Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to go against HV & midwife's advice

113 replies

Boymamabee22 · 18/06/2023 20:15

Combo feeding but I've been ff more this past week.

May have to move into temp accommodation so thinking of selling my perfect prep machine due to lack of space, etc.

Been told I shouldn't make bottles in advance and store them in the fridge (like I did with my first). Can somebody tell me why? Obviously I'll cool the bottles before storing them and I always make sure the fridge is clean.

Waiting 20 minutes for the kettle to cool and then another 20 mins for the milk to cool is a faff and v difficult with a screaming baby.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 19/06/2023 07:55

@madwife123 my babies are grown up now. I made the bottles, adding 5 oz boiling water onto 7oz powder, shaking and storing in the fridge for 24 hours. Added the additional 2oz straight from a boiled kettle at feeding time and a good shake to make sure there were no hotspots. All bottles sterilised.

In the odd emergency I made up a bottle with cold water and warmed it - not often.

May I ask, in a country like the UK with clean water what actual percentage of babies get bacterial poisoning? Or is it a bit like the anti FF mantra of midwives in the mid to late 90s where they would only talk or recommend bf and shunned women for whom it didn't work, refusing any advice or guidance or support to switch. Overall my baby and I suffered far more for 10 weeks than if I,'d been empowered to stop doing something that was agony and making me ill.

Madwife123 · 19/06/2023 07:37

Redebs · 19/06/2023 06:35

It's actually quite a challenge to cool liquids quickly. Making bottles in advance is risky because as they cool, they incubate bacteria rapidly and it might take an hour to get a bottle cool enough to go in the fridge.
The fridge needs to be left closed while formula is stored there. If you keep opening the door, then the bacteria count goes up.
Then they are reheated to feed baby and left around for another hour or two. By this time they are full of potentially harmful bacteria.

Adding cooled, boiled water that has been stored in 'sterilised' bottles to top up a freshly made 70°+ feed is really the only safe option. It also gets around the issue of feeding bottles too hot, which I've seen with friends who mistakenly think running a feed under the tap will cool it enough.

Or just feed ready-prepared at room temperature.

I agree with previous poster that those prep machines are not safe. There's a lot of hype about them, but no guarantee of safety.

The method you suggest is not safe at all!

The formula is not sterile, it must be added to freshly boiled water, left no longer than 20 minutes, to kill the bacteria in the formula.

Using a small amount of boiled water and topping it up a) is not a sufficient volume of water to kill the bacteria b) does not keep the bacteria in contact with the hot water long enough to kill it all. This is why the perfect prep machine is advised against also.

Cooling quickly and storing in the fridge is far far safer than what you suggest hence WHO, NHS and CDC suggest it.

Redebs · 19/06/2023 06:35

It's actually quite a challenge to cool liquids quickly. Making bottles in advance is risky because as they cool, they incubate bacteria rapidly and it might take an hour to get a bottle cool enough to go in the fridge.
The fridge needs to be left closed while formula is stored there. If you keep opening the door, then the bacteria count goes up.
Then they are reheated to feed baby and left around for another hour or two. By this time they are full of potentially harmful bacteria.

Adding cooled, boiled water that has been stored in 'sterilised' bottles to top up a freshly made 70°+ feed is really the only safe option. It also gets around the issue of feeding bottles too hot, which I've seen with friends who mistakenly think running a feed under the tap will cool it enough.

Or just feed ready-prepared at room temperature.

I agree with previous poster that those prep machines are not safe. There's a lot of hype about them, but no guarantee of safety.

cuckyplunt · 19/06/2023 06:32

I used to boil water, put it in bottles in the fridge, when required, microwave the waterin the bottles, shake, test the temperature and then add milk powder and shake again.

TedLassosBiscuits · 19/06/2023 06:14

@sandberry that's shocking! I worked In nicu and we had ready made formula from all the big brands in tiny bottles with separate sterile tests st different flow rates and tiny sterile water bottles, the only time I used powder is to add a thickener to feed.

Keeping made up formula in a communal fridge is appalling practice

My2pence2day · 19/06/2023 03:22

ReadingSoManyThreads · 18/06/2023 22:16

Hi @Boymamabee22 , I'm a Food Safety Consultant, so qualified in food safety to the same level as Environmental Health Officers. The reason that formula should be made up fresh for each feed using boiled water from a kettle (not perfect prep machine), is because the formula powder is not sterile and contains food poisoning bacteria in it. It needs contact with the boiling water to make sure the powder reaches a high enough temperature to kill any harmful bacteria in it.

The perfect prep machine does not pass safety testing for this essential step of killing the bacteria, so they are not recommended.

It will always be safer to make bottles up freshly to order, as even making them with a kettle and storing in the fridge can mean bacteria can still multiply, this is to prevent your baby becoming seriously ill with food poisoning.

What you can do is add boiled water from the kettle, do not let it cool for 20 mins as then it won't be hot enough to kill the bacteria. Add about two thirds of the water required to the powder, shake well, leave it to stand to give the temperature of the water time for the bacteria to be killed. Then top it off with the last third with some water that has previously been boiled in the kettle but is now at room temperature or has been in the fridge, so that'll get the bottle to the right temperature quicker. This is safer than a perfect prep machine as the pp machine doesn't add enough water in the hot shot and the temperature isn't high enough to kill the bacteria.

Yay an actual expert, rather than randoms! OP it's all about risk and what you're willing to risk. Factor in the age and general health of your baby when doing this.

coronafiona · 19/06/2023 02:37

I made up bottles with water and added powder just before feeding them. It was quicker.

Lottiexox · 19/06/2023 02:24

Nuby rapid cool! Please invest in one it’s the best thing I bought and portable! X

RosesAndHellebores · 19/06/2023 02:16

It was thus in 1994 @Madwife123. There have always been mantras and boxes to tick with limited listening.

Madwife123 · 19/06/2023 00:11

We’ve seen the exact same problem when it comes to bed sharing.

Midwives banned from talking about it. Tell all mothers they absolutely must not do it and offer no additional information. But mothers do it anyway, because they are humans not robots and for some mothers it’s the only way they get any sleep. Except now we haven’t taught them how to do it safely so the SIDS rate goes up. And all of a sudden it’s panic stations and lullaby trust release advice on safe bed sharing.

All could have been avoided if we simply shared this advice all along. Banning healthcare professionals from educating mothers who make a choice that the powers that be decide isn’t the right choice helps no one.

I swear my job is more about ticking a box and keeping management happy these days than actually supporting mothers as individuals with their own choices, wants and needs. Midwifery is so far away from what it’s supposed to be it’s unreal!

Footinturf · 19/06/2023 00:10

I've done the make up bottles correctly and store in fridge for two kids (still doing it for one of them) and have had absolutely no issues. I'd really recommend it, it's very handy. Making up a fresh bottle each time is unrealistic!

TimeToMoveIt · 19/06/2023 00:05

Don't know why they bothered changing advice then, with my first 2 we made them up quickly cooled them and put them in the fridge . By the time my 3rd came along 12 years ago it was make them when needed.

I'd keep the prep machine if you can op

Thesearmsofmine · 19/06/2023 00:02

Nobody is disputing that making it fresh each time is the most ideal way however it is not always realistic to do so and both the NHS and WHO say that to quickly cool and store in the back of the fridge is acceptable.

OP I did this with my 3 dc.

Madwife123 · 19/06/2023 00:00

@mrsneate
@TeaKitten

Here is the CDC leaflet. Also says it’s safe to store in a fridge!

But you are perfectly proving my point that banning health professionals educating regarding formula and making us treat it like its poison has led to this.

https://www.cdc.gov/nutrition/downloads/prepare-store-powered-infant-formula-508.pdf

https://www.cdc.gov/nutrition/downloads/prepare-store-powered-infant-formula-508.pdf

Madwife123 · 18/06/2023 23:57

@mrsneate The NHS only updates when advice changes. That’s not unusual.

@TeaKitten No actually it says if you have to take a feed out with you etc. The first choice is always make fresh, but a safe second choice is storing in the fridge in a safe manner. All the rubbish on here about making with cool boiled water is dangerous and it’s this that starts to happen because we are not advising women how to safely store formula! That’s how perfect prep machine started which also isn’t safe. Women will make it easier somehow and it’s better they do the second safe alternative than some other dangerous shortcut because people tell them it isn’t safe when it’s absolutely fine!

TeaKitten · 18/06/2023 23:52

Madwife123 · 18/06/2023 23:48

God this drives me mad seeing all this misinformation!

First of all I’m a midwife.
Second of all YOU CAN MAKE FORMULA IN ADVANCE AND STORE IN THE FRIDGE!!!!

Here is the link to the NHS advice. If you scroll down it explains you make the bottle up, flash cool it quickly and store in the back of the fridge (not the door) for up to 24 hours.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/bottle-feeding/formula-milk-questions/

Midwives used to teach mothers this. Then along came baby friendly initiative who quite literally stopped for a period of time midwives educating about formula feeding. We literally were not allowed. Now years of that and so much misinformation spread we have a whole load of mothers (and midwives) who don’t know what you can and can’t do anymore!

It says if you can not make up fresh, and explains fresh is best. Seems you are no better than your colleagues.

mrsneate · 18/06/2023 23:50

Madwife123 · 18/06/2023 23:48

God this drives me mad seeing all this misinformation!

First of all I’m a midwife.
Second of all YOU CAN MAKE FORMULA IN ADVANCE AND STORE IN THE FRIDGE!!!!

Here is the link to the NHS advice. If you scroll down it explains you make the bottle up, flash cool it quickly and store in the back of the fridge (not the door) for up to 24 hours.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/bottle-feeding/formula-milk-questions/

Midwives used to teach mothers this. Then along came baby friendly initiative who quite literally stopped for a period of time midwives educating about formula feeding. We literally were not allowed. Now years of that and so much misinformation spread we have a whole load of mothers (and midwives) who don’t know what you can and can’t do anymore!

Page hasn't been updated in 3 years so not the most up to date information

Milkand2sugarsplease · 18/06/2023 23:49

The WHO has a section about making in advance and storing safely in the fridge for up to 24hrs. As long as you've made the bottles using booking water in the first place you're fine to make a few at a time and store for later.

Madwife123 · 18/06/2023 23:49

@Boymamabee22 Forgot to tag you in my reply above.

Read the NHS link. You can make bottles in advance and store in the fridge!

Madwife123 · 18/06/2023 23:48

God this drives me mad seeing all this misinformation!

First of all I’m a midwife.
Second of all YOU CAN MAKE FORMULA IN ADVANCE AND STORE IN THE FRIDGE!!!!

Here is the link to the NHS advice. If you scroll down it explains you make the bottle up, flash cool it quickly and store in the back of the fridge (not the door) for up to 24 hours.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/bottle-feeding/formula-milk-questions/

Midwives used to teach mothers this. Then along came baby friendly initiative who quite literally stopped for a period of time midwives educating about formula feeding. We literally were not allowed. Now years of that and so much misinformation spread we have a whole load of mothers (and midwives) who don’t know what you can and can’t do anymore!

nhs.uk

Formula milk: common questions

Information and advice on formula feeding, including how much formula to give your baby, how many wet nappies they should have and how to handle feeds away from home.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/breastfeeding-and-bottle-feeding/bottle-feeding/formula-milk-questions/

Nat6999 · 18/06/2023 23:48

I used to make up 6 feeds first thing in a morning while washing & sterilising the other 6 bottles for the evening & night feeds then put them in the back of the fridge. As ds was feeding at least every 3 hours there was no chance of any bottle being in the fridge for over 24 hours. As he got bigger I dropped down to only making 4 at a time.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 18/06/2023 23:33

Mumtobabyhavoc · 18/06/2023 23:22

I stand corrected. Thank you for that. ☺️
I switched to doing it that way at about 7 months, so I guess was lucky! Thanks, again.

Was curious so just read the package. It states to use cooled boiled water. Doesn't specify water temp for mixing. Might be different country to country? I am in Canada. Brand is Enfamil. Used the same method with Costco's Kirkland brand. Obviously, follow package directions for the product you are using. Sorry for any confusion if you have different package directions there.

mrsneate · 18/06/2023 23:33

sandberry · 18/06/2023 21:21

It’s the second safest way. You absolutely can do it and anyone who doesn’t know that, hasn’t read the WHO or the NHS guidance.

Making up bottles in advance, flash cooling them and storing in the back of the fridge is safer than the flapping around with hot shots etc people do and safer than the perfect prep too.

Basically make up each bottle one at a time as needed (ideal)
or make in advance, flash cool, store in fridge and use within 24 hours. Obviously the less time you store the safer they are.
This is how they prepare powdered formula in NICU too.

Which nicu is this?!

We used ready made formula bottles on ours, which we open, make up into amounts and store in fridge for 10-12 hours

Breast milk is the same.

Nicu do not use powdered formula...

Mumtobabyhavoc · 18/06/2023 23:22

ChateauMargaux · 18/06/2023 21:26

@Mumtobabyhavoc... but that doesn't kill the bacteria in the powdered formula - it needs to be not less than 70 degrees when added to the formula.

You are not trying to kill the bacteria in the water by boiling and cooling, it's bacteria in the powdered formula that is the problem.

I stand corrected. Thank you for that. ☺️
I switched to doing it that way at about 7 months, so I guess was lucky! Thanks, again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread