Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegan given butter in restaurant

262 replies

Loveanavocado · 18/06/2023 21:53

Went out for dinner this evening with dd’s.
dd1 has been a vegan for years. The rest of us are vegetarian, although I’m verging on veganism too tbh.

we went for dinner this evening, to our local. We often eat here and know the staff really well. So they know our dietary requirements.

this evening we ordered a dish and were all eating it. The waitress came over laughing and told us it had butter in it!!

dd1 was horrified and began to get upset. The waitress took the dish away and went to the kitchen. She returned and said “the kitchen are making another but they’ve got cross with me and asked why I told you it had butter in it!’

this has infuriated me!! Firstly given butter when told vegan. But even worse..told by the waitress that the kitchen would’ve not told the customer it had butter in it!!

AIBU?? What if dd had an allergy????

my dd2 has severe allergies (has had anaphylaxis a few times now!) so how am I ever going to trust them now??

I don’t know what to do! I don’t want to make a fuss as it’s our local in a very insular community

OP posts:
BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 05:49

SmurfetteSalad · 19/06/2023 05:44

If my kid had a life threatening allergy, I'd mention that to someone cooking them food.

The post you're quoting doesn't say anything about life threatening allergies though.
It says intolerance which can make you be ill.
If you order vegan, it has no milk in it. Or bloody shouldn't do!

SmurfetteSalad · 19/06/2023 05:45

ILikeCatsandDogs · 18/06/2023 22:36

Wow there’s some real bullies on here. This is the same as feeding a blind person worms on toast and you think it’s funny. I guess if your a sicko maybe. I’m sorry for what happened to you don’t go back and remember the Facebook review. Perhaps it’ll less funny to the restaurant staff when it closes down. There are plenty of restaurants more deserving of customers that are.

It's really not the same.

SmurfetteSalad · 19/06/2023 05:44

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 18/06/2023 22:31

And vegan can be a shortcut way of saying no milk products. My dh is lactose intolerant but would often opt for a vegan dish as a way of getting dairy free. Fortunately for him a little dairy would be ok but he could be ill. When ordering it is not for the restaurant to decide to give you something different.

If my kid had a life threatening allergy, I'd mention that to someone cooking them food.

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 05:30

Just to add, while it can be upsetting or annoying, there is no sin accidentally eating pork for muslims. So it's also not actually, thinking about it, comparable to allergy or intolerance.

Outofthepark · 19/06/2023 05:22

Loveanavocado · 18/06/2023 22:23

I’m pretty shocked at some replies.

Firstly I wouldn’t make a fuss about nothing.
Secondly, I know better than a lot of folk, the magnitude of food allergies. I have a severe nut allergy, as does dd2. We both carry epipens. Dd2 has had to have it administered many times. Once on a long haul flight. To watch that is something no parent should have to endure! So please don’t tell me I’m muddling veganism with allergy seriousness. I’m well aware of the difference.

im simply saying..the standard of thought process and empathy from a restaurant in terms of customer food presence is disgusting. Would it be treated the same if this was a religious preference??

im pretty shocked here tbh. Nobody should have their beliefs and choices belittled. Whatever that may be

OP you're getting a hard time because you're comparing a food preference to:

  • an allergy which could kill, and a
  • religious need

Clearly your DD being given a bit of butter accidentally is nothing like a Muslim being given pork, or an allergic person having a life threatening reaction!!

It's how you communicate it that's earning you a hard time.

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 05:00

A Jewish or Muslim person ordering a chicken dish should be confident that they won't be served pork instead, and so on
We always asked in new places if there is any pork in it. Most people do because bacon etc are not always mentioned.

People cannot compare this to allergies/intolerances. If customer says they are allergic whole different process is put in to prevent cross contamination.
Pp is right though thay absolute mlst of places cannot possibly prevent 100% of cross contamination. We used to very clearly statethere are x and y in kitchen and we cannot guarantee no crosscontamination. Same like factories do on packed food.
It is treated differently to dietary preference so if anyone has allergy/intolerance and is just irdering vegan option, the extra safe process will not be there.

Waitress was laughing trying to make aituation lighter. I would bet that she wasn't actually finding that funny.

FelisCatus0 · 19/06/2023 04:55

Emmamoo89 · 18/06/2023 23:43

And I'm not surprised. Vegans always like to jam their views down your throat when you are a meat eater....

There are even several posters on this site with the word 'vegan' in their usernames, like it's a fad or something to show off or be proud of. I mean what is that all about? Just....why? They need to advertise it for some reason. You don't see 'meat eater' or 'carnivore' in usernames. Not even vegetarians use 'vegetarian' in their names.

FelisCatus0 · 19/06/2023 04:50

Loveanavocado · 18/06/2023 22:31

I think there’s a lot of folk here who don’t understand veganism!

It's not that we don't understand it, we don't believe in it and think it's wrong (and harmful). To be upset over eating something healthy and nutritious is silly. A first world problem and in my opinion shallow.

Codlingmoths · 19/06/2023 02:41

It seems they know you don’t have any dairy allergies so it’s not fair to assume they might do the same with an allergy. Of course this shouldn’t have happened, and the kitchen staff should be told off, but I’m not sure re the waitress. She obviously didn’t think it was a joke really as the kitchen staff said don’t tell them and she immediately went and told you. The laughing could have just been an awkward reaction to this.

MrsAvocet · 19/06/2023 01:45

I'd be annoyed too OP. My DS has non IgE mediated allergies to eggs and dairy and IgE mediated allergies to a number of things including nuts. So his default option for desserts when eating out is to pick something vegan and then ask if it contains nuts or any of the other things he might have an anaphylactic reaction to. He is not so sensitive to eggs and dairy that he needs to worry about minor cross contamination so something vegan prepared in a kitchen that also handles animal products is not a problem. However, a dish that is actually made with eggs or dairy would make him unwell so I'd be mightly pissed off if something that is supposed to be vegan turned out to contain butter.

When you order something vegan it is not unreasonable to expect it to actually ne vegan whatever your reason for that choice. Just because other people might not share those views doesn't mean they are entitled to ride rough shod over them. If you are teetotal and you order non alcoholic wine you are entitled to receive that. A Jewish or Muslim person ordering a chicken dish should be confident that they won't be served pork instead, and so on. What you order should be what you are given regardless of why you placed that order. And if the kitchen can't deliver what you've ordered then they need to tell you that before you start eating.

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 19/06/2023 01:18

I'm in the industry and this is completely unacceptable. At the very least, write a strongly worded letter of complaint to the owner. If it were me, I'd want to know what my staff were up to - and I would not find it remotely funny.

Lifeetc · 19/06/2023 01:14

My friend eats vegan food when out; because she is breast feeding a baby with CMA. If she was served food with butter it would make her baby unwell.
The baby also has other allergies (soy being one) eating out should be a nice treat not a minefield. Every place that serves food has to have an allergy book indicating exactly what is in each dish (I'm also allergic to some very standard foods)
Where we live there's two restaurants we can eat at safely out of hundreds!
I would not hesitate to complain to the manager and higher up

BrightLightsCalling · 19/06/2023 01:07

Amazed anyone would suggest damaging a business’s reputation over a butter preference.

The business will have brought it on themselves. They’re paid to provide food customers ask for and good service.

LocoCocoa · 19/06/2023 00:58

Veganphobia 😂😂
Everything is a phobia these days eh.

Amazed anyone would suggest damaging a business’s reputation over a butter preference.

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 19/06/2023 00:27

Gracewithoutend · 18/06/2023 22:56

You all survived it so I don't think it needs to be made into a massive drama.
Complain to the pub manager. It's disrespectful of them.
Staff need training.
You don't trust them now so don't go back.

It's difficult to eat out with dietary requirements. I know. Do you remember Gordon Ramsay giving a vegetarian meat and just laughing?
Some people don't understand what vegetarianism and veganism actually is. I went to Holyrood House Palace and there were menus in the dining room from a state dinner held the night before. The vegetarian option was fish. 🙄

I've been vegetarian for over 40 years. And this has often been my experience. Served prosciutto on melon - when queried - melon brought back with clear ham staining. When challenged. No more melon. Luckily my boss's wife was also vegetarian. I dont think that (shit) restaurant ever got any more party bookings from my quite large (Big4) accounting firm.

But even more recently - I volunteered Xmas day at an old people's home. (Perhaps 2018 - 2019?). Served fish - as all vegetarians eat fish. The chef was quite astonished when I said No.

But since veganism became trendy can I get ever a vegetarian meal. No - it always has the fake ersatz ingredients. Or is just shit. We have a local (quite trendy food) pub. I took my DC out for a meal - my only choice - despite all the supposed focus on local fresh ingredients was a roasted vegetable quiche. Just foul - not properly cooked and quite frankly I believe bought in (judging by the glop sauce). So I do have choices - eat elsewhere. And that's what you OP need to do. Neither you nor I have an allergy ( in any normal understanding of the word) but we are being conned as to what is being offered.

(And my dad who taught catering in an FE college for decades and was himself vegetarian at a time when only Cranks was around would be disgusted. At chefs who don't seem to have a fucking clue).

Ugzbugz · 19/06/2023 00:22

I cannot tell you how many places claim to have vegetarian dishes when they contain things such as fish sauce in certain things etc. Not acceptable but think alot are not fully vegetarian.

therescoffeeinthatnebula · 19/06/2023 00:19

Loveanavocado · 18/06/2023 22:00

We always say vegan. And always remind nut allergy.

we have this same dish often too as it’s a go to for us because ticks all the boxes. (Veggie pasta dish). It’s always vegan. Suddenly today it wasn’t despite us saying vegan.

it’s the attitude of laughing by staff. And for them getting cross we found out!!

Is this dish actually advertised as vegan, or is it an assumption you've made?

And are you sure it's previously been vegan? Butter would affect the flavour, so if it's something you regularly order and it tasted the same, I have my doubts...

Was the dish ordered by the vegan DD or by another person?

I think the server was unprofessional. But I also think there is a difference between a preference and an allergy. Like you, I have allergies. Whenever I check if a dish has nuts in it (because it's not obvious from the menu and it's the sort of thing that might), I always get asked 'do you just not like nuts, or is it an allergy?'

I would be surprised if any kitchen didn't take an actual allergy seriously, even if they were [insert swearword of your choice here] about DD's veganism. The people I know with dairy allergies have always declared them as such rather than said they're vegan, because it's an important difference for the kitchen to know.

I hate that you've jumped to 'but what if DD had an allergy?' She doesn't. As you're regulars, the staff probably know it's just a preference.

I don't think you should be angry about DD's non-existent allergy. You should be angry about the attitude of the server (and apparently the kitchen, by her account), which is a different thing. As for not wanting to kick up a fuss - they've made clear they don't respect your family. I wouldn't be going back. I mean, it sounds like they're fairly immature, and I don't really want to eat in a restaurant where the kitchen staff are likely to spit in my food.

PS I'm not an angry meat eater, I'm vegetarian where possible (i.e. where the vegetarian option isn't one I'm allergic to).

ApplesInTheSunshine · 19/06/2023 00:19

An allergy is serious. This isn’t allergy related, this is just your DD being fussy.

BrightLightsCalling · 19/06/2023 00:18

@Emmamoo89Online? So you don’t actually know any then? Do you really think these people you see doing that are representative of most vegans?

Emmamoo89 · 19/06/2023 00:13

BrightLightsCalling · 19/06/2023 00:01

And I'm not surprised. Vegans always like to jam their views down your throat when you are a meat eater....

Do they? Do you know many vegans? @Emmamoo89

I know lots and it’s not my experience at all. Some of them campaign for animal rights but that’s at the right time and place. Day to day, they don’t really mention it.

Yep see it all the time. Especially on social media. Proper little keyboard warriors 🙄 and look at the shit they pulled in some supermarkets. Tipping out milk to try and make a point. Pathetic man.

SarahDippity · 19/06/2023 00:02

Emmamoo89 · 18/06/2023 23:43

And I'm not surprised. Vegans always like to jam their views down your throat when you are a meat eater....

Jam? But .. the gelatin!

no but seriously, the restaurant is at fault here, without question. Vegan dishes should be vegan, without dispute.

BrightLightsCalling · 19/06/2023 00:01

And I'm not surprised. Vegans always like to jam their views down your throat when you are a meat eater....

Do they? Do you know many vegans? @Emmamoo89

I know lots and it’s not my experience at all. Some of them campaign for animal rights but that’s at the right time and place. Day to day, they don’t really mention it.

Catbumps · 18/06/2023 23:59

YABVU if you’ve not told them about an actual allergy. But I suspect this bit was added later to buoy your story.

7eleven · 18/06/2023 23:55

Soapyspuds · 18/06/2023 23:48

The kitchen staff should have taken your DD's dietary needs far more seriously

But it is not a need.
It is a want

It’s absolutely irrelevant whether it’s a need or a want.

7eleven · 18/06/2023 23:53

Bharath · 18/06/2023 23:21

I often wonder how vegans square the idea of “not taking any animal products” with the fact that growing vegetables are fertilised with the by-products of the meat industry? Either with manure, or with blood fish and bone which is the actual dead bodies of animals. That’s before you consider how many animals died from the pesticides they use on veg.

Sorry but they aren’t gonna be eating anything that costs no animal lives at all! I guess they know fuck all about farming which allows them to fool themselves into thinking that vegetables are vegan. But it’s silly really. Butter is the least of their problems, at least the milk cow isn’t dead.

😂