Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop contact if he can’t keep to the time?

412 replies

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 10:49

My ex has our kids every other weekend but he keeps dropping them back late. It’s supposed to be 6pm but he’s usually at least twenty minutes late. It’s a long drive so I have to give them their tea and get them ready for school on Monday.

AIBU to say he can’t have them if he can’t keep to 6pm?

OP posts:
the7Vabo · 20/06/2023 09:02

Under what legal system would a parent speak as if they have the power to stop the other parent seeing they kids. The OP speaks as if she has the power to do that. Surely that’s for a court.

Their dad gets to see the kids for what - 4 days a month & his ex wants to stop that because he’s sometimes late citing that she doesn’t get to spend time with them when she has the other 26 days???!!

aviatorsrus · 20/06/2023 08:52

You clearly don't like their dad and so want to remove him from their lives so your new man and you can play happy families. You seem very angry and bitter but why???

Changechangechanging · 20/06/2023 08:39

Not read the whole thread but if that’s the only issue, yes, you’re being massively unreasonable. Your children are not something with which you can control your ex. They deserve a relationship with him. You don’t mess with that relationship unless you are sure there is a issue or neglect taking place.

ChesterAndRaoul · 20/06/2023 08:35

Honestly OP you need to take a step back and think about your own behaviour.

Cutting contact with a parent is an absolute last result, not a punishment you can use when the father isn't doing what he is told. You both have equal parental rights and responsibilities.

There are plenty of things you can do to work around this and find a way for the whole thing to work for both of you, but it will take hard work and patience and from your responses you don't seem to be interested in putting in the work.

Not everything will go your way as a co-parent, you need to learn to pick you battles and understand that every day you take a child away from their father is hurting that child.

If I were you, (as a co-parent of 11 years) I would try very hard to find a way for dad to see them more often. Then you might find he is more happy to stick to the times you so rigidly try to enforce.

Good luck!

IndigoLaFaye · 20/06/2023 08:15

You’re clearly wanting to stop the kids relationship with their dad to insert step dad and not have the hassle. I suggest you seek some support as you are still very bitter.

You call the kids Dad a Disney dad but what choice does he have when living 2hrs away? Of course he’s gonna buy them nice things and take them places. Plus if he does their homework/reading with them, that’s not really a Disney Dad. He’s taking the responsibility that he needs to.

Leaving clothes and toys at his is normal and sensible.

He only gets them 4 days a month, maybe he does bring them back slightly late but it’s at most 12 times a year. So what? You say it’s to get at you, maybe it is, maybe he just doesn’t want to say goodbye to his kids. Either way, don’t let it get to you. You can’t change other people’s actions just your reactions.

You seem to be deliberately planning stuff on those nights that make it all stressful. You can choose not to do that. Quick tea, quick bath, bed. You have the other 20 odd nights a month to see and enjoy your kids. Let go.

Why on earth would you plan a big thing for their step dad, on a night you know their dad has them? You set that one up to fail. What support did you give the kids to celebrate Father’s Day with their father? Did you help them make a card or help them buy a small gift for him or did all the effort go into the step dad? It’s the kids Dads day, I’d have expected the lateness.

I suspect you won’t listen to anything on this thread because you seem to be out to break their relationship. Let them be, unless he is actively harming them which doesn’t seem to be the case at all. If he is a dead beat dad they will come to that conclusion themselves eventually.

RedRiverSun · 20/06/2023 00:24

It's either a reverse or the bloke has had a lucky escape.

GentlemanJay · 19/06/2023 23:50

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 10:57

I’ve asked him to bring them back at 5pm instead but he won’t because he says he won’t give up time with them. But this isn’t what’s best for them.

I had a friend who used to trot out "it's not in their best interests" all the time. Used it as a stick to beat his ex wife with.

Give him a break.

Flopsythebunny · 19/06/2023 23:47

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 11:08

I’d rather it was 5pm or earlier but if it has to be 6pm then I can work around that but he’s always late. Last night I’d planned a special Father‘s Day dinner with their stepdad but they got back so late it was ruined.

Can I insist on it being 5pm and then if he’s late and it’ll actually be 6pm?

But their step dad isn't their dad so there was no. See for them to be at the dinner. They were with their dad who only gets to see them 2 days out of 14.
Stop being so selfish!

CJsGoldfish · 19/06/2023 23:17

Even if he feeds them before he sets off, they’re still going to need something to eat before bed because the journey takes up to two hours
Then you go get them 🤷‍♀️
But, no, I guess that wouldn't work for you because it's not really about what is best for the children. We can all see that OP, even those of us who had similar situations ourselves.
Being mad that your children weren't home for a 'special Fathers Day dinner' when they were actually WITH their father is ridiculous. Especially when you KNOW he's 'usually' late. Sounds like just another stick to beat him with but do you really think your children should be the weapon?

MrsRaspberry · 19/06/2023 23:01

Its 20minutes twice a month you can't cut off contact for him being 20minutes late. If he were to take you to court your argument wouldn't even be a valid one. He has his kids 2 weekends a month you have a lot more time with them than he does. Don't spite your kids just to prove a point to their dad. At least he bothers with his kids theres dads out there that don't even give up an hour let alone 2 weekends

NojudgementGem · 19/06/2023 22:50

I get DD back as late as 8pm sometimes and I am thankful that her dad wants to spend as much time as he can with her. I never know if she’s eating with me or him until Sunday morning when they decide what they’re doing, I just roll with it unless there’s something specific I need her back for and we discuss it and agree that together.

He is always late for everything, always has been. I don’t let it bother me, I ask them to call me when they set off as it’s a 90 minute drive and I have dinner ready for when she’s home. If she’s not home, I cover everything with foil and warm it up if I need to. I do not let it ruin my night. I don’t let it ruin the positive co- parenting relationship I have with my ex and I definitely wouldn’t be ruining my child’s relationship with her father. YABU

ParadoxicalHippy · 19/06/2023 22:24

I’m really trying to be understand OP but you’re making it hard. You come across as a control freak. When I think of the hoops I had to jump through, the mind games played against me and the children used as pawns with regards to my ex-husband and contact, and the multitude of other separated parents who are dealing with similar bollocks from their ex-partners - your complaint is pretty insignificant.

Is your ex being late 20-40 minutes once a month (you do one pick up) really, really the issue? Or is there another agenda? I completely fail to see how being back home even less than an hour before the time you’d prefer the children to be home can cause so much apparent upset, and tiredness the next day.

Yeah the children are going to be emotional, they’re only human and only young so of course the end of the limited time they spend with the dad will affect them. If they go to bed at 7pm every school night, what time do they wake? Could an extra half hour in bed on that one Monday morning be the solution as opposed to you wanting to cut their dad’s contact 🤷‍♀️

Its fantastic that you have met a partner who contributes what he does to your ready-made family, but you get 24/28 days and nights as that family. Your ex gets four. Ideally he’d take them to school on a Monday but the distance is obviously prohibitive of that. You say he won’t have them four weekends per month but your words suggest that decision is your not his. If you’re indignant about your quality time with your children being eaten into by his timekeeping, would you really be so willing to give him extra weekends 🤔

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 19/06/2023 22:22

Bottom line, @BedtimesBackThen - you can’t stop contact over such a minor issue, but what you can do is mitigate the effects on the children.

As your ex to give them a main meal at lunch time, and a sandwich before he sets off with them, then you give them a top-up snack at home, pop them in the bath, and get them to bed. 7.30 bedtime on a school night once a fortnight won’t do them any harm.

I do wonder if they have picked up on you being cross that their dad brings them back late, and that might be contributing to them being stressed out when they get home. You need to make sure their return home is calm and peaceful, and that they see no inkling of you being cross with their dad.

BlumminKids · 19/06/2023 22:22

I am a mum of late teens and early 20's whose dad was an awkward sod, and also I was very regimented with their routines as it suited ME

I NEVER stopped any access for the various difficulties he put in my way.
I NEVER badmouthed him and never let anyone else badmouth him in front of the kids
I NEVER moaned that I did all the grunt work, washing, homework etc. I saw that as a privilege
I NEVER questioned what he had said to them or if he had said anything negative about me - I'm sure he did
I tried to introduce a new partner into their lives a few years after dad and I split up but it wasn't ever going to work for various reasons.

I am not perfect by any means and I've had my moments - but my kids are well rounded people who have all thanked me independently for NOT influencing their ideas and ideals about their dad

I was bitter, yes, that they saw their dad EVERY weekend and that we never had the opportunity to have movie night on a fri/sat night, or snuggles in bed on a sat/sun morning

We had mediation. We were encouraged to have a communication book. I wrote in all my important dates, family birthdays, grandparents, cousins etc. He had to do the same. If it was my weekend and it was his mums birthday, we swapped(where we possibly could). It was best for the kids.

Imagine what it's like for your poor kids if he's late and he's saying ' oh god, she's gonna go mad, we're late again' They will dread going cos they wont know how to deal with the fallout. You wont be doing any favours to your children if you let them take that attitude into their adult lives.

It really pissed me off that he was the Disney dad and I was behind the scenes doing all the continuity work.
But they now have a decent relationship with him. they don't see him that often, but when they do they enjoy it I think

Your ex (not your childrens EX - he's their dad for ever remember!) sees his kids from Friday night to Sunday night every other week- 48 hours out of a maximum of 336!

Cut him a bit of slack. Meet him halfway with this and be thankful that he wants to be in their lives. He sees another man taking his place as father and doesn't want to be forgotten

Mediocrates · 19/06/2023 22:20

”Sorry kids, you can’t see your dad because of a twenty minute delay”

I get it, the constant lateness is annoying and it might even feel like he’s trying to control you (I haven’t RTFT but I’ve seen exes of friends do similar). Those children are entitled to the opportunity to have a relationship with both of their parents, provided those are safe and loving relationships. You don’t get to stop that because it’s inconvenient that he’s late

HepzibahSmyth · 19/06/2023 22:05

You’re being utterly ridiculous and selfish. Take a day off.

KirstyGee0 · 19/06/2023 22:03

So. Controlling... so strict. Back down and maybe stop trying to take the step out of step daddy?

He's their dad and it sounds like they're not jumping out the car and running away as fast as they can from him.. I don't blame them for being upset with leaving daddy when it's back to communist state of mum.

You're on a slippery slope to being made the one who loses contact... from your own children in the future...

wizzyderbyshire · 19/06/2023 21:54

Maybe, just maybe, your children are emotional because they don’t see enough of their dad. EOW isn’t much really and you are trying very hard to put restrictions on that.
Don’t plan your ‘family’ activities for the weekend their dad has them - be like the Queen was - if you need to have an ‘official’ celebration and an unofficial one.

Don’t make your children feel awkward. Make them feel special because they have 2 sets of people looking out for them.

And please stop losing your shit for the sake of 20 minutes once a month. Life is too short!

Alwaytired44 · 19/06/2023 21:20

But you have them all of the other days, does it matter that you don’t get time with them on drop off day? Poor dad.

CM1897 · 19/06/2023 21:11

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 11:08

I’d rather it was 5pm or earlier but if it has to be 6pm then I can work around that but he’s always late. Last night I’d planned a special Father‘s Day dinner with their stepdad but they got back so late it was ruined.

Can I insist on it being 5pm and then if he’s late and it’ll actually be 6pm?

Their step dad isn’t their dad, they were spending time with their dad on fathers day. Pick one of the other days you have with them to celebrate it with their step dad. You’re being very unreasonable and controlling.

if you want them earlier why aren’t you picking them up?

CM1897 · 19/06/2023 21:06

Put yourself in his shoes… imagine your only see your children every other weekend and then he stops contact between you and the children because your 20-40 minutes late! If you stop contact and he takes you to court, there would be a big chance the judge would give him custody and you access. As you wouldn’t be putting the children’s well-being first

CM1897 · 19/06/2023 21:03

He is their other parent, he has as much right to have time with them as you and has as much right to decide on bedtimes etc as you.

it is just twenty minutes, be happy they have a relationship with their father. Stopping contact is just cruel

Only4nomore · 19/06/2023 19:50

I had the same with my ex....he prob is trying to get at you...but over time I learnt to just let It go.
The Disney dad will eventually stop and then they will see it for what it is as they get older and dad will get bored of pissing u off if u pretend u don't care. Its a play the long game situation I'm afraid. But trust me as they get older they will see it for what it is. My older children would rather not go now and it is their own choice because I refused to put him down when he did me. Gets easier x

ALJT · 19/06/2023 19:30

This just screams playing god with your kids

Tryagainplease · 19/06/2023 19:29

tiagra · 19/06/2023 12:58

Don't use your kids as a stick to beat your ex

This.
It reads to me as though it’s a inconvenience to you that he is their dad and that you would rather their dad is your new partner.
Sorry, but that’s not the case. He is their dad, you’re being precious over timings (6.40 is not that late!) and I think you’re trying to find excuses to end their contact with their dad because it interferes with the fantasy of your DP being their dad.