Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 13:16

Be good to see these studies, Tea. I've googled but didn't find anything.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 13:14

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 12:57

TeaKlaxon · Today 12:45

So its not enough to look at whether children removed from birth mothers at birth have difficulty. You'd need to specifically look at the impact on children born through surrogacy. And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.

Please would you send links to the studies you’ve seen? I should think they cannot be very extensive as surrogacy is relatively new.

As to the state of the mothers who are becoming surrogates, I wonder what living conditions or back grounds some of the more disadvantaged have experienced? Poor women are more likely to be surrogates.

My guess is there may also be a black market in this.

You can very easily google the studies if you wish.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 13:13

Clymene · 19/06/2023 12:50

Knowing that your mother has sold you before you were even born is going to cause trauma. Knowing that your father paid your mother specifically so that you would be removed from her - the only sound and smell you've ever known - is going to cause trauma.

The fact that there is no evidence for it is because it's such a new phenomenon, not because it doesn't exist.

Buying and selling human beings is morally repugnant.

Are you still standing by your claim that I was wrong to object to the label ‘completely damaged’ to refer to children?

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 12:57

TeaKlaxon · Today 12:45

So its not enough to look at whether children removed from birth mothers at birth have difficulty. You'd need to specifically look at the impact on children born through surrogacy. And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.

Please would you send links to the studies you’ve seen? I should think they cannot be very extensive as surrogacy is relatively new.

As to the state of the mothers who are becoming surrogates, I wonder what living conditions or back grounds some of the more disadvantaged have experienced? Poor women are more likely to be surrogates.

My guess is there may also be a black market in this.

Clymene · 19/06/2023 12:50

Knowing that your mother has sold you before you were even born is going to cause trauma. Knowing that your father paid your mother specifically so that you would be removed from her - the only sound and smell you've ever known - is going to cause trauma.

The fact that there is no evidence for it is because it's such a new phenomenon, not because it doesn't exist.

Buying and selling human beings is morally repugnant.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 12:45

BodegaSushi · 19/06/2023 11:07

Opinions on surrogacy aside, I don't think these are comparable.

People have different opinions on surrogacy, so while you may consider it 'a mother giving up her child' others consider it as someone helping a parent by carrying their child. A child raised with this thinking may not have this feeling of abandonment at all.

I'd think especially in cases where there is a mother and a father and the mother has used her own eggs as well (I'm thinking like Kim Kardashian).

I also think that adoption comes with additional traumas that could have led to your husband's issues. Things like abusive relationship causing a distressed mother during pregnancy, drug use/abuse etc. not to mention the whole 'origin' story of how he came to be with his parents.

With adoption you have a parent who, regardless of the reasons behind it, chose to give their child up. Surrogacy is viewed by some to be parents who always wanted children, who just used a different means. Much like IVF.

I'm not saying this in support of surrogacy, I'm just presenting the views that make it not so easily compatible to adoption.

100% this.

I have no doubt that the act of being separated from a birth mother shortly after birth has some impact on a baby. But the extent to which that creates long term difficulties for a child is really not very well evidenced.

Most studies in this area aren't specific to surrogacy, and carry particular challenges because in almost any other case where a child is removed from a birth mother at birth, there will be additional factors that will have potentially longer term impacts on the child. At the lowest level, a child born to a healthy, non-addicted, non-abused mother who wishes to place them for voluntary adoption will still likely have experienced elevated cortisol levels in utero because of the stress that an unplanned and unwanted pregnancy can place.

But more commonly, a mother who cannot keep her child at birth is likely to have experienced addiction, violence and very high stress levels. A child may be exposed to drugs or alcohol in utero, or physical harm, or extremely high cortisol levels.

So its not enough to look at whether children removed from birth mothers at birth have difficulty. You'd need to specifically look at the impact on children born through surrogacy. And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.

BodegaSushi · 19/06/2023 11:07

LuckyCats · 18/06/2023 23:45

My sons father was adopted as a young baby, don’t know anything about the birth family only to guess as that as he was adopted in Liverpool his mother might have been Irish. He could find out but has decided not to, when our son was born he was really thinking about it a lot more and wanting to know.
He was adopted to an upper middle class family, doting mother, grammar school educated, every opportunity i would love my own son to have.
He has suffered from abandonment issues, addiction, failure to meet his full potential in work or relationships. He’s a good dad and I’m grateful for my son for that.
Being given away, even to good people has obviously affected his whole life, i can’t imagine the trauma of knowing you were brought to order like a piece of made to measure furniture. But nobody seems to think of the babies in these situations, only when the parents can’t adopt and women are choosing to sell their lives. What choice do they have? Why are rich women not carrying other people’s babies for altruism or fun??

Opinions on surrogacy aside, I don't think these are comparable.

People have different opinions on surrogacy, so while you may consider it 'a mother giving up her child' others consider it as someone helping a parent by carrying their child. A child raised with this thinking may not have this feeling of abandonment at all.

I'd think especially in cases where there is a mother and a father and the mother has used her own eggs as well (I'm thinking like Kim Kardashian).

I also think that adoption comes with additional traumas that could have led to your husband's issues. Things like abusive relationship causing a distressed mother during pregnancy, drug use/abuse etc. not to mention the whole 'origin' story of how he came to be with his parents.

With adoption you have a parent who, regardless of the reasons behind it, chose to give their child up. Surrogacy is viewed by some to be parents who always wanted children, who just used a different means. Much like IVF.

I'm not saying this in support of surrogacy, I'm just presenting the views that make it not so easily compatible to adoption.

pinkginfizz9 · 19/06/2023 09:45

Is he the biological father?

FrancescaContini · 19/06/2023 08:41

He uses the phrase “people with vaginas” in an article about how he felt on being told how to keep clean his newborn daughter’s vagina.

Good grief.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 08:31

footballdramas · Yesterday 18:44
He also missed the birth for some reason. And yes he'll get a book out of it. When men parent children it's some kind of extraordinary challenge and sacrifice.
Sorry to derail but here is another man buying his children (twins in this case) via surrogate and now monetising them on every possible channel plus a book
.

https://womensagenda.com.au/life/womens-health-news/the-mini-period-why-fathers-must-take-active-roles-in-their-daughters-health/

If I knew my father had written that about me - and this girl will one day - I would feel fury, anguish, embarrassment and shame.
It is a complete breach of this girls’ privacy.

'The mini period': Why fathers must take active roles in their daughter's health

Relying on humans with vaginas to ‘deal with it’ is failing everyone, and it’s creating a divide between father and daughter. 

https://womensagenda.com.au/life/womens-health-news/the-mini-period-why-fathers-must-take-active-roles-in-their-daughters-health

LifeIsPainHighness · 19/06/2023 08:21

mycoffeecup · 18/06/2023 18:33

You don't understand medic humour and how dark it is. Of necessity, to get through life without all of us having PTSD from what we see

So that makes it OK to openly mock people with Down’s Syndrome and make money from it?

Bullshit

If you have to be a misogynist, racist, ableist etc to get through being a doctor then you need to immediately resign from the role

LifeIsPainHighness · 19/06/2023 08:12

Adam Kay is a disgusting misogynist so I am not the least bit surprised that he’s been entitled enough to think he can just borrow a couple of women’s wombs to suit his agenda.

Purplefoalfoot · 19/06/2023 08:04

adviceneeded1990 · 18/06/2023 21:10

Should pregnant drug addicts and alcoholics be subject to forced termination under these thoughts? Plenty of babies are damaged by their biological parents pre- birth and from the first days of life…

No, but surely you can see that it’s not a good idea to intentionally bring children into the world to be traumatised at birth.

Or do you think it’s good for children to be born to drug addicts? Would you purposely ‘commission’ a drug addict to have a baby? If your sister was a drug addict would be encouraging her to have a baby at all costs before she was clean? Your argument makes no sense and is irrelevant to the issue of surrogacy.

Except of course to say that surrogates are more likely to be abused, traumatised women themselves who may have a background of susbstance abuse.

Hairday · 19/06/2023 02:57

It really upsets me that surrogacy is becoming accepted and mainstream. It's messed up. That poor surrogate who had a "difficult birth". Now she's living with the consequences and two rich men are swanning around with their motherless daughter.

EachandEveryone · 19/06/2023 01:05

Ah, the more expensive route. Like hundreds of gay men before them. Im literally sick of them coming up on my instagram. Every single gay couple in Hollywood and New York does this. Very few adopt.

Clymene · 19/06/2023 01:00

EachandEveryone · 19/06/2023 00:59

Dows he say where the surrogates are from? The Ukraine is shocking for it and I know someone who got two babies from there from different mothers only a couple of weeks appart and during the war there.

They bought the babies from American women

EachandEveryone · 19/06/2023 00:59

Dows he say where the surrogates are from? The Ukraine is shocking for it and I know someone who got two babies from there from different mothers only a couple of weeks appart and during the war there.

angelicaelizapeggy · 19/06/2023 00:57

Was it somebody known to them or a stranger? And if a stranger, someone nearby or overseas?

i would wonder how much agency the women carrying the babies were allowed, his book openly talked about it being bad for women to make their own decisions in childbirth or have choices available or give consent, very much ‘doctors should be fully in charge’. Surely that attitude would be even stronger if said vessel woman carrying his own baby 🙄

FrancescaContini · 19/06/2023 00:50

RedToothBrush · 18/06/2023 18:01

Also if you are going to make money and raise your pr status off the back of selling your life story to the press, you lose the right to say it's no one else's business.

Spot on

SirVixofVixHall · 19/06/2023 00:49

Cyclebabble · 18/06/2023 20:26

I wish Adam and his partner well. I am sure they will be great parents. Well done to the surrogates who have helped them achieve this. Surrogacy is just another way where dedicated people can help people become parents. For many women this may be the only route they have. I do not understand the pushback here.

“Dedicated people “ ?? They aren’t “people” they are women.
How many of these women are “dedicated” do you think ? Dedicated to trying to feed their own children because they live in a relatively poor country perhaps. I know a couple who chose a specific country to buy their children from because it was the cheapest, and yet who boast all over their business about how they love to help people in impoverished nations.
Show me an affluent , well educated and confident woman, with no childhood trauma that has left them vulnerable (to the glow of attention, or emotional manipulation), who is also a surrogate and I will show you the tooth of a hen.
Possibly there are sisters out there who have done this out of love and not out of emotional coercion, but this is not the vast bulk of surrogacy, and it still does not take into account the effect on the child, or the ethics of accepting this offer from a sibling. I have two friends who have needed a hysterectomy post birth. There is also the increased risk in donor egg pregnancies, so popular in surrogacy to reduce the chance of a mother deciding to keep the baby. These pregnancies have a higher risk of pre-eclampsia which has a lifelong impact on health.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 19/06/2023 00:39

Regarding whether gestational surrogacy (where the birth mother is pregnant using another woman's egg) is better, I have two points to make.

First: pregnancies conceived using another woman's egg(s) carry higher risks of complications; medical risks of surrogacy and egg harvesting

Second: until surrogacy became, for want of a better word, fashionable in the last decade, the main use of donor eggs was by women undergoing fertility treatment to achieve a pregnancy themselves, as opposed to women and men paying another woman to go through pregnancy. In those days, everyone was quite clear that the baby's mother was the woman who finally gave birth. No-one thought the genetic connection to the woman who'd had eggs retrieved could supercede the nine months of gestation; no-one thought the baby would have a greater emotional link to the unknown egg donor than to the woman whose heartbeat and voice had been the background to his/her fetal development.

No-one thought mothers who had IVF using donor eggs had a duty to hand their babies back to the university student who'd sold her eggs, and I am willing to wager no-one thinks they should now. If you pay to have IVF treatment using someone else's donor eggs and you succeed in a full-term pregnancy and birth, the baby is regarded as yours.

However, in commercial surrogacy, the attitude flips. Suddenly, the genetic connection to the woman whose eggs were retrieved is prized beyond all else. If you pay another woman to have IVF treatment using your donor eggs and she succeeds in a full-term pregnancy and birth, the baby is... regarded as yours.

It seems that newborns are expected to recognise the person with the money and to bond with the person signing the cheques, above any other considerations.

Toseland · 19/06/2023 00:01

How can these rich and priviledged people be lauded for dealing in slavery?! Whilst in other parts of the country statues are being chucked into canals, and old institutions changing their names for having any connections to slavery.
Imagine growing up and finding out you'd been bought! Denied your own mother and family connections. Your history and ancestry. Shame on them.

LuckyCats · 18/06/2023 23:45

My sons father was adopted as a young baby, don’t know anything about the birth family only to guess as that as he was adopted in Liverpool his mother might have been Irish. He could find out but has decided not to, when our son was born he was really thinking about it a lot more and wanting to know.
He was adopted to an upper middle class family, doting mother, grammar school educated, every opportunity i would love my own son to have.
He has suffered from abandonment issues, addiction, failure to meet his full potential in work or relationships. He’s a good dad and I’m grateful for my son for that.
Being given away, even to good people has obviously affected his whole life, i can’t imagine the trauma of knowing you were brought to order like a piece of made to measure furniture. But nobody seems to think of the babies in these situations, only when the parents can’t adopt and women are choosing to sell their lives. What choice do they have? Why are rich women not carrying other people’s babies for altruism or fun??

KatherineSwynford1403 · 18/06/2023 23:35

mycoffeecup · 18/06/2023 18:33

You don't understand medic humour and how dark it is. Of necessity, to get through life without all of us having PTSD from what we see

Fair enough. My brother is a pathologist. But doesn't take that sort of humour out into the wider world and make jokes about it in public.

LuckyCats · 18/06/2023 23:19

I’ve witnessed first had the trauma of being given away at birth, not sold as these children have been which must add an extra layer of trauma.
Im in no way anti adoption,it’s a completely different thing than buying babies in inducing this trauma on purpose and as a known by product of buying a baby to be taken from its mother sooner than a pet rat would be.
Buying babies and women’s bodies should be illegal everywhere.