for him….Utterly ridiculous 😂

At least this situation highlights changes need to be made!

I’m just thankful that my DCs at 18 could cook, do their own washing etc and had to because they were at university!
Yes I would do it for them sometimes when they were at home but they’d also cook a meal for everyone and do the washing if there was a full load.

LorW · 19/06/2023 15:57

He’s 18 and working full time he can buy and cook his own food so I wouldn’t stress about that 🥴

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 19/06/2023 15:55

18 or not, he's still alternating between his parents' 2 homes, and your DH should have made arrangements for him to stay elsewhere if you didn't want to watch him and ensured it wasn't an issue, or you were going to have to step up to cover your DH

YABU because your DH clearly didn't talk to his ex and that's on him and his ex has every right to be cross about it.

altmember · 19/06/2023 15:54

As weird as it is for parents to still be maintaining a shared care type rota for an adult, it's step son's fault for lying about asking his mum when he didn't. He probably lied to her to cover up for not asking her either. He's an adult, he needs to accept responsibility for what he's done - go and tell his mother that it's all his fault and that he'd lied to his dad about asking.

And if he does choose to stay with you, he should be cooking for you half the time.

VaddaABeetch · 19/06/2023 15:46

So 3 adults are running around stressing about the meals of another adult?

JMKid · 19/06/2023 15:43

They are 16 and 18, why are they not getting to decide what contact they want and why does an 18 year old need looking after!!

Oioicaptain · 19/06/2023 15:42

Turning it on its head, why would his own mother resent him staying for longer with her. Surely at 18 she is not going to need a break from him. He's her own son.

clpsmum · 19/06/2023 15:38

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 19/06/2023 12:33

As an 18 year old surely he just comes and goes in either house as he pleases?

Why do you even need set weeks?

This

Mariposa26 · 19/06/2023 15:35

I can’t believe at 18 you are having to agree who “looks after him” for the week. He’s an adult!

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 15:34

The SS is in the wrong here for failing to sort himself out when he’s an adult and lying to you about it.

babbscrabbs · 19/06/2023 15:33

Blossomtoes · 19/06/2023 14:24

If they are going back and forth with no general plan then how do you know how much food to get in, for example?

Well stocked freezer.

Not everyone has a big freezer or the money to stock it.

Personally I think it's only courteous to let the house owner / food provider know when you'll be there or not.

Whether you're a child living with both parents, step child, or adult child coming back for the weekend.

I wouldn't have dreamt of just leaving or rocking up to my parents without letting them know in advance.

Dogstar78 · 19/06/2023 15:30

I am know a similar boat. If it is just me and step-daughter home. I make her something if it is just as easy. If not, or I am out I tell her she is on her own, but outline some options- looking is not one of her strong points. She is home from uni and working a lot of the time. She spends 98% of her time with us. Do I sometimes want the house to myself? Yes, don't we all, but it is her home. Am sure she wishes the same sometimes!!

Hayliebells · 19/06/2023 15:28

phoenixrosehere · 19/06/2023 14:38

Why?

They asked him since he is 18 if he would ask his mum and he said he had and she had no problem with it. They asked him a second time to confirm and he said yes. It is not on them that they trusted a legal adult at their word and he lied to them twice and told his mum instead of asking her like he said he had.

I’m curious on why his mum is making a fuss over it and not her adult child just dropping this on her and lying to his father and stepmother who he confirmed this with.

If he’s capable of having a job and has the thought process to turn down his father because he knew he already went on holiday and didn’t want to take time off, he should also be capable to follow through on what he was asked which makes me wonder if there is a reason he didn’t ask his mum, possibly even knew she would react like this regardless if he was ok with it or not.

Because during that week, it's his home. Yes it's unfortunate for the OP that she can't have the house to herself, but she doesn't get the house to herself that week because another person lives in the house. Not all of the occupants of the house have not vacated the house during that week, only two of the four of them are away on holiday/work. Yes, DS shouldn't have told them his mum was OK he was staying with her when she wasn't, but that's all he's done wrong. He should never have been put in the position where he was expected to ask her.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 19/06/2023 15:23

feghs111 · 19/06/2023 14:21

Thanks again everyone for all the messages, appreciate them!

For those asking if the ex might have had a date, she's married but her husband works away for months at a time. He's currently away so she's home alone and you would think she might like the company!

Taking on board everyone's comments things need to change, but I am curious with how you sort out general life with kids (or in this case an adult) coming and going as they please. If they live with you full time then I understand as you will know that generally your children will always be home, but I would find it quite diconcerting never knowing who was going to be at home and who wasn't from one day to the next.

If they are going back and forth with no general plan then how do you know how much food to get in, for example? My OH does a big food shop the weeks we have them and then less when we don't, but if they could just turn up whenever how would that work? I doubt all children stock the home with their own food from the supermarket, even if they do cook for themselves.

Genuinely asking for advice!

With food we have basics in all the time, but if our teens (who were mostly here 100% of the time) are going to be in for dinner then you let us know the night before to be guaranteed a share of the meal being cooked by whoever is cooking.

If you’re not going to be in on your night of cooking (everyone has a turn here) then two nights notice to everyone, or a swap, is required for it not to be rude (obviously unexpected/emergency events being tbt exception).

You do get used to them coming and going with less strict regularity.

Reugny · 19/06/2023 15:19

To answer your question about adult SC - after 16 we stayed in the parents home we decided to live in before then.

So if that parent went on holiday we fended for ourselves. Other relations and the other parent would check on us if we were all alone, but we were mature enough to look after ourselves.

Notcontent · 19/06/2023 15:19

Puppers · 19/06/2023 14:56

What happens when most kids turn 18? Do they just get shown the door and told they can visit by arrangement? Not in my experience. There's usually a period of time where they still live at home because they're finding their feet, getting established at work or going to uni, then at some point they will officially move out and start renting or whatever.

This lad has 2 homes because his parents are divorced. Should he be kicked out of both as he's now turned 18? Or is his mum now solely responsible for housing him while he is only expected to be able to "visit" his dad by prior arrangement?

Of course he shouldn't be living at either of his parents homes forever, but until he's an established adult and has moved out independently, he still lives at both his parents homes. Nobody would bat an eyelid at this if he was an 18yr old who's parents were still together.

Spot on. I have a 17 year old DD. My home is her home for as long as she wants it/needs it. It’s her home as much as mine. Of course one day that will change - and once she is fully moved out, she will ask me before just turning up. But that’s not the position now.

FlissyPaps · 19/06/2023 15:11

He doesn't need looking after no, but in general myself and OH both cook for the kids when they are here and it's just come to be expected. He could obviosuly cook himself a ready meal or whatver but I can't see him cooking a full meal when he gets home.

An 18 year old won’t/can’t cook a full meal for themselves?? That’s pathetic.

Why are you allowing this to happen?

Tell the grown adult to cook his own meals Jesus wept.

AliceOlive · 19/06/2023 15:10

It's a very hard thing to navigate between two parents who cannot get along with one another. He didn't ask her for a reason.

You cannot really control or predict the behavior of someone that is unreasonable. You are neither right nor wrong, but it doesn't even matter anyway.

But here you all are...You have to just learn to expect difficulties whenever she is involved.

It's interesting that he's in a position of being old enough to be expected to carry messages between parents but not mature enough to fend for himself.

I think it's time to gradually change the dynamic around meals in your house. I would tell him he can come and go as he chooses, but that he is now of an age that he should be pitching in for meals and also fending for himself. If he's not taking care of his own laundry and other household chores, it's time for that to start also.

aloris · 19/06/2023 15:01

If he needs to eat ready meals, that's ok. He can defrost meat if he wants it. Does he know how to cook at all? Scrambled eggs? Pancakes from a mix? Rice and beans? This week seems like good practice for independence. You're there in case there's an emergency but he can look after himself for the week. He can even go to the shop and get raw meat if he wants to cook it!

Susuwatariandkodama · 19/06/2023 14:59

He is 18? I don’t understand why anyone needs to look after him? He can look after himself and cook his one meals surely?

Swipe left for the next trending thread