Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family move and guns

168 replies

Appleblossompetal · 18/06/2023 23:16

Hello,

English Mum here with an American DH. We are considering a move to the US because in my DH’s line of work he would earn seriously more in the US compared to here, house prices would be cheaper and generally we would have a better lifestyle. We might just go for a few years and save rather than a permanent move.

However, some of the places where he could potentially work are in a state with very lax gun laws, as in open carry including of concealed guns is legal.

Would that be a deal breaker for you? I just feel like I don’t have a frame of reference for living in a country with guns but I don’t like the idea of my DC doing active shooter drills at preschool or seeing people carrying handguns around.

YABU- It’s not a dealbreaker, get over it.
YANBU- This would be a deal breaker for me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 11:59

StarchySturgess1 · 19/06/2023 11:08

I wouldn't live in America because my (and my daughters) access to basic female healthcare isn't safe. Dealbreaker.

And because the cheese is shit.

hahahaa that’s an important point.

OP posts:
GeorgiaGirl52 · 19/06/2023 11:50

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 19/06/2023 01:15

55 years for me, and I also have never seen anyone wandering around with a gun. Every time posts like this pop up I roll my eyes. People who have never even been to the US making it sound like we are constantly ducking bullets here.

70 years here and in a southern state. Also worked in public (state) schools for 35 years. Never saw a shooting, inside or outside of a school. Had a gun in my home for 45 years but never carried it, concealed it, or shot anyone with it.
You will need insurance (provided by employer for whole family) and you will not have to wait hours for an ambulance, days for a doctor's appointment or weeks for surgery.
You will have educational choices for your children - public schools, STEM schools, church schools of all denominations, art and drama schools, etc. Your children can attend specialized summer camps all over the US - and they will be taught to drive by the schools when they turn 16.
If you come, we will welcome you. If you don't, that's your choice.

notsayingmuch · 19/06/2023 11:47

Seriously? I have lived in the north east US for over 30 years and have never seen a gun. Perhaps it's the circle in which you move?

Does this mean that the American posters have never seen a police officer in real life? They are all armed! Perhaps guns are so engrained in society that they don't even notice them.

Azaeleasinbloom · 19/06/2023 11:40

OP, I lived in Texas. Loved it.

There were guns, my friend showed me where she kept hers in case I needed it 🙄, another offered to take me to the range to learn how to use one. Never did, never needed too.

In my limited experience, school shootings aside, which I would never ever downplay, the shootings I heard about were generally between people known to one another, people involved in crime, or sadly, law enforcement.

The teenagers I met were polite, well mannered and engaged.

As FirstTimeNameChanger said, not everyone enjoyed the same standard of living , but to be honest that’s been the same everywhere I have lived, except perhaps Scandinavia.

New Hampshire is one of my favourites . We visited often. My take would be try it.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 19/06/2023 11:30

There is not enough money in the world to tempt me to live in a country where the number one cause of childhood death is firearms

This.

Honeychickpea · 19/06/2023 11:28

FirstTimeNameChanger · 19/06/2023 11:22

Its really interesting hearing British expats to the US talk about how great it is, and how all of the problems we hear about are just media driven. I'm an American living in the UK. Yes, if you (or your husband) have been selected to work in an American branch of an international company on one of the coasts, you probably have great health care. You probably earn a lot more than you did before. You probably live somewhere with access to great schools, excellent services, and the weather is good. However, the people packing your groceries at the store for you don't have the same health care you do. Its not actually that great if you re poor or working class, much worse than in Europe. Medical debt, medical bankruptcy, people not able to afford antibiotics - this is all real. Its not a made up thing. America has a lot wrong with it. Its not an exaggeration, just because it's not your reality.

Also - the Americans on this thread who have never seen a gun - how? I grew up in the most liberal of North Eastern cities, in a wealthy neighbourhood, and of course I saw guns! How can you have avoided it?

Seriously? I have lived in the north east US for over 30 years and have never seen a gun. Perhaps it's the circle in which you move?

GasPanic · 19/06/2023 11:27

The vast majority of responses on here are going to be about why someone wouldn't live in the US because of x,y and z.

I would stick to the few responses from people that have legitimate experience.

And remember that trying to get an impression of what a place is like from the media is always going to be difficult, because the media always portrays outlier events. It doesn't show the reality of living in a particular country. Don't get your impression of what living in a country is like from the news.

Seas164 · 19/06/2023 11:22

@Wallaw exactly, who needs access to basic female healthcare when you can just chuck some Humboldt Fog at the problem

FirstTimeNameChanger · 19/06/2023 11:22

Its really interesting hearing British expats to the US talk about how great it is, and how all of the problems we hear about are just media driven. I'm an American living in the UK. Yes, if you (or your husband) have been selected to work in an American branch of an international company on one of the coasts, you probably have great health care. You probably earn a lot more than you did before. You probably live somewhere with access to great schools, excellent services, and the weather is good. However, the people packing your groceries at the store for you don't have the same health care you do. Its not actually that great if you re poor or working class, much worse than in Europe. Medical debt, medical bankruptcy, people not able to afford antibiotics - this is all real. Its not a made up thing. America has a lot wrong with it. Its not an exaggeration, just because it's not your reality.

Also - the Americans on this thread who have never seen a gun - how? I grew up in the most liberal of North Eastern cities, in a wealthy neighbourhood, and of course I saw guns! How can you have avoided it?

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 11:11

StarchySturgess1 · 19/06/2023 11:08

I wouldn't live in America because my (and my daughters) access to basic female healthcare isn't safe. Dealbreaker.

And because the cheese is shit.

That's an absolute load of garbage. Every farmer's market on the east coast is loaded to groaning with sublime artisan cheese, and Humboldt Fog is probably the best cheese I've ever had, and I live basically around the corner from La Fromagerie.

https://igourmet.com/products/humboldt-fog-cheese

igourmet_185_Cypress Grove_Humboldt Fog_Cheese

Humboldt Fog Cheese/Cypress Grove/Cheese – igourmet

As Americans have developed a deeper appreciation for great cheese, a change in American cheese making has occurred. Across the country, small-scale dairy farmers and cheese makers are making wonderful cheeses to rival those of Europe. One of these che...

https://igourmet.com/products/humboldt-fog-cheese

Deathbyfluffy · 19/06/2023 11:10

44PumpLane · 19/06/2023 00:18

There is not enough money in the world to tempt me to live in a country where the number one cause of childhood death is firearms.

Fine if you don't have kids, but with kids I honestly couldn't cope with the terror of sending them to school. Even active shooter drills can fully traumatise your child.

I had to Google this statistic - that's terrifying.
The wife and I have been over to the USA a few times with the DC, but might have to re-think now...

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 11:08

mindutopia · 19/06/2023 11:01

I'm an American living in the UK and yes it would be a deal breaker for me. We even have guns here (for legitimate reasons and follow all the rules to the t), but America is an entirely different world. It's unlike anything I've experienced living anywhere else in the world. I don't meant that just in terms of guns - and not everywhere is quite so lawless - but in terms of mentality and just sense of safety.

Now that doesn't mean it's not worth doing for you if you want a bit of an adventure for a few years. But I lived that adventure for 20+ years and I'd personally never in a million years move back, but that isn't just about gun laws.

@mindutopia

Do you mind sharing roughly where you've lived? Just curious, because while I'm the first person to put their hand up and say the US is all kinds of fucked up, that doesn't mirror my experience in any way.

Honeychickpea · 19/06/2023 11:08

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/06/2023 00:53

In my 47 years on this earth in the US I have never seen anyone just wandering around with a gun.

Your only frame of reference is the media, and I invite you to look at your own country to see what they regularly blow out of proportion.

I’ll be happy to answer any questions you might have, but I’m not getting into a debate about US gun laws. In other words move or don’t move based on your own risk assessment.

Why don't you just ask your American husband? Don't you trust his opinion? If you don't, it's not a good idea to move anywhere with him.

Cosycover · 19/06/2023 11:08

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/06/2023 00:53

In my 47 years on this earth in the US I have never seen anyone just wandering around with a gun.

Your only frame of reference is the media, and I invite you to look at your own country to see what they regularly blow out of proportion.

I’ll be happy to answer any questions you might have, but I’m not getting into a debate about US gun laws. In other words move or don’t move based on your own risk assessment.

There were 34 deaths just yesterday. Its not blown out of proportion. Not in the slightest.

StarchySturgess1 · 19/06/2023 11:08

I wouldn't live in America because my (and my daughters) access to basic female healthcare isn't safe. Dealbreaker.

And because the cheese is shit.

Honeychickpea · 19/06/2023 11:03

Singleandproud · 18/06/2023 23:19

I would not live in (or even visit) a country that allowed guns to be carried. Are you sure you'd even be that much better off once medical, housing association, school taxes etc are taken into account?

School taxes? Seriously?

mindutopia · 19/06/2023 11:01

I'm an American living in the UK and yes it would be a deal breaker for me. We even have guns here (for legitimate reasons and follow all the rules to the t), but America is an entirely different world. It's unlike anything I've experienced living anywhere else in the world. I don't meant that just in terms of guns - and not everywhere is quite so lawless - but in terms of mentality and just sense of safety.

Now that doesn't mean it's not worth doing for you if you want a bit of an adventure for a few years. But I lived that adventure for 20+ years and I'd personally never in a million years move back, but that isn't just about gun laws.

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 10:32

Lysianthus · 19/06/2023 09:08

'Live free or die'. It's a nice State. Never seen a gun. Easy flights back to UK. I'd definitely do it.

Thanks, yes I really like the look of it and liked it when we visited.

OP posts:
Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 10:31

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 09:17

Rural NH or one of the bigger towns/small cities? I'm American and while NH is certainly an interesting state, full of contradictions, it's not one that I would have major concerns about as long as I wasn't somewhere too rural. It's certainly a state with a favourable tax structure (no state income tax).

There will definitely be guns, but I'm yet another American who has never come across one in person in my entire life other than on a police officer.

Thank you! Yes that was my suspicion as well. City in NH.

OP posts:
Wallaw · 19/06/2023 09:17

Rural NH or one of the bigger towns/small cities? I'm American and while NH is certainly an interesting state, full of contradictions, it's not one that I would have major concerns about as long as I wasn't somewhere too rural. It's certainly a state with a favourable tax structure (no state income tax).

There will definitely be guns, but I'm yet another American who has never come across one in person in my entire life other than on a police officer.

Lysianthus · 19/06/2023 09:08

'Live free or die'. It's a nice State. Never seen a gun. Easy flights back to UK. I'd definitely do it.

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 08:02

Alaimo · 19/06/2023 00:10

What's the state otherwise like? I could possibly live in Washington state or some of the northeastern states that have open carry laws. If it's a southern state where abortion rights, women's rights and gay rights are under attack, book bans are on the increase, climate/science-denialism is rife, economic libertarianism the dream, and so on, then absolutely not.

Thanks, yes it’s New Hampshire so not as straightforward as somewhere like Florida or Texas.

OP posts:
Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 08:00

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 19/06/2023 01:14

Not this bullshit again. Award for previous US threads and you already know how it will go.

I’m struggling to see why on earth what I have written is bullshit. This is a state that only changed it’s gun laws in the last few years, in fact since my DH haas been in the UK, so actually previous threads may not be that helpful because the political mood in the US seems to have changed in the past few years.

And people saying I have no frame of reference outside of films… I have loads of in laws living there, actually on both sides of the political divide. Not to mention the fact that I have both lived in the US as a kid and worked there as an adult. What I haven’t done is lived there since being a parent, and I’m interested in people’s opinions about that.

OP posts:
Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 07:56

evuscha · 19/06/2023 02:07

As someone who has lived in the US for the past 4 years (west coast), and very happily, I wouldn’t personally live in a Republican state, assuming that’s what you’re thinking (are you thinking Florida?) because their policies are just incompatible with my beliefs (and my American DH’s too). I have some friends who have moved from west coast to Florida or Texas (properties much cheaper) and none of them (because they’re all pretty liberal, anti gun, pro choice etc) are having a good time, some consider homeschooling etc.

Statistically you’re not gonna get shot, despite the scary news it’s a very small % of cases in a huge population, in my 4 years I have never seen a gun in person. But the political vibe is just different, very polarized, people like to take a stand very openly and with election coming up soon it will get very heated again. So I suppose it depends on where you stand politically and how much it bothers you, not just guns, but abortions, LGBT/trans discussion and all the rest of it.

We’re considering moving to Europe in a few years (possibly not back to UK though) and the things I will miss are certainly the better lifestyle - big house much more affordable, higher salaries (I make more part time here for identical job that I made full time in the UK), we can afford more. People are generally friendly, I made some lovely friends and have pleasant interactions at work, with other school mums etc. Healthcare - expensive (make sure you get good insurance), but excellent quality and efficient. Schools very much depend on your area (funding is also from local taxes), we have some excellent public ones where we are including specialized ones such as dual immersion or STEM.
Things that pull me back home - well obviously missing my family, but also a more relaxed lifestyle hopefully (my DH works long hours and gets 3 weeks of annual leave where 5-6 weeks is pretty standard in Europe), and if I was having kids again then the lack of social support, no maternity leave or pay, would bother me (however we managed due to higher salary AND many jobs are actually fully remote which has worked well for me).

If you’re in a position to try it out, I would go for it, but perhaps not buy property right away but wait and see how you like it.

Thank you! This is really helpful. It’s New Hampshire.

OP posts:
SabrinaThwaite · 19/06/2023 07:34

I lived in Texas for a while. I was aware of the number of guns and it was something I took into account (like being aware whilst driving never to get into arguments with other road users and avoiding certain areas) but it didn’t put me off.

One thing to be aware of is DC going on play dates to other kids homes and ensuring that any guns in the house are safely locked away.

Our healthcare was heavily subsidised by the company but it was still a reasonable chunk of money each month. Summer electric bills were high due to running the a/c. Food was more expensive than the UK at the time (good quality meat and bread were costly).

DC were too young at the time for schooling, but we had a fab church run pre-school that our neighbours helped us get into.

Now I’d also consider what is happening to women’s rights in whichever state you’re considering.

We considering diving in and buying, but fortunately played it safe and rented, which turned out to be a very good decision!

Swipe left for the next trending thread