Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School won’t teach non-swimmers!

557 replies

Platypuslover · 19/06/2023 10:02

I don’t think I’m unreasonable just considering how far I may need to take this. Year 6 now lost out on swimming lessons because school is useless head was suspended last year and never returned and this has been a pattern for her from previous school. Not sure why other than incompetence but the grapevine said possibly to do with money. So kids didn’t get swimming lesson as no one thought to arrange them once lock down was relaxed the pools reopened.

They waited until end of year to do 2 session to asses swimming. Told we’d get an email if she can’t swim and will have further session.

No email arrived and I called today. So then was told they don’t take non-swimmers only the children that are confident and can almost swim independently and we have to pay for our own swimming lesson.

So I am expected to pay for someone else’s kids to learn to swim with my very hard earned taxes amidst a cost of living crisis and us barely being able to afford basics and we can not afford the extortionate private lessons.

Bet the letter they said they’d send us to give details to book those lessons are with the same company they use to take them swimming now. This reeks of an extortion ring to me why else would you not take the children that need it most!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Susuwatariandkodama · 19/06/2023 14:51

I thought they were for children who know the basics but needed booster lessons as the letter said it’s to ensure they can swim 20 metres. Our school asked those who can swim confidently for 20 metres or more not to attend.

It’s really rubbish though as I remember weekly swimming lessons when I was a child and we were taught how to swim and couldn’t progress until we’d achieved the badges for that particular move like backstroke etc.

OhYouBadBadKitten · 19/06/2023 14:50

I love how people are quoting how cheap and easy it is for them to get children's swimming lessons and then extrapolating their experience across the UK. Some councils are really crap and expensive when it comes to access to sports facilities and transport.

Orangetang · 19/06/2023 14:49

I’m a school governor.

Last year a school I know spent nearly £10k on swimming lessons for what is in effect 6 lessons for 1 very small year group. The local pool was closed and children had to be coached, this was the main cost.

No one should judge OP for not having taken her child, lots of reasons why that might be the case. About one-third of 9 YOs were in the beginners pool so this is common.

Whilst some children might have learned a few essential water safety lessons, in no way did they ‘learn to swim’. I am a big advocate of swimming as an essential life skill but this is not the best way forward any more in many schools.

In my view, and taking into account the broader financial situation at my school, this ranks as some of the worst spend of the school budget.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 19/06/2023 14:48

We are a low income family. When I realised schools swimming lessons weren’t cutting it when oldest DC was in year 6 I budgeted for £8.50 a lesson (paid in 10 weekly blocks) and at one point in the beginning all 4 dc were attending together. The oldest only needed 20 lessons to become competent as she was older. It was eye wateringly expensive but I’d do it again tomorrow.

You make sacrifices for good reason and this to me was a good reason.

School swimming lessons are dire…all 4 of my DCs got a block of 6 lessons..that was it. It’s not nearly enough to teach a kid to swim.

Scottishskifun · 19/06/2023 14:45

TripleDaisySummer · 19/06/2023 14:30

There have been times post kids when I couldn't afford the £7 at time prescription fee for asthma inhalator let alone £60 quid for lessons and the bus fare back and forth as nearest swimming pool - for one child let alone more than one.

Your council doing free lesson - well you are very lucky - friends and family live under many councils in UK and none off their do it - so it's blood rare and as such unlikely OP is under one.

We got to point were we could afford lessons - but I haven't forgotten how impossible it was at one point and how worried that left me.

My council isn't unique at offering free sessions multiple councils offer this or similar schemes in the holidays its about doing some digging though to find out.
A 1 minute Google came up with multiple councils including Manchester, Southwark or Wolverhampton.

Behindthelines · 19/06/2023 14:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sewannoying · 19/06/2023 14:42

This thread is really frustrating. Not everyone can teach their children to swim. If you asked my dad he would say I can swim as he taught me. If you ask me, I would describe myself as a non-swimmer. I can do a basic breaststroke for a few metres, and float on my back, but that’s it.

So no way was I going to be able to teach DD to swim. And while we do pay for lessons (to the extent she’s now a much better swimmer than me), it’s expensive and not something everyone can afford. It’s not just the cost of the lesson, it’s the travel to the pool, the time of the parent to take her and the swimming costumes and goggles.

skyeisthelimit · 19/06/2023 14:42

My DD's primary school only gave them one term of lessons in Year 5. By then, most kids had already had private swimming lessons and could swim. Anyone who couldn't swim, still couldn't swim. I paid for lessons for DD from 5yo,

A lot of people had their kids in lessons from birth practically.

When I went to primary back in the 80's we went swimming practically weekly at one point, plus had a very tiny pool in the playground, and I had gained my 2000m and bronze life saving award by the time we left primary school.

Times have changed a lot.

mayorofcasterbridge · 19/06/2023 14:42

SpringBunnies · 19/06/2023 14:17

@Bunnycat101 I agree with you that I don't see being able to swim is a must learn lifeskill. The chance to actually swim is pretty low in a lot of the UK. DH and I grew up overseas and it was very different. DH lived 5 minute walk to the beach and he remembered summers surfing with friends every day. I also learned really young and couldn't remember a time I couldn't swim. I never had lessons and was taught by my parents. We went almost every day to swim during holidays. Both my local pool and the school's pool are outdoor unheated so it was a lot cheaper to run. I remember walking to the pool from my house in swimwear. Neither DH and I swim well. We just can and no more. I think it's because neither of us were taught, other than get into the water and swim.

Whereas here in the UK, it's very easy to avoid any swimming opportunities. I used to take DCs when they were toddlers to the council pools and I remembered it was very expensive. It was also very busy and you need to prebook instead of just turning up. If it's not for us paying for DC swimming lessons, the children don't go swimming at all. Except for when on holidays in a water park. It's really not the same as when DH and I were young.

I couldn't disagree more!! Swimming is good exercise, and it's reassuring to know my kids can swim if they ever needed to. It opens up possibilities like open sea swimming, surfing, canoeing - and as an island there's lots of opportunities to have these experiences.

I can't swim and I've always felt like I missed out - and no, I can't learn now because I have a phobia of putting my face in the water. Probably as a result of the crap school swimming lessons when the first thing they tried to make you do was put your face in the water.

@Platypuslover I literally couldn't be arsed to get antsy over this. Yes, I agree, it's stupid on the part of the school. The school lessons are a waste of time. They don't get enough to even gain their confidence in the water - unless they can already swim, which all three of mine could.

I spent 9 years of my life sitting weekly in that overheated leisure centre which I abso-fucking-lutely hated, and must have spent thousands to ensure they all became competent swimmers. It was that important to me.

RedToothBrush · 19/06/2023 14:41

SerafinasGoose · 19/06/2023 14:35

I agree with this except the bit about London - london kids need to swim too! There are bodies of water to fall into, plus we go on holiday too.

That's an important point too. Most kids go to the beach. The sea, even close into shore, is dangerous. It's as well to know how to spot rip currents, what to do (and not do) if you get caught in one, how to avoid water craft, surfers etc, and where there are lifeguards, to always swim between the flags.

Tragically, even a good level of swimming ability will not always be enough to save someone in those predicaments.

Yep.

My argument is that water safety and confidence rather than swimming would save more lives.

If you are actually going swimming its likely to be for leisure reasons more available to middle classes anyway.

Where it should be pushed more is for health reason - but with pools more likely to be closing in deprived areas and it having a cost thats stupid - no facilities and no money make learning almost pointless.

BUT where the OP really did my head in was with the comment about taxes and the expectation that it was the school's responsibility.

I don't think its the school's fault - I think its government. And I do think if she feels its that important, then waiting til yr6 before getting upset about it, is a parental fail. If you are going to get upset about lack of school lessons, your time to do that is yr3 not yr6.

AllPlayedOut · 19/06/2023 14:40

I can’t believe that any child is a non- swimmer by Year 6 . Why have your children been taught to swim before then OP?

I can't believe that you have so little imagination that you can't come up with a few reasons by yourself.

in my case I had literally dozens of lessons(Sorry for all the wasted money Mum) but I'm dyspraxic and autistic and I just couldn't do it. Yes some with dyspraxia can learn to swim as a young child but not all. We're individuals. I still can't swim.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 19/06/2023 14:36

How on earth have you let your child get to 11 years old with no swimming lessons 🤦🏼‍♀️

Luxell934 · 19/06/2023 14:36

I only went when I was in year 6 and I could already swim by then, I never had lessons but I went swimming regularly and my dad must of taught me.

I’ve never known a school to take year 2s and up swimming regularly. It’s always been just year 6, 10 sessions. No non swimmer ever learns to swim but they might gain a-little confidence in the water.

Snugglemonkey · 19/06/2023 14:35

cyncope · 19/06/2023 14:28

Are you arguing that all swimming pools should be free to use for families with children?

No. I am saying people need to budget for swimming lessons when thinking about how much it costs to raise a family, or pay to use swimming pools to teach them themselves, or teach their children in lakes, the sea etc or accept their children will be non swimmers. Why is it someone else's responsibility to pay?

SerafinasGoose · 19/06/2023 14:35

I agree with this except the bit about London - london kids need to swim too! There are bodies of water to fall into, plus we go on holiday too.

That's an important point too. Most kids go to the beach. The sea, even close into shore, is dangerous. It's as well to know how to spot rip currents, what to do (and not do) if you get caught in one, how to avoid water craft, surfers etc, and where there are lifeguards, to always swim between the flags.

Tragically, even a good level of swimming ability will not always be enough to save someone in those predicaments.

JudgeJ · 19/06/2023 14:34

CommonDecency · 19/06/2023 12:19

Are you a teacher? Do you mean ‘progeny’ or is every child a genius…?

Yes, I realised that error too late, definitely not prodigies! I was a Maths teacher so can I be excused, though the English Department used to get very annoyed when we corrected children's spelling!

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 14:32

TheaBrandt · 19/06/2023 14:30

You need to realise that the state will now only provide the absolute basics - the bare minimum. You want anything over and above that you pay and source it yourself. Not saying this is right but it’s how it is now. Sport / music / counselling/pastoral etc it’s on you. People need to factor this in before starting a family.

And society needs to factor it in when we end up with the additional cost of these children becoming adults, who then become parents.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/06/2023 14:32

Bunnycat101 · 19/06/2023 14:00

I have spent £1000s on swimming over the years. I am under no illusion that it can be an expensive activity. Baby swimming was £17 a pop and council lessons are reasonable at £35 a month but for many that will be unaffordable.I don’t regret it as it fits with our lifestyle and I want my children to strong swimmers to enjoy holidays and water based activities. The need to swim is much less clear cut if you’re living in central London, don’t go away etc.

if swimming is on the national curriculum then I absolutely think the non-swimmers should be prioritised and the school is failing to deliver the curriculum if it just gives up on the weakest ones. The range in a year 6 class will be massive as likely some competitive swimmers alongside those who can’t swim at all.

I agree with this except the bit about London - london kids need to swim too! There are bodies of water to fall into, plus we go on holiday too.

TheaBrandt · 19/06/2023 14:30

You need to realise that the state will now only provide the absolute basics - the bare minimum. You want anything over and above that you pay and source it yourself. Not saying this is right but it’s how it is now. Sport / music / counselling/pastoral etc it’s on you. People need to factor this in before starting a family.

TripleDaisySummer · 19/06/2023 14:30

Scottishskifun · 19/06/2023 14:21

My DS1 council lessons are £60 for 15 lessons that's £4 a week which is cheap! His brothers private lessons are expensive but the council pools are too cold for him at 1!
Our council do free family swim sessions in the school holidays and still do!

There have been times post kids when I couldn't afford the £7 at time prescription fee for asthma inhalator let alone £60 quid for lessons and the bus fare back and forth as nearest swimming pool - for one child let alone more than one.

Your council doing free lesson - well you are very lucky - friends and family live under many councils in UK and none off their do it - so it's blood rare and as such unlikely OP is under one.

We got to point were we could afford lessons - but I haven't forgotten how impossible it was at one point and how worried that left me.

CornflakesOnTheSolesOfHerShoes · 19/06/2023 14:30

Wow, so now the judgment has moved from being snotty about non-swimming 11 year olds to anyone who hasn’t got their children swimming confidently before they even start school?!! I’ve never met a four-year-old who could swim. I don’t doubt it’s perfectly possible but it’s certainly not the default!

cyncope · 19/06/2023 14:28

Snugglemonkey · 19/06/2023 14:27

School age is just stupidly late to leave it. Like most skills, the younger the better. The easier pick up etc. Also, I do not care if it comes across as judgemental, people should not rely on schools to parent. Basic skills should be in place before starting school.

Are you arguing that all swimming pools should be free to use for families with children?

passmethedettol · 19/06/2023 14:27

All these judgy comments implying OP couldn’t be bothered or is not a half decent parent!! There are loads of reasons people can’t take kids to swimming lessons. Disabilities, money, time, interruptions during pandemic, maybe it’s too hard juggling multiple kids close in age at once in the pool, maybe she has no family help to support her with this. No one is perfect.

Snugglemonkey · 19/06/2023 14:27

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 19/06/2023 14:18

Shall we insert a reason here so you can judge if it reaches your moral bar?

School age is just stupidly late to leave it. Like most skills, the younger the better. The easier pick up etc. Also, I do not care if it comes across as judgemental, people should not rely on schools to parent. Basic skills should be in place before starting school.

Doopersuper · 19/06/2023 14:26

Our state primary only took the non swimmers to lessons after covid. Sadly not sure it actually got many of them swimming. @Platypuslover does your local leisure centre offer free lessons in the summer holidays to non swimmers? I know some do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread