Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 17:17

I don't even know that words can fix what is going to be at root a biological, instinctive response/trauma, tbh. Not sure how much it matters how you try to present the 'story' of a surrogate birth as a positive, feel-good event; the trauma is likely to be at a very deep, pre-verbal level.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 17:04

ManyMaybes · 19/06/2023 16:41

If you choose to describe something very negatively then of course that will have an impact on the way a child perceived the situation.

Saying to a child that they were bought, trafficked, torn from their exploited mother etc etc is never going to be a good idea… How about they were wanted so much that lots of people had to come together to bring them into the world? As others have said, this is very different to adoption so I don’t buy the argument of the child being forever, irretrievably damaged.

I do agree though that there is lots of scope for exploitation when it comes to surrogacy. But that doesn’t mean every single surrogacy arrangement is exploitative. If the right processes are followed, the right checks made and so on, then it should most probably be a positive experience for everyone (but there will always be exceptions and risks, as with anything).

Cutesy language might work for pre schoolers, but a 14 year old isn't going to be placated with 'lots of people came together to bring you into the world'. Sooner or later the purchasing parents are going to have to have a conversation about having paid for the child to be created and removed from the birth mother; OR the child will have to cope with the confusion and pressure of that being unspoken because their purchasing parents can't face going there and leave the child to try to make sense of it all. Either way I think there is a lot of potential for distress in this scenario are the children get older.

ManyMaybes · 19/06/2023 16:41

If you choose to describe something very negatively then of course that will have an impact on the way a child perceived the situation.

Saying to a child that they were bought, trafficked, torn from their exploited mother etc etc is never going to be a good idea… How about they were wanted so much that lots of people had to come together to bring them into the world? As others have said, this is very different to adoption so I don’t buy the argument of the child being forever, irretrievably damaged.

I do agree though that there is lots of scope for exploitation when it comes to surrogacy. But that doesn’t mean every single surrogacy arrangement is exploitative. If the right processes are followed, the right checks made and so on, then it should most probably be a positive experience for everyone (but there will always be exceptions and risks, as with anything).

SirVixofVixHall · 19/06/2023 16:34

Clymene · 19/06/2023 12:50

Knowing that your mother has sold you before you were even born is going to cause trauma. Knowing that your father paid your mother specifically so that you would be removed from her - the only sound and smell you've ever known - is going to cause trauma.

The fact that there is no evidence for it is because it's such a new phenomenon, not because it doesn't exist.

Buying and selling human beings is morally repugnant.

Agree with this.

ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 16:30

BodegaSushi · 19/06/2023 11:07

Opinions on surrogacy aside, I don't think these are comparable.

People have different opinions on surrogacy, so while you may consider it 'a mother giving up her child' others consider it as someone helping a parent by carrying their child. A child raised with this thinking may not have this feeling of abandonment at all.

I'd think especially in cases where there is a mother and a father and the mother has used her own eggs as well (I'm thinking like Kim Kardashian).

I also think that adoption comes with additional traumas that could have led to your husband's issues. Things like abusive relationship causing a distressed mother during pregnancy, drug use/abuse etc. not to mention the whole 'origin' story of how he came to be with his parents.

With adoption you have a parent who, regardless of the reasons behind it, chose to give their child up. Surrogacy is viewed by some to be parents who always wanted children, who just used a different means. Much like IVF.

I'm not saying this in support of surrogacy, I'm just presenting the views that make it not so easily compatible to adoption.

The mother doesn't just 'carry' a child.

A mother feeds her baby, nurtures it, develops and grows the child in a deeply interconnected relationship; her body carefully calibrating and adjusting to cater for the needs of the foetus/baby as it grows. The baby learns her voice, smell, heartbeat in the womb.

'babies can tell the difference between the voices of their mothers and the voices of strangers ... listening to mom may increase a preterm infant’s autonomic stability, and promote healthy weight gain ...

https://parentingscience.com/how-do-children-respond-to-a-mothers-voice/

She then labours, and births the baby. Various other interdependent processes play out, including rooting for the breast, latching, grooming, and many other instinctive and unlearned acts and actions performed by both mother and baby, processes which build on each other to create as a whole the safety, responsiveness and care that a child needs for a good psychological start in life.

All of this is the most intricate and (I'd say) amazing process or series of processes and interactions, all of which speak to the importance of the mother/baby dyad, which is the foundational relationship of our lives. As mammals this is just how we have evolved - a strong mother/baby bond is very important for the wellbeing of a baby.

To imagine that a woman is some kind of anonymous oven that can carry a baby and then pop it out and pass it over with no effect on the mother or the baby is a very sad and grim misunderstanding.

Our understanding of adoption means the trauma of mother/child separation is understood and acknowledged. In surrogacy, this trauma appears to be being strenuously denied. Babies born of surrogates do not seem to have this understanding or acknowledgement of their trauma - I suspect because most of the parents buying babies don't want to admit that they've knowingly and deliberately inflicted this trauma on the baby they're charged with caring for.

How do children respond to a mother's voice?

© 2021 Gwen Dewar, Ph.D., all rights reserved A mother's voice has special power. It can provide comfort -- and improve outcomes -- for babies

https://parentingscience.com/how-do-children-respond-to-a-mothers-voice

sanluca · 19/06/2023 16:15

Hairday · 19/06/2023 02:57

It really upsets me that surrogacy is becoming accepted and mainstream. It's messed up. That poor surrogate who had a "difficult birth". Now she's living with the consequences and two rich men are swanning around with their motherless daughter.

I think commercial surrogacy needs an ironclad contract that protects the mother who is pregnant and compensates her for all the health impact of being pregnant, including all birth after effects, plus a hourly rate for being pregnant. The mother also has end decision on her body, including the fetus until birth, and the purchasing people have zero decision rights.
The contract also should contain a mandatory insurance for death and serious injuries, paid for by the purchasers.

Only then can I even begin contemplating seeing renting a woman as an incubator and purchasing the end product as a viable commercial transaction.

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 15:49

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 15:31

Yes, absolutely parents who have children through surrogacy should do life story work with their child and include photos and details of their biological mother.

I'm not sure why you think I'm contradicting myself - I think being open with their child about their life story, and giving them the tools to understand their identity and life story, is incredibly important in all scenarios.

Yes but my point is that knowing about it and having all manner of “tools” doesn’t mitigate the reality of it. Nothing you can ever do or say or dress up nicely will change the fundamental fact that these children have been separated from their biological mothers at birth.

And the fact that in a surrogacy context you will be brought up by a biological father doesn’t necessarily help in circumstances where you will also have to confront the fact that your biological father paid to exploit your biological mother. What a great guy.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 15:37

QuickWash · 19/06/2023 15:27

Are you suggesting that any of that is done with children acquired through surrogacy?

Do they have life story books, photos of or contact with their bio mother, information about their genetic history, are they brought up always knowing they were conceived and born to order etc?

Because you seem to arguing with yourself a little here. If that stuff all mitigates the impact of adoption then shouldn't we consider it may be needed in surrogacy?

That's a really good point. Lots of work is done with adopters these days so that they can have open, age appropriate conversations with their children about the child's origins and how they came to be adopted. Including really difficult stuff like the child being abused by birth parents, or the product of rape. Is anyone coaching users of surrogates on how to age appropriately explain that they were purchased from a Ukrainian woman who was then left behind in a warzone, or a very poor Indian woman who was kept on a baby farm? Are they heck.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 15:31

QuickWash · 19/06/2023 15:27

Are you suggesting that any of that is done with children acquired through surrogacy?

Do they have life story books, photos of or contact with their bio mother, information about their genetic history, are they brought up always knowing they were conceived and born to order etc?

Because you seem to arguing with yourself a little here. If that stuff all mitigates the impact of adoption then shouldn't we consider it may be needed in surrogacy?

Yes, absolutely parents who have children through surrogacy should do life story work with their child and include photos and details of their biological mother.

I'm not sure why you think I'm contradicting myself - I think being open with their child about their life story, and giving them the tools to understand their identity and life story, is incredibly important in all scenarios.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 19/06/2023 15:31

QuickWash · 19/06/2023 15:27

Are you suggesting that any of that is done with children acquired through surrogacy?

Do they have life story books, photos of or contact with their bio mother, information about their genetic history, are they brought up always knowing they were conceived and born to order etc?

Because you seem to arguing with yourself a little here. If that stuff all mitigates the impact of adoption then shouldn't we consider it may be needed in surrogacy?

Indeed. The work done before parents can adopt is extensive, to the extent that many people give up. All surrogacy appears to needs is a fat wallet and a lack of concern about the trade in human beings.

QuickWash · 19/06/2023 15:27

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:28

They're not irrelevant.

When a child finds out they are adopted and how it is spoken about, how their life story work is done, how others treat it etc are massively important to their outcomes.

Now perhaps her adoptive parents and those around her were uniquely progressive. But in general, adopted kids in the 1980s and 1990s did not experience the same openness about life story that is encouraged now.

Are you suggesting that any of that is done with children acquired through surrogacy?

Do they have life story books, photos of or contact with their bio mother, information about their genetic history, are they brought up always knowing they were conceived and born to order etc?

Because you seem to arguing with yourself a little here. If that stuff all mitigates the impact of adoption then shouldn't we consider it may be needed in surrogacy?

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 15:24

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 14:35

i meant they are not relevant to my point, not that they are not relevant to the question of how adoption impacts a child.

I met my friend when we were in our early teens and unsurprisingly we didn’t have in depth discussions about how her adoption was handled. All I can say is that she believes it was handled as well as it possibly could have been AND she believes that her mental health struggles (which did not emerge until she was in her late teens/early twenties) are due to the fact of being adopted.

Fundamentally whatever work you do with a kid, they have to live with the knowledge that they were separated from their birth parent (in whatever circumstances). It is incredible that anyone would suggest (if that is what you are actually suggesting) that there are no lasting impacts from that.

And that’s before you get on to a child born to a surrogate coming to the realisation that they were created as part of an exploitative commercial transaction.

But it is relevant to your point, because we now know that there are ways that the trauma of adoption can be mitigated (which is not to say it can be completely eliminated), and those mitigations were not common in the 1980s or 1990s.

I also don't think it's a given that being conceived through surrogacy would be an exacerbating factor compared to adoption at birth. For many adopted people, a lasting feeling is one of not being wanted, not being good enough, of parents having to be found for them because their biological parents 'didn't want them'.

I don't think it's straightforward to say that a child will have more trauma to cope with because of being conceived through surrogacy. Yes, they will have to wrap their heads around being conceived with the intention of not having contact with one of their biological parents. But on the other hand, they also know that the decision not to be raised by one biological parent was made before they even existed and so cannot possibly have been a reflection on them (of course the fact that someone was adopted is also not a reflection on them, but that can be harder to rationalise).

In addition, unlike the adopted child (in the case of stranger adoption), the child conceived by surrogacy has at least one of their biological parents in their life.

None of which is conclusive - but the blanket claims that surrogacy must be incredibly damaging for a child (to the point that non-existence would be preferable) has no real basis in evidence, and the reality is much more complex.

Clymene · 19/06/2023 14:41

MrsOvertonsWindow · 19/06/2023 13:24

I'm often reminded of the very wise words of MNHQ to posters when faced with things they find unbelievable - "So we always ask users to remember that not everyone on the internet is who they say they are"

Very good advice.

Thank you for the timely reminder

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 14:35

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:28

They're not irrelevant.

When a child finds out they are adopted and how it is spoken about, how their life story work is done, how others treat it etc are massively important to their outcomes.

Now perhaps her adoptive parents and those around her were uniquely progressive. But in general, adopted kids in the 1980s and 1990s did not experience the same openness about life story that is encouraged now.

i meant they are not relevant to my point, not that they are not relevant to the question of how adoption impacts a child.

I met my friend when we were in our early teens and unsurprisingly we didn’t have in depth discussions about how her adoption was handled. All I can say is that she believes it was handled as well as it possibly could have been AND she believes that her mental health struggles (which did not emerge until she was in her late teens/early twenties) are due to the fact of being adopted.

Fundamentally whatever work you do with a kid, they have to live with the knowledge that they were separated from their birth parent (in whatever circumstances). It is incredible that anyone would suggest (if that is what you are actually suggesting) that there are no lasting impacts from that.

And that’s before you get on to a child born to a surrogate coming to the realisation that they were created as part of an exploitative commercial transaction.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:28

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 14:23

I didn’t post any of that stuff because it’s not relevant. She always knew she was adopted. Her adoptive parents were amazing and she loves them. All same cultural backgrounds and in fact she physically resembles her adoptive mother.

I never said anyone was completely damaged by anything. But my friend (who has direct personal experience) believes that she has suffered lasting harm as a result of being adopted. Of course you may say (and want to believe) that her struggles were caused by other factors but ultimately who can say. I can only go on what she believes herself.

They're not irrelevant.

When a child finds out they are adopted and how it is spoken about, how their life story work is done, how others treat it etc are massively important to their outcomes.

Now perhaps her adoptive parents and those around her were uniquely progressive. But in general, adopted kids in the 1980s and 1990s did not experience the same openness about life story that is encouraged now.

ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 14:25

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 14:10

@TeaKlaxon
“And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.”

From what you said these seem to be specific studies so I would be interested to read them. So far I can only find some reporting on the mother’s interaction with the child during their early years, age 1, 3, and a little at age 7, but nothing about the outcomes as the child goes through adolescence, or in adulthood.

Yes, I found one that specifically said they couldn't find any data beyond age 7.

But hopefully Tea can furnish us wth the study they are referencing.

As has been noted, outcomes and impact seem to vary with age.

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 14:23

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:16

Incidentally, there's a lot more to this than what you've posted.

When did she find out she was adopted? What life story work was done with her as a child? How much did she know as a child about her birth family? How was it handled and addressed by her adoptive family? How did her friends and extended family treat the fact that she was adopted? Were her adoptive family of a similar cultural background? What did they do to promote her identity?

It's hugely simplistic to say that because she had a loving family, that her adoption might not have been handled in a counter-productive way. The way we think about children's interactions with adoption have changed massively since the 1980s.

I didn’t post any of that stuff because it’s not relevant. She always knew she was adopted. Her adoptive parents were amazing and she loves them. All same cultural backgrounds and in fact she physically resembles her adoptive mother.

I never said anyone was completely damaged by anything. But my friend (who has direct personal experience) believes that she has suffered lasting harm as a result of being adopted. Of course you may say (and want to believe) that her struggles were caused by other factors but ultimately who can say. I can only go on what she believes herself.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:16

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 13:51

Not direct personal experience but a very close friend was adopted at birth. Her birth parents were 16 (in Ireland in the 1980s so abortion was not available). There was no alcohol or drug issues or family trauma or anything that a pp has referenced that could also impact a baby. She has been told that her mother was a model student and didn’t know that she was pregnant until the pregnancy was fairly advanced. She was adopted by loving parents who gave her a great life (and on paper she too has a great life - excelled academically and now a doctor). But she has really struggled mentally and emotionally with being adopted and has a number of mental health issues now.

Saying “completely damaged” is extreme but it would be naive to think that there is no impact of losing your mother at birth.

Incidentally, there's a lot more to this than what you've posted.

When did she find out she was adopted? What life story work was done with her as a child? How much did she know as a child about her birth family? How was it handled and addressed by her adoptive family? How did her friends and extended family treat the fact that she was adopted? Were her adoptive family of a similar cultural background? What did they do to promote her identity?

It's hugely simplistic to say that because she had a loving family, that her adoption might not have been handled in a counter-productive way. The way we think about children's interactions with adoption have changed massively since the 1980s.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:13

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 14:10

@TeaKlaxon
“And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.”

From what you said these seem to be specific studies so I would be interested to read them. So far I can only find some reporting on the mother’s interaction with the child during their early years, age 1, 3, and a little at age 7, but nothing about the outcomes as the child goes through adolescence, or in adulthood.

The ones I've seen go to age 10, and include assessments of children's psychological development.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 14:12

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 13:51

Not direct personal experience but a very close friend was adopted at birth. Her birth parents were 16 (in Ireland in the 1980s so abortion was not available). There was no alcohol or drug issues or family trauma or anything that a pp has referenced that could also impact a baby. She has been told that her mother was a model student and didn’t know that she was pregnant until the pregnancy was fairly advanced. She was adopted by loving parents who gave her a great life (and on paper she too has a great life - excelled academically and now a doctor). But she has really struggled mentally and emotionally with being adopted and has a number of mental health issues now.

Saying “completely damaged” is extreme but it would be naive to think that there is no impact of losing your mother at birth.

But nobody said there is no impact.

But it is totally ignorant to refer to any child, regardless of the trauma they have had, as 'completely damaged'.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 14:10

@TeaKlaxon
“And in the studies I've seen, there is no evidence of significant lasting harm to those children.”

From what you said these seem to be specific studies so I would be interested to read them. So far I can only find some reporting on the mother’s interaction with the child during their early years, age 1, 3, and a little at age 7, but nothing about the outcomes as the child goes through adolescence, or in adulthood.

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 13:51

Not direct personal experience but a very close friend was adopted at birth. Her birth parents were 16 (in Ireland in the 1980s so abortion was not available). There was no alcohol or drug issues or family trauma or anything that a pp has referenced that could also impact a baby. She has been told that her mother was a model student and didn’t know that she was pregnant until the pregnancy was fairly advanced. She was adopted by loving parents who gave her a great life (and on paper she too has a great life - excelled academically and now a doctor). But she has really struggled mentally and emotionally with being adopted and has a number of mental health issues now.

Saying “completely damaged” is extreme but it would be naive to think that there is no impact of losing your mother at birth.

TeaKlaxon · 19/06/2023 13:51

Clymene · 19/06/2023 13:26

I can't find who used the phrase 'completely damaged' except you @TeaKlaxon

You said Those of us raising children who never knew their birth mother know that they are not damaged. And that it’s bloody ignorant and offensive to say they are.

I don't believe that. Any child who is removed from their mother at birth - whether they've been bought by another person or because their mother is incapable of caring for them - will be impacted.

Impacted =|= Damaged.

Also that quote of mine was in response to a poster who claimed such children were ‘completely damaged’.

With or without the ‘completely’, it is an ignorant and insulting thing to say.

Clymene · 19/06/2023 13:26

I can't find who used the phrase 'completely damaged' except you @TeaKlaxon

You said Those of us raising children who never knew their birth mother know that they are not damaged. And that it’s bloody ignorant and offensive to say they are.

I don't believe that. Any child who is removed from their mother at birth - whether they've been bought by another person or because their mother is incapable of caring for them - will be impacted.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 19/06/2023 13:24

I'm often reminded of the very wise words of MNHQ to posters when faced with things they find unbelievable - "So we always ask users to remember that not everyone on the internet is who they say they are"

Very good advice.