Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be a bit miffed that he took the toys?

84 replies

MiniMileaway · 18/06/2023 20:19

BF spends a lot of time at my house, even when he has his DS EOW.
That’s fine - his DS and my kids get on well and we have a lovely time together, so much so that I invested in a toy box for my living room for DS to keep some things in so that he has toys to play with / things to do when he’s here.
When it came to going back to his mum’s tonight, though, BF let his DS pack up a lot of the toys and take them with him AIBU to be annoyed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
J0S · 20/06/2023 18:05

It’s really common for people who often have children visiting ( friend's kids , nieces and nephews , grandchildren ) to have a box of toys that they bring out when kids visit. These toys belong to the house, not to any visiting children who want to take them away with them.

I don’t understand why the Ops visitors don’t understand this common custom. Fair enough if the child was 3 , he would need it explained. But not at 8. I assume the child goes on play dates to his friends homes and doesn’t load up a bag of their toys when he leaves?

Your Bf is out of order @MiniMileaway

PurpleBugz · 20/06/2023 17:05

How long have you been with partner?

How much does partner have his child?

If 50/50 or close enough fair enough but if it's something like every other weekend - If he has his own home why is step kiddo staying at yours? This is time for child and father not child to get board while father has a relationship and dads gf realising kid board and getting toys.

For that matter if they are at your enough for you to see a need for toys why has the father not seen this?

Re the toys I think YANBU. Toys can be for just one house as long as the child has the freedom to take favourites back and forth. But it sounds like he took quite a few so that's not the case here.

deveronvalley · 20/06/2023 17:04

The boyfriend and his son are visitors to your house - you've been very considerate to provide his son with something to do while he is there. But this is not their house and they shouldn't have taken stuff out of it without asking. Going between parents' houses is different and toys/clothes might be more transferable - that's up to them. It seems like your home is gradually becoming their home without any sort of discussion or boundaries being put in. If you don't want this, it's time to speak up.

Bananalanacake · 20/06/2023 16:42

Don't let him move in with you, he sounds like a right freeloader

Mumof4plusbonus · 20/06/2023 16:26

What does dp do about toys at his house? Does he send them all home? I don’t like when kids can’t bring a toy between houses. That was the way it was with my dss and I never liked it. If things went back to his mums though it never returned, and he was never allowed to bring stuff to ours. Ideally it should be their stuff to bring where they please though. However a box of stuff to play at your house is very different than one toy that’s a present that he can bring home and back again.

off · 20/06/2023 16:26

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 16:05

The DS didn’t take all the toys either…I would presume he wasn’t finished playing with them.

OP said BF let his DS pack up a lot of the toys and take them with him, including at least one other, unopened set. A bit different from, say, being halfway through solving a puzzle or whatever, and asking nicely to borrow it and bring it back next week.

The reason I mentioned borrowing is to show that you can even have flexibility in there if you want, while still having no difficulty understanding that just taking away a load of the stuff you've been invited to enjoy while visiting, without even asking, is unacceptable.

Since you wanted an adult parallel involving books, I gave you one that actually happens.

YoucancallmeKAREN · 20/06/2023 16:15

Sprinkles211 · 18/06/2023 20:30

Things belong to the child not to the house

Ok, so any child that comes through your door can just help themselves ? Should the OP replace the toys every other weekend ?

LimeCheesecake · 20/06/2023 16:12

I would just be clear to your DP - “hi DP are you bringing DSS here this weekend? If so, make sure you bring some toys for him to play with as he took the toys back last time and there’s nothing for him to play with now.” If he suggests dss can share your dcs things say no, you thought you’d been clear they don’t want to share their things which is why you bought a set of toys for dss to play with when here. As DP let him take the toys away with him, it’s it down ti DP to ensure there’s things for DSS to play with next time he’s at yours.

Cas112 · 20/06/2023 16:09

Yes it would annoy me too because the likelihood of them coming back is low and then you will have to purchase more and it will become a recurring thing

theemmadilemma · 20/06/2023 16:07

I get the thinking, seems totally reasonable right?

But it's just so difficult in reality. You've just provided new toys and now he can't continue to play with them, they aren't really his because he has to leave them behind etc. It's a bit shit.

In the end (back in the day when I was a SM) it was easier to just let them come to the understanding that if everything went home, it would leave nothing there to play with and so they would need to bring things back and forward.

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 16:05

off · 20/06/2023 16:03

My family member has a bookcase full of books on their landing, and I know I'm welcome to read any of them if I didn't bring anything to read with me. I might possibly ask to take one home with me if get halfway through and didn't finish, and bring it back next time. I don't empty their bookshelf into the boot of my car when I leave.

The DS didn’t take all the toys either…I would presume he wasn’t finished playing with them.

off · 20/06/2023 16:03

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 15:30

So, say your MIL gives you a gift of a book to read, and then objects when you take it away with you because she says that book is meant to be so you have something to read when you are visiting her? That’s reasonable? Sorry I don’t agree.

My family member has a bookcase full of books on their landing, and I know I'm welcome to read any of them if I didn't bring anything to read with me. I might possibly ask to take one home with me if get halfway through and didn't finish, and bring it back next time. I don't empty their bookshelf into the boot of my car when I leave.

itshotontheplayground · 20/06/2023 15:59

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 15:30

So, say your MIL gives you a gift of a book to read, and then objects when you take it away with you because she says that book is meant to be so you have something to read when you are visiting her? That’s reasonable? Sorry I don’t agree.

My MIL has a few boxes of toys for visiting children. Some Fisher Price and lego going back decades, some new.

She also gives gifts to the children.

There has never been any confusion between the 2, even among the youngest children 😂

HoneybeesAndBluebells · 20/06/2023 15:56

We have the opposite problem, grandparents let DS take toys home to our house. Toys then subsequently go missing and/or grandparents ask for them back as they have nothing at theirs for DS to play with, it's a royal pain in the arse.
Yanbu toys at your house should stay there unless specified otherwise.

caringcarer · 20/06/2023 15:53

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 14:43

Im baffled by this. You bought toys for your step son - fantastic very good of you. But you want your step son to only play with them when he is staying at home with you? I think that is unreasonable.

It’s hard enough to be a child going between two homes without adults dictating which toys can only be in which house. If you say the toys you bought him he can’t take with him to his other home, then they’re not a gift. They’re not his toys. They’re your toys and you only let him play with your toys when he is with you.

I think that’s really petty. Of course you should not replace the toys, but give the kid the freedom to take HIS favourite toys back and forth between his two homes. If his mum takes his toys and sells them/whatever then your DH should address that with her as that is abusive parenting.

But if the child had favourite toys at his Mum's every time he visits his Dad and OP he is arriving without them every single time, then expecting to play with OP's children's toys. Why do you think this is if favourite toys go two ways?

Louoby · 20/06/2023 15:50

I do not think you are unreasonable. You bought him toys for your house to play with whilst he is at yours. You did not gift him toys to take him - it's very different. Maybe you should of said they are toys for everyone and not just him. I would be telling your boyfriend to make sure they are returned to your house as they weren't just for him to enjoy!

caringcarer · 20/06/2023 15:50

Theunamedcat · 18/06/2023 22:25

Everytime he tries to share your children's toys say no you have your own in your box that I bought you

This and if bf comments remind him he would have had something nice to play with if he hadn't sent them to his Mum's house.

caringcarer · 20/06/2023 15:47

lalaloopyhead · 18/06/2023 20:42

My Mum bought toys for my kids to play with at her house but I never considered that they belonged to my kids! How very strange of your BF to take them...have you asked why?
YANBU at all.

Same here. My Mum had a toy cupboard at her house and all of her dgc played with them and they remained there for the next time they went.

Globules · 20/06/2023 15:43

I have a box of toys for young children to play with when they come round. I want the whole family to feel welcome.

The toys are mine. Not the visiting child's.

Stressfordays · 20/06/2023 15:40

Yeah I don't think they should have been taken. Most people who have children visiting their home if their own children aren't in that age bracket have a box of toys. Mine are all out of baby age but I keep a small box as my friends are still having babies. Id ask boyfriend to replace or bring back.

cstaff · 20/06/2023 15:37

My mam as a gm has always kept toys in her house for her grandkids over the last 30 years. Things like lego, cards, board games etc. They have gotten great usage and no-one ever felt the need to take them home. Your bf and his 8yo are being complete jerks. If they don't bring them back definitely don't replace them. Real jerk move to such a lovely gesture from you.

twoshedsjackson · 20/06/2023 15:33

Perfectly reasonable to have toys which stay at your house for visiting children, and he's old enough to understand that,
(I still have a small toy cupboard on the go; on a recent visit, my undergraduate goddaughter made a beeline for her childhood favourite, as a reminder of younger days; she accepted quite happily, as a tiny, that this was where they lived.)
Next time a visit is planned, send a reminder in advance that this was your intention when buying them, clearly expecting them to be returned.
As PP said, his response will tell you a great deal.
Not the slightest possibility of replacing them.

L3ThirtySeven · 20/06/2023 15:30

ScientificallyProcessedCrisps · 20/06/2023 15:11

Im baffled by this. You bought toys for your step son - fantastic very good of you. But you want your step son to only play with them when he is staying at home with you? I think that is unreasonable.

It really isn’t. 🙄

So, say your MIL gives you a gift of a book to read, and then objects when you take it away with you because she says that book is meant to be so you have something to read when you are visiting her? That’s reasonable? Sorry I don’t agree.

changeyerheadworzel · 20/06/2023 15:23

No I would be pissed off, they are toys you bought so he would have toys to play with when he was in your house, they were not a present or a gift to be taken away.

LaMaG · 20/06/2023 15:19

YANBU. Its most likely a simple misunderstanding. Many kids at 8 still need very clear instructions and maybe BF didn't realise either? Is say next time BF is bringing DS remind him to bring back the toys for your toy box and make is very clear to the child and Dad that these toys are for this house.