Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to insist my son uses his phone

67 replies

callmeson · 19/06/2023 06:33

My son is going into year 7 and will start taking the bus in Sept so I just got him his first phone for his birthday.

He goes to his dad's a lot too and I like the idea of being able to keep in touch when needed. I rarely contact with him when he's with his dad but maybe once every couple of days to say hi, or if anything comes up that I need to ask him.

I bought the phone and pay the bills. His dad doesn't work so doesn't pay any child support.

My ex and I have an awful relationship (he cheated on me many many times) so it's great not to have to go through him to contact my boy.

The problem is, my son never seems to have his phone with him (or it's on silent) when he's with his dad. I needed to ask him something important his weekend and no reply. I asked his dad on Saturday to ensure he checked his phone and reply to the message, and no reply from either them them the whole weekend.

I try to remind him whenever he heads out, to keep an eye on his phone.

He'll be home this morning and I'm quite angry, honestly. I'm not a shouty parent at all, and I know he's not used to having a phone (he's had it about a month) but I'm really annoyed that he's not checking the phone at all.

I do realise it's his dad's time with him and I don't want to get in the way of that, but the purpose of the phone is to make communication much easier, when I do need something, particularly as he's sometimes gone for a whole week.

OP posts:
Abreezeintheglade · 20/06/2023 09:45

Be glad he’s not bullying people on Tick tock to be honest, I’d rather have a technophobe child than an 11 year old who’d watched horrific porn (according to our school newsletter it’s happening).

hellywelly3 · 20/06/2023 09:38

It’s not his fault you and his father can’t co-parent. Leave the kid be.

GC1 · 20/06/2023 09:29

We had this for years with my nephew's dad! He's take all our number out his phone and prank call or send nasty messages. Hed take the phone off him or turn it off so we couldn't contact him. The purpose was a court order I'd he wanted to come home early. Judge went mad at this so then he started diverting the calls and text from nephew's phone to his own. So nephew couldn't answer ect. Just accept that if you ex is toxic contact won't happen with your son. It horrible for the kids. Nephew was so embarrassed and got a hard time if we contacted in the end so he just ignored it to save getting hassle. Xx

GoodChat · 20/06/2023 06:14

It does sound like you're trying to use the phone to one-up his dad and invade their contact time.

How many emergencies do you have that you need to contact your 11 year old for?

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 20/06/2023 04:46

callmeson · 19/06/2023 07:35

This is exactly the kind of thing I mean. Like “James wants to come for a play date later, but did you get all your homework finished at dad’s house, otherwise you’ll need to do that instead”…..

That kind of communication. (That’s just an example).

Does he have a device he does use regularly? I chat with DC on kid messenger on their tablets.

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 03:52

@WandaWonder in my own case, my DC do want to be in contact with me thankfully. Maybe not the case for everyone, but my DC love being able to contact me directly.

WandaWonder · 20/06/2023 03:46

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 02:43

Couldn't disagree with this more. Since when does a child's time with their father mean they're no longer your child and you can only contact them in an emergency? What utter tripe, apologies @Murdoch1949 but this is total bull. My DC is my DC 24/7 and I will contact them when I like, whether it's a simple 'I love you' call or an actual emergency.

And some things are time sensitive... if a Mum wants to arrange a sleepover with me, but I can't confirm for 2 days because DC is at their fathers, and that's too late for the Mum to make plans then and my DC miss out... who looses there? And don't just say go through their father... there are incredibly valid reasons why at 12, you would hope not to have to go through and abusive father for these 'non emergencies'. Wise up a bit

That does not mean a child wants to be in contact with you (in a general sense sense you) at 12 or older

Mariposista · 20/06/2023 03:03

A teenager that doesn’t need surgically removing from their phone sounds like a dream

Toxicityofourcity · 20/06/2023 02:43

Murdoch1949 · 19/06/2023 16:44

Before next visit to dad's, have a conversation with your son about the phone. Assure him you will only contact him for genuine emergencies - and you must keep to this. While your son is with his father you need to leave him alone, completely. Any friend or homework arrangements can wait until his return. Do not use things as an excuse to attempt to contact him, it's his and his dad's time, not your's. You need to train yourself to enjoy your time while your son is away, in the knowledge that his father is in charge and has full responsibility.

Couldn't disagree with this more. Since when does a child's time with their father mean they're no longer your child and you can only contact them in an emergency? What utter tripe, apologies @Murdoch1949 but this is total bull. My DC is my DC 24/7 and I will contact them when I like, whether it's a simple 'I love you' call or an actual emergency.

And some things are time sensitive... if a Mum wants to arrange a sleepover with me, but I can't confirm for 2 days because DC is at their fathers, and that's too late for the Mum to make plans then and my DC miss out... who looses there? And don't just say go through their father... there are incredibly valid reasons why at 12, you would hope not to have to go through and abusive father for these 'non emergencies'. Wise up a bit

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/06/2023 18:09

Oh no, I see it was a birthday present so you can't take it back.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/06/2023 18:08

I wouldn't be angry with him, but if you bought it so he could stay in touch with you and he is not doing so then I think it would be reasonable to withdraw it and try again in September.

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 18:02

Surely in a genuine emergency if you call and he doesn’t answer you’d just call the dad?

Murdoch1949 · 19/06/2023 16:44

Before next visit to dad's, have a conversation with your son about the phone. Assure him you will only contact him for genuine emergencies - and you must keep to this. While your son is with his father you need to leave him alone, completely. Any friend or homework arrangements can wait until his return. Do not use things as an excuse to attempt to contact him, it's his and his dad's time, not your's. You need to train yourself to enjoy your time while your son is away, in the knowledge that his father is in charge and has full responsibility.

girlfriend44 · 19/06/2023 14:38

people managed ok when kids went to dads before phones.

Anything urgent phone dad.

LadyJ2023 · 19/06/2023 09:00

I'm really sorry but our 13 is the exact same they don't watch there phones. If he at grandparents he will rarely reply because he is always busy doing something fun with his grandad or cousins. I dont bother him if I don't need to tbh

Toxicityofourcity · 19/06/2023 08:52

I completely get this as well and don't see why you're having such a hard time here.

Just because my DC is with their dad, doesn't mean they stop being my DC and I don't want to contact them for days on end. Like your example above, arranging play dates and sleepovers. Or checking to make sure they have house keys, school stuff they need etc.

This level of communication is not putting pressure on your DC and doesn't need his father as a go between. Having bought him a phone, I would expect him to check it periodically, maybe once or twice throughout the day.

My DC has a phone as of recently too and I love being able to drop a text and ask how their day has been, tell them I love them etc.

brunettemic · 19/06/2023 08:51

callmeson · 19/06/2023 06:58

The thing is, I’m like the least overbearing parent in the world (honestly). It’s more about being frustrated that he’s kind of discarded it and isn’t getting into the habit of checking it. I feel like it’s a new level of responsibility that he should be learning.

Maybe that’s a good thing. I’m conflicted in it to be honest (precisely because he’s really independent and I’m not generally overbearing in any way, so this is new for both of us), but I felt like he was old enough for me to be able to contact him directly. When his friends come over, they’ve all already got phones and their parents would always contact them, rather than me, about pick up times etc, or just to say hi.

Firstly, despite your protests, this come across as really overbearing. Secondly, if you want him to learn it just let him learn it rather than forcing it on him.

Marblessolveeverything · 19/06/2023 08:49

I wouldn't contact my DC for a query of this kind it isn't urgent. You are placing a burden on him he obviously doesn't want.

Eldest here is 15 only brings his phone to school. When they are with their dad I contact their dad if urgent otherwise it waits.

I'm delighted my children aren't attached to phones , I take that as the win.

Rachie1973 · 19/06/2023 08:41

What could be so urgent for a 12 year old that he needs to know whilst with his Dad?

lljkk · 19/06/2023 08:37

I can't get my 80yo father to learn to pick up messages I send him.

I often miss messages on my phone, DC consider me hopeless.

I am baffled at people who pick up every msg quickly. Are you every 5 minutes unlocking your phone & checking every single app (Messenger, texts, Twitter, Insta, Snapchat, personal emails, private emails, WhatsApp, Facebook groups...) to see if someone said something to you?

I dunno, as long as you know he's safe, I am leaning towards YABU. Let him be a kid.

callmeson · 19/06/2023 08:35

Thanks all for your feedback. I think it's just a habit thing. There's nothing remotely entertaining on the phone - it's only for texts to family, so I guess there's no reason he's drawn to checking it.

It would be good if he remembered to glance at it, maybe once a day, when we're away from each other for long blocks of time. But I agree I don't want him glued to it.

OP posts:
Nomorenonbinary · 19/06/2023 08:34

What do you think used to happen before kids had their own mobiles?

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 08:28

Maybe his dad is doing stuff with him rather than letting him sit around on his phone like most kids his age. I’d be glad of that tbh.
If there’s anything you desperately need to tell him while he’s away surely you can just call his dad? Otherwise let them have their time together. Does his dad contact him when he’s with you?
Unless he’s asking to call you and his dad is refusing (which doesn’t sound like the case from what you’ve posted), I think yabu.

callmeson · 19/06/2023 08:04

HelpMeUnpickThis · 19/06/2023 07:50

@callmeson

I really don’t think your example above about the play date is urgent.

You do sound overbearing, sorry.

I don’t remember saying it was urgent? I’m saying that’s the kind of thing I might message him about, that’s not urgent but would be useful if he responds.

OP posts:
Vintagecreamandcottagepie · 19/06/2023 08:00

A mum wanting to contact her son occasionally while he's away for a week?

How awful 🙄

You are defo not being unreasonable, a phone for this is a great idea. Of course you want/ need to contact him sometimes!

Getting angry with him for not checking his phone, maybe a tad unreasonable. Just remind him, he's not used to having one. Check his dad didn't stop him using it too.