Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is in the wrong here? Stepchildren

321 replies

feghs111 · 19/06/2023 12:31

My partner has two children aged 18 and 16 from his previous marriage and they live with us 50/50 (week on/week off).

This week is our week, however two weeks ago my OH found out he had to go abroad for work this week. He thought he would turn it into a nice trip with the kids though (he would have to work a bit in the days but they could chill by the pool etc and they could all spend time together in between) and asked them along. SS16 said yes as he has just finished his GCSEs but SS18 said no as he works full-time (left school at 16) and recently went on holiday with his friends and therefore didn't want to take anymore time off. Fair enough, but I asked OH if his mum could look after him for the week rather than stay with me here as I'm super busy at work, don't really have time to be cooking meals in the evening etc (I can just do quick things for me but I would feel under pressure to make food for him when he is home from work etc). Selfishly I was also looking forward to the peace of the place to myself for a week as I never get that.

Unfortunately OH and his ex aren't on the best terms so OH asked SS18 two weeks ago to talk to his mum and see if it was OK he stayed with her the extra week. He said he had spoken to her and she said yes. We confirmed with him again on Thursday last week and he said it was all sorted.

Yesterday was change over day and it transpires SS hadn't asked her at all and just dropped it on her that he wasn't coming back to dad's for the week and was staying with her. She then sends OH a mean voice message saying how he's a terrible parent, always shirking his responsibilities (not true at all, he is a great dad), has no respect for her time etc etc. I do understand why she is put out as she obviously didn't know that the older son was staying with her longer, but we really did think it was all cleared with her as we checked twice.

Also she knew OH had asked SS18 to come with him but he had said no, so she would have known he wasn't in the country this week.

I just feel sorry for my OH as she says really harsh things to him but I think she is overreacting here. OH will send SS18 money for whatever he needs this week.

I have now offered to have SS here but I think that will just cause even more drama!

Do you think we are in the wrong here? Maybe OH should have confirmed with her too but SS is 18 not 8 after all so we should be able to trust him when he says he had cleared it with his mum.

OP posts:
jannier · 19/06/2023 22:49

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 22:27

@jannier oh dry your hankie. He's an 18 year old not 10. Ridiculous carrying on this nonsense of 'transfer day'

His DAD, invited him to go with him, his Mum knew his Dad was away & he didn't want to go with him. She should have assumed he'd be staying with her (as he apparently needs his meals made for him) & why should the OP be lumbered with that?? He didn't want to go with parent 1, so parent 2 is the default, NOT the OP.

it's sad that both 'children' and both parents haven't sorted this ridiculous situation out long before now, it's not up to the OP to pick up their slack.

Why treat him as a child he's an adult and needs to cook his own food and do his own washing ....if he was 18 living with mum and dad nobody would say you can't leave him home it's pathetic I don't see what a hankie has to do with it....both houses are his home maybe he has friends near dad's he wants to see

Buyyouflowers · 19/06/2023 22:45

It may be 50/50… which is odd a hell at 18
but if his parents isn’t around then he can stay at the other parents house.
Why would he even want to stay with his step mum anyway.

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 22:27

jannier · 19/06/2023 12:55

Isn't it sad that the son isn't treated as family but needs hosting

@jannier oh dry your hankie. He's an 18 year old not 10. Ridiculous carrying on this nonsense of 'transfer day'

His DAD, invited him to go with him, his Mum knew his Dad was away & he didn't want to go with him. She should have assumed he'd be staying with her (as he apparently needs his meals made for him) & why should the OP be lumbered with that?? He didn't want to go with parent 1, so parent 2 is the default, NOT the OP.

it's sad that both 'children' and both parents haven't sorted this ridiculous situation out long before now, it's not up to the OP to pick up their slack.

phoenixrosehere · 19/06/2023 22:20

HostaLuago · 19/06/2023 21:40

He's eighteen.

Why woud an 18 year old want to stay with his stepmother, if it were my son he would tell me to bugger off, he's staying at home.
Most lads that age don't want to go to their dad's anywhere they're elsewhere with girlfriends etc.

The mother sounds bonkers to me, insisting her adult son goes to the stepmothers.

It's all crackers

It is. I’m wondering why she’s so put out and wanting him to stay there with OP even though his dad is not there.

She mentioned about her ex having no respect for her time, but she showing she doesn’t have any respect for OP’s either when she’s expecting her son to stay with them without the father present.

Her own DH isn’t home for months at a time and currently not there now so she has the house to herself every week when her sons are with their father and OP until her DH returns. I get wanting some time to yourself as a parent but to this degree, no.

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 22:20

BlinkeredBay · 19/06/2023 12:56

Oh sorry I thought when you had 50:50 custody that both the parents had homes for their children, didn’t realise that his wife trumped his children and the home was more hers?

imagine a SD living with his SC insisting that they went elsewhere if their mother wasn’t there.

@BlinkeredBay

well as the adult of the house, paying the mortgage, it is, yes. It won't kill him to stay with his mum (as he didn't want to go with his Dad) and give the op a bit of space for the week.

hes 28, he can rent a room or do a house share if he wants to, he doesn't have to stick to this ridiculous 50:50 nonsense anymore.

Valeriekat · 19/06/2023 22:17

GameofStrife · 19/06/2023 12:35

I'm afraid you were in the wrong. He lives 50/50 meaning your home is his home. He should be able to come and go as he pleases.

He is an adult!

HostaLuago · 19/06/2023 21:40

He's eighteen.

Why woud an 18 year old want to stay with his stepmother, if it were my son he would tell me to bugger off, he's staying at home.
Most lads that age don't want to go to their dad's anywhere they're elsewhere with girlfriends etc.

The mother sounds bonkers to me, insisting her adult son goes to the stepmothers.

It's all crackers

ProfessorXtra · 19/06/2023 21:04

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 20:13

@ProfessorXtra

You said To be fair, she wouldn’t stay at mine if I wasn’t there but dp was.

that reads like she's not comfortable to me.

the difference between the OP saying she wants the house to herself & your DD saying it, is blatantly obvious, it's the OP's house in a way it's not your DD's house.

When you move in with someone with kids you know it’s everyone’s home

and for years she has welcomed them & been a step parent, cooking for them etc, but for fucks sake, she's allowed to want her house to herself for once, while their DAD is away, but their MUM is not. She's allowed not to want to work her week around a working 18 year old, who can just as easily stay with his MUM.

How it reads to you, is about you. I didn’t say you wouldn’t be comfortable. You decided that even though I didn’t say that. Just because you decide to add words in doesn’t make it true.

the difference between the OP saying she wants the house to herself & your DD saying it, is blatantly obvious, it's the OP's house in a way it's not your DD's house.

Who owns the house is irrelevant, imo. It’s just as much my dds home as it is Dps home. I wouldn’t ask dp to go elsewhere because I want the house to myself, just because I own it. That’s horrific. I find step parents who believe it’s not their step kids home when they spend half the time there, a bit odd.

I don’t think even see how it works. Is neither their home? If it’s only their home on the week they stay there, it’s still the 28 year olds home that week.

Most people would like their house to themselves for a bit. And what?

You are disregarding the hypocrisy. Op and her dh believe the 18 year old needs ‘taking care of’. If they really believe he can’t look after himself for a week, he can’t also arrange his own care. He should be able to take care of himself and make arrangements. But if I’m he isn’t matured enough to do one he isn’t mature enough to do the other.

In which case the husband that op feels sorry for should have been arranging it. Op is also participating in treating this adult like a child and talking about he needs a full cooked meal cooked by her. He absolutely doesn’t. Also, if the 18 year old needs taking care of, why does the Op and her Dh get to decide that care falls to the boys mother when it’s not her week without discussing it with her?

It sounds like they treat the 18 year old like a child when it suits. Then when it suits he is an adult.

Though I can’t believe we are discussing it in these terms for an adult.

SpainToday · 19/06/2023 20:26

There have been a few threads recently that make me suspect contact arrangements are more about parents negotiating their child-free time, rather than time with the children

SpainToday · 19/06/2023 20:24

Why on earth are you pinning this on the step-mother? His OWN mother wants him out of her home...that blows my mind. I can't imagine a scenario where I would be angry that my own 18 year old was living in OUR home.

THIS!

Olive19741205 · 19/06/2023 20:23

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 19/06/2023 16:34

So did his stepmother when she married someone with a 50/50 arrangement.

A 50/50 arrangement for an 18 year old? I don't think so 😂. It's absolutely ridiculous. Why on earth are you pinning this on the step-mother? His OWN mother wants him out of her home...that blows my mind. I can't imagine a scenario where I would be angry that my own 18 year old was living in OUR home.

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 20:13

ProfessorXtra · 19/06/2023 13:22

What do you mean I frequently make no bones about? I mentioned it was. Where it was revelant because legally I could ask him to leave and still wouldn’t. You don’t have to own a property for it to be your home.

It’s a fact. I own the property and it’s entirely Dps home. Do you know my dp and me? Because I can assure you he sees it as his home and his happy to say if he isn’t comfortable about something.

You last paragraph makes no sense at all. I didn’t say dd wouldn’t be comfortable. She may see it as a chance to spend extra time with her dad, that doesn’t mean she wouldn’t be uncomfortable in my home without me there. Op hasn’t said she is uncomfortable with her dss being there and said if the mum said no, she would have had him there.

If my dd was uncomfortable she can choose to stay elsewhere. She wouldn’t get to choose for other people (my dp) who also share the home to leave. If you are going to compare step parents and step (adult children). But you can’t really compare those. Especially when the adult child is treated like a child.

When you move in with someone with kids you know it’s everyone’s home.

@ProfessorXtra

You said To be fair, she wouldn’t stay at mine if I wasn’t there but dp was.

that reads like she's not comfortable to me.

the difference between the OP saying she wants the house to herself & your DD saying it, is blatantly obvious, it's the OP's house in a way it's not your DD's house.

When you move in with someone with kids you know it’s everyone’s home

and for years she has welcomed them & been a step parent, cooking for them etc, but for fucks sake, she's allowed to want her house to herself for once, while their DAD is away, but their MUM is not. She's allowed not to want to work her week around a working 18 year old, who can just as easily stay with his MUM.

Behindthelines · 19/06/2023 20:11

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AxolotlOnions · 19/06/2023 20:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You can use it but not recognise it... got it!

ThursdayFreedom · 19/06/2023 20:03

Blossomtoes · 19/06/2023 13:58

You’re all being unreasonable. He’s 18, ffs. He sorts out his own meals, laundry, etc. it shouldn’t make a scrap of difference where he sleeps.

@Blossomtoes

of course it does if the OP wants the house to herself while her DH is away, he can stay at his Mums (you know his PARENT).

Usernamenotavailab · 19/06/2023 19:59

Why would an 18 year old boy choose to stay the week with his step mum though?

surely you’d choose to stay with your actual parent.

issue is with mum, imo, refusing to have your adult child at home for the week and insisting on sticking with “contact” arrangements?

it’s not as if she needs to sort childcare or change her plans, he’s an adult!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 19/06/2023 19:52

Of course he should still be able to stay in your house on the week he is supposed to. It is his home that week. At 18 you don’t get kicked out of your home just because your parent is away.

thisplaceiscrazy · 19/06/2023 19:50

@ProfessorXtra

"if an 18 year old needs looking after and it’s the time he should be with his dad then his dad should arrange it’."

🤦🏽‍♀️

For goodness sake how silly. His dad offered the holiday which didn't work for the son, is sending him money for the week he's off. To suggest his dad should arrange a babysitter for an 18 year old is bizzare, I'm sure next time the dad will ask some of the local 15 year old babysitters if they are free to watch his 18 year old son before work and once he finishes work

HeckyPeck · 19/06/2023 19:47

Avondale89 · 19/06/2023 19:21

It’s the 18 year old’s home, regardless of whether his Dad was there or not. I’m sure we’d all enjoy a night off with no kids now and then, but you share a house 50% of the time with teenagers. I feel sorry for him. It’s not only his house when his dad’s there.

However, you shouldn’t be running round after him and cooking him meals. That is ridiculous.

I feel sorry for him that his own mother is annoyed at having to spend an extra week with him. Very sad.

Behindthelines · 19/06/2023 19:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

jannier · 19/06/2023 19:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

My 30 year old had his own home but he's welcome to rock up anytime he needs to he can sort out his own food, bed etc so no problems

jannier · 19/06/2023 19:41

thisplaceiscrazy · 19/06/2023 19:00

If the mother posted instead.....

50/50 custody of kids ages 16 and 18 never usually a problem. EX husband has to work away on his week and has offered to take both the kids with him. 18 year old doesn’t want to go due to full time work commitments and already been on holiday with his friends this year. Ex has said he will send money to son for while he is away working for a week. I am really annoyed and have just sent a voice message to my ex telling him how he is out of order that I now have to ‘look after’ my 18 year old son. It’s his week so I don’t see why he doesn’t stay in his other house with his stepmother so I can have my week off as usual.

I’m sure the comments would state‘ contact is for quality time with other parent and as other parent isn’t there then it makes sense for the son to stay with the mother’ , ‘ why don’t you want him with you’, ‘ he’s your son NOT the stepmothers

Contact I'd for a child not a working adult why are so many talking like he's a child no wonder why we have so many useless young adults if this is the norm.

jannier · 19/06/2023 19:38

Dixiechickonhols · 19/06/2023 16:23

I wouldn’t like the just coming and going either, It’s not practical for food shopping or locking up at night.
I can imagine shopping very different if there’s 2 teen lads sometimes especially if working one takes a packed lunch.

As adults they can feed themselves you just tell him that....what are you going to do if you have adult children who can't afford to move out say in by 10 or the doors are locked or give them a key?

Avondale89 · 19/06/2023 19:21

It’s the 18 year old’s home, regardless of whether his Dad was there or not. I’m sure we’d all enjoy a night off with no kids now and then, but you share a house 50% of the time with teenagers. I feel sorry for him. It’s not only his house when his dad’s there.

However, you shouldn’t be running round after him and cooking him meals. That is ridiculous.

jannier · 19/06/2023 19:18

NowItsLikeSnowAtTheBeach · 19/06/2023 15:55

18 or not, he's still alternating between his parents' 2 homes, and your DH should have made arrangements for him to stay elsewhere if you didn't want to watch him and ensured it wasn't an issue, or you were going to have to step up to cover your DH

YABU because your DH clearly didn't talk to his ex and that's on him and his ex has every right to be cross about it.

Watch an 18 year old

Swipe left for the next trending thread