Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about 'healthy eaters' who scoff your 'naughty' food while telling you how much harm it's doing you?

134 replies

GoldfincTart · 19/06/2023 11:45

We were away camping this weekend with friends we haven't seen for about 18 months. They talked a lot about how they'd completely overhauled their diet. Fair play, they look great on it and we could learn a few tips from them.

Their breakfast was home-made spelt crackers eaten with home-made hummus and radishes and carrot sticks. They drank herb or green tea. We had bacon sandwiches on sourdough from the wholefood shop and ordinary tea. We wouldn't normally have bacon sandwiches, but we were on holiday and had an active day planned. They were 'White bread! Bacon! Yorkshire Tea! Do you know what that's doing to your body?' — and then later in the day asked whether we could spare them a slice or two of bread with real butter, because for them it was a treat. We did. And it went on. DH and I got back from a 7-mile walk and a swim and had tea and a slice of the lemon drizzle cake I'd made. I didn't offer them any because obviously it's not the kind of thing they would eat. And next thing they were 'Oh, if it's home-made... so bad for us, but just a little slice.' Or two, as it turned out. For dinner they had a big green salad and a lentil salad. We had salmon with asparagus, spinach and Jersey Royals with lemon and butter. Although they 'never eat potatoes' they were salivating over ours and quietly finished off the rest of the Jerseys, which I'd cooked with the intention of making potato salad for the next day. They helped themselves to all our 'bad' snacks, they even asked for a coffee. 'We don't drink coffee, it's so bad for you, but if you're making one...'

Then at the end of it when we said goodbye it was 'You two are terrible with all your naughty food, it's back to healthy eating tomorrow.' So bloody rude, surely?

OP posts:
GraysPapaya · 19/06/2023 20:12

I eat healthily, BMI 21, but this is tedious!! Everyone needs a break and some joy in their lives. I never lecture anyone and it’s all about balance.
I don’t find that strict type of regime sustainable for many people in my experience. They’re still craving it which is why they nicked yours.

Lemonademoney · 19/06/2023 20:05

Can’t believe you didn’t take the piss out of them every single time! I would have literally chortled whilst polishing off my dinner

sweetdreamstenasee · 19/06/2023 20:02

I suspect you wouldn’t have a problem with sharing your food with them if they weren’t being so rude and superior in the first place. They sound like a drag. Craving lemon drizzle cake now!

JudgeJ · 19/06/2023 20:01

UnDruidlyWords · 19/06/2023 17:24

Love that film!

"What's the treat today, Keith?"
"Raw mushrooms"
"Hmm, raw mushrooms, my favourite!"

I am far from being a food bore like the OP's friends but, whisper it, raw mushrooms are actually quite nice, sliced into a bit of olive oil, garlic and black pepper.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 19/06/2023 19:46

You should have stopped them eating the leftover potatoes that you planned making a potato salad with.

Conflictedcommunication · 19/06/2023 19:41

Your dinner sounds healthier than theirs. Hooray for Yorkshire Tea.

Jezzifishie · 19/06/2023 19:39

Ah, I see you've met my in-laws.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/06/2023 19:35

There's more than a few mumsnetters like this on the diet threads. Although whether they would eat your lemon drizzle I'm not sure.

Piglet89 · 19/06/2023 19:34

@stbrandonsboat

I eat healthily, but if I'm within a sniff of something tasty I turn into an absolute gannet and can't control myself.

LOOOOOOOOL!

Tetchypants · 19/06/2023 19:34

“oi you can fuck off eating my spuds, I’m saving them for tomorrow”

“yes you can have cake on condition you stop wanging on about your sodding diet”

”caffeine kills, enjoy your herb water”

MysteryBelle · 19/06/2023 19:29

I’d drop them like hot Jersey Royals.

Startyabastard · 19/06/2023 19:23

MotherWol · 19/06/2023 18:32

This, absolutely! "No, I wouldn't want you undoing all your hard work, and besides, your spelt crackers look delicious. No, you know how terrible caffeine is, you just enjoy your herbal tea - I'll drink my cappuccino in the tent. As you say, this food is all terribly bad for you, and who would want cake when you have [dramatic pause] lentils?"

Then clear all the food up and keep it well out of reach.

Good idea. That might stop them

Startyabastard · 19/06/2023 19:21

MagicTape · 19/06/2023 14:52

I had a colleague years ago who did this. We had a staff kitchen / sofa area where people went to eat lunch and she'd come and nose into everyone's food and in a really odd oo-er Matron way would say "oooh! Naaaaaughty!" if she saw anything she thought was unhealthy. On a Friday lots of us used to go to the chip shop and she'd do this "ooh! Shall I be a DIRTY GIRL and have some!" routine in a tone of voice that suggested she'd been offered a trip to the nearest seedy sex shop. When there was chocolate / cake on offer for a birthday she'd perform a dramatic monologue about it before (always) having some.

In the end I got pissed off with her and told her that calling food naughty and dirty could cause anyone who'd had an ED to relapse. She huffed off and never spoke to me again which was a result, although I could still hear her honking away in the kitchen from where I sat.

That would greatly annoy me.
I'm a mostly healthy eater but would never dream of telling anyone else what to eat because it's none of my business. She sounds like a massive twat!

Coolhwip · 19/06/2023 19:19

Urgh they sound infuriating.

I have what many may consider a restrictive diet, and I really don't like talking about it or drawing attention to it.

I like it when people compliment on my body changes but that's it.

ripplingwater · 19/06/2023 19:11

Meh- if they're that easily persuaded, I doubt they're as angelic as they make out. I bet as soon as they got home they made a trip to Greggs 😆

bostonchamps · 19/06/2023 19:08

I know this is the extreme end of the spectrum, but I've suffered with ED since I was in my early teens are conversations around 'naughty' vs 'good' food are so triggering for me. It's such an unhealthy attitude to food. I'm so glad you didn't give in and change your eating plans because they guilted you into doing so OP!

Tryagainplease · 19/06/2023 18:51

They sound dull as fuck.
Also - since when are potatoes bad for you Confused

And - coffee is good for you. And entirely necessary.

It’s sad but so few people have good relationships with food. Your friends definitely don’t!

SchoolShenanigans · 19/06/2023 18:50

I know people like this. It gets tiring very quickly and they just don't realise how bloody rude it is.

I guarantee you, within three years they'll be back to eating the awful food daily. They won't stick it out on salads forever.

I'd just be honest with them. Can you stop saying how naughty food is to us? This is what we're choosing to eat so it just comes across rude. And even a little ridiculous given you've eaten so much of it yourselves. Let's just not talk about food?

Yazo · 19/06/2023 18:48

They're following a fad diet and it's probably miserable. Savoury breakfast sounds like one of those obsessive glucose diets where even oats and fruit juice are 'bad' they sound incredibly annoying and I'd find it hard to hang out with people like that. Food is a really joy as a balanced diet and camping is not the time for anything elaborate!

Strawberrypicnic · 19/06/2023 18:41

Why is Yorkshire Tea specifically bad for you 😅

EggInANest · 19/06/2023 18:35

They will probably calm down.

Go with them again if you otherwise have fun but be prepared. Just tell them you have brought extra portions of Heart Attack but can they bring hearty salad to share, please.

MotherWol · 19/06/2023 18:32

Goldbar · 19/06/2023 17:23

"Oh I couldn't possibly lead you from the straight and narrow. As your friend, I'd never forgive myself for sabotaging all your good efforts".

Said with a gentle smile as you firmly put the cake away or transfer the potatoes to a tupperware box.

This, absolutely! "No, I wouldn't want you undoing all your hard work, and besides, your spelt crackers look delicious. No, you know how terrible caffeine is, you just enjoy your herbal tea - I'll drink my cappuccino in the tent. As you say, this food is all terribly bad for you, and who would want cake when you have [dramatic pause] lentils?"

Then clear all the food up and keep it well out of reach.

SparklyShark · 19/06/2023 18:26

I had a housemate like this once.

Always talking about the amazing healthy food he made, then in the middle of the night would eat all of my bread! Often didn't get a slice of my own bread as he had eaten it all.

I also personally quite like cooking healthy balanced meals and reading about health benefits of different foods, but don't think I have ever felt the need to mention it to anyone (outside from my own children/this post!)

It's the combination of preachiness and cheekiness which sounds irritating.

I also remember co-workers always commenting on my lunch 'ooh you're being good', 'cheeky slice of cake' etc - the whole good Vs bad food language annoys me too. Even for my own children I would only say how some foods have xyz benefits for the body, and some others don't have those benefits so it's good to regularly make food choices which give you something which helps your body. But I would never discuss that with adults.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 19/06/2023 18:25

How did you not laugh at them?
I do eat healthily but I enjoy the more unhealthy foods too, everything in moderation and I wouldn’t dream of preaching to anyone else about what they should or shouldn’t be eating. It’s up to them.

Startyabastard · 19/06/2023 18:16

Don't waste your tasty potatoes on them next time.