Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegan given butter in restaurant

262 replies

Loveanavocado · 18/06/2023 21:53

Went out for dinner this evening with dd’s.
dd1 has been a vegan for years. The rest of us are vegetarian, although I’m verging on veganism too tbh.

we went for dinner this evening, to our local. We often eat here and know the staff really well. So they know our dietary requirements.

this evening we ordered a dish and were all eating it. The waitress came over laughing and told us it had butter in it!!

dd1 was horrified and began to get upset. The waitress took the dish away and went to the kitchen. She returned and said “the kitchen are making another but they’ve got cross with me and asked why I told you it had butter in it!’

this has infuriated me!! Firstly given butter when told vegan. But even worse..told by the waitress that the kitchen would’ve not told the customer it had butter in it!!

AIBU?? What if dd had an allergy????

my dd2 has severe allergies (has had anaphylaxis a few times now!) so how am I ever going to trust them now??

I don’t know what to do! I don’t want to make a fuss as it’s our local in a very insular community

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 19/06/2023 21:49

I know plenty of people who couldn't tell silk from rayon...

So its ok to sell people something other than what they were asking for, as long as they don't know..... ok! Got it.

Soapyspuds · 19/06/2023 21:43

If you pay me for silk and I provide something made with fucking rayon, you'd be pissed off

If you pay for solid silver and receive silver plated copper... you'd rightfully be angry

Yes, because they are clearly different products.

The ops daughter was completely unable to tell that the product contained butter, and they did not have an allergy. It did her no harm and she did not even notice.

I think I would have noticed if my earrings were made of butter and not silver.

😂

WiddlinDiddlin · 19/06/2023 21:10

It doesn't matter if its a need a want, a whim or a fucking fancy.

If you agree to sell someone the product they have asked for, then thats what you do.

It isn't legal to tell someone a product is one thing and then provide something else!

If you pay me for silk and I provide something made with fucking rayon, you'd be pissed off.

If you pay for solid silver and receive silver plated copper... you'd rightfully be angry.

If you pay for real wood flooring and get laminated plastic photos of wood...

It doesn't matter what the product is or why you want it specifically, if someone says they can provide it then provides something else without informing you and finding out if that is ok - it's not acceptable and it is not legal.

I don't see people saying 'well its just a want, not a need' when people complain about being missold other products, why is food any different?

Soapyspuds · 19/06/2023 20:35

It’s absolutely irrelevant whether it’s a need or a want

PishPosh

A need to avoid a certain food is a matter of life and death

A want to avoid a certain food means you will still be alive the next day. After a hissy fit.

MrsAvocet · 19/06/2023 19:21

I've never worked in the food industry but both DH and I work/ed in (different) safety critical industries in roles that include things like quality assurance, conformity of production and so on. I think that the posters on here that are convinced that this error doesn't matter because it was only a preference and not an allergy are being a bit naive. Whilst the reason for a request for vegan food may be different to that for, say, nut free food, I'd expect the process and checks involved in making sure that the right food gets to the right customer would be very similar in both cases. If there is a lack of oversight or a workplace culture in which these things aren't seen as important that may well translate into other similar errors. In my experience it's quite rare to find a workplace where some protocols are followed diligently and others ignored. If you find one problem there are often others. Of course anyone can make a mistake and what happens next is quite telling. The OP reports attempts to hide and minimise the issue and in my experience that is a bad sign. I wouldn't trust a restaurant where that attitude can be seen to feed my multi allergic son. It could be a one off and they may be red hot on preventing cross contamination for allergic customers, but if I had to put money on it, I'd say it's more likely that things are a bit sloppy in general and I probably wouldn't trust them.

AromanticSpices · 19/06/2023 18:52

Loveanavocado · 19/06/2023 13:53

I haven’t got back to answer as I’m at work!

yes it was advertised as vegan. Yes we reiterated vegan diet plus nut allergies. Yes we also asked for vegan mayo.
short of wearing a hat saying vegan, I’m not sure what some of you expected me to do differently?

Ah, you didn't do the special Morse code wink-and-blink that indicates you actually mean the words you are saying and that you will act on the assumption the words you are hearing are correct!

Silly you, must be the vegan diet Wink

greenstrawberry · 19/06/2023 18:44

I'd honestly report to trading standards, maybe even health and safety. And make a negative review on Google, TripAdvisor, FB etc. In line with a proper complaint to the management asking them for their explanation.

Way out of line.

BreatheAndFocus · 19/06/2023 18:41

AllyCart · 19/06/2023 14:14

Uh huh, right you are 🙄 Now try substituting “butter” with ‘bacon’ and ‘vegan’ with Jewish. Nice, eh? Not.

WTF? How on earth are you comparing those 2 completely disparate scenarios??

Don’t be disingenuous- they’re very much the same. You might not share someone’s belief, whether that be religious or otherwise, but trivialising it is uncalled for.

Both the above examples have beliefs which inform their diet. If arestaurant says a meal fulfils their needs and it actually doesn’t, then that’s wrong. To then dismiss the person’s understandable concerns and upset as ‘making a fuss about nothing’ trivialises their belief system. You think vegans are fair game to trivialise, it seems.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 19/06/2023 15:57

If you are allergic, bloody say it so kitchen can act adequately.
Saying vegan does not mean there will be super extraprecautions for cross contamination.

Once again, a lot of people have allergies that don't need 'super extraprecautions'. They just need food that doesn't contain an ingredient it should never have contained in the first place. If vegan food is actually vegan that's enough to not set off my dairy allergy, or my friend's egg allergy. If a restaurant is going to go.to the trouble of putting a vegan label on the menu I should be able to trust that, and skip the 10 minute conversation and waiter going back-and-forth to the kitchen to check. Which is frankly a bore for everyone involved.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 15:06

YourMusic · 19/06/2023 14:53

It’s often vegans that have a bad reputation but this thread has only shown ‘non vegan/meat eaters/omnivores as being the problem.

Agree
I always find that's the way though.
Facebook is brilliant for a laugh at people getting upset at the mere thought of vegan food lol.
Brand posts a picture of a new meat free product -
Comments underneath you're guaranteed to get
" Mmm, I just want a juicy steak, mmm bacon butty!"
(Knock yerself out Trevor, nobody's stopping you! 😂)
Wot about protein tho?
Did you know cauliflower cries too, or do you ever think about the poor carrots?! Hmm? HMMM?" 🙄😂

Theres that saying " How do you know if someone is a vegan? Don't worry they'll tell you.
I find it's usually the opposite
How do you know if someone is a triggered meat eater? Don't worry they'll tell you lol

I'm not even vegan but I find it bonkers how much it winds people up if they find out you are or facing a meat free food.

Summer1912 · 19/06/2023 14:58

Theres lots of different names for some allergens.
Plus bear in mind pay for some jobs is low (if 33% dont pass gcse eng for example) others have kitchen staff who dont speak eng. Or agencies put temp staff in. Theres been a lot of staff shortages in some places.
We've had completely uncooked food twice and red raw steak once.

YourMusic · 19/06/2023 14:53

It’s often vegans that have a bad reputation but this thread has only shown ‘non vegan/meat eaters/omnivores as being the problem.

Summer1912 · 19/06/2023 14:52

Obviously not great, especially laughing, but agree with others it was a preference. And by their reaction seems likely they often give you non vegan....
On Sunday i asked chain restaurant to have maple syrup on side not on pancakes as not sure dc would like it (also can be sensitive to golden syrup for eg). Anyway it came and had dollop on pancakes and rest separately obviously an error.

Vegan and veggies probably have meat occasionally
-genuine errors
-odd spider overnight
-some intentional misleading restaurants
-some lack of accuracy
-some intentional spiking as people dont like vegans etc
But also loads of foods.allow certain amount of bugs in so x amoubt in chocolate.

In terms of trusting others over a severe allergy..
I was at kids activity a d saw epi pen handed over. Later kid querying the choc spread -- it had nuts in like nutella. Completely the leaders error, not reading ingredients. However the child was 7+ could have checked or asked too.

The kid was luckily fine no reaction. But in some respects havin to cater to vegans veggies etc does take focus off life threatening cases.

The vegans could have just had no butter or cheese etc. Not restaurants but say schools and activities i dont think they should try to cater to vegan. That would be up to child or parent and more akin to some kids being so.fussy they dont fancy anything.

Also at a party for y1 the parents served and said on whatsapp beforehand it would be only hotdogs (asked for reply if issues). I got there and 1 parent had veggie/vegsn child who had nothing to eat. Like really not hard to have replied or tsken something. I myself had sausages in bag as thought my dc might not eat them.

Actually another parent at place that just does pizza didnt say beforehand and the host bought kid something from cafe (again veggie kid). Have to say not keen on places like this as loads of kids dont like pizza. ..

It is rubbish i agree but its mire their reaction/obvious distain for food preference.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 14:41

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 14:29

If you are allergic, bloody say it so kitchen can act adequately.
Saying vegan does nkt mean there will be super extraprecautions for croas contamination.

Since people keep pulling religions in, same like ordering chicken will not mean it's not cooked on same part of grill as pork.

Allergies mean different process andextra precautions. Veggie, vegan, etc do not compare.

Saying vegan does nkt mean there will be super extraprecautions for croas contamination.
I know, but it's not all about allergies- there's intolerances as well.
I don't usually need extra special super precautions, but when you eat out you expect people in the food industry to have the first clue what they're doing.
If a dish is advertised as not having a main allergen in, then it shouldn't be in there.

nettie434 · 19/06/2023 14:41

At first I thought you'd assumed the pasta dish was vegan but hadn't checked but I can see from your posts that you had been clear so I think the restaurant was definitely in the wrong.

I appreciate it's difficult to bring it up with the manager but as you don't have a lot of restaurant choices locally, you will have to mention it if you want to eat there again. It might have been a different chef on duty who didn't understand that that particular dish was meant to be vegan. Although the waitress shouldn't have laughed, at least she told you what had happened so I'd start off the discussion by mentioning that as a positive.

PatchworkElmer · 19/06/2023 14:38

The amount of venom on MN for vegans absolutely astonishes me. Why are this people so threatened by others making a kinder choice 🙄🙄

I’d not eat there again OP- I agree, you can’t trust them now.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 14:35

Potentially ill, not I'll
Stupid autocorrect

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 14:34

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 19/06/2023 09:52

If you have a dairy allergy, which might be triggered by cross contamination, you need to tell the staff each and every time.

The Vegan Society is absolutely fine with products that 'may contain' milk and egg being labelled vegan, but for someone with a severe allergy they may still have an allergic reaction to such an item.
https://www.vegansociety.com/news/blog/TM2021/allergen-vs-vegan-labelling

Lactose intolerance - you probably don't need to tell staff as it will take a significant amount of dairy to produce a reaction - but you should probably tell the staff anyway.

The Vegan Society is absolutely fine with products that 'may contain' milk and egg being labelled vegan, but for someone with a severe allergy they may still have an allergic reaction to such an item.

Yes, if labelled "may contain milk" or "may contain egg " t is because it has been produced or packaged in an enviroment that handles milk or egg products so they can't guarantee no cross contamination.
It's not an ingredient in the product though, so can be classified vegan.
This pasta dish had bloody butter IN it, so definitely not vegan, and a a definite ingredient to make people potentially I'll

Ponderingwindow · 19/06/2023 14:31

A person with a religious diet is no different than a person following a vegan diet. I don’t understand why people act like it is special that someone declares they have a belief in a particular deity and decides not to eat a particular food.

since we gave the privilege of choosing our food, we all get to control what we eat, but if it isn’t medically dictated, it is a preference, not a requirement.

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 14:31

Avocado allergy example pp though has massive case of complaint and I would be reporting the place in their situation
(and yes, why does everything have avocado!)

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 14:30

So many typos

Chermeup · 19/06/2023 14:29

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 14:25

Milk and egg allergy can kill or make very ill as well, you know!
They're known allergens.
If you order vegan, you know it has no milk or egg in it.
I regularly order vegan when eating out despite not being vegan for this reason, as I know it's a dish I'll be able to eat.
They definitely need complaining about, as they don't seem to have a clue- you can't advertise dishes as having no milk in if it actually does.

If you are allergic, bloody say it so kitchen can act adequately.
Saying vegan does nkt mean there will be super extraprecautions for croas contamination.

Since people keep pulling religions in, same like ordering chicken will not mean it's not cooked on same part of grill as pork.

Allergies mean different process andextra precautions. Veggie, vegan, etc do not compare.

DrCoconut · 19/06/2023 14:26

@IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems agreed about gluten free. So many people just roll their eyes at the mention of it. People who work in catering are often not clued up or very complacent. The "a little bit won't hurt"/"treat yourself" brigade are really harmful to those of us who medically have to be properly gluten free.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 19/06/2023 14:25

DidyouNO · 19/06/2023 13:50

Let's stop comparing food allergies to first world food choices firstly.
Complain if you want but eating butter as a vegan doesn't kill you the way peanuts do for a nut allergy sufferer.

Milk and egg allergy can kill or make very ill as well, you know!
They're known allergens.
If you order vegan, you know it has no milk or egg in it.
I regularly order vegan when eating out despite not being vegan for this reason, as I know it's a dish I'll be able to eat.
They definitely need complaining about, as they don't seem to have a clue- you can't advertise dishes as having no milk in if it actually does.

AllyCart · 19/06/2023 14:14

Uh huh, right you are 🙄 Now try substituting “butter” with ‘bacon’ and ‘vegan’ with Jewish. Nice, eh? Not.

WTF? How on earth are you comparing those 2 completely disparate scenarios??