Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adam Kay and his husband’s babies

434 replies

MatildaTheCat · 18/06/2023 17:38

Apologies if this has already been covered.

I read in the paper this morning that AK and his DH have welcomed TWO babies into their lives, born to two different surrogates. One child is six months old and their sibling is two months old.

I genuinely cannot wrap my head around this. It seems so very odd to me. Is it a case of ‘one each’ or ‘get the baby stages over asap’?

Obviously nobody but the two parents can answer this but AIBU to find this really quite disturbing?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ChlorineBromine · 20/06/2023 06:33

I have been an NHS consultant for over thirty years. This man crosses so many lines for me in terms of his ‘humour’ and confidentiality. I understand dark humour and share it with close colleagues where I work. I don’t give any details to my own husband and family, never mind the wider world. He disgusts me and I am glad he no longer practises.

WhenIWasAFieldMyself · 20/06/2023 05:49

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 20/06/2023 00:20

I haven't listened to it yet but I'm curious as to what it was about what he said on DID that made you come to that conclusion? I've always found him quite calm seeming and thoughtful in interviews, so am intrigued as to why he came across this way to you here.

Oh do give over.

Why don't you tell us, in light of everything that's been said BY HIM, about women, the disabled and the vulnerable, his patients, his former profession etc and everything he's done (see: surrogacy (no shit Sherlock)) why YOU still defend him and keep saying what a dude he is.

One example of Adam Kay being a decent human being, without an ounce of arrogance or prejudice or "it's all about ME" will suffice for starters.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 20/06/2023 00:20

BretonBlue · 19/06/2023 22:04

I listened to his DID episode today. He sounded like a very damaged, unhappy man.

I haven't listened to it yet but I'm curious as to what it was about what he said on DID that made you come to that conclusion? I've always found him quite calm seeming and thoughtful in interviews, so am intrigued as to why he came across this way to you here.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 22:48

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 21:49

nothingcomestonothing · Today 21:18

ScrollingLeaves · Today 20:40

I wouldn’t judge a desperate woman, and I would feel pleased for her happiness, even if to myself I don’t think surrogacy is a good idea.

Well by that logic should we also not judge a woman who steals a baby from a maternity ward? If she's desperate and it makes her happy?

What you say is logical to an extent but it is two steps worse, as in surrogacy the mother agrees to the baby leaving her and has mentally prepared for it, and she also knows the buyers/adopters.

In the circumstance you describe though there would be the extra two elements of the mother’s intense distress at the sudden loss of her baby, and of her not knowing what sort of person had taken her child.

As for judging the baby stealer, if that means actually berating her, no, what would be the point? She must be desperate, and she must be mad. She needs psychological help.

Judging someone and thinking to yourself that someone has done a wrong thing, and thinking that wrong thing should be prevented, are separate imo.

If you read the stories on the Legalize Surrogacy Why Not site posted upthread, there are examples both of surrogates who experienced intense distress when their baby was taken from them, even though they always knew that was the plan, and examples of surrogates finding out too late what sort of person had taken their child - such as a convicted paedophile.

I'm not looking to berate anyone, but I do think that surrogacy should be illegal, both doing it in the UK or bringing babies into the UK from surrogacy carrried out elsewhere. None of us has the right to a child, no matter how sincerely we want one, and none of us has the right to buy the use of another person's body.

GailBlancheViola · 19/06/2023 22:40

Because of the nature of the arrangement I don't think any surrogacy can be guaranteed to be free of coercion ESPECIALLY within families and existing friendships. There will ALWAYS be this element of guilt / duty which can be emotionally exploited.

I agree with everything you have posted @RedToothBrush I've seen stories from women who acted as a surrogate for a family member whose lives when pregnant were controlled to the nth degree by those they were carrying the child for. And, yes, contrary to popular belief, the surrogate struggled after the birth and the handing over of the child but had to keep it to themselves.

Relationships have been damaged by the practice it is not all fluffy bunnies and skipping hand in hand into the sunset and that is because human emotions are involved.

At is most basic surrogacy boils down to I want a child, I can't have one so I should be able to use another woman's body for that purpose and either be given the child or pay for it.

It should be banned across the board worldwide.

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 22:10

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 21:22

I agree in the case where women are
exploited and used. But where a women has acted as a surrogate altruistically and without coercion, I can’t see that as using a women’s body or risking their life, not if they have volunteered.

I agree my longing for a child is selfish. All conception is self-centred. No one brings a baby into the world because it’s best for the baby; we try to conceive because WE want children. Despite many circumstances of conception being less than ideal.

I’m not refuting the idea of post birth/removal trauma at all, I’m sure it occurs, as it does in the case of adoption. But to me there isn’t yet enough research to say it occurs in every case. I also disagree with paid/transactional surrogacy.

But as the above poster says, should we judge what anyone does to create their family? Is it more altruistic or morally worthy to accidentally create a life, a real life person, who may experience trauma, as a teenager who doesn’t use contraception? As a women who is financially struggling and can’t feed her existing children? As an addict? Plenty of women in these situations become pregnant by choice. Is it more morally worthy to do so? I’m not sure. Which is why I don’t and won’t judge.

So the risk of death and physical harm disappears just because they’ve agreed to it voluntarily does it?

Yes all conception is selfish but where a surrogate is not used there is no collateral
harm to others and to the child. I come back to my point: no one is entitled to a child.

Lots of children are born into less than ideal situations but that doesn’t make it ok to deliberately set out to engineer a horrible situation in order to satisfy a selfish desire either.

And it’s pretty disingenuous to say that there isn’t enough research yet to suggest it’s harmful. The harm and potential harm to the mother is obvious. And the research in an adoption context is clear.

RedToothBrush · 19/06/2023 22:10

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 21:22

I agree in the case where women are
exploited and used. But where a women has acted as a surrogate altruistically and without coercion, I can’t see that as using a women’s body or risking their life, not if they have volunteered.

I agree my longing for a child is selfish. All conception is self-centred. No one brings a baby into the world because it’s best for the baby; we try to conceive because WE want children. Despite many circumstances of conception being less than ideal.

I’m not refuting the idea of post birth/removal trauma at all, I’m sure it occurs, as it does in the case of adoption. But to me there isn’t yet enough research to say it occurs in every case. I also disagree with paid/transactional surrogacy.

But as the above poster says, should we judge what anyone does to create their family? Is it more altruistic or morally worthy to accidentally create a life, a real life person, who may experience trauma, as a teenager who doesn’t use contraception? As a women who is financially struggling and can’t feed her existing children? As an addict? Plenty of women in these situations become pregnant by choice. Is it more morally worthy to do so? I’m not sure. Which is why I don’t and won’t judge.

Because of the nature of the arrangement I don't think any surrogacy can be guaranteed to be free of coercion ESPECIALLY within families and existing friendships. There will ALWAYS be this element of guilt / duty which can be emotionally exploited. And surrogate mothers just aren't the ultra rich celebrities doing it for a poor stranger theyve met online for a reason.

Therein lies my issue - separating coercive situations from non coercive ones in so called altruistic arrangements.

It is impossible.

I also think the fallout from such arrangements if the existing relationship breaks down during its course - keeping in mind the high levels of stress it involves and how prospective parents can feel they 'own' the mother and her birth, is exceptionally high risk. And potentially much more catastrophic. It carries the real risk of destroying the extended family / support network at a time it's perhaps needed most. That's actively dangerous and could cause real harm.

Altruistic surrogacy is always seen through the lens of the greatest gift. Never the greatest risk.

Throw into the mix, the extra physical risks of a surrogate pregnancy (compared to a natural one) and the stress of doing it for someone else... What happens if you have kids, but you end up with life changing birth injuries or die because of a family member or friend? Do you think relationships can be maintained?

The risks are enormous. It's just dressed up as a wonderful thing where everyone lives happy ever after. It doesn't match reality.

BretonBlue · 19/06/2023 22:04

I listened to his DID episode today. He sounded like a very damaged, unhappy man.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 21:49

nothingcomestonothing · Today 21:18

ScrollingLeaves · Today 20:40

I wouldn’t judge a desperate woman, and I would feel pleased for her happiness, even if to myself I don’t think surrogacy is a good idea.

Well by that logic should we also not judge a woman who steals a baby from a maternity ward? If she's desperate and it makes her happy?

What you say is logical to an extent but it is two steps worse, as in surrogacy the mother agrees to the baby leaving her and has mentally prepared for it, and she also knows the buyers/adopters.

In the circumstance you describe though there would be the extra two elements of the mother’s intense distress at the sudden loss of her baby, and of her not knowing what sort of person had taken her child.

As for judging the baby stealer, if that means actually berating her, no, what would be the point? She must be desperate, and she must be mad. She needs psychological help.

Judging someone and thinking to yourself that someone has done a wrong thing, and thinking that wrong thing should be prevented, are separate imo.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 21:31

I would never judge a woman I knew, or post a negative judgement in reply to a particular woman who wanted to use a surrogate who happened to come on here, say. But I would do other things to stop it, as a general trend if I could.

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 21:22

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 20:59

I do not doubt that you have experienced great pain. I do have children but suffered years of recurrent miscarriages and considered my options during that time. But the thing is - your whole post is about you - how much you want a child, the pain you feel, how you want that pain to disappear.

If you had a child via a surrogate you would be doing it because of your need for a child and despite the fact you’d be putting another woman’s life at risk and be parting a baby from its biological mother.

No one has a right to a child. No one has the right to use another woman’s body. No child deserves to be created to order to be taken away from their mother.

I agree in the case where women are
exploited and used. But where a women has acted as a surrogate altruistically and without coercion, I can’t see that as using a women’s body or risking their life, not if they have volunteered.

I agree my longing for a child is selfish. All conception is self-centred. No one brings a baby into the world because it’s best for the baby; we try to conceive because WE want children. Despite many circumstances of conception being less than ideal.

I’m not refuting the idea of post birth/removal trauma at all, I’m sure it occurs, as it does in the case of adoption. But to me there isn’t yet enough research to say it occurs in every case. I also disagree with paid/transactional surrogacy.

But as the above poster says, should we judge what anyone does to create their family? Is it more altruistic or morally worthy to accidentally create a life, a real life person, who may experience trauma, as a teenager who doesn’t use contraception? As a women who is financially struggling and can’t feed her existing children? As an addict? Plenty of women in these situations become pregnant by choice. Is it more morally worthy to do so? I’m not sure. Which is why I don’t and won’t judge.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 21:18

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 20:40

I wouldn’t judge a desperate woman, and I would feel pleased for her happiness, even if to myself I don’t think surrogacy is a good idea.

Well by that logic should we also not judge a woman who steals a baby from a maternity ward? If she's desperate and it makes her happy?

Teder · 19/06/2023 21:03

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 20:40

I wouldn’t judge a desperate woman, and I would feel pleased for her happiness, even if to myself I don’t think surrogacy is a good idea.

I understand the sentiment but how far do we go with that? To what level to we “not judge”?

Embarra55ed · 19/06/2023 20:59

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 19:13

I’d say curiosity rather than manipulation as it’s far easier to judge people when you’ve never experienced their pain.

I don’t know where I come to rest on this issue. I’m struggling to conceive and I can’t honestly 100% say I’d rule out surrogacy if it was my only option. Luckily, I have many options left to explore. And yes, I’d want it to happen in a well regulated way that protects vulnerable women from exploitation, but if a friend or a sister offered in an altruistic way, I can’t be 100% certain I’d say no. If that makes me a monster then so be it.

I’d just be intrigued to know how many of the judgemental people have experienced the pain you mention your friend experiencing, as I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy. And as I said I’m fairly early in my journey compared to
many. I can honestly say I’ve contemplated suicide at the thought of never being a mother. I’ve met people via support groups who have had similar thoughts. It’s a visceral pain where you feel broken and incapable and like something has ripped a hole through your very being: I’d never judge anyone for how they explore their options relating to making that feeling disappear.

I do not doubt that you have experienced great pain. I do have children but suffered years of recurrent miscarriages and considered my options during that time. But the thing is - your whole post is about you - how much you want a child, the pain you feel, how you want that pain to disappear.

If you had a child via a surrogate you would be doing it because of your need for a child and despite the fact you’d be putting another woman’s life at risk and be parting a baby from its biological mother.

No one has a right to a child. No one has the right to use another woman’s body. No child deserves to be created to order to be taken away from their mother.

ScrollingLeaves · 19/06/2023 20:40

I wouldn’t judge a desperate woman, and I would feel pleased for her happiness, even if to myself I don’t think surrogacy is a good idea.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 20:20

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 18:26

And many surrogates are not any of those things as others have said in this thread.

To be honest I’d be interested in knowing how many of those standing in judgement of those who use surrogacy as a means to have a family are sitting surrounded by their own children as they type. Compared to those who are anti-surrogacy who have experienced infertility and the utter desperation it brings.

I'm an adopter, my children are not biologically related to me. I did not have them from birth and they and I are dealing with the effects of their early trauma and their removal from their birth family, which was for their own safety.

I am 100% against surrogacy. Being unable to have birth children yourself, no matter how painful that might be, does not give you the right to exploit another woman or to cause potentially serious and life long trauma to a child. Your pain doesn't give you the right to do that, and doesn't make doing that okay. So yes I do judge those who use surrogacy.

Conflictedcommunication · 19/06/2023 19:35

Those poor babies

Teder · 19/06/2023 19:22

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 19:13

I’d say curiosity rather than manipulation as it’s far easier to judge people when you’ve never experienced their pain.

I don’t know where I come to rest on this issue. I’m struggling to conceive and I can’t honestly 100% say I’d rule out surrogacy if it was my only option. Luckily, I have many options left to explore. And yes, I’d want it to happen in a well regulated way that protects vulnerable women from exploitation, but if a friend or a sister offered in an altruistic way, I can’t be 100% certain I’d say no. If that makes me a monster then so be it.

I’d just be intrigued to know how many of the judgemental people have experienced the pain you mention your friend experiencing, as I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy. And as I said I’m fairly early in my journey compared to
many. I can honestly say I’ve contemplated suicide at the thought of never being a mother. I’ve met people via support groups who have had similar thoughts. It’s a visceral pain where you feel broken and incapable and like something has ripped a hole through your very being: I’d never judge anyone for how they explore their options relating to making that feeling disappear.

It took me some time to conceive which was excruciating and I don’t even pretend to know how it must feel to be in the position of anyone struggling longer term with their fertility. I don’t judge anyone for passing thoughts “oh my sister easily has babies, I wish she’d have one for me!”. Those sort of thoughts and feelings are very human.
The commercial surrogacy process is series of stages. It isn’t a passing thought or feeling.

Brokendaughter · 19/06/2023 19:17

ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 19:15

Experiencing pain oneself doesn't give anyone the right to inflict pain on another, I'm sorry.

This

ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 19:15

Experiencing pain oneself doesn't give anyone the right to inflict pain on another, I'm sorry.

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 19:13

Teder · 19/06/2023 19:03

This is just emotional manipulation.
The heartache and pain of infertility is enormous, beyond words. There are plenty of people who have posted on these threads before who are infertile and will never have biological children who are still anti commercial surrogacy. My dearest best friend is one of those people. I cannot even begin to imagine her pain but she says her pain doesn’t give her a right to do something she believes in immoral. It’s a particular concern where the surrogate isn’t the egg donor as they are then anonymous.

I’d say curiosity rather than manipulation as it’s far easier to judge people when you’ve never experienced their pain.

I don’t know where I come to rest on this issue. I’m struggling to conceive and I can’t honestly 100% say I’d rule out surrogacy if it was my only option. Luckily, I have many options left to explore. And yes, I’d want it to happen in a well regulated way that protects vulnerable women from exploitation, but if a friend or a sister offered in an altruistic way, I can’t be 100% certain I’d say no. If that makes me a monster then so be it.

I’d just be intrigued to know how many of the judgemental people have experienced the pain you mention your friend experiencing, as I wouldn’t wish it on my worst enemy. And as I said I’m fairly early in my journey compared to
many. I can honestly say I’ve contemplated suicide at the thought of never being a mother. I’ve met people via support groups who have had similar thoughts. It’s a visceral pain where you feel broken and incapable and like something has ripped a hole through your very being: I’d never judge anyone for how they explore their options relating to making that feeling disappear.

GailBlancheViola · 19/06/2023 19:12

This is just emotional manipulation.

It is and blackmail of the worst sort. No-one is owed children, parenthood is not a right. Essentially you @adviceneeded1990 are saying that because someone really, really wants a child and is unable to have one then it is right and acceptable for them to use someone else's body and to purchase the resulting child. Other women's bodies are not there to service someone else's wants, a child is not an object to be traded.

Teder · 19/06/2023 19:03

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 18:26

And many surrogates are not any of those things as others have said in this thread.

To be honest I’d be interested in knowing how many of those standing in judgement of those who use surrogacy as a means to have a family are sitting surrounded by their own children as they type. Compared to those who are anti-surrogacy who have experienced infertility and the utter desperation it brings.

This is just emotional manipulation.
The heartache and pain of infertility is enormous, beyond words. There are plenty of people who have posted on these threads before who are infertile and will never have biological children who are still anti commercial surrogacy. My dearest best friend is one of those people. I cannot even begin to imagine her pain but she says her pain doesn’t give her a right to do something she believes in immoral. It’s a particular concern where the surrogate isn’t the egg donor as they are then anonymous.

adviceneeded1990 · 19/06/2023 18:26

Purplefoalfoot · 19/06/2023 08:04

No, but surely you can see that it’s not a good idea to intentionally bring children into the world to be traumatised at birth.

Or do you think it’s good for children to be born to drug addicts? Would you purposely ‘commission’ a drug addict to have a baby? If your sister was a drug addict would be encouraging her to have a baby at all costs before she was clean? Your argument makes no sense and is irrelevant to the issue of surrogacy.

Except of course to say that surrogates are more likely to be abused, traumatised women themselves who may have a background of susbstance abuse.

And many surrogates are not any of those things as others have said in this thread.

To be honest I’d be interested in knowing how many of those standing in judgement of those who use surrogacy as a means to have a family are sitting surrounded by their own children as they type. Compared to those who are anti-surrogacy who have experienced infertility and the utter desperation it brings.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/06/2023 17:22

ArabeIIaScott · 19/06/2023 17:17

I don't even know that words can fix what is going to be at root a biological, instinctive response/trauma, tbh. Not sure how much it matters how you try to present the 'story' of a surrogate birth as a positive, feel-good event; the trauma is likely to be at a very deep, pre-verbal level.

Very true. It's not a positive, feel good event for the baby, quite the opposite. And pre verbal trauma is very hard to mitigate.