Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to go against HV & midwife's advice

113 replies

Boymamabee22 · 18/06/2023 20:15

Combo feeding but I've been ff more this past week.

May have to move into temp accommodation so thinking of selling my perfect prep machine due to lack of space, etc.

Been told I shouldn't make bottles in advance and store them in the fridge (like I did with my first). Can somebody tell me why? Obviously I'll cool the bottles before storing them and I always make sure the fridge is clean.

Waiting 20 minutes for the kettle to cool and then another 20 mins for the milk to cool is a faff and v difficult with a screaming baby.

OP posts:
Redebs · 18/06/2023 23:13

Dubaibutwhy · 18/06/2023 21:06

Hot water to sterilise the milk powder then cold water to cool it to drinking temp. Get your ratios right and it takes 5 mins.

Alternative is buying cartons for night feeds and pooping in microwave. Shaking to avoid hot spots obviously

Definitely don't poop in the microwave. That's not ok.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 18/06/2023 22:48

Just make sure your storage system is top notch and if in doubt, dump it.

Mommasgotabrandnewbag · 18/06/2023 22:47

We did this for our first, born in 2013.

Made enough for 12 hours, wash sterilise and repeat for overnight feeds. It's fine, they're still alive to tell the tale.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 18/06/2023 22:42

Kidsaregrim · 18/06/2023 22:40

We have had lots of poorly babies whose milk has not been prepped or made correctly.

which but of this are you intrigued about? I would be happy to explain further?

Has that been given as an official cause? Poorly with what?

Kidsaregrim · 18/06/2023 22:40

We have had lots of poorly babies whose milk has not been prepped or made correctly.

which but of this are you intrigued about? I would be happy to explain further?

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/06/2023 22:20

@Boymamabee22 you can also pre-empt when a bottle will be needed so right at the start of the hunger cues, get it made, it really shouldn't take longer than ten minutes or so to have it made up and ready using the methods I've mentioned.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/06/2023 22:18

@Boymamabee22 if you need the bottle quickly, you can also pop the freshly made up bottle in a jug of cold water or run it under the cold tap to cool it down.

TeaKitten · 18/06/2023 22:17

sandberry · 18/06/2023 22:13

It’s definitely how they make up powdered formula in NICU. My daughter was on powdered formula in the NICU of a very well known children’s hospital and later on the ward and in the PICU and they prepare formula 12 hours in advance.

Most preterm infants are on liquid formulas anyway but where powdered formula is needed it is prepped in advance.

This is a dangerous exception to the norm thankfully. It’s significantly more risky for babies in NICU and not something I would encourage anyone to think is ok in those situations. Especially in a communal fridge when the door can get left open and you’d never no etc. it’s just piss poor practice.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/06/2023 22:16

Hi @Boymamabee22 , I'm a Food Safety Consultant, so qualified in food safety to the same level as Environmental Health Officers. The reason that formula should be made up fresh for each feed using boiled water from a kettle (not perfect prep machine), is because the formula powder is not sterile and contains food poisoning bacteria in it. It needs contact with the boiling water to make sure the powder reaches a high enough temperature to kill any harmful bacteria in it.

The perfect prep machine does not pass safety testing for this essential step of killing the bacteria, so they are not recommended.

It will always be safer to make bottles up freshly to order, as even making them with a kettle and storing in the fridge can mean bacteria can still multiply, this is to prevent your baby becoming seriously ill with food poisoning.

What you can do is add boiled water from the kettle, do not let it cool for 20 mins as then it won't be hot enough to kill the bacteria. Add about two thirds of the water required to the powder, shake well, leave it to stand to give the temperature of the water time for the bacteria to be killed. Then top it off with the last third with some water that has previously been boiled in the kettle but is now at room temperature or has been in the fridge, so that'll get the bottle to the right temperature quicker. This is safer than a perfect prep machine as the pp machine doesn't add enough water in the hot shot and the temperature isn't high enough to kill the bacteria.

sandberry · 18/06/2023 22:13

It’s definitely how they make up powdered formula in NICU. My daughter was on powdered formula in the NICU of a very well known children’s hospital and later on the ward and in the PICU and they prepare formula 12 hours in advance.

Most preterm infants are on liquid formulas anyway but where powdered formula is needed it is prepped in advance.

BettyBoopy · 18/06/2023 21:52

Hankunamatata · 18/06/2023 20:18

I'm totally out of touch as my kids are older but is there any reason you cant just put some boiling water into the bottle with the powder and top of with cooled pre boiled water (that you keep in the fridge)

This 💯

ShowOfHands · 18/06/2023 21:51

Aah just checked. It's insufficient temperature rather than volume.

RosesAndHellebores · 18/06/2023 21:50

Well I don't know how DS survived. I sterilised the bottles, made-up 7oz of formula with 5.5 oz of boiling water, kept 6 bottles in the fridge for 24 hours and added 1.5oz of boiling water when a bottle was needed. He was never sick and never had the runs.

My Mwives told me to rest the breast, not rest the breast, to use breadt pads, not use breast pads. That being engorged was OK. Hollow laugh.

My HV told me shebwas responsible for immunities my baby, breast was best and when I rang and sobbed due to the pain told me to sit by the fire and wrap myself in a blanket. When I objected, she told me to phone the NCT. The NCT told me to take paracetamol every four hours to take the edge off the pain.

I followed the guidance of the NCT breast pump lady, a former A&E sister whontook one look at me, went to the chemist and bought me two bottles, a tinnof Aptamil and showed me what to do.

After infective mastitis, thrush of the inner breast, and a breast abscess it was the first time I was out of pain for ten weeks and DS settled. DS grew into a happy chap, brought me home a first from Oxbridge, got a PhD and made the 1st XI cricket, 1st XI football and 1st XV rugby.

The chair of the HV Association was quoted in the Times as saying the role of the HV was to teach ignorant mothers the three c's: cooking, cleaning and communication.

I'll listen to an experienced mother or fully qualified doctorel, before I'd ever listen to a midwife or HV again. When DD was born a few years later all went swimmingly because I banned the HV's from the house, had more experience and refused to let in more than two named community midwives.

ShowOfHands · 18/06/2023 21:49

putthatdownsteve · 18/06/2023 21:40

The only reason perfect preps get a bad rep is because of idiots who don’t read the instructions and don’t clean them properly. Also people who buy cheap filters that shouldn’t be used in them, or never change the filters in the first place.
.
There was a mum I knew who heard they could get mouldy, took hers apart and shouted from the roof tops that it was and how dangerous they were. Turns out, she had used it over two babies for 3 years solid and had never done the cleaning cycle or even washed it out.

This isn't quite true. Yes the filter and cleaning is an additional issue, but the reason they aren't recommended is that the hot shot isn't of sufficient volume to destroy all bacteria.

putthatdownsteve · 18/06/2023 21:40

The only reason perfect preps get a bad rep is because of idiots who don’t read the instructions and don’t clean them properly. Also people who buy cheap filters that shouldn’t be used in them, or never change the filters in the first place.
.
There was a mum I knew who heard they could get mouldy, took hers apart and shouted from the roof tops that it was and how dangerous they were. Turns out, she had used it over two babies for 3 years solid and had never done the cleaning cycle or even washed it out.

Debini · 18/06/2023 21:39

I prepared all my bottles in advance when I had my baby 15 years ago. It’s not recommended by my hV now but it is actually on the NHS website saying it’s fine to do so the advice very conflicting.
I had a baby 8 weeks ago and using the prep machine didn’t agree with her, I’ve swapped to pre-making them and she has much less wind and her poops are better too.
Just do what works for you.

Skodacool · 18/06/2023 21:38

humpty74 · 18/06/2023 20:25

With a bit of experimentation you can replicate what the prep machine does, put boiling water into bottles, seal them and chill them.

Take new bottle, put powder and boiling water in, give it a shake, top up with the water from a bottle in the fridge, give it a shake, check temperature. Use the now empty bottle for the next feed etc.

With some experimentation you know the volumes of hot and cold to make it the right temperature. The important bit is putting boiling water onto the powder to sterilise it.

This

ChateauMargaux · 18/06/2023 21:37

The water should not be boiling when it touches the formula, it releases BPA from the bottles at a rate of 55 times more than cooled water and destroys nutrients including thiamin, folate, pantothenic acid and vitamin C.

Livindavivaloca · 18/06/2023 21:35

I was advised against pre-preps because the tubes get dirty and it doesn’t get the formula hot enough to be sterilised.

you can’t win 🤷🏻‍♀️

I bought the ready made stuff which was a lifesaver with multiples

Anycrispsleft · 18/06/2023 21:34

In the UK HV and midwives will tell you that the water has to be boiling when it touches the powder as the powder is not sterile. But here in Germany there is no instruction on the milk packets to do that and none of my friends here was ever given that advice. I made up bottles of boiled, cooled water and stored them in the fridge, then added formula and warmed in the microwave.

JeandeServiette · 18/06/2023 21:32

Newname2323 · 18/06/2023 21:20

Did it with all mine made up 6 bottles, rapid cooled them in the small compartment of the sink and put them in the fridge. Used within 24 hours. My youngest isn't a year old yet so not years ago. Once they were on solids I stopped and made up as and when. All my kids were greedy and impatient in the first few months, I wouldn't have survived without doing it this way. You do have to be very careful making sure they don't go over 24 hrs, are cooled correctly etc. All advice is just that, so do what you thinks best!

Even doing 12 hours' worth at a time (if you understand the theory and the risks) prevents that bit where a hungry newborn melts down if they don't get a teat within 60 seconds. There's no reason it has to be 24 hours' worth made up at a time.

MsCactus · 18/06/2023 21:31

Boil water in advance - put it in a flask, or two flasks, for the day.

Put dry scoops of formula into your bottles for the day and secure the lid. When you need to make up a bottle, undo the flask, pour in the boiled water and shake.

This will drastically cut down bottle making time, but won't run the risk of the milk spoiling and causing illness (which can happen when you mix up bottles in advance - dry formula doesn't start to spoil until it's mixed with water)

JeandeServiette · 18/06/2023 21:30

ChateauMargaux · 18/06/2023 21:15

@Kidsaregrim .. I am intrigued that you have had 'lots of poorly babies' and my understanding is that cases associated with Cronobacter sakazakii, which is the main concern, are incredibly rare: Approximately 130 cases of Cronobacter infections, including 20 cases in adults, have been documented worldwide in the last 50 years including 27 deaths.

https://www.anses.fr/en/system/files/MIC2000sa0003FiEN.pdf

Hmm. That's quite a discrepancy.

I've never seen a case of a baby I'll sue to formula prep hit the headlines, I know that.

Mammatoone · 18/06/2023 21:29

Buy a Nuby rapid cool. I bought mine for about £25 on Amazon and wouldn't have been without it. It cools the bottle made with boiling water to the perfect temperature in 2 minutes. I wouldn't have been without it when baby was newborn. It's also great to take out if baby is screaming for a bottle in a restaurant so you don't have to wait ages for it to cool down. By far the best purchase I made. Keep a flask of boiled water so that you don't have to boil the kettle each time too.

TeaKitten · 18/06/2023 21:27

sandberry · 18/06/2023 21:21

It’s the second safest way. You absolutely can do it and anyone who doesn’t know that, hasn’t read the WHO or the NHS guidance.

Making up bottles in advance, flash cooling them and storing in the back of the fridge is safer than the flapping around with hot shots etc people do and safer than the perfect prep too.

Basically make up each bottle one at a time as needed (ideal)
or make in advance, flash cool, store in fridge and use within 24 hours. Obviously the less time you store the safer they are.
This is how they prepare powdered formula in NICU too.

NICU do not prepare formula by leaving it in the fridge for 24 hours. Why would they? Premature babies are far more vulnerable that others and there are staff there 24/7 that can help with making fresh bottles if needed. Any unit taking a risk like that with premature babies needs seriously looking at.