Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family move and guns

168 replies

Appleblossompetal · 18/06/2023 23:16

Hello,

English Mum here with an American DH. We are considering a move to the US because in my DH’s line of work he would earn seriously more in the US compared to here, house prices would be cheaper and generally we would have a better lifestyle. We might just go for a few years and save rather than a permanent move.

However, some of the places where he could potentially work are in a state with very lax gun laws, as in open carry including of concealed guns is legal.

Would that be a deal breaker for you? I just feel like I don’t have a frame of reference for living in a country with guns but I don’t like the idea of my DC doing active shooter drills at preschool or seeing people carrying handguns around.

YABU- It’s not a dealbreaker, get over it.
YANBU- This would be a deal breaker for me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Cantstandbullshitanymore · 19/06/2023 13:18

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 08:00

I’m struggling to see why on earth what I have written is bullshit. This is a state that only changed it’s gun laws in the last few years, in fact since my DH haas been in the UK, so actually previous threads may not be that helpful because the political mood in the US seems to have changed in the past few years.

And people saying I have no frame of reference outside of films… I have loads of in laws living there, actually on both sides of the political divide. Not to mention the fact that I have both lived in the US as a kid and worked there as an adult. What I haven’t done is lived there since being a parent, and I’m interested in people’s opinions about that.

It’s bullshit because every 3-5 days there’s these US this threads rang just descends I to how horrible the US is and amazing the UK is and over and over and over.

You should not be coming to mumsnet if your want unbiased views about the US as all you get is the typical stereotypical from people who don’t really know what they are talking about.

ReachForTheMars · 19/06/2023 13:17

More importantly, do you want to normalise guns with American laws and values about them for your son?

KimberleyClark · 19/06/2023 13:15

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 19/06/2023 01:15

55 years for me, and I also have never seen anyone wandering around with a gun. Every time posts like this pop up I roll my eyes. People who have never even been to the US making it sound like we are constantly ducking bullets here.

There have been 305 mass shootings in the US this year alone. Over the weekend 38 people shot - two fatally - in three separate incidents. Why does a supposedly civilised country tolerate this?

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jun/18/us-mass-shootings-weekend

At least 38 people shot, including two fatally, at weekend in US

There have been more than 305 mass shootings in the US so far this year as of Sunday morning

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/jun/18/us-mass-shootings-weekend

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 13:14

Honeychickpea · 19/06/2023 11:08

Why don't you just ask your American husband? Don't you trust his opinion? If you don't, it's not a good idea to move anywhere with him.

We’re sort of working it out together. He’s from a different state and has been out of the country for a while and is very anti-gun, so it’s a question from both of us really.

OP posts:
jellyminelli · 19/06/2023 13:13

"If you were into hiking and never came face to face with a bear you might not bother about having a gun, or some form of other protection with you.

One experience of that though might change your mind."

Mate, I saw a bear (3 actually) on that hike. Had he shot them he'd have been completely fucking mental.

They were black bears in the Great Smoky Mountains, he is not ok to shoot them. Bear spray, yes, guns, no.

DoubleHelix79 · 19/06/2023 13:13

I lived in Texas for a good year - the ubiquity of guns (combined with a lot of drugs, poverty and gang culture)ade me quite uneasy. Didn't see so many openly carried, but knowing they were all around me, and occasionally hearing a shot in the distance was somewhat unsettling. It was a relatively rough area though, so it may feel very different in the area you're considering. I did feel very homesick for a more European culture as well, despite being very adventurous, and settling easily in the UK (I'm from Germany originally)

LaBefana · 19/06/2023 13:12

I wouldn't live in a country that has lax gun laws, and where parts still have capital punishment. The US would be a total deal breaker for me.

GasPanic · 19/06/2023 13:06

jellyminelli · 19/06/2023 12:48

"Does this mean that the American posters have never seen a police officer in real life? They are all armed! Perhaps guns are so engrained in society that they don't even notice them."

Yep, I think they just don't notice them. I saw men going about their normal routines (queuing in a fast food restaurant and another hiking on a popular trail) with their guns on their belts. Both of these were in Tennessee. No obvious reason to need to carry the gun but yes, the police all have them as well as the security guy at a motel we stayed at.

If you were into hiking and never came face to face with a bear you might not bother about having a gun, or some form of other protection with you.

One experience of that though might change your mind.

MissConductUS · 19/06/2023 13:06

Appleblossompetal · 19/06/2023 11:59

hahahaa that’s an important point.

Cheap supermarket cheese anywhere is shit. America makes lots of fine cheeses.

By the way, New Hampshire is lovely and safe, and you're close to Boston for fine dining and culture. You'll love it there.

An American Cheese Won the World Cheese Awards for the First Time Ever

American cheeses performed well this year, as seven U.S. cheeses were included in the competition's list of the World's 84 Best Cheeses. But not everyone is celebrating America's new dairy dominance; according to Sky News, France isn't taking the results well. One widely read newspaper in the country called it "sacrilege" that only one French cheese placed in the top 16. (That cheese tied for eighth.)

An American Cheese Won the World Cheese Awards for the First Time Ever

Here's where you can buy it.

https://www.foodandwine.com/news/world-cheese-awards-2019-winner-oregon-rogue-river-blue

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 13:01

For what it's worth, here's a link to a quality of life index - I can't vouch for their numbers and it's pretty general, although you can do some specific city to city comparisons. US and UK essentially equal

https://www.numbeo.com/quality-of-life/compare_countries_result.jsp?country1=United+States&country2=United+Kingdom

Family move and guns
EnthENd · 19/06/2023 12:56

I'm not sure it would be a dealbreaker. But you claim that "generally we would have a better lifestyle". That's something I'd think twice about when I consider that the USA has expensive healthcare, very little social safety net, basically no job security, frequent school shootings and higher violent crime generally, abortion bans in many states, more car crashes, general lack of public transport and even lack of sidewalks, and unless you like it hot then a worse climate in a lot of the country.

Again, not necessarily a dealbreaker - pick the right neighbourhood in the right city in the right state and it addresses most of those complaints. But there's more to quality of life than how much discretionary income you have.

jellyminelli · 19/06/2023 12:48

"Does this mean that the American posters have never seen a police officer in real life? They are all armed! Perhaps guns are so engrained in society that they don't even notice them."

Yep, I think they just don't notice them. I saw men going about their normal routines (queuing in a fast food restaurant and another hiking on a popular trail) with their guns on their belts. Both of these were in Tennessee. No obvious reason to need to carry the gun but yes, the police all have them as well as the security guy at a motel we stayed at.

FirstTimeNameChanger · 19/06/2023 12:38

@Theelephantinthecastle yes I get it. I probably will move back to the US one day, but I will and do find the attitudes very difficult. The crazy individualism and fear of socialism and utter self belief is hard to handle. As is the idea that, for example, American health care and education is world beating. Well, yes, for a privileged sub group it is, but what about everyone else?

Re the guns - I have family in Georgia and Florida, so that accounts for a fair few. But even in my liberal NE hometown some school friends parents had guns, and the kids would show them off.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/06/2023 12:37

croft89 · 19/06/2023 12:36

I have cousins who left England to live in the U.S. I've seen photos of the guns one of the lads owns and it's shocking

He has a sniper rifle and another gun used by front line Marines, he can legally carry them in public if he wanted to

Absolutely ridiculous

Has he shot anyone with the guns he owns?

croft89 · 19/06/2023 12:36

I have cousins who left England to live in the U.S. I've seen photos of the guns one of the lads owns and it's shocking

He has a sniper rifle and another gun used by front line Marines, he can legally carry them in public if he wanted to

Absolutely ridiculous

Theelephantinthecastle · 19/06/2023 12:24

FirstTimeNameChanger · 19/06/2023 11:22

Its really interesting hearing British expats to the US talk about how great it is, and how all of the problems we hear about are just media driven. I'm an American living in the UK. Yes, if you (or your husband) have been selected to work in an American branch of an international company on one of the coasts, you probably have great health care. You probably earn a lot more than you did before. You probably live somewhere with access to great schools, excellent services, and the weather is good. However, the people packing your groceries at the store for you don't have the same health care you do. Its not actually that great if you re poor or working class, much worse than in Europe. Medical debt, medical bankruptcy, people not able to afford antibiotics - this is all real. Its not a made up thing. America has a lot wrong with it. Its not an exaggeration, just because it's not your reality.

Also - the Americans on this thread who have never seen a gun - how? I grew up in the most liberal of North Eastern cities, in a wealthy neighbourhood, and of course I saw guns! How can you have avoided it?

I am (or was - now renounced my citizenship) also an American living in the UK and I agree with everything you said (except for the guns bit which I will come back to)

It always makes me wince when I read posters talking about how amazing the schools in the rich areas are and the healthcare if you have great insurance is - because that is all true but the disparities are so huge. Really much bigger than in the UK. You have school districts without much money right alongside ones where there's loads of money.

I went to a truly amazing American high school for a couple of years but it made me really uncomfortable that the schools a few miles away were literally crumbling. One of the biggest reasons why I don't want to live there again is that I wasn't able to take the "I'm alright Jack" POV.

On guns - on here here is a real obsession with school shootings which do obviously happen in the US but are rare. The thing I would find harder to deal with with young children is that I would not be happy for my kids to go on playdates to people's houses without knowing whether they have a gun and, if so, is it carefully locked away. But it's socially awkward to ask about that in the US in my experience. My parents come from a different culture and did ask this sort of question and got very angry reactions.

But in my time living in and visiting the US I don't think I actually saw a gun (except with a police officer) more than once or twice so I don't find it hard to believe some Americans have never seen them.

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 12:23

gogohmm · 19/06/2023 12:07

Just remember everything costs more, food, kids activities, adding taxes to things, etc etc.

@gogohmm New Hampshire has no sales tax (VAT equivalent) and no state tax, so overall tax liability is likely to go down.

@FirstTimeNameChanger

What you've said above is largely true, but I work with very deprived families here, and I can assure you, they are not living a very pleasant existence.

Trainsplanesandfeet · 19/06/2023 12:21

Definitely a deal breaker for me. Guns terrify me. But then so does American politics in general so I know I couldn’t ever live there happily.

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 12:20

notsayingmuch · 19/06/2023 11:47

Seriously? I have lived in the north east US for over 30 years and have never seen a gun. Perhaps it's the circle in which you move?

Does this mean that the American posters have never seen a police officer in real life? They are all armed! Perhaps guns are so engrained in society that they don't even notice them.

I specifically said, except for on a police officer in my reply. Certainly not so ingrained in society that I wouldn't notice them. In fact, the biggest, scariest guns I've ever seen in my life are the ones I see every morning casually slung about by the police officers strolling down Kensington High Street on their way (I assume) to embassies.

Other than those instances, I have never seen a gun.

Seas164 · 19/06/2023 12:18

Cheese quality is a fairly high priority when relocating a family, to be fair.

Wallaw · 19/06/2023 12:14

Seas164 · 19/06/2023 11:22

@Wallaw exactly, who needs access to basic female healthcare when you can just chuck some Humboldt Fog at the problem

@Seas164

I was responding only to the assertion that the cheese is bad. My more complicated feelings about my home country are alluded to above.

Wnikat · 19/06/2023 12:10

It's not just the guns, it's that your kids would have to do active shooter drills in school which would be damaging in itself. My DH has vetoed a move to the States for precisely this reason.

gogohmm · 19/06/2023 12:07

Just remember everything costs more, food, kids activities, adding taxes to things, etc etc.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 19/06/2023 12:03

I live in New England and visit New Hampshire often. I love Portsmouth; pretty, upscale with lots to see and do. NH is a very socially liberal state. Crime rates are low and gun ownership is mostly due to hunting. I'd be very surprised if you saw anyone other than a police officer actually carrying a firearm.

Abortion is legal and easily accessible in NH up to 24 weeks (with exceptions after that for maternal/fetal/medical issues).

No state income tax. Unlimited recreational opportunities - hiking, skiing, etc. Depending on where in the state you are you may have a short(ish) drive into Boston and be close to the Portland Maine area. The White Mountains are gorgeous. Winter is no joke; hope you like snow!

Rural areas are not for me so I can't offer much there.

I think the New England states offer the least amount of "culture shock" to someone from the UK.

FirstTimeNameChanger · 19/06/2023 12:00

Never been shot at and never witnessed a shooting, are not the same thing as never saw/ seen a gun.

Also, I'm not just talking about different standards of living or income disparity. Of course that exists massively in the UK as well. I am saying it is false to pretend that the issues around healthcare, lack of welfare, gun violence and violence against women don't exist just because you as a British expat aren't likely to experience them. You may be okay as an expat, you probably will. But you will be living in a society and culture that is very much not okay. So many of the safety nets that Europeans take for granted just don't exist in the US. And while that may not affect you individually it definitely affects society as a whole.