Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop contact if he can’t keep to the time?

412 replies

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 10:49

My ex has our kids every other weekend but he keeps dropping them back late. It’s supposed to be 6pm but he’s usually at least twenty minutes late. It’s a long drive so I have to give them their tea and get them ready for school on Monday.

AIBU to say he can’t have them if he can’t keep to 6pm?

OP posts:
SchoolShenanigans · 20/06/2023 20:20

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 11:50

Why shouldn’t they show appreciation for the man who is their father figure the vast majority of the time? They wanted to and wanted to buy him presents and make cards.

OP - you've clearly got a huge chip on your shoulder.

Your partner of 36 months (I don't care how long he was friends with you before), is not their father. He can pay every bill going, that still won't make him their dad.

The fact you made their actual dad rush back, or tried to make him feel guilty for being 20 mins late on father's day, is a joke.

You aren't putting your kids first. You're putting your boyfriend first. Get a grip.

x2boys · 20/06/2023 20:18

Nowaynowayhose · 20/06/2023 19:59

It’s not about you though OP, it’s about the DC’s. My adult DS was in a very short relationship with his DD’s mum (before their DD was born) but he drives over an hour every other Friday to pick up his DD and returns her on a Sunday evening. He’s done this since she was a month old and she’s now 9. She eats a meal before they drive back and has a bath or shower on Sunday morning. He does her homework with her too. They split Xmas holidays and he collects her on Xmas Day too. She spends half term with DS and us and holidays abroad with DS and us too. She’s an integral part of our family and extended family. And she’s the most happy, balanced, child you could meet. And that’s because she has her Dad in her life, and his family too. It seems to me you’re looking for reasons to remove him (and by default his family) from your children’s life. They are half his (and half of him) whether you like it or not. If I was him I’d go to court, my DS would have (and still would if needs be) but his ex has realised that her DD comes first and they have a good relationship now - with their DD coming first. Children pick up on everything and if you’re negative about their Dad, then you’re raising children who’ll be in therapy when they’re older. And I can guarantee they’ll resent you too.

I wish more ex partners could be as reasonable as your son and his ex
my dh,s ex was very obstructive in their now adult daughters relationship with her dad
The people who get hurt the most are the kids .

Genevieve29 · 20/06/2023 20:11

Tbh, you just sound very bitter and as though you're using your DCs to get at your ex. Kids need both parents - even if no longer together. Do your kids a favour and keep quiet. it seems they hardly see him as it is.

Nowaynowayhose · 20/06/2023 19:59

It’s not about you though OP, it’s about the DC’s. My adult DS was in a very short relationship with his DD’s mum (before their DD was born) but he drives over an hour every other Friday to pick up his DD and returns her on a Sunday evening. He’s done this since she was a month old and she’s now 9. She eats a meal before they drive back and has a bath or shower on Sunday morning. He does her homework with her too. They split Xmas holidays and he collects her on Xmas Day too. She spends half term with DS and us and holidays abroad with DS and us too. She’s an integral part of our family and extended family. And she’s the most happy, balanced, child you could meet. And that’s because she has her Dad in her life, and his family too. It seems to me you’re looking for reasons to remove him (and by default his family) from your children’s life. They are half his (and half of him) whether you like it or not. If I was him I’d go to court, my DS would have (and still would if needs be) but his ex has realised that her DD comes first and they have a good relationship now - with their DD coming first. Children pick up on everything and if you’re negative about their Dad, then you’re raising children who’ll be in therapy when they’re older. And I can guarantee they’ll resent you too.

QuitMoaning · 20/06/2023 19:57

Imagine your children were old enough to have an informed opinion. Now imagine asking them would they rather be home a bit late or significantly early, every fortnight, or not see their father at all.

Now imagine their answer.

Notattheseaside · 20/06/2023 19:56

Honestly, can't believe what I have just read, everytime OP tried to make a point she sounded more and more unreasonable.

So you refer to his partner as his 'girlfriend' meanwhile your partner is stepdad despite you all getting together around the same time, you are annoyed about his fathers day meal being ruined for stepdad but refer to her as the girlfriend and describe she takes time to do the children's homework and reading with the kids

It's an issue that Dad is spending time hugging his girls when he will clearly miss them as they are far away and he doesn't see them everyday, I would be more concerned if he wasn't showing interest or affection

You are unhappy he has toys and clothes at his house he has purchased, do you happily hand over all the stuff you have bought? Guarantee you don't, the kids should have belongings with both parents

You complain and say he would rather work on Fridays than pick up, have you considered he needs to work, don't know many people who would rather work than have time off

Overall you have managed to come across as difficult and obstructive and clearly don't sound like you have the children's best interest at heart and are totally unreasonable, most people would consider stopping contact for serious issues such as neglect or the children being in danger and all you have described is a father who is dedicated and cherishes time with his kids. I really can't see what the issue here is other than you OP. I feel really sorry for your ex

Densol57 · 20/06/2023 19:48

Persistently late ……. As in ONE Sunday per month 🤣

97% say you are being unreasonable yet you are still going on !
Did he ever accuse you of being a nag by any chance ?

Solonge · 20/06/2023 19:46

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 11:03

He does do their reading/homework (actually it’s mostly his girlfriend who does) and they have a shower in the morning at his but they’re still grubby when they get home if they’ve been outside playing, which they usually have.

I don’t see what else I can do to stop him from being late every time.

So dont. Swallow your pride, have a bath run for 20 minutes after they are due, bedclothes laid out and a nice sandwich and drink for supper. If you try and stop visitation rights you lose and your kids lose. You lose as you are seen as mean and small minded and they lose because time with dad is precious. Goodness…you even complain them coming back 20 minutes late limits your time with them. Try swapping hours with him and see how it feels.

Bubble656 · 20/06/2023 19:39

You can stop being selfish and thinking of yourself! You have the children 12/14 days, he sees them twice a month, and you’re whining about 20-30 minutes? Give your head a wobble.

Thisworldsnofun · 20/06/2023 19:33

My parents had this custody arrangement from the time I was 2. He was consistently late, never paid maintenance, told all manner of lies too. If my mum had reacted to it in the way you want to, we would have hated her for it. Be careful OP. If you make this your hill to die on, you'll regret it when they're older. They won't forget it and they'll never forgive you either.

AnalLysis · 20/06/2023 19:31

Apologies if this has already come up, but is it ex doing all the driving? Seems a lot of his contact time taken up in the car. I’ve no experience so no idea whether travel time is included in contact, but maybe it would be fairer to go and pick them up sometimes so he can have quality time right up until 6 rather than having to get them on the road.

Ap42 · 20/06/2023 19:24

As a parent who has stopped contact before, I would say that's not in the best interests of the children either. I stopped contact for legitimate and serious reasons. 20 or 40 mins late doesn't fall into that category. Unless there are other more serious issues, all you will achieve by stopping contact is an angry ex, upset children and a judge (because he's bound to take it to court) who will not view this issue as reason to stop contact.
I do understand the frustration, my ex used to bring our 2 year old back at 7pm, she would often fall asleep in the car and then not go to bed until stupidly late. The only way around this issue is talking to the ex and compromising.

Pumpkinspice13 · 20/06/2023 19:22

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 10:57

I’ve asked him to bring them back at 5pm instead but he won’t because he says he won’t give up time with them. But this isn’t what’s best for them.

Are you being for real? I feel like this can’t be a real post! Grow up! It’s 20-40 minutes extra he gets to spend with his children ever 2 weeks. In the very little time he does get you’re asking for him to have less. Unbelievable! You have them all the rest of the time. Blows my mind how selfish some women can be. Your children have 2 parents.

Chubble · 20/06/2023 19:10

I barely saw my dad growing up cos he couldn’t be arsed.
My 7 month old has seen his dad for roughly the same amount of time you’re complaining about your kids being late, cos he also can’t be arsed.
Yes, you’re being very unreasonable. What I wouldn’t give for a good dad who wants to spend time with their children.

Crispymandm · 20/06/2023 19:04

You need to work on yourself, it’s very petty of you to even consider stopping contact in my opinion. You’re making it all about you when you say things like “ He’s late to get at me on purpose.” This is paranoid thinking and it’s not best for your DC. I understand that he doesn’t do school runs or pick up the pieces and that must be frustrating but I’m sure there father has frustrations too. At the end of the day it’s your girls right to see their father and been 20 minutes late is not their fault. Stopping contact would be a punishment for them and would impact them massively.

LadyJ2023 · 20/06/2023 19:00

Interesting how your ignoring the majority of responses telling you the problem is basically you. 20 mons is nothing every other weekend as stated, its great they have a lovely time with dad. Why make an issue when there's no need for one and the majority of excuses your using as to why they need to be back are exactly that excuses. They see there dad as they should they have a nice time and much as your partner may be nice he is not there dad. He does not return them late for the ages they are and ye calm down and carry on and stop getting in a tizz about 20mins every other week

GameOverBoys · 20/06/2023 18:56

He sounds annoying and like he doesn’t have the children’s best interests at heart. However, you sound a bit petty and you’ll need to choose your hill to die on at some point so I wouldn’t choose this.

bellsandwhistles333 · 20/06/2023 18:49

With two our travel you unfortunately just have to be flexible to a a degree as he's not just round the corner.

Make sure he is doing a proper full tea so it's a snack at yours or supper. All homework and a full bath and then every other Sunday you just have to adjust to not seeing them much it's home quick catch up over a snack and ready for bed

blondieminx · 20/06/2023 18:44

my ex husband did this - except it was often hours late.

it’s not them that has to deal with tired kids on a Monday.

I insisted we change the contact times because of it and my daughter comes home Sunday lunchtime instead now. Try that? Good luck, and solidarity to you!

AnnieSnap · 20/06/2023 18:41

Of course you can’t give him that ultimatum. He’s their father and has a good relationship with them. It would be outrageous for you to deprive them of visits with their dad. Plus, a court would never agree to it! Either allow yourself to work on the basis that they will be home by 7.45pm or ask him if, due to a ‘change in circumstances’, could he bring them home for 5.30pm and work on the basis that they will be home by 6.15pm.

Buythedammshoes · 20/06/2023 18:41

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 10:57

I’ve asked him to bring them back at 5pm instead but he won’t because he says he won’t give up time with them. But this isn’t what’s best for them.

Best for them or you ? ( I am asking this kindly 🤗 )
Whats the split of when they are with you & when they are with their dad ?
Is he a good dad?
I do get it - I have shared residency with my exh & he rarely brings my DC back on time. It’s frustrating but my DC have a great relationship with their dad so I rise above his bad time keeping - not the hill I want to die on.
I always have to remind myself - even though I think exh is a total cock - he’s their dad & they love him.

I make sure I don’t clock watch & keep myself busy otherwise every second feels like an hour.

JenWillsiam · 20/06/2023 18:41

BedtimesBackThen · 19/06/2023 11:08

I’d rather it was 5pm or earlier but if it has to be 6pm then I can work around that but he’s always late. Last night I’d planned a special Father‘s Day dinner with their stepdad but they got back so late it was ruined.

Can I insist on it being 5pm and then if he’s late and it’ll actually be 6pm?

He is their father. Not their stepdad.

you being so unreasonable. Do you realise how many kids don’t have two parents? And here you are moaning about 20 minutes. Get over it.

Lucyh999 · 20/06/2023 18:40

Not to mention the fact that you don’t have the right to ‘stop contact’

Lucyh999 · 20/06/2023 18:39

stichguru · 20/06/2023 17:56

You have a very tiny issue which doesn't need solving because it isn't really a problem (kids can go to bed 20 mins late once a week). Or if it really is a problem (maybe they get cranky) it can easily be solved. (Dad feeds them before he brings them home, you have a quick tea waiting for them, and/or one night a week they skip bath and just eat tea, and change for bed.) Your solution is to massively cut their contact with a very important person in their life. Stop emotionally abusing your kids, stop using them to manipulate your ex, and start parenting to what they need, instead of hurting them to get your own way for no reason.

This

Lucyh999 · 20/06/2023 18:38

Agreed