Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School won’t teach non-swimmers!

557 replies

Platypuslover · 19/06/2023 10:02

I don’t think I’m unreasonable just considering how far I may need to take this. Year 6 now lost out on swimming lessons because school is useless head was suspended last year and never returned and this has been a pattern for her from previous school. Not sure why other than incompetence but the grapevine said possibly to do with money. So kids didn’t get swimming lesson as no one thought to arrange them once lock down was relaxed the pools reopened.

They waited until end of year to do 2 session to asses swimming. Told we’d get an email if she can’t swim and will have further session.

No email arrived and I called today. So then was told they don’t take non-swimmers only the children that are confident and can almost swim independently and we have to pay for our own swimming lesson.

So I am expected to pay for someone else’s kids to learn to swim with my very hard earned taxes amidst a cost of living crisis and us barely being able to afford basics and we can not afford the extortionate private lessons.

Bet the letter they said they’d send us to give details to book those lessons are with the same company they use to take them swimming now. This reeks of an extortion ring to me why else would you not take the children that need it most!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
RedToothBrush · 19/06/2023 12:19

Bananarepublic · 19/06/2023 11:39

But schools are also financially stuffed too. They can't fund these extra services either. And as people have repeatedly explained, six lessons of mixed ability group sessions will not teach a non swimmer to swim.

As I said upthread, its not just about the schools not having the funding its also about a lack of pools and a lack of swimming teachers.

From September 2021:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/swimming/58641741
Almost 2,000 swimming pools in England could be closed by 2030 without urgent government action, a Swim England report has suggested.
The number of quality facilities could drop by 40%, limiting access for competitive and recreational swimmers.
It adds that pools built in the 1960s and 70s have not been refurbished at a sufficient rate.
Without investment of £1bn, it says there will be a "huge decline" in the availability of pools.
Latest figures from Swim England show that 4.7 million people swim at least twice a month, making it one of the most popular physical activities in the country - their predictions suggest that 3.86 million people could be pushed out of swimming.
Swim England suggests that the issue has been exacerbated by the coronavirus pandemic, with 206 swimming pools already having closed.

AND

From March 2023
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/mar/12/england-has-lost-almost-400-swimming-pools-since-2010
England has lost almost 400 swimming pools since 2010, with parts of the country that have the greatest health needs losing out the most.
The national body for swimming said there was “an urgent need to invest” in England’s pools, after new figures revealed that the pandemic had accelerated a decade of decline in aquatic facilities.
Guardian analysis of data collected by Sport England found a net decline of 382 swimming pools across the country since 2010. These figures include local authority- and community-owned pools, privately run health facilities, schools and sports clubs. The loss of pools has led to an estimated £1bn loss of associated social value through health and community benefits.
The number of pools in council areas with the highest levels of health-related deprivation fell by 14% over the last 12 years, while those in the least health-deprived areas fell by 6%, the analysis shows.

AND

Hartlepool, one of the most health-deprived areas in the country, has seen six of its 12 pools close over the last 12 years. Three were at schools and the other three were at gyms or community centres.

AND

Brighton and Hove lost four pools since 2019, more than any other local authority in the same period. Three were lost during the closure of Virgin Active in 2021 and one when Sports Direct Fitness in Hove closed in 2022.

Where I live there is a massive waiting list for lessons outside school. It took over a year for me to get DS a space - we signed up for three separate places. The centre used to do swimming lessons on a Friday but they stopped this post pandemic. It reduced the number of available lessons by 16%. This was at a time that kids needs more lessons as they've not swum for so long / were older and there was more kids who'd never swum wanting lessons. They've now closed the waiting list for lessons because there are so many kids wanting to learn. They can't open on Friday evenings anymore because of lack of teachers / lifeguards.

The centre serves 5 primary schools in walking distance. As well as being located at a High School. It can't put on more lessons during school time. Its full. All the other swimming pools locally are some distance away and aren't really viable. The High school actually has 8 feeder primaries, so I don't know what they do.

All it means is there are loads more kids who won't learn to swim.

Swim England have been saying all this for some time.

The problem really doesn't lie solely at schools. Its also about local and national government strategy, covid and the cost of living crisis.

There SHOULD be free classes available for low income families outside school hours. But pools can't afford this and councils can't afford this. And its not a priority for national government to fund.

Knowing this, anyone who can afford to fund their kids to swim really should try...

BruceAndNosh · 19/06/2023 12:19

Puppers · 19/06/2023 12:12

🙄 You don't think you will benefit from those children having had a decent education? When, as adults, they are providing all the services you - and the whole of society - rely on?

Yes, I'm totally aware of that. I accept that a significant part of my tax funds services that I do not use, I also agree that education is vital.
I was just parroting back the OP's comment that "my taxes pay for other children" while she ignored who pays for HER children

CommonDecency · 19/06/2023 12:19

JudgeJ · 19/06/2023 11:57

Teachers also get that rubbish, from both revolting parents and their equally obnoxious prodigy, I had a well developed look. eyebrows raised and eye roll, mentally saying And who provides your free ciggy money?

Are you a teacher? Do you mean ‘progeny’ or is every child a genius…?

SunIsShininInTheSky · 19/06/2023 12:17

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:08

I’m going to put this in bold as it seems important

how can you teach your child to swim if you can’t swim yourself?

Swimming is a basic and essential life skill, if you can't take your kids yourself pay for lessons after school. It never crossed my mind that school are meant to teach my kids to swim, I think they do one term in my kids school in Y5. Imagine being 9 years old and not being able to swim, it's bad parenting. My parents taught me to swim around aged 4, my dad took us every sunday without fail. My primary school also took the entire school swimming from reception age, I was already swimming confidently. Do parent's just think that it's school's job to raise their kids these days?

CommonDecency · 19/06/2023 12:16

I work with families who I imagine don’t or can’t take their kids to swimming lessons. Either due to deprivation, parental mental illness or educational/learning limitations.

The competitive ‘my kids could do lengths when they were two and all four strokes by 10’ is typical MN cringe.

All the ‘we live on an island’ 🙄Some inner city kids may never see the coast during their childhood.

It feels counter-intuitive for me to exclude the ones who can’t swim. Giving them even a taster lesson might springboard them into wanting to learn, parents to seek resources out etc.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:16

BruceAndNosh · 19/06/2023 12:09

So I am expected to pay for someone else’s kids to learn to swim with my very hard earned taxes amidst a cost of living crisis and us barely being able to afford basics and we can not afford the extortionate private lessons.

Actually MY hard earned taxes are paying to educate your child. Completely

This bit of your post op makes you a bit of a dick as that is how our society works. But it does seem at odds with the curriculum to take the swimmers swimming.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:14

RagingWoke · 19/06/2023 12:07

But why should the already struggling and underfunded schools then be responsible? Especially when the entitled parent is shouting about their taxes paying for it.

Of course not everyone can afford lessons, or regular swimming pool trips but that's not free for the school either.

Fwiw £35 is a lot. My dc have lessons at £50 per 10 week block, so £5 a lesson. It's not massively cheap but £5 a week is manageable for most. Fully expect dd to be utterly bored at school lessons when they start because she will be a lot more advanced than most by then but I won't be kicking off that they aren't catering to her and my taxes are paying for it.

It’s £45 a month at the council one near me. When I say near it’s a 9 mile drive on no bus routes.

Puppers · 19/06/2023 12:12

BruceAndNosh · 19/06/2023 12:09

So I am expected to pay for someone else’s kids to learn to swim with my very hard earned taxes amidst a cost of living crisis and us barely being able to afford basics and we can not afford the extortionate private lessons.

Actually MY hard earned taxes are paying to educate your child. Completely

🙄 You don't think you will benefit from those children having had a decent education? When, as adults, they are providing all the services you - and the whole of society - rely on?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:12

Just checked how much my local council swimming pool is
To see if it’s any cheaper now.
it’s £45 a month for weekly child swimming lessons.

TripleDaisySummer · 19/06/2023 12:11

My kids could swim by the time they got their school lessons. No one in the non swimming group could swim by the end of the six lessons. It's a waste of time.

I saw the same but many no swimming pupils parenst did then try and book some council lessons.

DD1 was y6 when we moved here -she'd had a few terms with previous council lessons which weren't very good and put her off - term with a lesson a week with school - and couldn't really swim. She did council lessons here as soon as we moved start of y 6 - one of the oldest children but we also did school holiday accelerator lessons - by summer term she could swim and was one of the better swimmers - she kept it up for another year or so getting to stage 5 and then got frustated and stopped.

So I'd look at council lessons as even if they got school lessons it likely won't be enough to get swimming.

OMG12 · 19/06/2023 12:10

BeachBlondey · 19/06/2023 11:49

My DH is a Policeman, and he has been shouted at many times by people saying "I pay your wages". Mostly by people who are on the dole. The irony.

My DH is a special and gets this a lot (even more ironic that he does it for free) yes usually it’s some tosser who doesn’t work, drunk 24/7 with neglected kids no one in social services will actively intervene with.

BruceAndNosh · 19/06/2023 12:09

So I am expected to pay for someone else’s kids to learn to swim with my very hard earned taxes amidst a cost of living crisis and us barely being able to afford basics and we can not afford the extortionate private lessons.

Actually MY hard earned taxes are paying to educate your child. Completely

Padamae · 19/06/2023 12:09

Our school, all of year 5 got to go swimming for 2 terms and then if children still couldn't swim then they found money from the PE budget for those children to go again in year 6.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:08

I’m going to put this in bold as it seems important

how can you teach your child to swim if you can’t swim yourself?

RagingWoke · 19/06/2023 12:07

Puppers · 19/06/2023 11:34

Wow. Some real (privileged) arseholes on this thread.

Where I live, in a relatively cheap area, it's £35/month for one child to have swimming lessons at the council leisure centre. 10% discount for siblings. Or alternatively you can pay £9 odd per session for one adult and one child to take them swimming on your own, that's assuming that you have another adult to look after any other children you may have.

Those costs are quite simply beyond a lot of families at the moment. Nothing to do with being too lazy to sort lessons.

But why should the already struggling and underfunded schools then be responsible? Especially when the entitled parent is shouting about their taxes paying for it.

Of course not everyone can afford lessons, or regular swimming pool trips but that's not free for the school either.

Fwiw £35 is a lot. My dc have lessons at £50 per 10 week block, so £5 a lesson. It's not massively cheap but £5 a week is manageable for most. Fully expect dd to be utterly bored at school lessons when they start because she will be a lot more advanced than most by then but I won't be kicking off that they aren't catering to her and my taxes are paying for it.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 12:07

I can’t swim.
I couldn’t afford the council swimming lessons (closest are a 9 mile drive)

thankfully the mine got taught at school and they did come away from the school lessons being able to swim.

SunIsShininInTheSky · 19/06/2023 12:06

How old is your child? Are you saying your y6 child, so age 10/11 can't swim? How is that possible, don't you ever take your children yourself? Our children learned to swim with us they have just done the paid lessons outside of school as a hobby/to advance their swimming. It's pretty poor parenting if you think learning to swim is school's responsibility. It's cheap as chips to go to the local council pool, coats us around £10 for a family of 5.

Hyppogriff · 19/06/2023 12:04

Teach your own kids to swim for heaven’s sake - basic skill which is required

MooMooSharoo · 19/06/2023 12:03

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 19/06/2023 10:45

Bollocks is it a fiver or less. At our local pool an adult and a child is £9.50. (And it’s very basic, big old pool with communal changing, nothing fancy.)

I had no idea how much our local leisure centre is, so I've just checked. You'd have to go to the "Family Fun" sessions as lane swimming isn't allowed for children, and you don't get a free child's place. One adult + one Junior = £12.20!

Our next two closest public pools are £13.50 or £10.10 (the cheaper one is a small 15m pool, compared to the main leisure centre that has 2 x 25m pools and the most expensive which is a 33m outdoor pool).

I think the OP is getting a bit too much grief in terms of why her DC can't swim already. Maybe she can't swim herself? Or money is just too tight to be able to take family swimming trips at the weekend.

Clearly it's a National Curriculum requirement and obviously the school have been very shit. Covid delayed everything and if the school have since been saying "we're on it - please wait" you do kind of assume they'll sort it out.

To now prioritise the kids that can already swim is awful. It makes it sound like they're just being taken for a splashabout session, not lessons to make them meet the requirements of the National Curricum, because it's easier that way.

OP needs to lodge a complaint about this to the current Head and the Governors. If not for her own benefit, but for the benefit of younger pupils.

The school have definitely failed OP's DC, but unfortunately it's now going to fall on her to plug the gaps. Look for local pools and find the cheapest around. Many might do some sort of deals over the summer holidays so, if you can, take the DC to that and teach them some basics (You Tube would be good for pointers on this). As and when and if money allows you can get official lessons later.

Mummyoflittledragon · 19/06/2023 12:03

I’d be taking this up the complaints procedure. The school is failing to offer lessons to non swimmers in favour of swimmers, which seems like a strange choice.

I can only imagine this policy is for the benefit of the school. Ie It is better for them to have x number of students able to do over 25m than registering none able to do it, which could potentially be the case if they haven’t been able to register the ones, who can.

scoobydoo1971 · 19/06/2023 12:02

My kids learned to swim by observing others and being in the pool with me. My eldest hated lessons and has hypermobility syndrome so not a natural swimmer. He learned by watching his friends. My youngest has autism, severe dyspraxia and auditory processing disorder so being instructed on a physical skill was always going to be challenging. She learned by watching me and having me help her in the pool until she floated independently. Lessons only go so far, and it is the responsibility of every parent to ensure their kids have a basic set of life skills. This is stuff like swimming, crossing the road safely, knowing a bit of the Highway code and a bit of first aid. It costs next to nothing to get kids to a local pool and teach them the basics of swimming even if you are not the greatest swimmer yourself. If I can do it with one disabled arm and hand, anyone can. I got expelled from swimming class at 7 as I told the coach where he could stick his floats. He was a control freak and I was a stroppy kid. I then learned out of stubborn determination and did this by splashing about in the water until I floated. Watching other people swim in helpful to some trying to figure out the right positions to keep going.

ShepherdMoons · 19/06/2023 11:58

It's not brilliant that the school doesn't arrange swimming lessons for non swimmers.
I agree with other posters with the idea of getting private lessons. There are good small group lessons either at the local pool or through a swimming business. It's important for them to learn to swim and, unfortunately, it may mean paying out to ensure this is sorted.

JudgeJ · 19/06/2023 11:57

BeachBlondey · 19/06/2023 11:49

My DH is a Policeman, and he has been shouted at many times by people saying "I pay your wages". Mostly by people who are on the dole. The irony.

Teachers also get that rubbish, from both revolting parents and their equally obnoxious prodigy, I had a well developed look. eyebrows raised and eye roll, mentally saying And who provides your free ciggy money?

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 19/06/2023 11:55

Gosh, it’s so easy to be horrified by someone else’s child not being able to do something that yours either took to easily or that it was logistically straightforward for you to arrange.

Mine are Yr 6 and Yr 5 and only just swimming relatively confidently in the past year. They’ve had years of swimming lessons, initially in a small group and then just the two of them when it was clear they spending most of the time waiting for other people. It was a nightmare to find lessons that worked for us as I don’t drive, there’s no pool local to us accessible by public transport, and DH works weekends. It was also heavily interrupted by Covid, but we made it happen as much as we could. We take them ourselves when we can (tricky to fit in for the same reasons) and have made intensive practice with us a focus of summer holidays. It’s taken FOREVER for either of them to be remotely competent in the water. Some people just find it a much harder skill to master than others. I couldn’t swim till I was 10, and I was at a private school with its own pool plus intensive remedial lessons! I was fine once I’d cracked it.

I’m not saying people should leave it up to school, but the shocked cries of “what do you mean she can’t swim in Yr 6” are unnecessarily judgmental.

Incidentally, DS in Yr 6 is currently getting two weekly lessons through the school - one for the whole class, and one for a small group identified as needing extra practice/support. Not sure how they’ve budgeted for it, but it’s great. So not surprised you’re cross at them offering your DD nothing, OP.

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 19/06/2023 11:55

I don't understand the outrage at the school?

I can't swim (I can chill in the pool on holiday, fanny around a bit and make my way from one end of the pool to the other, but I could very easily get in trouble, and would never take my DCs swimming alone)

I had the usual lessons at school, but as they were my only lessons they didn't really do any good.

I'm not angry with anyone about it. My parents could not afford lessons, and then once my mum was a single mother to 4, there was no spare cash for popping to the local leisure centre.

If there's a ratio or funding issue for the school, it absolutely makes sense for them to try and improve people that are almost there, rather than use the resource on someone who isn't going to gain anything from it in the long run.