Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To love my dogs as much as my kid?

107 replies

passioninthisworld · 18/06/2023 17:59

Okay rationally, I know that if I had to choose between saving my dogs or saving my kid, I'd choose my kid of course. But wow, do I love my dogs.

I've had cats in the past and dogs growing up and sure I've loved them and been fond of them but these two are honestly like my children.

They're very small dogs so not sure if that makes a difference as they can be 'baby like' but I honestly feel the same way I did with my daughter when I was bonding with her.

Pure pride, contentment when I'm with them. I still feel this way when with my daughter but she is getting into the teens and is quite moody and sometimes just doesn't seem to like me very much. My dogs are always happy to see me and they keep me company when my daughter is out or at her dads for the weekend.

I just love them so much, I get this fuzzy feeling when I look at them and they've honestly brought me soooo much joy the past year and a bit.

It was hard in the beginning but now that they're all trained they are just lovely.

Does anyone else feel this way about their pets? Is it normal?

OP posts:
Avondale89 · 18/06/2023 21:30

I love my old rescue dog to a ridiculous extent. I’ve only had him a year and I already think about how sad I’ll be when he dies.

However, it’s incomparable to how I feel about my child or partner. You just can’t compare the two as it’s, obviously, completely different.

Certainly normal to like dogs more on difficult days 😂 but it’s easy to love a dog isn’t it? They don’t ask for much and provide unconditional love, no matter what you look or behave like. However actual human relationships take effort and people talk back!

I assume this is a lighthearted comment but, as others have said, please don’t mention it in front of your child.

AmeliaWarnerBros · 18/06/2023 21:29

As a happily childfree person, I get it. I love my dog more than anything & have never wanted a human child. My sister- who has a son & 3 dogs- loves her human & fur babies more or less the same. Pets are wonderful 💕

MiniTheMinx · 18/06/2023 21:29

I spend more time with my dog than my DC, but they are older. I like spending time with my dog and it brings me happiness. I sometimes think I do love him more, but I think I just respond to the fact the dog is more dependent on me than the DC now. I'm fairly certain I'd be very upset if something happened to him, but since dogs have a shorter life I fully expect to lose the dog one day. If anything happened to my sons I would be devastated because I expect them to outlive me.

WeedSmellDramas · 18/06/2023 21:29

Groutyonehereagain · 18/06/2023 18:50

Another take on this, when my friend’s dog died she said she was more upset than when her parents died. I do sort of get that.

Actually I have felt this.

But.

I think it's due to the simplicity of a pet dying.

When I lost my old girl a few years ago I was absolutely heartbroken. She was a rescue, she'd had a hard first couple of years and I was the first human she ever trusted or loved and she loved me with all of her heart.

We'd had 15+ wonderful years together. With only love and good feelings.

When she was put to sleep I wailed. I cried on and off for days. I was so sad. And so full of loss and sadness for the love we had for each other.

I have also recently lost a parent.

It was a long gruelling illness that took them. I sat by their bed for days at the end wishing the struggle would be over for them. Even though really they should have had 20 years more life to live.

I was of course and still am sad.

But I had so much to do afterwards. Sort the funeral, finances, look after my other parent, be a parent myself.

Untangle our sometimes tricky relationship in my head.

The sadness was and is so different as there's so many other emotions and things involved.

Animal relationships are so pure and uncomplicated. It makes it easier to grieve but I also think that simpleness makes it easier to just feel that overwhelming sadness of the loss.

I can't (or won't allow myself to) feel that with my lost parent. There's too much to do and cope with and untangle.

Earlydancing · 18/06/2023 21:25

Poetnojo · 18/06/2023 18:11

Jesus no, I don't love my dog anywhere near as much as I love my children, and I would feel quite hurt if I thought my mother loved an animal as much or almost as much as she loved me

I think both my mum and my dad did. But to be honest I was never hurt because she was the most gorgeous, sweet natured angel. I don't blame them.

Kanaloa · 18/06/2023 21:24

The pets I often like more. And am on the surface more tolerant and patient with (pre-teen in this house and a lot of attitude some days.)

I wonder if this is what people mean - I definitely see how you can like your dog more 😂 when the kids are stroppy and demanding despite having the world at their feet and the dog is delighted because you say let’s go for a walk!

WeedSmellDramas · 18/06/2023 21:21

Adore my pets. Love them unquestioningly. I prefer animals to people undoubtedly.

The pets I often like more. And am on the surface more tolerant and patient with (pre-teen in this house and a lot of attitude some days.)

But.

Nowhere close to how I feel about my DC.

I'm not nearly as proud of their achievements. Invested in their futures or worried about how the world will treat them.

If one died suddenly I'd of course be devastated. But I I'd get over it.

If my DC died I'm not sure how I'd keep on living.

AnxDog · 18/06/2023 20:57

Sounds completely normal to me!
I had 1 DC and had no plans for anymore so when my DC wanted to get a dog i agreed although I'd never owned one before. Well I fell completely in love with my dog, she was my baby, I loved her just as much as my DC and I loved her just as much as my my DC2 when they came along unexpectedly 🤣 I never thought it was possible to bond with a pet in a similar way to children but I 100% did.
The only difference being my dog unfortunately passed last year and while I was devastated I did have to move on with life, I can't imagine losing a child and I could never compare that to losing a pet 💔

NewNovember · 18/06/2023 20:42

That's actually quite worrying.

Silvergoldandglitter · 18/06/2023 20:40

God no way do I love my dogs like my child. I find it weird that people think like this.

Austenland · 18/06/2023 20:37

No need for competition in our house. Happy people don’t need to rank their partner, kids, pets, family, friends etc in order of how much they’re loved. I need all the ones I love in my life.

This.

I have found people that are keen to tell you who they love more. aren’t very nice at all. They are so busy talking about it to prove a point, but don’t show much love at all. It’s all about themselves.

HamBone · 18/06/2023 20:37

Atethehalloweenchocs · 18/06/2023 19:58

Relationships with animals are much easier than with humans. I get the warm and fuzzys too.

@Atethehalloweenchocs sums it up perfectly. Your relationship with your dogs is much simpler than that with your child.

I love my dog as well, it really helps that he can’t talk to me and he asks so little of me. Essentially, he’s the perfect yes-dog. 🤣

CharlotteRumpling · 18/06/2023 20:36

I get what you mean. Dogs are always happy to see you. You are a hero to your dog. Meanwhile teenage children look at you like you are the dirt from their shoes.

thaegumathteth · 18/06/2023 20:34

I love dogs and animals and was / am heartbroken when we lost our old spaniel last year but there's no way it's comparable to the love I have for my children.

Makemyday99 · 18/06/2023 20:29

I have dogs & I love them but nowhere near as much as my DC. If I lost a child I don’t know how I could go on functioning or how I could ever get over it but I’ve lost dogs in the past & I coped just fine despite loving them.

Greycheck · 18/06/2023 20:27

It doesn't even compare. I adored my dog and all my animals but they are animals and not my children. Massive difference in feelings.

NameChangeThreeThousand · 18/06/2023 20:27

Well!! Growing up I definitely loved the family dogs! I loved them a lot, they were part of the family. But I didn't love them as much as my family

I now have a 10 month old puppy. I like him a bit! He's becoming part of the family and one day (hopefully soon) I'll have bonded enough with him to have love for him. But no way will I love him as much as my kids. I couldn't ever love anyone/anything as much as them!

Right now though, my dog is a stinky, farting, pooping, hair-dropping, hyperactive ball of fluff that is sapping all my energy! I also really hate the man bits dangling out and the other things that happen down there 🤢 Makes me gag. So it's hard to imagine loving that all that intensely right now!

Beginningless · 18/06/2023 20:26

I have been amazed to notice that our puppy got soooo much more adoration from strangers than my babies did, I found that pretty weird. Before I had a dog I wasn’t much of a doggy person though and didn’t find them that loveable, now I am much more interested in all dogs.

I felt there were interesting comparisons in the early days of puppy life. This little thing trying to communicate with me in ways I didn’t understand, it took time to get to know one another. Also I found a very liberating difference in being able to hate the dog at times! So a bit different to you but I could rant about what an arsehole he was, still do on a bad day, in a way that I can’t quite let myself do about my kids…

ladygindiva · 18/06/2023 20:24

Hrrpy · 18/06/2023 18:08

I love my dog. Not more than my kids but more than my husband.

This is me too.

LobeliaSackville · 18/06/2023 20:22

Xmasbaby11 · 18/06/2023 19:35

I’m bit horrified when people say this and hope they don’t mean it. Pets are animals at the end of the day and I don’t think you can compare it with the love for a human. I have 2dc and a cat. I love my cat, totally adore her and she brightens my day, but she’s just a cat. I wouldn’t risk my life to save her. If she dies, we’ll be sad and miss her but will get another one. Totally not the same with children.

Humans are just animals as well.

ThreeCoursesForMe · 18/06/2023 20:22

Also its statistically proven that people who were abused as children or in someway affected by the atrocities that unfortunately only humans can inflict on them are more inclined to bond with their pets and find connection with animals in adulthood. Hence the use of therapy dogs etc but that's a whole different argument. Either way it's actually really offensive to suggest to someone that there's something wrong wrong them for prioritising love for dogs and pets over people, it might be the only pure love they've ever known. Not everyone has had the traditional loving upbringing where a dog has been just an addition to their household, humans can be horrific.

RunningAndWriting · 18/06/2023 20:20

My kids say they’d be disappointed in me if I didn’t love our dogs as much as I love them. 😅

No need for competition in our house. Happy people don’t need to rank their partner, kids, pets, family, friends etc in order of how much they’re loved. I need all the ones I love in my life.

drpet49 · 18/06/2023 20:18

Poetnojo · 18/06/2023 18:11

Jesus no, I don't love my dog anywhere near as much as I love my children, and I would feel quite hurt if I thought my mother loved an animal as much or almost as much as she loved me

This

ThreeCoursesForMe · 18/06/2023 20:17

Yanbu, you're allowed to love your dogs the same as your kids although some posters will say you aren't! It doesn't lessen the love for the kids it just means you love your dogs as much as if they were human beings which is lovely

JMSA · 18/06/2023 20:15

Hrrpy · 18/06/2023 18:08

I love my dog. Not more than my kids but more than my husband.

Poor guy, that's awful.